Edited volume · 2021
Contested Antiquity: Archaeological Heritage and Social Conflict in Modern Greece and Cyprus
Esther Solomon (ed.)
Bloomington: Indiana University Press
A collection of ten chapters and an introduction on contested archaeological heritage in Greece and Cyprus, from excavation and museums to law, urban memory, a prison and contemporary art.
Ten case studies and an introduction examine how archaeological remains and heritage are interpreted, managed and contested in Greece and Cyprus. The cases connect national and colonial histories with local claims, public memory, urban change, archaeological law, former prisons and contemporary art. Solomon's introduction sets out the approach to heritage and material culture before the chapters follow in three parts, and one chapter, by Bounia, Nikolaou and Stylianou-Lambert, is on Cyprus.
How it is organised
Solomon's introduction, Contested Antiquity in Greece and Cyprus, frames archaeological heritage through nationalism, colonial relations, memory, tourism, preservation and local identity (pp. 1–50).
Part I, Between Nationalism, Colonialism, and Crypto-Colonialism: Historical Perspectives and Current Implications, holds four chapters: Dimitris Plantzos, Hellas Mon Amour: Revisiting Greece's National Sites of Trauma; Niki Sakka, Archaeology and Politics in the Interwar Period: The Swedish Excavations at Asine; Alexandra Bounia, Polina Nikolaou and Theopisti Stylianou-Lambert, Contested Perceptions of Archaeological Sites in Cyprus: Communities and Their Claims on Their Past; and Marlen Mouliou, Pressed On in Press: Greek Cultural Heritage in the Public Eye: The Post-War Years.
Part II, Spatial Metaphors and Ethnographic Observations: Heritage, Memory, and Dissonance, has three: Styliana Galiniki, The Gentrification of Memory: The Past as a Social Event in Thessaloniki of the Early Twenty-First Century; Katerina Konstantinou, The Oracle of Dodona: Contestation over a Sacred Archaeological Landscape; and Aris Anagnostopoulos, Archaeological Protection Zones and the Limits of the Possible: Archaeological Law, Abandonment, and Contested Spaces in Greece.
Part III, Competing Pasts, has three more: Andromache Gazi, Heritage as Obstacle: Or Which View to the Acropolis?; Eleni Stefanou and Ioanna Antoniadou, Eptapyrgio, a Modern Prison inside a World Heritage Monument: Raw Memories in the Margins of Archaeology; and Eleana Yalouri and Elpida Rikou, Contemporary Art and Difficult Heritage: Three Case Studies from Athens. The volume closes with a dedication to Calliope Farmakidi and an index.
The papers
In Part I, Plantzos writes on archaeological displays and national trauma, and Sakka on the interwar Swedish excavations at Asine: the campaigns under Persson and Frödin, the loans, returns and transfers of finds to Sweden, and the decisions of the Greek Archaeological Council. Mouliou analyses newspaper reporting from 1948 to 1967 in To Vima and I Avgi, including the post-war debates over the Stoa of Attalos.
The Cyprus chapter concerns communities and their claims on archaeological sites. It takes in the collectors Luigi Palma Di Cesnola and Demetrios Pierides, the Cyprus Museum and the Musée Lapidaire, a museum of medieval architectural remains (pp. 108–130).
Galiniki treats memory politics and urban space in Thessaloniki, where the mayor Yiannis Boutaris is associated with that politics. Konstantinou follows the sacred site of Dodona from Carapanos's excavations through the annual festival and the theatre restoration to the conflict over the Roman arena. Anagnostopoulos compares Poros and Gonies as contrasting cases of archaeological protection zones, tied to archaeological law, abandonment and contested spaces.
Gazi writes on the two houses, numbers 17 and 19, beside the New Acropolis Museum and the view of the Acropolis. Stefanou and Antoniadou trace the prison history of Eptapyrgio through the memories of former political prisoners, among them Nondas Ohounos and Akis Maltsidis. Yalouri and Rikou examine art interventions at the Athenian and Roman Agoras, among them Tino Sehgal's This Progress, Aemilia Papaphilippou's Pulsating Fields and Natasa Biza's Plan for Planting (pp. 297–317).
What it records
- The Cyprus Museum was established on 15 June 1882.p. 118
- Five excavation campaigns took place at Asine, in 1922, 1924, 1926 and 1930, under Persson and Frödin.p. 86
- In 1929 a committee recorded and photographed 371 artifacts in Uppsala.p. 90
- About 270 boxes of finds from Asine had arrived from Sweden by 12 January 1931.p. 92
- Panagiotis Kastriotis supported the Swedish demands over the Asine finds, alongside Konstantinos Kourouniotis.p. 92
- In 1934 the Archaeological Council authorized the export of about 223 boxes of finds for Swedish universities.p. 93
- Mouliou's newspaper sample holds 1,291 articles from To Vima and 181 from I Avgi.p. 156
- Konstantinos Carapanos excavated Dodona in the 1870s.p. 196
- Carapanos's bronze collection was later donated to the National Archaeological Museum in Athens.p. 196
- Sotiris Dakaris succeeded Dimitris Evaggelidis at Dodona after Evaggelidis died in 1959.p. 198
- The Society of Epirote Studies inaugurated the annual Eortes Dodonis festival in 1960.p. 200
- The sanctuary of Poseidon at Kalaureia led the Greek state to declare the surrounding area a zone of absolute protection.p. 226
- Gonies had about 1,040 residents in the mid-1950s, and more than 300 children attended its primary school.p. 234
- In late May 2009 the Council of State issued a final verdict against the demolition of the two houses beside the New Acropolis Museum.p. 257
- Eptapyrgio operated as a prison from about 1890 until 1989, when it came under the Ministry of Culture's jurisdiction.p. 272
- Aemilia Papaphilippou's installation at the ancient Athenian Agora consisted of 64 marble slabs.p. 306
Where to read
- Asine excavation campaigns and project contextpp. 84–88
- Asine finds, loans, returns and transfers to Swedenpp. 89–94
- Cyprus Museum and local claims to antiquitiespp. 115–120
- Post-war press, the Stoa of Attalos and heritage debatespp. 136–150
- Dodona festival, theatre restoration and conflict over the Roman arenapp. 200–211
- Poros and Gonies as contrasting cases of archaeological protection zonespp. 224–238
- The Number 17 and 19 houses dispute beside the New Acropolis Museumpp. 251–257
- Former political prisoners’ memories and contemporary art at the Agoraspp. 279–313
Contents
- Introduction: Contested Antiquity in Greece and CyprusEsther Solomon1
- Part I: Between Nationalism, Colonialism, and Crypto-Colonialism: Historical Perspectives and Current Implications51
- Hellas Mon Amour: Revisiting Greece’s National Sites of TraumaDimitris Plantzos53
- Archaeology and Politics in the Interwar Period: The Swedish Excavations at AsineNiki Sakka80
- Contested Perceptions of Archaeological Sites in Cyprus: Communities and Their Claims on Their PastAlexandra Bounia, Polina Nikolaou, Theopisti Stylianou-Lambert108
- Pressed On in Press: Greek Cultural Heritage in the Public Eye: The Post-War YearsMarlen Mouliou131
- Part II: Spatial Metaphors and Ethnographic Observations: Heritage, Memory, and Dissonance163
- The Gentrification of Memory: The Past as a Social Event in Thessaloniki of the Early Twenty-First CenturyStyliana Galiniki165
- The Oracle of Dodona: Contestation over a Sacred Archaeological LandscapeKaterina Konstantinou194
- Archaeological Protection Zones and the Limits of the Possible: Archaeological Law, Abandonment, and Contested Spaces in GreeceAris Anagnostopoulos219
- Part III: Competing Pasts243
- Heritage as Obstacle: Or Which View to the Acropolis?Andromache Gazi245
- Eptapyrgio, a Modern Prison inside a World Heritage Monument: Raw Memories in the Margins of ArchaeologyEleni Stefanou, Ioanna Antoniadou272
- Contemporary Art and Difficult Heritage: Three Case Studies from AthensEleana Yalouri, Elpida Rikou297
Objects published here
4- Dendra gold cup, Dendra (p. 96)
- Bearded terracotta male head from the Mycenaean settlement, northwestern slope of Asine’s acropolis (p. 98)
- Incantadas, sculpted pillars of a Roman colonnade, Louvre, courtyard of a house in the Jewish quarter of Thessaloniki (p. 177)
- Stumbling Stones with the names of Jewish Thessalonian pupils killed in Auschwitz, sidewalk outside a middle school in Thessaloniki, fig. 5.4 (p. 185)
People, places and institutions
People
- Panagiotis Kastriotissupported the Swedish demands over the Asine finds
- Axel W. Perssonco-directed the Asine excavations
- Otto Frödinco-directed the Asine excavations
- Konstantinos Kourouniotisdirector of the Archaeological Service
- Luigi Palma Di Cesnolaconsul and collector of antiquities
- Demetrios Pieridescollector and Cyprus Museum founder
- Yiannis BoutarisThessaloniki mayor associated with memory politics
- Konstantinos Carapanosexcavated Dodona in the 1870s
- Dimitris Evaggelidisarchaeologist at Dodona
- Sotiris Dakarisdirected excavations at Dodona
- Kostas Frontzospromoted the Dodona festival
- Nondas Ohounosformer political prisoner interviewed
- Akis Maltsidisformer political prisoner interviewed
- Tino Sehgalartist of This Progress and Silence
- Aemilia Papaphilippouartist of Pulsating Fields
- Natasa Bizaartist of Plan for Planting
Institutions
- Archaeological Councildecided archaeological policy in Greece
- Cyprus MuseumCypriot national museum
- Musée Lapidairemuseum of medieval architectural remains
- To Vimanewspaper analysed by Mouliou
- I Avginewspaper analysed by Mouliou
- National Archaeological Museumreceived Carapanos’s bronze collection
- Society of Epirote Studiesadministered the Dodona festival
- Central Archaeological Counciladvised on restoration and site decisions
- Council of Stateruled against demolition of the two houses
Places
- Asinesite of Swedish excavations and the finds dispute
- Thessalonikisetting for memory-politics case study
- Dodonaoracle site and case study
- Poroscase study of archaeological protection zones
- Goniescase study of local land and archaeology
- Dionyssiou Areopagitou Streetstreet of the two-house demolition dispute
- Eptapyrgiofortress and modern prison in Thessaloniki
- Ancient Athenian Agorasite of contemporary art interventions
- sanctuary of Poseidon, Kalaureiasanctuary within protection zone
- New Acropolis Museummuseum beside the disputed houses
- Roman Agorasite of Sehgal's This Progress
Also named: Indiana University Press, Sir Robert Biddulph.
Extent index pp. 321–330
Defines practiced heritage, gentrification of memory, protection zone
ModernRomanHistory of ArchaeologyMuseumsLooting and the LawArchitectureCollecting
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1867–1869Idalion, Goshi and Pyla: Robert Hamilton Lang's excavations (sanctuary of Apollo)Directed by Robert Hamilton LangClearance and early digging
Who did what
15 recordsBuying, selling and giving 8
- p. 113
Hasan (Hasen) of DaliAgent forLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Lang identified Hasen as General Cesnola's middleman in the antiquities trade.
Dali
- 1889 · p. 115
F. PartidesSold toBritish Museum
F. Partides offered to sell the British Museum some Cypriot antiquities.
- 1889 · p. 115
J. CaridiAgent forF. Partides
Caridis wrote to the British Museum on behalf of F. Partides about selling Cypriot antiquities.
some Cypriot antiquities
- 1870–1876 · p. 126
Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toMetropolitan Museum of Art
Cesnola agreed to sell his collection to the Metropolitan Museum for £1,200.
£1,200New York
- 1872–1873 · p. 127
Robert Hamilton LangSold toBritish Museum
One of Lang’s heads was sold at auction to the British Museum for 50 pounds.
one female stone head from Pyla50 poundsLondon
- 1872 · p. 127
Robert Hamilton LangGave toLouvre
Robert Hamilton Lang offered several sculptures to the Louvre, including representations of local Artemis goddesses.
several sculptures, including local Artemis figuresNo. MNB 358, MNB 757
- p. 127
Robert Hamilton LangLent toGlasgow Art Gallery and Museum
Robert Hamilton Lang lent a substantial group of antiquities to Glasgow Art Gallery and Museum before donating them.
a substantial group of Cypriot antiquities
- p. 127
Robert Hamilton LangGave toGlasgow Art Gallery and Museum
Robert Hamilton Lang donated a substantial group of antiquities to Glasgow Art Gallery and Museum after lending them.
a substantial group of Cypriot antiquities
Excavation 2
- 1880–1890 · p. 112
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterDug forBritish Museum
Max Ohnefalsch-Richter excavated at Salamis as part of research for the British Museum.
floor mosaic
- p. 113
Hadji Georgi StyllisDug forRobert Hamilton Lang
Lang placed Hadgi Georgi Styllis among the people in charge of his excavating teams.
Dali
Recording and study 5
- p. 112
Max Ohnefalsch-RichterPublished
Ohnefalsch-Richter wrote an article about the vases workers had placed among the site's finds.
ancient vases decorated with concentric circlesLarnaca
- p. 115
Robert Hamilton LangWorked withDemetrios Pierides
Lang described Pierides as his coadjutor in matters connected with antiquities.
- 1882 · p. 116
Demetrios PieridesFoundedMusée de Chypre
Dimitri Piérides was one of the founders of the Musée de Chypre in 1882.
- 1903 · p. 119
George JefferyRecorded
Jeffery pursued establishing a museum for Venetian findings in Famagusta and a medieval museum in Nicosia.
Famagusta and Nicosia
- 1914 · p. 127
John Linton MyresCatalogued the collection ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola
Myres catalogued and described objects from the Cesnola collection in his Handbook.
No. Handbook, nos. 1 à 5985New York
People it is cited for
1 personInstitutions it is cited for
1 institution- Indiana University Press2 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.