Scholar · Cataloguer
Frank Henry Stubbings
1915–2005 · United Kingdom
Cambridge classicist whose 1951 book and article studied the Mycenaean pottery found in Cyprus, including the first published attempt to attribute Mycenaean pictorial vases to individual painters.
Biography
Frank Henry Stubbings was a Cambridge classicist, University Lecturer in Classics from 1949 to 19808.
Life
According to Wikidata, Stubbings was born on 8 March 19157. He came to Emmanuel College, Cambridge, on an entrance scholarship in 1933 from the Perse School9. He took a first in Part I of the Classical Tripos in 1935, winning the Browne scholarship and the Porson Prize, and a first in Part II in 1937 with the second Chancellor's Medal for Classics9. At the British School at Athens in 1937-8 he worked on Mycenaean pottery from Attica and took part in excavations in Ithaca9. In 1938-9 he widened his field to the Mycenaean pottery found in Cyprus, Syria and Egypt, and was on Alan Wace's staff at Mycenae9. The war found him in Athens, doing secretarial work at the British Legation until April 1941, and then in Cairo9.
He took up his Emmanuel fellowship in October 1945, completed his PhD in 1948 and became a University lecturer in 19499. At Emmanuel he was Librarian from 1959 and Vice-Master in 1965-99. He succeeded Wace as joint editor of A Companion to Homer (1962), wrote Prehistoric Greece (1972), and was University Orator from 1974 to 19829. After retiring in 1980 he stayed honorary keeper of special collections in the college library until September 2000, according to the college9; the University's obituary notice gives his keepership as 1980-988. He died on 29 October 2005, aged 908.
Mycenaean pottery in Cyprus
His PhD was published as Mycenaean Pottery from the Levant (1951)9. A reviewer in the Antiquaries Journal says it rested on his own survey of most of the principal museums of Europe and the Levant holding such pottery10. Stubbings wrote that European museums held perhaps more Mycenaean pottery from Cyprus than from Greece, but that the Swedish Cyprus Expedition had shown it far less common than native wares even at Enkomi6. Because so many Cypriot finds had come to light in unscientific ways, he did not list them all6. He called Enkomi of the highest importance but said fuller publication was needed6. For the IIIA 2 phase he saw more active commerce and probably colonies of Mycenaean traders, and he judged the great majority of IIIB pottery in Cyprus to be of local manufacture6.
The sources disagree on where he thought this pottery was made: the Antiquaries Journal reviewer says he took "the middle course", recognising ware made in the island beside imports from the mainland and Rhodes10. A 1970 review in Bibliotheca Orientalis counts him among those who held it was made in Cyprus by Mycenaean potters11. Gert Jan van Wijngaarden writes instead that in 1951 Stubbings saw technique, shape and decoration all pointing to manufacture on mainland Greece12. Sara A. Immerwahr, reviewing the book in the American Journal of Archaeology, wrote that almost half of it dealt with pottery from Rhodes and Cyprus, and objected that he suggested a manufacturing centre at Tell Abu Hawam while denying one to Ras Shamra3.
Painters and pot-marks
In "Some Mycenaean Artists" (1951) Stubbings grouped Cypriot Mycenaean pottery that he believed could be given "with some degree of confidence" to individual craftsmen13. He judged two jugs from Hala Sultan Tekké in the British Museum certain examples of Cyprus-made Mycenaean13. He asked whether a pot-mark shared by two vases was a signature, but held that to conclude so "would at present be rash"13. Sara Immerwahr called the article "the first published attempt to detect the work of individual Mycenaean vase-painters", but held that his Groups I and II split the work of one painter, the Protome Painter, and would not go as far as he did in giving vases to single hands14. Jack L. Benson wrote that this painter "was first recognized (in print) by F. Stubbings"5.
He also wrote two chapters of the Cambridge Ancient History, volume II15. At the 1972 international archaeological symposium in Cyprus, a government press release reports, he argued that the island's Mycenaean pottery was partly imported and partly made locally, and voiced serious doubts about the new method of scientific analysis16. An earlier letter from Claude Schaeffer to Vassos Karageorghis, however, lists Stubbings among those who would not be present17.
Life and work
1951
- Published Mycenaean Pottery from the Levant (Cambridge University Press), which treats Mycenaean pottery from Rhodes and Cyprus as control groups for imports into the Levant
- In the Annual of the British School at Athens 46 (pp. 168-176) made what Immerwahr calls the first published attempt to detect the work of individual Mycenaean vase-painters, in groups of pictorial vases including Cypriot finds from Enkomi and Hala Sultan Tekke
Sara A. Immerwahr (1955). Some Mycenaean Artists Reexamined (abstract). American Journal of Archaeology 59, 172, p. 172; J. L. Benson (1961). Observations on Mycenaean Vase-Painters. American Journal of Archaeology 65, p. 338
1955
- Thanked by Woolley for advice on sections of the Alalakh report, which discusses Mycenaean and Cypriot pottery
1972
- Dr. F. Stubbings of Cambridge University argued that Mycenaean pottery of Cyprus was partly imported from mainland Greece and partly made in Cyprus, and expressed doubts about the new scientific clay-analysis method.
- mycenaeologist not attending in Claude Schaeffer's papers (Collège de France), 1 document, 1972.
Connections
4 peopleDisputes & the law
- Rival of Sara ImmerwahrRude Style Mycenaean vase classification American Journal of Archaeology 1961-10: Vol 65 Iss 4 (1961)
Colleagues & contacts
- Helped Sir Charles Leonard Woolleyadvice on sections of the Alalakh report (Mycenaean pottery among them) Leonard Woolley, 1955, Alalakh: An Account of the Excavations at Tell Atchana in the Hatay, 1937-1949, Preface1955
- Connected with Arne FurumarkRude Style classification American Journal of Archaeology 1956-04: Vol 60 Iss 2
- Connected with J. VercoutterMycenaean Pottery from the Levant American Journal of Archaeology 1955-04: Vol 59 Iss 2 (1955)
- Connected with Sara ImmerwahrImmerwahr (1955) re-examined his attributions of Mycenaean vase-painters and combined two of his stylistic groups into the Protome Painter Sara A. Immerwahr, 1955, Some Mycenaean Artists Reexamined (abstract), p. 172; Jack L. Benson, 1961, Mycenaean pictorial vases (painters of Cypriot vases), p. 339
Recording and study
1 record- Studied1
Stubbings recently studied the animal bones from the Vounous-Bellapais cemetery, as Dikaios's footnote states.
animal bones from the Early Cypriot cemetery of Vounous-BellapaisDikaios 1953, p. 431
Mentioned in
9 mentionsDocuments · 5
- An Index to the Late Bronze Age Aegean Pottery from Syria-Palestine
1994
studied Levantine Mycenaean pottery
Leonard 1994
- Khirokitia: Final Report on the Excavation of a Neolithic Settlement in Cyprus on Behalf of the Department of Antiquities, 1936-1946
p. 431
Stubbings recently studied the animal bones from the Vounous-Bellapais cemetery, as Dikaios's footnote states.
Dikaios 1953
- The Mycenaean Pictorial Style 50 years later
1993
Immerwahr 1993
- Alalakh: An account of the excavations at Tell Atchana in the Hatay, 1937–1949
Woolley 1955
- MYKENAIKA: Actes du IXe Colloque international sur les textes mycéniens et égées
OLIVIER 1992
- People · 4listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.Leonard Woolley (1955). Alalakh: An Account of the Excavations at Tell Atchana in the Hatay, 1937-1949.
- 2.Jean-Pierre Olivier (1992). Mykenaika: Actes du IXe Colloque international sur les textes mycéniens et égéens. 646.
- 3.Sara A. Immerwahr (1952). “Review of F. H. Stubbings, Mycenaean Pottery from the Levant”. American Journal of Archaeology 56.
- 4.Sara A. Immerwahr (1955). “Some Mycenaean Artists Reexamined (abstract)”. American Journal of Archaeology 59, 172.
- 5.J. L. Benson (1961). “Observations on Mycenaean Vase-Painters”. American Journal of Archaeology 65.
- 6.Frank H. Stubbings (1951). Mycenaean Pottery from the Levant. Cambridge University Press.
- 7.Wikidata (null). Frank Henry Stubbings (Q15906413). Online
- 8.University of Cambridge (2005). “Special Obituary Notices”. Cambridge University Reporter 6023. Online
- 9.Emmanuel College, Cambridge (2020). “Dr Frank Stubbings”. Emmanuel College, Fellows & Researchers.
- 10.The Antiquaries Journal (1952). “Review of F. H. Stubbings, Mycenaean Pottery from the Levant”. The Antiquaries Journal 32.
- 11.Bibliotheca Orientalis (1970). “[Review article on Mycenaean pottery in Cyprus]”. Bibliotheca Orientalis 27.
- 12.Gert Jan van Wijngaarden (2002). Use and Appreciation of Mycenaean Pottery in the Levant, Cyprus and Italy (ca. 1600-1200 BC). Amsterdam University Press. Online
- 13.F. H. Stubbings (1951). “Some Mycenaean Artists”. The Annual of the British School at Athens 46, 168-176.
- 14.Sara A. Immerwahr (1955). “Some Mycenaean Artists Reexamined [abstract]”. American Journal of Archaeology 59.
- 15.Bibliotheca Orientalis (1976). “[Review of The Cambridge Ancient History, vol. II, 3rd ed.]”. Bibliotheca Orientalis 33.
- 16.Press and Information Office, Republic of Cyprus (1972). Έληξαν αι εργασίαι του Διεθνούς Αρχαιολογικού Συμποσίου.
- 17.Claude F.-A. Schaeffer (1972). “[Letter to V. Karageorghis replying to his letter of 24 January 1972]”. Collège de France, Fonds Claude Schaeffer, 34 CDF art. 169.
- 18.P. Dikaios (1953). Khirokitia: Final Report on the Excavation of a Neolithic Settlement in Cyprus on Behalf of the Department of Antiquities, 1936-1946. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
- 19.Press and Information Office, Republic of Cyprus, press release of 1 April 1972, «Έληξαν αι εργασίαν του Διεθνούς Αρχαιολογικού Συμποσίου».
- 20.Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 169, «[Réponse de Schaeffer à la lettre de Karageorghis du 24 janvier 1972]», 1 February 1972of 6. Online
- 21.Leonard Woolley, 1955, Alalakh: An Account of the Excavations at Tell Atchana in the Hatay, 1937-1949.
- 22.Sara A. Immerwahr, 1955, Some Mycenaean Artists Reexamined (abstract), p. 172; Jack L. Benson, 1961, Mycenaean pictorial vases (painters of Cypriot vases).
- 23.American Journal of Archaeology 1955-04: Vol 59 Iss 2 (1955).
- 24.American Journal of Archaeology 1956-04: Vol 60 Iss 2.
- 25.American Journal of Archaeology 1961-10: Vol 65 Iss 4 (1961).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.