Article · 2001
Archaeology, science-based archaeology and the Mediterranean Bronze Age metals trade: a contribution to the debate
European Journal of Archaeology 4(1) 113-130
An article on lead isotope evidence for the sources of Bronze Age copper oxide ingots, answering a discussion of science-based archaeology and disputing explanations by pooling and recycling.
Gale answers Bernard Knapp's discussion of science-based archaeology by going back over the lead isotope evidence for copper oxide ingots and the Mediterranean Bronze Age metals trade. He separates the source of the ingots dated after 1250 BCE from the several copper sources that supplied Cypriot tools and weapons.
His discussion compares lead isotope measurements from Cypriot and Sardinian ores, oxide ingots, copper artefacts and slags, together with trace-element analyses, furnace evidence from Enkomi and Kition, and a comparison of ingots and artefacts from the Cape Gelidonya wreck (pp. 116–124). Gale argues that the ingots after 1250 BCE match ores from the Apliki region of Cyprus. Gale keeps the Apliki ore deposit apart from the small settlement of Apliki Karamallos, and holds that Politiko Phorades and other Troodos sites show multiple sources behind other copper production. He rejects explanations that pool Cypriot ores or mix metal across a Mediterranean-wide network.
The change of source around 1250 BCE is central to the argument. Gale sets the earlier ingots, among them those from Hagia Triadha and Uluburun, against the later ones: the earliest ingots he discusses came from an unknown source, probably outside the Mediterranean, and the Uluburun ingots from another unknown source, probably Cypriot but not Apliki. All ingots after 1250 BCE he assigns to the Apliki deposit or its environs, and Cypriot tools and weapons to copper sources around the Troodos (pp. 125–126).
What it records
- Apliki Karamallos, a small archaeological site, is distinct from the larger Apliki copper mine and ore deposit, in Gale's account.p. 114
- Oxide ingots dated after 1250 BCE appear to have been made from copper of the Apliki deposit or its vicinity, Gale states.p. 115
- Lead isotope analyses of slag from Politiko Phorades show that the ores smelted there did not come from the Apliki deposit.p. 115
- The mean arsenic concentration is 0.45 per cent in Cypriot oxhide ingots and 0.46 per cent in Sardinian ones.p. 117
- The artefacts from the Cape Gelidonya wreck show a broad range of lead isotope compositions, while its oxhide ingots show a narrow range, Gale argues.p. 124
Where to read
- Lead isotope evidence for ingots after 1250 BCE and Aplikipp. 119–125
- Against pooling of ores and recycling as the source of oxide ingotspp. 120–125
- Cape Gelidonya artefacts and oxide ingots comparedpp. 123–125
Contents
- Introduction113
- Detailed Critique114
- Interpretation of Lead Isotopes118
- Mixing and Recycling120
- Recycling122
- Conclusions125
- Acknowledgements126
- References126
- Biographical Note129
- Abstracts130
People, places and institutions
People
- Bernard Knappauthor of the position Gale answers
Institutions
- Isotrace Laboratorycarried out lead isotope analyses
Places
- Aplikicopper mine and ore source for the ingots
- Apliki Karamallossmall Late Bronze Age settlement near the deposit
- Politiko PhoradesBronze Age copper smelting site
- Troodos Mountainsregion of multiple copper sources
- Hagia Triadhafindspot of earlier oxhide ingots
- Uluburun ship-wreckfindspot of ingots dated to about 1300 BCE
- Cape Gelidonya Bronze Age shipwreckwreck with ingots and copper artefacts
- Sardiniafindspot of oxhide ingots and copper artefacts
Also named: Mavrovouni, Skouriotissa, Enkomi, Kition, Kalavassos.
Extent pp. 113–130, 2 figs; bibliography
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- Under a KilogramArticle
Who did what
1 recordPosts and family 1
- p. 129
Noël H. GaleMarried toZofia Anna Stos-Gale
The biographical note identified Zofia Stos-Gale as Noel Gale's wife.
People it is cited for
1 person- A. Bernard Knapp2 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.