Chapter · 1993

The Mycenaean Pictorial Style 50 years later

S. A. Immerwahr; edited by C. Zerner, P. Zerner and J. Winder

In Wace and Blegen: Pottery as evidence for trade in the Aegean Bronze Age, 1939-1989 217-223. J. C. Gieben

A chapter on whether Mycenaean Pictorial Style vases found in Cyprus were made there or imported from the Greek Mainland, weighed on stylistic, archaeological and scientific evidence.

Immerwahr reviews the debate over whether Mycenaean Pictorial Style vases found in Cyprus were made on the island or brought from the Greek Mainland, tracing how interpretations have changed since the 1939 article by Wace and Blegen. She weighs stylistic, archaeological and scientific evidence, and argues that distribution, preservation and unusual vessel shapes do not establish a Cypriote place of manufacture.

Immerwahr points to stylistic comparisons identifying painters whose work occurs in both Cyprus and Greece, and finds from Corinth, Mycenae, Nauplion, Argos, Aegina and Tiryns establish a Mainland presence. At Berbati, rejected and misfired vessels lie alongside fragments in shapes associated with Cyprus. Immerwahr places most Berbati fragments in LH IIIA2 and IIIB, with some earlier, relates the emergence of the style to the LM II Palace style, and discusses later IIIC material at Tiryns (pp. 218–220).

Petrographic analysis, optical emission spectroscopy and neutron activation analysis generally align the fabric of Pictorial fragments from Cyprus with Mainland Mycenaean pottery, and the Kouklia woman fragment is an anomaly. Together with the similarities between painters' work in the two regions and the evidence for production at Berbati, these studies lead Immerwahr to favour Mainland manufacture for most of the Pictorial vases found in Cyprus, against proposals for Cypriote workshops and for movement of potters or clay between the regions (pp. 220–223).

What it records

  • Immerwahr describes the chamber tombs excavated by the Swedish Cyprus Expedition, especially at Enkomi, as holding mostly local Cypriote pottery, unlike the tombs of Mycenaean colonists known at Ialysos.p. 217
  • Immerwahr reads Cypro-Minoan pot-marks on some vases from the Levant as probable dealers' marks showing that the pots passed through Cypriote hands.p. 218
  • Berbati yielded fragments from about 70 amphoroid and open strap-handled kraters with chariot scenes, which Immerwahr says were evidently intended for export.p. 219
  • Fragments of an open krater by Painter 19 come from Tiryns, with fragments from at least three different vases from Berbati.p. 219
  • The large Berbati krater, the only nearly complete Pictorial vase, warped badly in firing, had a hole bored in its base and was sunk in a house floor.p. 219
  • Scientific analyses favour, without absolutely proving, Mainland manufacture for most Pictorial Style vases found in Cyprus, in Immerwahr's summary.p. 220

Where to read

  • The debate over Cypriote or Mainland manufacturepp. 217–218
  • Berbati and evidence for Pictorial pottery productionpp. 219–220
  • Fabric analyses and the Kouklia fragmentpp. 220–223

People, places and institutions

People

  • A.J.B. Waceco-author of the 1939 article under discussion
  • E. Gjerstadfavoured an export-trade interpretation
  • Furumarkproposed the term Levanto-Mycenaean
  • Sjöqvistproposed the term Levanto-Helladic
  • J.F. Danielexcavated Bamboula at Kourion
  • H.W. Catlingstudied Pictorial pottery and its fabric
  • Å. Åkerströmpublished Pictorial pottery from Berbati
  • E. Vermeuleco-authored a collection of Pictorial Style vases
  • V. Karageorghisstudied and attributed Pictorial Style vases

Institutions

Places

  • BerbatiPotter's Quarter, evidence for production
  • Enkomisource of Pictorial Style vases
  • Tirynssource of Pictorial Style fragments
  • Mycenaesource of early Pictorial Style finds

Also named: C.W. Blegen, E.J. Forsdyke, Myres, F. Stubbings, R.E. Jones, S. Casson, Kourion, Corinth, Nauplion, Kouklia (Old Paphos), Ialysos, Fitch Laboratory.

Extent pp. 217–223, 2 pls (25–26)

Late Bronze AgePotteryTradeForeign ContactsChronology and Dating

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Who did what

1 record

Recording and study 1

  • Hector CatlingPublished

    H.W. Catling first published the woman fragment from Kouklia as LH IIIA.

    a woman fragment from KoukliaKouklia (Old Paphos)

    p. 220

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.