Article · 2012
Confronting complexity in the preservation of cultural property: Monuments, art, antiquities, archives, and history. What can Cyprus teach us?
Proceedings of the Annual Meeting (American Society of International Law) 106 462-469
An article on Cyprus's efforts to recover and protect cultural property through litigation, agreements, loans and cooperation, drawing on the Lysi frescoes and the Kanakariá mosaics.
Kline draws on his work with the Republic and the Church of Cyprus to discuss the risks to cultural property and Cyprus's responses. The Lysi frescoes and the Kanakariá mosaics are the case studies, followed by agreements with the United States, recoveries of icons and gospel covers, and future policy.
Kline describes the Menil Foundation's long-term loan of the Lysi frescoes, the Indianapolis litigation over the Kanakariá mosaic fragments, Cyprus's agreements with the United States, and settlements concerning six icons and two silver gospel covers (pp. 463–467).
The Kanakariá litigation, agreements with the United States and Switzerland, and cooperation with German and Dutch authorities appear as parts of one recovery effort. Kline argues for consistent international cooperation and a shift from episodic action to systematic protection, setting out the roles of litigation, import restrictions, long-term loans, public information about losses and engagement with museums and the art market. He recommends maintaining public databases of losses, developing research and educational resources, pursuing claims where necessary, and preferring agreements and long-term loans where possible, and he calls for separating cultural protection from political objectives and involving Turkish Cypriots in protecting shared heritage (pp. 467–469).
What it records
- The 1970 UNESCO Convention defines cultural property as property designated by a state as important for archaeology, prehistory, history, literature, art or science.p. 462
- Dominique de Menil acquired, conserved and exhibited the Lysi frescoes in Houston on long-term loan from the Church of Cyprus.p. 463
- The Lysi frescoes were returning to Cyprus in March 2012 after their display in Houston.p. 463
- The Church of Cyprus recovered four Kanakariá mosaic fragments through litigation in Indianapolis: the adolescent Christ, an Archangel, and portraits of Mathew and James.p. 464
- The court affirmed that the Church of Cyprus had not abandoned the Kanakariá church and its mosaics, because the congregation had been expelled and had not left voluntarily.p. 464
- Professional antiquities and art thieves operated under cover of large-scale looting after the invasion, in Michael Jansen's description.p. 464
- Cyprus became one of the first major source countries, and the first in the Mediterranean region, to enter a CPIA agreement with the United States in 1999, Kline reports.p. 465
- Cyprus and the United States agreed on a full memorandum of understanding concerning archaeological material in 2002.p. 465
- The Pankow Foundation established that the six icons it offered for sale had left Cyprus before April 1999, so the agreements between Cyprus and the United States did not apply.p. 466
- The seller agreed to return the silver gospel covers after being presented with information about their likely origin in occupied Cyprus.p. 467
Where to read
- Lysi frescoes and the Menil Foundation long-term loanp. 463
- Kanakariá mosaic recovery and litigationpp. 463–464
- Cyprus’s recovery cases and international cooperationpp. 465–469
Contents
- Cultural Property in Jeopardy462
- Lysi Frescoes: Recovery through Long-Term Loan463
- Kanakari Mosaics: Successful Litigation463
- Significance of the Kanakariá Mosaics Case464
- Cyprus Providing Leadership in Protecting Cultural Property under the 1970 UNESCO Convention and 1983 Cultural Property Implementation Act465
- Upset over Protecting Ancient Coins466
- Additional Efforts by Cyprus to Recover Cultural Objects466
- Summary and Overview of Cyprus's Leadership Role467
- International Context of Cyprus's Efforts467
- For Cyprus to Achieve the Next Level of Protection, International Cooperation Is Required468
- Conclusion469
Objects published here
4- Christ Pantocrator fresco from the Church of Ayios Themonianos, Church of Cyprus, Church of Ayios Themonianos in Lysi (p. 463)
- Adolescent Christ mosaic fragment, Church of Cyprus, Church of Panagia Kanakariá, Lythrankomi (p. 464)
- Six icons returned as part of a settlement, Churches in the occupied area, for some of the icons (p. 466)
- Silver gospel covers, Church of the Archangel in Zodia (p. 466)
People, places and institutions
People
- Aydin Dikmannamed as a suspected smuggler
- Dominique de Menilarranged the frescoes' long-term loan
- Michael Jansenwrites about looting after the invasion
- Maria Paphitistudied the six icons
Institutions
- Church of Cyprusclaims ownership and pursues recoveries
- Republicworks with the Church on cultural property
- Menil Foundationconserved and exhibited the Lysi frescoes
- Dumbarton Oaks Byzantine Research Centerconserved and published mosaic evidence
- U.S. Customsdeclined to intervene over the mosaics
- Pankow Foundationoffered six icons for sale
- Smithsonian Institutionhosted an exhibition of Cypriot material
Places
- Church of Ayios Themonianos in Lysichurch from which the frescoes were removed
- Church of Panagia Kanakariáchurch whose mosaics were removed
- Lythrankomivillage where the Kanakariá church stands
- Zodiatown identified as the likely origin of the gospel covers
Also named: Michel van Rijn, Andreas Kakouris, Cyprus Antiquities Department, Karpass Peninsula.
Extent pp. 462–469
Defines cultural property
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageWho did what
5 recordsBuying, selling and giving 3
- p. 463
Dominique de MenilAcquired
Icons and church artDominique de Menil acquired the frescoes; they were exhibited in Houston on long-term loan from the Church.
With a smuggler in Munichthe Lysi frescoes
- p. 463
Thomas R. KlineAgent forthe Church of Cyprus
Icons and church artThomas R. Kline served as lead counsel for the Church of Cyprus in litigation over the Kanakariá mosaics.
Indianapolis, Indiana
- p. 463
Thomas R. KlineAgent forthe Republic of Cyprus
Icons and church artThomas R. Kline served as lead counsel for the Republic of Cyprus in litigation over the Kanakariá mosaics.
Indianapolis, Indiana
Recording and study 2
- p. 462
Thomas R. KlineWorked withthe Republic of Cyprus
Thomas R. Kline worked with the Republic of Cyprus to protect Cypriot cultural heritage.
- p. 462
Thomas R. KlineWorked withthe Church of Cyprus
Thomas R. Kline worked with the Church of Cyprus to protect Cypriot cultural heritage.
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.