Thesis

Oxhide Ingots, Copper Production, and the Mediterranean Trade in Copper and Other Metals in the Bronze Age

Michael Rice Jones

MA thesis

A master's thesis on Bronze Age copper production and trade around the Mediterranean, with oxhide ingots, Cypriot copper and the Uluburun cargo as its main evidence.

Jones surveys the production and trade of copper and tin in the eastern and central Mediterranean in the Bronze Age, drawing on written records, shipwreck cargoes, mining and smelting sites, and analyses of copper objects. Oxhide ingots and Cyprus as a supplier of copper receive most attention, along with the Uluburun ingots and the Cypriot production sites. The thesis runs to nine chapters and three appendices, followed by the works cited and a vita.

How it is organised

Chapters I and II introduce the subject and review the textual evidence for copper production and exchange. Chapters III and IV turn to ingot forms and marks, then to copper-ore processing and smelting technology. Chapters V and VI survey metal sources and trade routes, followed by lead-isotope and trace-element analyses. Chapter VII examines how ingots were produced and manufactured, Chapter VIII reviews the archaeological evidence for copper production on Cyprus, and Chapter IX discusses the organisation and evolution of the Mediterranean copper trade (pp. 1–340).

Appendix 1 sets out comparative Bronze Age chronologies, Appendix 2 catalogues the locations and contexts of copper oxhide and tin ingot finds, and Appendix 3 is a glossary of metallurgical terms (pp. 415–434).

The evidence

Textual records come from Egypt, the Levant, Anatolia, Mesopotamia and the Aegean, among them the Amarna letters, the Ugaritic archives and the Linear B tablets from Pylos and Knossos. Jones uses them to discuss royal exchange, palace metalworking, merchants and copper deliveries, and also the limits of written evidence for how ore was mined and smelted (pp. 10–70).

For the ingots, Jones compares oxhide, bun or plano-convex, pillow, slab, ovoid and other forms and considers incised and impressed marks. Shipwreck cargoes, above all Uluburun and Cape Gelidonya, are set beside finds from settlements, hoards, tombs and palaces around the Mediterranean, with attention to weights, surfaces, transport and the possible uses of marks (pp. 71–109, 202–210).

A chapter on technology covers ore beneficiation, smelting and refining, fuel, furnaces, slag and forced-draught equipment. Jones compares the metallurgical remains with proposed reconstructions of furnaces and casting, and stresses that installations are hard to identify where workshops were repeatedly altered or their debris reused (pp. 110–143, 211–238).

The survey of copper and tin sources ranges across Cyprus, Crete, the Aegean, Anatolia, Sardinia and other regions, and a separate chapter explains lead-isotope and trace-element methods, including the limits of assigning objects to ore sources, as applied to ingots and to other copper and bronze objects (pp. 144–201).

The review of Cyprus begins with earlier production evidence at Pyrgos-Mavrorachi and Ambelikou-Aletri, then takes Late Cypriot coastal and inland settlements and mining areas. It discusses slag, furnaces, tuyeres, ingot fragments, workshops and settlement contexts at Enkomi, Kition, Hala Sultan Tekke, Atheniou, Kalavasos Ayios-Dhimitrios, Maroni Vournes, Politiko Phorades and Apliki Karamallos (pp. 239–316).

The argument

Jones proposes three phases in the use and trade of oxhide ingots. In the first, the earliest examples are associated with Minoan centres on Crete, while the ingot shape and the sources of much of the copper remain uncertain. He suggests that the form may have developed in Anatolia or central Asia and that an early copper trade supplied the Aegean from several sources (pp. 317–319).

The second phase coincides with Cyprus becoming a major copper supplier in the 14th and 13th centuries B.C. Levantine cities, particularly Ugarit, appear as consumers and distributors, and Cypriot and other merchants take part in exchanging raw materials and manufactured goods. Jones treats the Uluburun cargo as evidence of the scale and variety of this trade, while noting that its origin and the roles of the merchants remain debated (pp. 319–329).

A third phase is associated with greater production of Cypriot bronze objects, copper finds at sites in the central Mediterranean, and expanding trade after c. 1200 B.C. Jones asks whether the weakening of palace-based exchange let other trading networks grow, and whether Cyprus traded with Sardinia for metals including tin (pp. 329–336).

Within this scheme Jones describes Cyprus as the dominant copper source for much of the eastern Mediterranean by the end of the 14th century B.C. He links the expansion to Cypriot copper and pottery appearing abroad and to a large rise in the number of ingots and fragments found on land. Island-wide centralised control of production he finds ambiguous in the evidence, with local or regional production and seasonal smelting among the possibilities. Workshops at major settlements may have refined and cast metal yet left few traces, since slag, furnaces, crucibles, tuyeres and moulds could be discarded, reused or destroyed, so the thesis weighs town-based production against smaller operations near the ore deposits, including seasonal production or tribute (pp. 321–323, 330–333).

Jones associates copper with ritual activity in some Late Cypriot contexts, particularly at Enkomi and Kition, and considers how copper production, elite power and religious practice were related. He also discusses the growth of metal circulation and trade links between Cyprus and the central Mediterranean after 1200 B.C., observing that the duration and volume of this exchange are difficult to establish (pp. 333–336).

Dating

Period designations come from several regional chronologies. Appendix 1 places the earliest Cretan oxhide ingot evidence in LM IB, c. 1500–1450 B.C., and gives Late Cypriot II A–C as c. 1400–1200 B.C. and Late Cypriot IIIA–IIIB as c. 1200–1050 B.C. Jones treats the expansion of Cypriot copper exports in the 14th and 13th centuries B.C. and the changing trade after c. 1200 B.C. as separate stages in the history of the ingots (pp. 317–320, 415–416).

What it records

  • The foothills of the Troodos Mountains in western and central Cyprus contained the largest accessible copper deposits in the eastern Mediterranean.p. 4
  • Amarna letter EA 33 records the king of Alashia sending 200 units of copper and 10 units of fine copper to Egypt.p. 20
  • Pylos palace records list approximately 300 to 400 copper workers.p. 40
  • Sixty ingots listed on Knossos tablets Oa 730, 733 and 734 have a recorded total weight of approximately 1,562 kg.p. 44
  • A limestone oxhide-ingot mould was found at Ras Ibn Hani, 4.5 km from Ugarit/Ras Shamra.p. 52
  • The Uluburun ship carried 354 complete oxhide ingots, the largest single-site assemblage the thesis describes.p. 73
  • At least 187 Uluburun oxhide ingots and fragments bear incised secondary marks, with at least 52 mark types recorded.p. 97
  • Jones argues that the earliest securely dated oxhide ingots come from an unknown source or sources and that their shape originated outside Cyprus.p. 182
  • In the research Jones cites, all analysed Cypriot ingots from post-1250 B.C. contexts can be traced specifically to the Apliki mining area in northwest Cyprus.p. 184
  • Uluburun copper and bun ingots are typically 98–99% copper.p. 203
  • The Uluburun ship carried 121 or more complete plano-convex ingots.p. 209
  • New Kingdom period furnaces at Timna were capable of producing copper ingots of 3–4 kg.p. 216
  • The Enkomi Area III building measured approximately 45 by 13.3 metres.p. 276
  • The Enkomi Area III slag dump covered an estimated 80 square metres and stood up to one metre high.p. 277
  • The Ashlar Building at Maroni Vournes yielded four oxhide ingot fragments alongside metallurgical debris.p. 301
  • The remains at Politiko Phorades date to c. 1700–1500 B.C.p. 307
  • The excavators estimate from the slag that Politiko Phorades could have produced about 300 kg of copper, enough for roughly ten oxhide ingots.p. 310
  • Excavators at Apliki Karamallos recovered twelve large tuyeres and fragments.p. 311
  • Jones argues that the archaeological evidence for centralised control of copper production on Cyprus remains ambiguous.p. 316

Where to read

  • Amarna letters and Alashian copper deliveriespp. 10–24
  • Pylos, Knossos, Alalakh and Ugarit: palace metalworking recordspp. 40–53
  • Oxhide ingot forms, transport and markspp. 71–109
  • Copper ore processing, smelting, fuel and furnacespp. 110–143
  • Mediterranean copper and tin sources and routespp. 144–166
  • Lead-isotope and trace-element sourcing, including Cyprus and Sardiniapp. 167–201
  • Uluburun ingot composition and castingpp. 202–238
  • Copper production at Enkomi Area III and changing workshop organizationpp. 276–281
  • Metallurgical remains at Kition’s workshops and temple precinctpp. 282–289
  • Conclusions on the stages of oxhide-ingot tradepp. 317–340
  • Appendix catalogue of ingot find locations and contextspp. 417–430
  • Definitions of metallurgical processes and ingot surface featurespp. 431–434

Contents

  • Chapter I: Introduction: Oxhide Ingots, Copper Production, and the Mediterranean Copper Trade in the Bronze Age1
  • Chapter II: Textual Evidence for Copper Production and Trade in the Eastern Mediterranean Bronze Age10
  • Copper Ingots in Egyptian Texts and Tomb Paintings33
  • Textual Evidence for Organized Metalworking in Mycenaean and Syro-Palestinian States40
  • Pylos and Knossos40
  • Alalakh45
  • Ugarit47
  • Textual Evidence for Trade in Metals in Anatolia and the Near East58
  • Mesopotamian Texts and Iconographic Evidence62
  • Chapter III: The Archaeological Contexts and Physical Characteristics of Bronze Age Metal Ingots71
  • Oxhide Ingots71
  • Incised and Impressed Marks on Bronze Age Ingots96
  • Chapter IV: Smelting Technology and the Processing and Smelting of Copper Ores in the Bronze Age110
  • Fuel for Metallurgical Processes123
  • Bronze Age Evidence for Smelting Technology131
  • Chapter V: Copper and Tin Sources in the Mediterranean Region during the Bronze Age144
  • Chapter VI: Sourcing Copper: Lead Isotope and Trace Element Analyses of Copper Ingots and other Bronze Age Copper and Bronze Artifacts167
  • Artifacts178
  • Chapter VII: Bronze Age Metallurgical Production and the Manufacture of Copper Ingots202
  • Ingot Composition and Evidence for Production Processes203
  • Evidence for Bronze-Age Metallurgical Installations and the Casting of Copper Ingots208
  • Chapter VIII: Archaeological Evidence for Copper Production in Late Bronze Age Cyprus239
  • Evidence of Large-Scale Metallurgical Activity Pre-dating the Late Bronze Age/Late Cypriot Period242
  • Late Cypriot Sites and the Copper Trade262
  • Metallurgy in Cypriot Coastal Settlements271
  • Enkomi271
  • Kition282
  • Hala Sultan Tekke290
  • Metallurgy at Inland Settlements292
  • Atheniou293
  • Kalavasos Ayios-Dhimitrios and Maroni Vournes299
  • Late Cypriot Metallurgical Activity in Mining Areas305
  • Politiko Phorades306
  • Apliki Karamallos311
  • Chapter IX: Conclusion. the Organization and Evolution of the Copper Trade in the Bronze-Age Mediterranean317
  • Appendix 1: Bronze Age Chronologies415
  • Appendix 2: Locations and Contexts of Copper Oxhide Ingot and Tin Ingot Finds417
  • Appendix 3: Glossary of Metallurgical Terms431

Objects published here

8
  • Clover-shaped copper ingot from the Uluburun cargo, Uluburun shipwreck, KW 1983, Figure 9a (p. 79)
  • Limestone oxhide ingot mould, Ras Ibn Hani, Syria, Figure 16 (p. 106)
  • Copper oxhide ingot KW 1548, Uluburun shipwreck, KW 1548 (p. 206)
  • Copper ingot fragment IC.241, Mochlos, Artisans’ Quarter, IC.241 (p. 183)
  • Rectangular ingot KW 388, proposed as a pillow ingot, Bodrum Museum of Underwater Archaeology, Uluburun shipwreck, KW 388, KW 388, Figure 25 (p. 211)
  • Rectangular ingot fragment KW 3329, Bodrum Museum of Underwater Archaeology, Uluburun shipwreck, KW 3329, KW 3329, Figure 25; Figure 26 (p. 212)
  • Bun ingots KW 512 and KW 514 with copper fins, Uluburun shipwreck, KW 512; KW 514 (p. 214)
  • Bronze 'Ingot God' statuette, Enkomi, Sanctuary of the Ingot God, Figure 30 (p. 273)

People, places and institutions

People

Places

  • EnkomiCypriot settlement and metallurgical centre
  • Uluburun shipwreckmajor Late Bronze Age ingot cargo
  • Alashiacopper-exporting polity in ancient texts
  • Troodos Mountainscopper deposits and ore sources
  • Kitionsettlement and copper-production site
  • Hala Sultan Tekkesettlement with metallurgical remains
  • Kalavasos Ayios-Dhimitriosregional centre and workshop site
  • Cape GelidonyaLate Bronze Age metal cargo
  • Pylospalace records on bronze workers
  • KnossosLinear B ingot records and workshops
  • Ugaritport and palace trade archives
  • Ras Ibn Haniport and ingot-mould findspot
  • Tell el Amarnaroyal archive and copper correspondence
  • ThebesEgyptian tomb scenes with ingots
  • Creteingot finds and Minoan copper trade
  • SardiniaNuragic ingot finds and metallurgy
  • MochlosMinoan metallurgical deposits and ingot finds
  • AplikiCypriot copper mining area
  • Politiko PhoradesLate Bronze Age smelting site
  • Pyrgos-Mavrorachiearly ore-processing and smelting site
  • Ambelikou-AletriMiddle Cypriot mining and settlement evidence
  • Atheniouinland site with copper-processing remains
  • Maroni VournesLate Cypriot regional centre
  • the ‘Fortress’building with successive copper workshops
  • Timnacopper smelting and mining centre

Also named: Bodrum Museum of Underwater Archaeology, Institute of Nautical Archaeology, Texas A&M University.

Extent pp. 1–435, 3 appendices; works cited pp. 341–414

Defines primary marks, secondary marks, beneficiation, tap slag, Matte, Smelting, Mold surface/Rough surface, Fin

Early Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCopperTradeSeafaringTechnologyCraft Production

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

7 pages

Excavations it is cited for

2 projects

Who did what

4 records

Excavation 1

  • Claude Frédéric-Armand SchaefferExcavated

    Schaeffer's excavations uncovered a presumed temple precinct in the center of Enkomi.

    A presumed temple precinct, later dubbed the “Sanctuary of the Ingot God”

    p. 273

Recording and study 3

  • Michael Rice JonesStudent ofCemal Pulak

    Michael Rice Jones made preliminary notes from post-conservation cataloguing of oxide ingots under Cemal Pulak.

    2003–2004 · p. 97
  • Tom LarsonStudied

    Tom Larson was researching the manufacture of the Uluburun copper bun ingots, including their experimental replication.

    copper bun ingots from the Uluburun wreck

    p. 210
  • Noël H. GaleStudied

    N. H. Gale analyzed copper droplets from the mold and found their lead isotope ratios consistent with a Cypriot source.

    Copper droplets from the Ras Ibn Hani ingot moldRas Ibn Hani

    p. 228

People it is cited for

2 people

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

Missing from this record

  • Date not recorded
  • Publisher not recorded

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.