Scholar
Noël H. Gale
fl. 1980–2019
Oxford nuclear physicist (1931–2014) who, with Zofia Stos-Gale, used lead isotopes to trace Bronze Age copper and argued that most later oxhide ingots were made of copper from Apliki in Cyprus.
Biography
Noël Harold Gale was an Oxford physicist who turned lead isotope analysis to the provenance of Bronze Age metals, and who argued, with Zofia Stos-Gale, that most copper oxhide ingots made after about 1400 BC came from the Apliki ore deposit in Cyprus7,8.
From physics to archaeology
Gale was born on 24 December 1931 in Valletta, Malta, where his father was serving in the Royal Navy9. Zofia Stos-Gale calls him a star pupil of Brockenhurst Grammar School10. As a Royal Scholar he read physics and mathematics under Sir George Thomson at the Royal College of Science, Imperial College, London11. He began a PhD at St Bartholomew's Hospital, London, on nuclear physics applied to medicine, then changed to pure physics and finished the degree at the University of Manchester7,10.
He worked for several years at the Harwell Laboratory of the Atomic Energy Research Establishment until the early 1960s, when the University of Oxford's Department of Geology (later Earth Sciences) employed him to build one of the earliest mass spectrometers used in isotope geochronology7. According to Stos-Gale, his work in the department's Age Laboratory led in 1975 to a meeting with Wolfgang Gentner of Heidelberg University, who proposed that they collaborate on using lead isotopes to find the origin of ancient Greek silver coinage10. Soon afterwards Colin Renfrew suggested to him that Bronze Age sources of lead and silver in the Aegean would make a good project10. Gale's own account is that Renfrew directed his work towards Bronze Age Mediterranean archaeology, leading to the founding of the Isotrace Laboratory in 1978 with his wife and colleague, Zofia Stos-Gale11.
The Oxford programme and Cyprus
Writing in 1989, the Gales said that seven years earlier they had started the first systematic research programme applying lead isotopes to provenance in archaeology12. For the first two years they worked mostly on sources of lead and silver in Bronze Age Greece, Cyprus and Egypt, and in 1982 they pioneered the method for copper-based artefacts12. By then they had explored ore deposits in Greece, Cyprus, Sardinia and the Sinai over eight years12.
Their 1986 paper on oxhide ingots from Cyprus and from Hagia Triadha in Crete reported preliminary work, and claimed that lead isotope geochemistry "bids fair to succeed where other approaches have largely failed"13. It stated that oxhide ingots "have a special connection with Cyprus"13. The Gales could not yet identify the copper of the Hagia Triadha ingots, which they suggested may have come from Anatolia13.
In 1991 Gale published new trace-element analyses and some metallographic evidence for Chalcolithic metal objects and native copper from Cyprus, with a lead isotope analysis for the one object that gave a large enough sample5. He concluded that the known Chalcolithic copper objects were probably not made of Cypriot native copper, that the start of metallurgy on the island was not connected with picrolite, and that the one analysed object was not of Cypriot copper5. Twenty years later Edgar Peltenburg still called this the most recent survey of copper use in Cyprus before the Early Bronze Age, built on nine certain artefacts from systematic excavations14. Peltenburg set it beside James D. Muhly's view that the objects were of native copper, against Gale's doubt that they represented "any use of Cypriot copper ores at all"14. Peltenburg removed the axe KM 457 from Gale's list, since it came from disturbed Early Bronze Age levels at Kissonerga; Gale had used its lead isotope result, pointing to northwestern Anatolia, to argue that some Chalcolithic copper came from abroad14. Peltenburg argued that Philia metalwork should be kept out of the Chalcolithic14.
Also in 1991, Gale estimated that 130 oxhide ingots had been found on land sites15. In the Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East, the bibliography of the Uluburun entry by Cemal Pulak and George F. Bass notes his oxhide-ingot paper as a "demonstration of the Cypriot origin of the Ulu Burun copper"2. Gale's analyses also reached single objects: Serena Sabatini and Fulvia Lo Schiavo report that his analysis of the lead clamp on a Nuragic jar from Pyla-Kokkinokremos confirmed a source at Sa Duhessa in the Sulcis district of Sardinia16. Bettelli and Lo Schiavo cite his then unpublished analyses as showing that an oxhide-ingot fragment in the Florence collection had travelled anciently from Cyprus to Crete17.
The Apliki debate
Before 1995 only 33 lead isotope analyses of Cypriot ores existed, among them a single Apliki ore donated by Tylecote8. In 1995 the Gales organised a field trip to Cyprus with the Cypriot Geological Survey Department, and G. Maliotis, chief geologist of the Hellenic Mining Co. Ltd., took them to many mines they could not otherwise have entered, Apliki among them8. Gale records a second field trip in 199618. Nearly 200 new analyses of ores from 26 Cypriot copper mines followed, published in 19978,18.
In 2001 Gale argued that no Mediterranean-wide mixing or recycling of copper was needed to explain post-1250 BC oxhide ingots, since they matched the Apliki region of Cyprus; the paper set out to correct "misconceptions" in A. Bernard Knapp's papers of 1999 and 200011. Knapp, for his part, wrote in 2000 that the Oxford team had at first held that lead isotopes could give conclusive evidence only negatively, ruling a source out, and that their later work "has not infrequently overlooked this principle"19. He also recalled Chippindale's attack on lead isotope analyses, made with reference to papers in Archaeometry19.
In 2011 Gale wrote that LM IB oxhide ingots from Gournia and Mochlos were also of Apliki copper, so that the deposit seems to have been used before 1250 BC, perhaps as early as 1550 to 1400 BC18. He insisted that the Apliki finding was "an empirical conclusion, not remotely anticipated", and noted reservations from Knapp, Vassiliki Kassianidou and Muhly18. He held that new analyses of cores drilled through Uluburun ingots validated the method18.
Giampaolo Graziadio reports Muhly's objection that the Gales said the copper of all post-1250 BC artefacts was not from Apliki while the contemporary ingots were20. Graziadio also reports Muhly's point that only about 16 per cent of 300 analysed Neopalatial Cretan artefacts were of Cypriot copper20. Knapp wrote in 2012 that Apliki copper was almost never used for artefacts and that, as Kassianidou had set out, many archaeologists found the one-mine idea hard to accept21. Knapp also recorded Gale's 2009 reply charging Pollard with complaints unbacked by data, and still wrote that he had "little doubt" the lead isotope data were "objective"21.
In the same 2012 volume the Gales restated their thesis, which they said had "proved unexpectedly controversial"8. They wrote that doubters had found it hard "to produce logical arguments or proven evidence against it", and called Muhly's claim that no bronzes were of Apliki copper "in fact incorrect"8. They charged Knapp, Kassianidou and Muhly with rejecting Apliki while accepting, largely from lead isotopes, that most ingots were of Cypriot copper, and called the debate that followed the method's introduction "sterile and largely useless" and "full of errors"8. Against Kassianidou's objections that Apliki was smaller than Mavrovouni and Skouriotissa, highest on the Troodos foothills and farthest from the sea, they cited reserves of 1.85 million short tons, and wrote that only one who had not seen its open-cast pit could call it, as Muhly had, "a fairly small mine"8. They concluded that if Apliki were rejected there would be no evidence left that oxhide ingots were of Cypriot copper, that some Cypriot bronzes were of Apliki copper, and that the Enkomi slags showed very limited use of Apliki ore8.
By 2018 Kassianidou wrote, citing Gale, that Apliki was "most probably" the mine that produced the copper for the vast majority of oxhide ingots found in Cyprus and abroad22. In a chapter of Beyond Cyprus, Vasiliki Kassianidou credits the work of Noel Gale and Zofia Stos-Gale with showing the extent of the trade in Cypriot copper through the eastern Mediterranean and beyond15.
Oxford and his last years
Gale became a faculty fellow of Nuffield College in 1987 and an emeritus fellow in 19999. In 2001 he was emeritus Director of the Isotrace Laboratory, Dean of Nuffield College and Professor of Archaeological Science, and associate editor of Archaeometry11. Richard Mayou recalled that his change from nuclear physicist to archaeologist bewildered colleagues and caused "epic administrative problems" over his duties and departments9. Gale also opposed the changes to Oxford's governance put forward by the vice-chancellor John Hood9. Stos-Gale writes that the controversy over the method helped refine it and kept it on strong scientific grounds, and his Oxford notice says he raised the technique to a standing among archaeologists like that of carbon-14 dating7,10.
Gale died of cancer on 3 February 20149. The sources name two wives: Gale's 2001 note calls Zofia Stos-Gale his wife, and Matthew Reisz's obituary says he was survived by his third wife, Daphne Robertson-Hicks, with three sons and five grandchildren9,11.
Life and work
1989
December
Conference at Rewley House, Oxford, on Bronze Age trade in the Mediterranean; Gale edited the resulting volume (Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology 90, 1991).
1991
- Published 'Copper Oxhide Ingots: Their Origin and their Place in the Bronze Age Metals Trade in the Mediterranean', pp. 197-239; the Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East summarises it as demonstrating the Cypriot origin of the Uluburun copper.
Robert Stuart Merrillees (2014). George Basil Palma, Chemist and Collector of Cypriote Antiquities in Famagusta, Cyprus, in the 20th Century A.D.. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 44, 401-429; Eric M. Meyers (ed.) (1997). The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East. New York, Oxford University Press
2019
- Said in the recorded talk «A Conference in Honour of A. Bernard Knapp: Late Cypriot Copper Production and Memory Landscapes at Petras, Crete» (Archaeological Research Unit - University of Cyprus, 2019-06-06): Had done lead isotope analyses on material from Ayios Dhimitrios.
Connections
4 peopleFamily
- Married to Zofia Anna Stos-GaleThe biographical note identified Zofia Stos-Gale as Noel Gale's wife. Gale 2001, p. 129
Disputes & the law
- Rival of James D. MuhlyApliki copper ingots lead isotope interpretation NICHOLAS CHR. STAMPOLIDIS; VASSOS KARAGEORGHIS, ΠΛΟΕΣ Sea Routes Interconnections in the Mediterranean 16th-6th Centuries BC: Proceedings of the International Symposium held at Rethymnon, Crete, September 29t (2003), p. 1442002
Scholarship
- Wrote with John WalshChalcolithic Cyprus Walsh et al., Chalcolithic Cyprus, 19911991
- Wrote with Zofia Anna Stos-GaleOxford Isotrace laboratory lead isotope database and oxhide ingot studies N. H. Gale; Z. A. Stos-Gale; G. Maliotis; N. Annetts, 1997, Lead isotope data from the Isotrace Laboratory, Oxford: archaeometry data base 4, ores from Cyprus, pp. 237-246
Colleagues & contacts
- Worked with Zofia Anna Stos-GaleApliki copper ingots lead isotope analysis; Bronze Age Copper Sources in the Mediterranean NICHOLAS CHR. STAMPOLIDIS; VASSOS KARAGEORGHIS, ΠΛΟΕΣ Sea Routes Interconnections in the Mediterranean 16th-6th Centuries BC: Proceedings of the International Symposium held at Rethymnon, Crete, September 29t (2003), p. 144; Hans-Günter Buchholz, Ugarit, Zypern und Ägäis: Kulturbeziehungen im zweiten Jahrtausend v.Chr. (1999), p. 1991982–2002
- Worked with Vassos KarageorghisTwo silver ingots from Cyprus Lead isotopes and archaeometallurgy (2009), p. 1421983
Recording and study
7 records- Studied6
Noël H. Gale researched sources of lead and silver in Bronze Age Greece, Cyprus, and Egypt.
N. H. Gale analyzed copper droplets from the mold and found their lead isotope ratios consistent with a Cypriot source.
Copper droplets from the Ras Ibn Hani ingot moldRas Ibn HaniJones, p. 228
Nöel H. Gale carried out lead isotope analysis on the jar's lead clamp.
Lead clamp on a Nuragic jar from Pyla-KokkinokremosPyla-Kokkinokremos, CyprusSabatini & Schiavo 2020, p. 10
Gale analysed Early Cypriot copper-based objects from Vounous, Cyprus.
Early Cypriot copper-based objects from Vounous tombsNo. T111.51-53; T161.43-48; T15.73; T15.80Gale 1991, p. 49
Gale carried out lead isotope analysis of the axe KM 457 and copper ore KM 633 from Kissonerga-Mosphilia.
copper axe butt KM 457 and copper ore KM 633 from Kissonerga-Mosphilia, lead isotope analysisNo. KM 457; KM 633Gale 1991, p. 53
probablyThe Gales' lead isotope analysis programme at Oxford University was expected to help attribute copper and bronze provenance.
copper and bronze objects found elsewhereSouth & Todd 1985, p. ?
- Surveyed1
Noël H. Gale explored ore deposits in Greece, Cyprus, Sardinia, and the Sinai.
Mentioned in
29 mentionsDocuments · 19
- On the structure and composition of copper and tin ingots excavated from the shipwreck of Uluburun
2002
discussed lead isotope provenance work
Hauptmann et al. 2002
- Archaeology, science-based archaeology and the Mediterranean Bronze Age metals trade: a contribution to the debate
Family · p. 129
The biographical note identified Zofia Stos-Gale as Noel Gale's wife.
Gale 2001
- Bronze Age Archaeometallurgy of the Mediterranean: The Impact of Lead Isotope Studies
p. 164
Noël H. Gale researched sources of lead and silver in Bronze Age Greece, Cyprus, and Egypt.
Gale & Stos-Gale 1989
- In Quest of Cypriote Copper Traders: Excavations at Ayios Dhimitrios
Probably · ?
The Gales' lead isotope analysis programme at Oxford University was expected to help attribute copper and bronze provenance.
South & Todd 1985
- Late Bronze Age Metal Exploitation and Trade: Sardinia and Cyprus
p. 10
Nöel H. Gale carried out lead isotope analysis on the jar's lead clamp.
Sabatini & Schiavo 2020
- Metals and Metallurgy in the Chalcolithic Period
pp. 49, 53
Gale analysed Early Cypriot copper-based objects from Vounous, Cyprus.
Gale 1991
Lectures and videos · 3
- Under the Mediterranean: Harbours at Amathus, Dreamer's Bay and Paphos, and the Carob and Copper Trades
2017
Empereur et al. 2017
- A Conference in Honour of A. Bernard Knapp: Late Cypriot Copper Production and Memory Landscapes at Petras, Crete
2019
Kassianidou & Rupp 2019
- Cypriot copper production, consumption and trade in the 12th century BC
2021
Kassianidou 2021
On Ancient Cyprus · 3
- People · 4listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.Robert Stuart Merrillees (2014). “George Basil Palma, Chemist and Collector of Cypriote Antiquities in Famagusta, Cyprus, in the 20th Century A.D.”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 44, 401-429. Online
- 2.Eric M. Meyers (ed.) (1997). The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East. New York, Oxford University Press.
- 3.S. Rogge (ed.), C. Ioannou (ed.), T. Mavrojannis (ed.) (2019). Salamis of Cyprus: History and Archaeology from the Earliest Times to Late Antiquity. Münster, Waxmann.
- 4.N. H. Gale (1991). “Copper Oxhide Ingots: Their Origin and Their Place in the Bronze Age Metals Trade in the Mediterranean”. Bronze Age Trade in the Mediterranean, 197-239. Jonsered.
- 5.N. Gale (1991). “Metals and Metallurgy in the Chalcolithic Period”. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 282-283, 37-62.
- 6.N. H. Gale (ed.) (1991). Bronze Age Trade in the Mediterranean. Jonsered, Åström.
- 7.OXALID, University of Oxford (2014). “Noël Harold Gale, MA, DSc, PhD, BSc, ARCS, FSA”. Oxford Archaeological Lead Isotope Database (OXALID). Online
- 8.Noël H. Gale and Zofia A. Stos-Gale (2012). “The role of the Apliki mine region in the post c. 1400 BC copper production and trade networks in Cyprus and in the wider Mediterranean”. V. Kassianidou and G. Papasavvas (eds), Eastern Mediterranean Metallurgy and Metalwork in the Second Millennium BC (Oxford: Oxbow).
- 9.Matthew Reisz (2014). “Noel Gale, 1931-2014”. Times Higher Education (6 March 2014). Online
- 10.Zofia Stos-Gale (2014). “Noël Harold Gale. 24 December 1931–3 February 2014”. Aegeus Society, News (5 March 2014). Online
- 11.Noel Gale (2001). “Archaeology, science-based archaeology and the Mediterranean Bronze Age metals trade: a contribution to the debate”. European Journal of Archaeology 4.1, 113-130.
- 12.Noël H. Gale and Zofia A. Stos-Gale (1989). “Bronze Age Archaeometallurgy of the Mediterranean: The Impact of Lead Isotope Studies”. Archaeological Chemistry IV (Advances in Chemistry 220). American Chemical Society.
- 13.N. H. Gale and Z. A. Stos-Gale (1986). “Oxhide Copper Ingots in Crete and Cyprus and the Bronze Age Metals Trade”. The Annual of the British School at Athens 81, 81-100.
- 14.Edgar Peltenburg (2011). “Cypriot Chalcolithic Metalwork”. Metallurgy: Understanding How, Learning Why. Studies in Honor of James D. Muhly (Prehistory Monographs 29). INSTAP Academic Press.
- 15.Vasiliki Kassianidou. “Tracing Cypriot connectivity with the Eastern Mediterranean and beyond through the trade of copper and other metals”. G. Bourogiannis (ed.), Beyond Cyprus: Investigating Cypriot Connectivity in the Mediterranean from the Late Bronze Age to the End of the Classical Period (AURA Supplement 9).
- 16.Serena Sabatini and Fulvia Lo Schiavo (2020). “Late Bronze Age Metal Exploitation and Trade: Sardinia and Cyprus”. Materials and Manufacturing Processes. Online
- 17.M. Bettelli and F. Lo Schiavo (2010). “La raccolta del Museo archeologico di Firenze nel quadro della storia del collezionismo di antichità cipriote in Italia”. Researches in Cypriote History and Archaeology.
- 18.Noël H. Gale (2011). “Copper Oxhide Ingots and Lead Isotope Provenancing”. Metallurgy: Understanding How, Learning Why. Studies in Honor of James D. Muhly (Prehistory Monographs 29), ed. P. P. Betancourt and S. C. Ferrence, 213-220. INSTAP Academic Press.
- 19.A. Bernard Knapp (2000). “Archaeology, science-based archaeology and the Mediterranean Bronze Age metals trade”. European Journal of Archaeology 3.1, 31-56.
- 20.Giampaolo Graziadio (2025). The Aegean and Cyprus: Interaction Between Two Distinct Cultural Mediterranean Areas from the Third Millennium to ca. 1200 BC.
- 21.A. Bernard Knapp (2012). “Metallurgical production and trade on Bronze Age Cyprus: views and variations”. V. Kassianidou and G. Papasavvas (eds), Eastern Mediterranean Metallurgy and Metalwork in the Second Millennium BC (Oxford: Oxbow).
- 22.Vasiliki Kassianidou (2018). “Apliki Karamallos on Cyprus: the 13th century BCE miners' settlement in context”. Mining for Ancient Copper: Essays in Memory of Beno Rothenberg (Tel Aviv University Monograph Series 37).
- 23.N. H. Gale (2001). “Archaeology, science-based archaeology and the Mediterranean Bronze Age metals trade: a contribution to the debate”. European Journal of Archaeology 4, 113-130.
- 24.Noël H. Gale, Zofia A. Stos-Gale (1989). “Bronze Age Archaeometallurgy of the Mediterranean: The Impact of Lead Isotope Studies”. Archaeological Chemistry IV, 159-198. American Chemical Society.
- 25.Michael Rice Jones. “Oxhide Ingots, Copper Production, and the Mediterranean Trade in Copper and Other Metals in the Bronze Age”. MA thesis.
- 26.Serena Sabatini, Fulvia Lo Schiavo (2020). “Late Bronze Age Metal Exploitation and Trade: Sardinia and Cyprus”. Materials and Manufacturing Processes.
- 27.Alison K. South, Ian A. Todd (1985). “In Quest of Cypriote Copper Traders: Excavations at Ayios Dhimitrios”. Archaeology 38, 40-47. Archaeological Institute of America. Online
- 28.Vasiliki Kassianidou and David Rupp, «A Conference in Honour of A. Bernard Knapp: Late Cypriot Copper Production and Memory Landscapes at Petras, Crete», recorded conference paper, A Conference in Honour of A. Bernard Knapp: The Archaeology of Cyprus and the Wider Mediterranean, Archaeological Research Unit - University of Cyprus, published on YouTube 2019-06-06, at 0:28:10. Online
- 29.Walsh et al., Chalcolithic Cyprus, 1991.
- 30.Lead isotopes and archaeometallurgy (2009).
- 31.NICHOLAS CHR. STAMPOLIDIS; VASSOS KARAGEORGHIS, ΠΛΟΕΣ Sea Routes Interconnections in the Mediterranean 16th-6th Centuries BC: Proceedings of the International Symposium held at Rethymnon, Crete, September 29t (2003).
- 32.N. H. Gale, 2001, Archaeology, science-based archaeology and the Mediterranean Bronze Age metals trade: a contribution to the debate.
- 33.J. Walsh et al., 1991, Chalcolithic Cyprus.
- 34.Hans-Günter Buchholz, Ugarit, Zypern und Ägäis: Kulturbeziehungen im zweiten Jahrtausend v.Chr. (1999).
- 35.N. H. Gale; Z. A. Stos-Gale; G. Maliotis; N. Annetts, 1997, Lead isotope data from the Isotrace Laboratory, Oxford: archaeometry data base 4, ores from Cyprus.
- 36.Jeffrey S. Soles; Costis Davaras; Joanna Bending; Tristan Carter; Despina Kondopoulou; Dimitra Mylona; Maria Ntinou; Ann M. Nicgorski; David S. Reese; Anaya Sarpaki; Werner H. Schoch; Mary Ellen Soles; Vassilis Spatharas; Zophia A. Stos-Gale; Donald H. Tarling; Christopher Witmore, Mochlos IC Period III. Neopalatial Settlement on the Coast: The Artisans' Quarter and the Farmhouse at Chalinomouri. The Small Finds (2004).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Date of birth unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.