Article · 1967
Cape Gelidonya: A Bronze Age Shipwreck
Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, new series 57(8) 1-177. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society
An excavation report on the 1960 underwater excavation of a Late Bronze Age shipwreck off Cape Gelidonya, with its cargo, excavation methods, analyses and an interpretation of the voyage and trade.
A Late Bronze Age shipwreck off Cape Gelidonya, on the southern coast of Turkey, is reported through its discovery, the underwater excavation of 1960 and specialist studies of the hull, cargo and finds. Throckmorton recounts the discovery and earlier investigations, and Bass and Throckmorton the excavation. The later chapters take in turn the ship and its lading, ingots, bronzes, pottery, stone objects, miscellaneous finds, weights, scarabs, a cylinder seal, and basketry and matting, before Bass’s conclusions, and appendices give radiocarbon and analytical results.
The fieldwork
Earlier investigations of the wreck are recounted first, with Hakki Gültekin of the Izmir Museum as the expedition’s representative and Frédéric Dumas as chief diver and excavation adviser. Andrew Megaw identified the ingots as almost certainly Cypriot, and Eric Sjöqvist the weapons as Cypriot Late Bronze Age (p. 18).
The excavation record combines measured plans, photographs, underwater drawings and object recording with descriptions of the seabed and the arrangement of the cargo. Bass and Throckmorton discuss diving, survey and lifting methods, including the difficulties created by current and the need to document finds in place before raising them (pp. 21–39). Du Plat Taylor then describes the condition and treatment of the finds.
The evidence
Bass reconstructs a vessel about nine or ten metres long, carrying roughly a ton of metal cargo and other goods. He proposes that the ship took on its principal cargo in Cyprus and struck rocks between the islands near Cape Gelidonya while sailing towards the Aegean. The ship’s weights he reads as equipment for dealing with merchants across the eastern Mediterranean, and its tools and stone implements as signs that a travelling smith may have been aboard (pp. 44–51).
The cargo and associated finds include copper oxhide, bun and slab ingots; bronze tools, weapons and vessels; pottery; stone implements; weights; five scarabs; a cylinder seal; beads; lead and metal foil; and basketry, matting and rope. The catalogue chapters record materials, dimensions, areas, object numbers and comparisons in separate series by class, with the prefixes In, BI and SI for the ingot types, B for bronzes, P for pottery, St for stone, W for weights, Sc for scarabs and BM for basketry and matting, and letters for excavation areas (pp. 52–162).
The appendices report radiocarbon measurements on hull brushwood, wood identifications, spectrographic analysis of copper ingots and pottery, analyses of lead and beads, an examination of a suspected tin sample, and a note on model ingots in Egyptian foundation deposits (pp. 168–174).
The ingots
Bass considers the forms, markings, distribution and possible production of the oxhide, bun and slab ingots, and takes the oxhide ingots to be portable raw copper for smiths, discounting their use as currency. Comparisons run from depictions of ingots at Thebes and Linear B ingot tablets from Knossos to ingot distribution in Sardinia (pp. 52–83).
The bronzes are compared with material from Cyprus and the Near East, among them finds from Enkomi, Mathiati, Kourion, Ras Shamra and Megiddo. The report also considers evidence for itinerant metalworkers and the relationship between ingots, scrap and tools in trade (pp. 84–121).
Dating
The pottery chapter treats the wreck date as broad and notes that the pottery alone does not give an exclusive Late Bronze Age date (pp. 122–125). The radiocarbon appendix gives several calculations for the hull brushwood and discusses the uncertainty in relating them to true age. Bass’s conclusion weighs the pottery, scarabs, ingots, bronzes and radiocarbon evidence together and places the wreck at 1200 BCE ± 50 years.
The argument
Bass argues that the ship was a Phoenician merchantman carrying a largely Cypriot cargo westward. He separates the origin of the cargo from the identity of the vessel, and treats personal and official possessions, including a Syrian cylinder seal, scarabs, a Syro-Palestinian lamp, weights and stone implements, as evidence for the crew and merchant (pp. 163–167).
He further argues that Phoenician seafarers played a major part in Late Bronze Age trade, carrying metal west and returning with Mycenaean pottery and other goods. The wreck and comparative material, in his view, require reconsideration of the role of Phoenician merchants in maritime commerce. He cautions that conclusions about one ship do not establish a merchant fleet, while arguing that the wider distribution of metal objects and Syrian cylinder seals supports a larger trading role. The discussion draws on Albright and Lorimer on Phoenician trade and the Homeric evidence, and on Immerwahr on Mycenaean commerce.
What it records
- John Cochran and Susan Phipps discovered the wreck by chance on a last dive in July 1959.p. 17
- The underwater excavation began on 14 June 1960, after the team pitched camp on a narrow beach opposite Su Ada.p. 21
- The wreck lay at depths of 26 to 28 metres.p. 22
- Bass estimates from the spread of the heavy cargo that the ship was about ten metres long.p. 45
- At least 34 oxhide ingots were carried in the ship, stacked in neat piles with matting as wrapping or packing.p. 52
- Oxhide ingots are, in Bass’s interpretation, raw copper cast in shapes convenient for carrying, to be handed to smiths.p. 71
- Nineteen slab ingots, stacked in piles of three or four, were all found in area G.p. 82
- Dikaios reported that copper smelting at Enkomi reached its peak in the thirteenth century (Late Cypriot IIB), and that the bulk of the ingots may come from that period.p. 120
- Hennessy and Taylor suggest a broad wreck date of 1200 BCE ± 50 years, more probably after 1200 than before.p. 125
- A concretion in area P contained several hundred glass beads and a bracelet.p. 132
- Sixty small objects of stone and metal were catalogued as weights or possible weights.p. 135
- Five scarabs were recovered from area G, the ship’s cabin area: three by divers and two by air lift.p. 143
- The vessel was a Phoenician merchantman sailing towards the Aegean when it sank around 1200 BCE, in Bass’s identification.p. 164
- Bass concludes that the shipwreck dates to 1200 BCE ± 50 years, with more evidence pointing to the earlier part of that range.p. 165
- The cargo was certainly Cypriot, Bass argues, but nothing suggests that the ship itself was.p. 165
- Metal, above all, reached Greece on ships such as the one that sank at Gelidonya, Bass argues.p. 165
- The wood identifications include Cupressus among worked timbers and Quercus among the brushwood.p. 168
- Lead-isotope results place sample L 22 in a group of about ten samples from Athens, Mycenae, Corinth, Ceos, Cyprus, Sardis and Antioch.p. 170
- The foundation deposits containing four model ingots date, according to O’Connor, to between 1209 and 1185 BCE.p. 174
Where to read
- Discovery, site location and underwater excavation methodspp. 14–39
- Ship structure, cargo arrangement and brushwood dunnagepp. 44–51
- Oxhide, bun and slab ingot types, markings and trade interpretationspp. 52–83
- Bronze tools, comparisons and dating discussionpp. 84–121
- Pottery catalogue and proposed wreck datepp. 122–125
- Weights and the proposed trade connectionspp. 135–142
- Scarabs, cylinder seal and basketry cataloguespp. 143–162
- Conclusions on the voyage, Phoenician trade and scientific appendicespp. 163–174
Contents
- I. the DiscoveryPeter Throckmorton14
- II. the ExcavationGeorge F. Bass, Peter Throckmorton21
- I. Problems of Underwater ExcavationGeorge F. Bass, Peter Throckmorton21
- III. Condition and Treatment of FindsJ. du Plat Taylor40
- IV. the Ship and Its LadingGeorge F. Bass44
- V. the IngotsGeorge F. Bass52
- VI. the BronzesGeorge F. Bass84
- VII. the PotteryJ. B. Hennessy, J. du Plat Taylor122
- VIII. the Stone ObjectsJ. du Plat Taylor126
- IX. Miscellaneous FindsGeorge F. Bass131
- X. the WeightsGeorge F. Bass135
- XI. the ScarabsAlan Richard Schulman143
- XII. the Cylinder SealHans-Günter Buchholz148
- XIII. Basketry and MattingJ. du Plat Taylor160
- XIV. ConclusionsGeorge F. Bass163
- Appendix168
- 1. Carbon-14 Dates for WoodE. K. Ralph168
- 2. Identification of WoodA. C. Western168
- 3. Report on Copper Ingots by Spectrographic AnalysisMark C. Han169
- 4. Chemical Analysis and Isotope Ratio Examination of Lead (L 22)Robert H. Brill170
- 5a. Analysis of BeadRobert H. Brill170
- 5b. Analysis of BeadEdward V. Sayre171
- 6. Analysis of Tin SampleF. R. Dykstra171
- 7. Spectrographic Analyses of PotteryA. Millet172
- 8. Model Ingots in Egyptian Foundation DepositsDavid O'Connor172
Objects published here
21- Oxhide ingot, Type 2b, complete, 19.95 kg, Cape Gelidonya, area P, In 1, fig. 56; fig. 90 (p. 53)
- Oxhide ingot, Type 2c, Cape Gelidonya, In 24, fig. 59 (p. 57)
- Bun ingot, Cape Gelidonya, BI 1, fig. 93 (p. 78)
- Slab ingot, Cape Gelidonya, SI 3, fig. 97 (p. 82)
- Bronze hoe with incised Cypro-Minoan sign, Cape Gelidonya, area G, B 69, fig. 104 (p. 91)
- Bronze double axe, Cape Gelidonya, area P, B 101, figs. 107 and 108 (p. 95)
- Bronze pruning hook casting, Cape Gelidonya, B 219, figs. 126 and 127 (p. 113)
- Jug, probably Cypriot plain white wheel-made ware, Cape Gelidonya, area S, P 14, fig. 132 (p. 123)
- Mycenaean stirrup jar, Cape Gelidonya, area S, P 23, fig. 155 (p. 124)
- Stone macehead, spherical with bronze-lined socket, Cape Gelidonya, area G, St 1, figs. 134 and 136 (p. 126)
- Stone mortar, Cape Gelidonya, area P, St 3, figs. 135 and 136 (p. 128)
- Scarab in white frit, Cape Gelidonya, area G, Sc 1, Fig. 150 (p. 143)
- Scarab-shaped plaque inscribed on both faces, Cape Gelidonya, area G, Sc 3, Fig. 150 (p. 145)
- Haematite cylinder seal, Area M IV, Figs. 152–154 (p. 148)
- Sphendonoid haematite weight, Cape Gelidonya, area P, W 60, Fig. 146 (p. 137)
- Large stone, possible two-talent weight, Area S, W 61; also St 5 (p. 142)
- Diorite stone, possible weight of 1,000 nesefs, Area P IV, W 62; also St 7 (p. 142)
- Bracelet embedded in glass beads, Area P, B 188 (p. 132)
- Coiled basketry fragment, Area P, BM 1, Figs. 156a and b (p. 160)
- Model copper or bronze ingot inscribed for Siptah, University Museum, Probably the foundation deposits of Siptah’s funerary temple at Thebes, E 2029, Fig. 162 (p. 173)
- Lead fragment analysed for isotope ratios, Area P, L 22 (p. 170)
People, places and institutions
People
- George Beanheard of the Demeter statue find
- Hakki GültekinIzmir Museum director and expedition representative
- Mustafa Kapkindiver and equipment designer
- Rasim Divanlidiver and equipment designer
- Ahmet Erbincaptain of the sponge trawler that raised the Demeter
- Kemal Arascaptain who located the wreck
- John Cochrandiver who discovered the wreck
- Susan Phippsdiver who discovered the wreck
- Stanton Watermanunderwater explorer who provided a vessel
- Drayton Cochranprovided the Little Vigilant for investigation
- Frédéric Dumaschief diver and excavation adviser
- Andrew Megawidentified the ingots as almost certainly Cypriot
- Eric Sjöqvistidentified the weapons as Cypriot Late Bronze Age
- Porphyrios Dikaiosreported the Enkomi copper-smelting chronology
- Robert Barnesmade an experimental ingot mould
- H. W. Hodgesreported on corrosion and recording
- A. E. Parkinsonchemist who cleaned a model ingot
- Mark C. Hananalysed metal foil and copper ingots
- Sara Immerwahrher view on Mycenaean commerce is discussed
- A. C. Westernreported plant distributions and wood
- E. K. Ralphreported radiocarbon dates
- Robert H. Brillanalysed lead and a bead
- Edward V. Sayreanalysed bead material
- F. R. Dykstraanalysed a tin sample
- A. Milletreported pottery analyses
- David O’Connorstudied Egyptian model ingots
- W. F. Albrightdiscussed Phoenician trade
- Miss Lorimerdiscussed Homer and Phoenician routes
- W. M. Flinders Petrieexcavated Theban temple deposits
- J. E. Quibellexcavated at Thebes with Petrie
Institutions
- University Museum of the University of Pennsylvaniasponsor of the excavation and report
- Izmir Museumsupported the wreck investigation
- French Navy’s Undersea Research Grouplent a diver and camera housing
- American Philosophical Societypublisher and excavation funder
- Bodrum Museumreceived the excavated finds
- Radio-carbon Laboratory of the University of Pennsylvaniadated the hull brushwood
- Jodrell Laboratoryidentified basketry fibres
- Archaeological Research Laboratories at Oxfordconducted pottery analyses
Places
- Cape GelidonyaBronze Age shipwreck excavation site
- Su Adaexcavation camp location
- Bodrumexcavation base and finds depot
- EnkomiCypriot comparison site and copper centre
- Knossossource of Linear B ingot tablets
- Ras ShamraSyrian comparison site for ingots and stands
- MegiddoNear Eastern comparison site for artefacts
- Thebessource of ingot depictions and model ingots
- Antikytheraearly underwater excavation example
- Grand ConglouéFrench underwater excavation example
- Sardiniawestern ingot distribution and trade region
- Finikefresh-water source near the cape
- Mycenaecomparative site for seals and trade
- Ramesseumdisputed provenance for a model ingot
Also named: G. L. Harrington, Gottfried Gruben, Nilsson, Cyrus Gordon, Michael C. Astour, Department of Antiquities on Cyprus, Turkish Antiquities Department, Institute of Archaeology, London University, Mathiati, Yassi Ada, Kourion, Athens, Corinth, Ceos, Sardis, Antioch.
Extent Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, New Series, vol. 57, part 8, pp. 1–177; plates, figures, maps and site plans; index
Defines oxhide ingots, Type 2a, Type 2b, Type 2c, bun ingots, slab ingots
Late Bronze AgeModernCopperTradeSeafaringTechnologyChronology and Dating
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
2 pages- Complex VesselsCompendium
- Copper Metallurgy in Ancient CyprusCompendium
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1934–1974Enkomi: the French MissionDirected by Claude F. A. Schaeffer, Olivier Pelon, Jacques-Claude Courtois (sector director) and othersExcavation
Who did what
17 recordsBuying, selling and giving 1
- p. 155
Major B. SeagerBequeathed toMetropolitan Mus.
The Metropolitan Mus. seal no. 26.31.285 was identified as a Seager bequest.
cylinder sealNo. 26.31.285
Excavation 8
- 1960 · p. 3
George Fletcher BassDug forUniversity Museum of the University of Pennsylvania
George F. Bass directed the Cape Gelidonya excavation for the University Museum of the University of Pennsylvania.
Cape Gelidonya shipwreckCape Gelidonya, Turkey
- 1959 · p. 15
Drayton CochranLent toIzmir Museum
Drayton Cochran placed the Little Vigilant at the disposal of the Izmir Museum for an investigation of the wreck site.
his seventy-foot steel auxiliary ketch, Little Vigilant
- p. 15
Kemal ArasFound
A preliminary report stated that Kemal Aras had discovered the wreck site four years earlier.
the Gelidonya shipwreck siteGulf of Finike, off Anadolu Burnu
- p. 15
Kemal ArasFound
The preliminary report said Kemal Aras took a bronze spear and brought up a small bronze box from the site.
a bronze spear and a small bronze boxthe Gelidonya wreck site
- 1959 · p. 17
John CochranFound
John Cochran and Susan Phipps discovered the wreck by chance during a last dive.
the Cape Gelidonya shipwreckCape Gelidonya
- 1959 · p. 17
Susan PhippsFound
Susan Phipps and John Cochran discovered the wreck by chance during a last dive.
the Cape Gelidonya shipwreckCape Gelidonya
- p. 28
Frédéric DumasExcavated
Frédéric Dumas used a crowbar to pry a lump loose from area P.
- p. 164
Claude Frédéric-Armand SchaefferFound
Schaeffer's discovery at Enkomi was of a god standing on an oxide ingot.
Recording and study 8
- 1958 · p. 14
Peter ThrockmortonPhotographed
Peter Throckmorton and Captain Kemal Aras photographed more than a dozen wrecks or possible wrecks of ancient ships on their first trip.
down the coast
- p. 70
Robert BarnesHelpedGeorge Fletcher Bass
Robert Barnes made a small mold for an oxhide ingot at G. F. Bass's request.
- p. 102
Paul ShawStudied
Paul Shaw identified the swage block after G. F. Bass had guessed its use.
No. B 136Cape Gelidonya
- p. 122
Basil HennessyCatalogued
J. B. Hennessy co-authored the catalogue of pottery from Cape Gelidonya.
pottery from the Cape Gelidonya shipwreck
- p. 122
Joan du Plat TaylorCatalogued
J. du Plat Taylor co-authored the catalogue of pottery from Cape Gelidonya.
pottery from the Cape Gelidonya shipwreck
- p. 126
Joan du Plat TaylorCatalogued
J. du Plat Taylor catalogued the stone objects recovered from Gelidonya.
stone objects from Gelidonya
- p. 137
George Fletcher BassCatalogued
Bass catalogued W 60 as a sling bullet before Miss Taylor corrected him.
the first of the Gelidonya weightsNo. W 60Gelidonya
- 1965–1966 · p. 173
A. E. ParkinsonHelpedDavid O'Connor
Parkinson cleaned the ingot at O'Connor's request.
model copper or bronze ingotNo. E 2029
People it is cited for
1 personMentioned in
9 mentionsTomb records · 6
- Enkomi, BM Tomb 48
Discussion · 1967 · p. 124
- Enkomi, SCE Tomb 11
Discussion · 1967 · p. 125
- Enkomi, SCE Tomb 18
Discussion · 1967 · p. 124
- Enkomi, SCE Tomb 6
Discussion · 1967 · pp. 123, 125
- Lapithos-Vrysi tou Barba, SCE Tomb 316
Discussion · 1967 · p. 128
- Larnaca-Laxia tou Riou, CEF Tomb 1
Discussion · 1967 · p. 128
in Tomb 1, Laxia tou Riou (Ashmolean Museum C. 125), both of Middle Cypriot II date
- On Ancient Cyprus · 2listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
- Excavations · 1listed under Excavations it is cited for
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.