Article · 2000
The David Plates Revisited: Transforming the Secular in Early Byzantium
The Art Bulletin 82(3) 407-427. College Art Association
An article on the nine David Plates, early seventh-century silver found at Lambousa, Cyprus, read by Leader as domestic display silver that adapts classical heroic narrative to a Christian setting.
Leader examines the nine early seventh-century silver David Plates: their imagery, their find history and their place in early Byzantine art. She reviews the imperial interpretations that read the plates as gifts or as statements about Heraclius, and compares them with Christian images of David, illustrated manuscripts, textiles and mythological silverware. The plates are described by size, shape, stamps and biblical scenes. The find history covers the discovery at Lambousa in 1902, a report that the plates were walled into a niche, and the dispersal of the treasure to collections in Nicosia, New York and Dumbarton Oaks.
Leader questions the imperial readings, noting the lack of direct evidence for a commission and the general character of the plates' ceremonial imagery. The comparative material includes David images at St. Catherine's monastery on Mt. Sinai and in the Sinope Gospels, Coptic textiles, the Quedlinburg Italia and the Kaiseraugst Achilles Plate. She analyses costume, composition, narrative sequence and the domestic display setting of the silver (pp. 417–423).
She argues that the plates present David's youthful story as a Christian counterpart to the classical heroic narratives used on domestic silver. Their focus on David's preparation for kingship is set beside the upbringing of Achilles on the Kaiseraugst plate, and, Leader proposes, the plates' luxury and narrative imagery address elite domestic culture. Leader proposes that viewers could read David's youthful adventures as a form of paideia. Their David narrative works as an independent sequence in a secular setting, while royal signs allow a general, secondary association between David and the Byzantine emperor rather than an allegory of a particular ruler (pp. 421–424).
What it records
- The David Plates are nine circular silver plates in three sizes: one large, four medium and four small.p. 407
- Control stamps on the plates date from 613–29/30 CE, in the reign of Heraclius.p. 407
- The Second Cyprus Treasure, which includes the David Plates, was discovered in 1902 in the ruins of Lambousa.p. 407
- The jewelry was found in a pot beneath a floor and the plates were walled up in a niche, according to the son of one of the finders.p. 407
- The rest of the treasure was smuggled out of Cyprus and sold in Paris; J. Pierpont Morgan bought most of it, and his heirs gave it to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.p. 407
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art holds six of the David Plates and the Museum of Antiquities in Nicosia holds three.p. 407
- Leader argues that the plates were designed as expensive domestic display tableware and that their meaning lies in the Christianisation of the domestic sphere.p. 407
Where to read
- Critiques of imperial readings and the Heraclius proposalspp. 407–416
- David imagery in the Sinai mosaics, Sinope Gospels and luxury manuscriptspp. 417–421
- Domestic silver, the David narrative and Christian paideiapp. 421–424
Contents
- Imperial Readings and Their Problems407
- David as Emperor416
- Old Testament Narratives and Luxury Art418
- Christian Paideia421
- The Secular Transformed424
Objects published here
1- Set of nine circular silver plates showing episodes from the early life of David, Lambousa, Figs. 1–9 (p. 407)
People, places and institutions
People
- Davidbiblical figure depicted on the plates
- Heracliusemperor associated with proposed readings
- GoliathDavid's opponent on the largest plate
- Saulking in the plates' narrative
- Samuelanoints David in the plates' narrative
- Achilleshero on the Kaiseraugst silver plate
- Steven Wanderproposed a Heraclius analogy for the plates
- Suzanne Spain Alexanderinterpreted the plates through Heraclius's Persian Wars
- Mariette van Grunsven-Eygenraamproposed links between David and Heraclius
- James Trillingcompared plate imagery with court poetry
- Kurt Weitzmannstudied the plates' iconographic sources
- John Hansonanalysed interpretations of David imagery
- Philip Griersondiscussed the treasure's gold girdle
- J. Pierpont Morganbought most of the treasure sold in Paris
Institutions
- Metropolitan Museum of Artholds six David Plates
- Dumbarton Oaksholds objects from the Second Cyprus Treasure
- Museum of Antiquities in Nicosiaholds three David Plates
Places
- Lambousafindspot of the Second Cyprus Treasure
- Mt. Sinailocation of church mosaics of David
Also named: Dodd, Karavas.
Extent pp. 407–427, 19 figs; bibliography
Defines paideia
Late AntiqueModernIconographyReligion and CultDaily LifeCollectingHistory of Archaeology
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- LapithosSite
Who did what
1 recordBuying, selling and giving 1
- p. 407
John Pierpont MorganBought
J. Pierpont Morgan bought most of the remainder for a large sum in Paris.
With a dealer in Parismost of the rest of the Second Cyprus Treasurea large sum
People it is cited for
14 people- John Pierpont Morgan5 citations
- Philip Grierson5 citations
- Steven H. Wander4 citations
- Arthur Sambon3 citations
- Erica Cruikshank Dodd3 citations
- J. P. Morgan Jr.3 citations
- Ormonde Maddock Dalton3 citations
- Suzanne Spain Alexander3 citations
- Cecil Smith2 citations
- Judith Dobell2 citations
- Andreas Stylianou
- Ernest McDonald
- Gregori Haji Lambrou
- Josef Strzygowski
Institutions it is cited for
3 institutions- Courtauld Institute of Art2 citations
- King's College London2 citations
- Metropolitan Museum of Art
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.