Book · 2014

Communities of style: Portable luxury arts, identity, and collective memory in the Iron Age Levant

M. H. Feldman

University of Chicago Press

A study of Iron Age Levantine ivories and metalwork, asking how style, memory, ritual use and the reuse of luxury objects formed communities, with case studies from Nimrud, Salamis and Greek sanctuaries.

Feldman studies the portable luxury arts of the early Iron Age Levant, above all carved ivories and decorated metalwork, and asks how making, viewing, inscribing, using and reusing them formed social ties and collective memories. Her case studies range from the Levant and Assyria to Cyprus, Greece and Italy, and the book questions whether stylistic categories can be mapped directly onto individual workshops, city-states or ethnic identities.

The analysis combines formal and technical study of ivories, metal bowls, carved stone reliefs and seals with findspots, architectural and burial contexts, inscriptions, historical records and earlier scholarship.

How it is organised

After an introduction on scope and approach, chapter 1 reviews connoisseurship and challenges the attribution of Levantine ivory styles to bounded workshops. Chapter 2 treats stylistic practices and collective memory, with animal markings as its case study. Chapter 3 turns to Assyrian court style and its representations of foreign goods, chapter 4 to inscribed metal bowls and ritual drinking, and chapter 5 to the reuse and displacement of luxury objects. A conclusion draws the cases together and sets out their implications for materiality and community formation.

The argument

Feldman argues that shared practices of making and appreciating objects form overlapping communities across space and time, so that style cannot be read as the expression of a group already defined by geography or ethnicity. In chapter 1 she criticises connoisseurial attributions that equate style groups with single workshops and city-states, and proposes networks of skilled practice to account for stylistic variation (pp. 11–41).

In chapter 2 Feldman reads recurring animal markings as material practices that link Iron Age works to memories of Late Bronze Age luxury and heroic kingship. Chapter 3 sets against this fluidity a coherent Assyrian court style, which Feldman ties to the representation of foreign people and goods in Assyrian form (pp. 43–110).

Chapter 4 argues that personal inscriptions, decoration and drinking or libating practices tied bowls to named individuals and to later users, making them supports for memory. Chapter 5 sets out distinct pathways of displacement, reuse and recycling, and holds that each object's changing context has to be considered, since trade or imperial distribution alone does not account for them (pp. 111–173).

Feldman concludes that stylistic variation among Levantine ivories and metalwork points to interconnected practices, while the Assyrian court style helped to form a courtly identity through consistent rendering across media. Inscribed bowls and reused objects gained meanings through ritual, memory, changing ownership and deposition, and through their material and visual properties.

The evidence

Chapter 4 follows inscribed bowls found at Nimrud, in Cyprus, in Greece and in Italy. They include a gold bowl inscribed for Yaba from Queens' Tomb II at Nimrud and bowls from the Treasure of Kourion, now in the Metropolitan Museum of Art (pp. 111–137).

Chapter 5 draws on the bronze relief bands of Olympia, ivory assemblages at Nimrud, Til Barsip and Arslan Tash, the Haza'el-inscribed bronzes from Samos and Eretria, and the reused furnishings of Tomb 79 at Salamis. Those furnishings, excavated by Vassos Karageorghis and now in the Cyprus Museum, were refashioned and reused across two burials (pp. 139–173).

Dating

Feldman treats the early Iron Age Levant and surrounding regions as broadly circa 1200–600 BCE, set against a preceding Late Bronze Age that she gives as circa 1600–1200 BCE. Her discussion of stylistic and social change across these periods avoids treating stylistic labels as secure geographic dates, and the case studies include Iron Age objects deposited in later Greek and Italian contexts as well as older objects reused in new settings.

What it records

  • The greater Levant, as Feldman defines it, extends from the southern Levant north to Antioch, northwest into Cilicia and east across the Jabul Plain to the middle and upper Euphrates.p. 4
  • Feldman presents the reception buildings at Zincirli and Hama as settings for the high-status use of luxury ivories and metal objects.p. 5
  • Only about 60 per cent of an elephant tusk is suitable for carving.p. 48
  • Feldman interprets the Assyrian court style as a way of keeping a memory of conquest while making the Other powerless within Assyrian imagery.p. 80
  • Sixteen decorated metal bowls with inscriptions make up the group examined in chapter 4.p. 115
  • The inscribed bowls examined measure 15 to about 21 centimetres in diameter and date between the ninth and seventh centuries BCE.p. 115
  • The inscribed bowls carry Phoenician, Aramaic, possibly Hebrew, Cypriot Greek, Akkadian and hieroglyphic Luwian texts.p. 116
  • The bronze relief bands at Olympia were deposited with other votive objects in Well 17, whose closure is dated to circa 475 BCE.p. 144
  • Twelve carved ivories were excavated at Til Barsip in 1993 and 1994.p. 147
  • Most Arslan Tash ivories came from room 14 of the Bâtiment aux Ivoires, where Feldman argues they may have formed a suite of furniture.p. 151
  • Nine elaborate tombs at Salamis date from the eighth to the sixth centuries BCE.p. 154
  • Tomb 79 is described as the richest of the Royal Tombs at Salamis.p. 154
  • Chair gamma was found almost complete and in situ against the west wall at the bottom of the dromos of Tomb 79.p. 155
  • The ivory overlay of chair gamma is mostly plain plaques, with a gold scale-patterned sheet at the top of its back.p. 155
  • The chair, bed and bronze cauldron belong to the first burial in Tomb 79.p. 155
  • Two large ivory à jour plaques, one with a voluted palmette tree and one with a striding sphinx, are tentatively associated with chair gamma.p. 156
  • The reconstructed bed from Tomb 79 measures 188.5 by 111.2 centimetres.p. 157
  • Karageorghis regards his reconstruction of the Salamis bed as conjectural, resting on the size of the pieces and on analysis by Cyprus Museum technicians and himself, as Feldman notes.p. 157
  • The bronze cauldron from Tomb 79 had a maximum diameter of approximately 86 centimetres and bore eight griffin protomes and four Janus-headed male siren attachments.p. 158
  • Feldman suggests that the Haza'el-inscribed bronzes from Greece originally belonged to the kingdom of 'Unqi and that the inscription was added during Haza'el's reign.p. 166

Where to read

  • Tomb 79 at Salamis: context and two burialspp. 154–155
  • Ivory-inlaid chair gamma and associated à jour plaquespp. 155–157
  • Reconstructed bed and bronze cauldron in Tomb 79pp. 157–160
  • Inscribed bowls, their findspots and languagespp. 113–117
  • Reuse and refashioning of the Salamis tomb furnishingspp. 153–160
  • Arslan Tash ivories and the Bâtiment aux Ivoirespp. 151–153
  • Haza'el’s inscribed frontlet and Eretria blinkerspp. 161–170
  • Nimrud Town Wall Houses and Til Barsip ivory findspp. 146–151

Contents

  • Introduction1
  • Workshops, Connoisseurship, and Levantine Style(s)11
  • Levantine Stylistic Practices in Collective Memory43
  • Creating Assyria in Its Own Image79
  • Speaking Bowls and the Inscription of Identity and Memory111
  • The Reuse, Recycling, and Displacement of Levantine Luxury Arts139
  • Conclusion175

Objects published here

12
  • Ivory-inlaid chair gamma from Tomb 79, Salamis, Cyprus Museum, Tomb 79, Salamis, plate 16 (p. 155)
  • Pair of ivory à jour plaques, palmette tree and striding sphinx, associated tentatively with chair gamma, Cyprus Museum, Tomb 79, Salamis, nos. 258 and 143, plate 17a, b (p. 156)
  • Reconstructed ivory-inlaid bed from Tomb 79, Cyprus Museum, Tomb 79, Salamis, plate 18 (p. 157)
  • Detail of the bed headboard corner pieces, Cyprus Museum, Tomb 79, Salamis, nos. 277 and 251, plate 19 (p. 158)
  • Bronze cauldron with griffin and siren attachments, Cyprus Museum, Tomb 79, Salamis, no. 202, plate 20 (p. 158)
  • Gold bowl inscribed for Yaba, Iraq Museum, Queens' Tomb II, Nimrud, IM 105697, plate 9 (p. 126)
  • Silver bowl naming Epiorwos, son of Dies, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Treasure of Kourion, Cyprus, 74.51.4552, plate 10 (p. 133)
  • Gilt silver bowl naming Akestor and Timokretes, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Treasure of Kourion, Cyprus, 74.51.4554, plate 11 (p. 126)
  • Bronze bowl naming Abipat, The British Museum, Northwest Palace, Nimrud, BM N 19, plate 8 (p. 129)
  • Bronze bowl naming Muwazi, Lamia Archaeological Museum, burial at Tragana, Greece, M3510, fig. 4.1 (p. 114)
  • Bronze horse-bridle frontlet inscribed for Haza'el, Samos Archaeological Museum, Heraion on Samos, fig. 5.5 (p. 162)
  • Bronze horse-bridle blinker inscribed for Haza'el, Athens, National Museum, Temple of Apollo area, Eretria, 15070, fig. 5.6 (p. 163)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Vassos Karageorghisexcavated Tomb 79
  • Haza'elname inscribed on luxury goods
  • Yabanamed on a gold bowl from Queens' Tomb II
  • Katumuwanamed on a funerary stele at Zincirli
  • AshurbanipalAssyrian king shown with foreign furnishings
  • SennacheribAssyrian king in the Lachish reliefs
  • Irene Winterscholar of ivory styles and their distribution
  • Georgina Herrmannscholar of the Nimrud ivories
  • Luigi Palma di Cesnolaassociated with the Treasure of Kourion finds

Places

  • Salamislocation of Tomb 79 and the Royal Tombs
  • Tomb 79elite tomb with reused furnishings
  • Zincirlisite with elite and funerary contexts
  • Hamasite with luxury objects
  • Nimrudfindspot for ivories and metal bowls
  • Arslan Tashprovincial context for ivory furnishings
  • Til Barsipfindspot for ivories in Building C1
  • Olympiafindspot of bronze relief bands
  • Samossanctuary findspot of a Haza'el-inscribed frontlet
  • Eretriasanctuary findspot of Haza'el-inscribed blinkers
  • Nimrud Town Wall Housespost-palatial ivory finds
  • Northwest PalaceAssyrian palace and ivory findspot
  • EnkomiLate Bronze Age ivories used for comparison
  • Tell Halaffindspot of ivories and animal-marked reliefs
  • Kefar Veradimburial findspot of an inscribed bowl
  • PraenesteEtruscan burial findspot of a silver bowl
  • Pontecagnanoreported findspot of a silver bowl
  • Traganaburial findspot of a Luwian-inscribed bowl
  • Bâtiment aux Ivoiresbuilding containing grouped ivory furnishings

Also named: Cyprus Museum, Iraq Museum, The British Museum, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Department of Antiquities, Cyprus.

Extent 20 colour plates, 3 maps, figures numbered by chapter; bibliography pp. 215–239; index pp. 241–249

Defines style-group, habitus, collective memory, Assyrianization, community of practice

Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicMetalworkBurialTradeWritingArchitecture

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Excavations it is cited for

1 project

Who did what

3 records

Excavation 2

  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaFound

    Luigi Palma di Cesnola claimed that he found the bowls in a temple.

    inscribed bowls

    p. 120
  • Vassos KarageorghisExcavated

    Vassos Karageorghis excavated Tomb 79 at Salamis.

    1966 · p. 154

Recording and study 1

  • Vassos KarageorghisStudied

    Vassos Karageorghis reconstructed disassembled ivory plaques as a bed.

    ivory plaques reconstructed as a bedTomb 79, Salamis

    p. 157

People it is cited for

5 people

Mentioned in

7 mentions

Tomb records · 5

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.