Curator · Museum director · Donor · Scholar

Edward Robinson

fl. 1887–1928

Boston curator whose 1893 vase catalogue found modern paint on Cesnola's Cypriot vases, later Director of the Metropolitan Museum, who asked for the Cesnola collection to be examined in 1909.

Biography

Edward Robinson was a classical archaeologist who catalogued the Cypriot vases that Boston had bought from Cesnola, found modern painting on some of them, and was later Director of The Metropolitan Museum of Art13,14. He was born in Boston on 1 November 185813. After graduating from Harvard in 1879 he spent five years in Europe in study13. Winifred E. Howe places those years in Greece and at the University of Berlin15. In 1884 he assembled a collection of casts of classical and Renaissance sculpture for the Slater Memorial Museum at Norwich, Connecticut9,13.

Boston and the Cesnola vases

The sources disagree on when he joined the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston: the Metropolitan's memorial gives 1885, as Curator of Classical Antiquities, while Walter Pach gives 18879,13. Both put his directorship there from 19029,13. Joseph Breck wrote that the greater part of Boston's classical collections was acquired during his curatorship13. He was Lecturer in Classical Archaeology at Harvard in 1893-1894 and 1898-190213.

His Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases (1893) described the vases of Case 2, part of a collection of Cyprian antiquities bought by subscription for the museum from General L. P. di Cesnola in 187214. He classed the first group as the "Alambra Type", vases found at Alambra, near Dali14. On Nos. 193-196, he wrote, "the principal decorations are either wholly or partially modern, although the vases themselves and the minor decorations are genuine"14. The horse on No. 193 was painted in glossy black over a design of another character, and the horned creature on No. 194 was entirely modern, painted over another design14. The main design on No. 195 was copied from a unique Cyprian vase in the British Museum published by Perrot and Chipiez, and the decorations of No. 196 were "apparently entirely modern"14.

In May 1894 The Art Amateur said the catalogue confirmed "beyond further cavil" its position, held since 1880, on the untrustworthiness of Cesnola's statements about his Cyprus discoveries2. The magazine proposed giving "the curator of the Metropolitan Museum of Art" indefinite leave and inviting Robinson to make "a truthful catalogue of the Cesnola collections in New York"2. In 1904 Floyd G. Ballentine wrote that a Cesnola terracotta of a nymph seemed a forgery, and that Robinson had told him "the whole appearance of the figure is against its genuineness"3.

The Metropolitan and the Cesnola collection

The sources differ on the date of his move to New York: Howe makes him the Met's first Assistant Director in 1905; the memorial says he resigned at Boston in 1905 and began as Assistant Director and Curator of Classical Art on 8 January 190613,15. Pach wrote that he left Boston to become director of the Metropolitan9. David C. Preyer wrote in 1909 that the assistant director had special oversight of the antiquities, whose nucleus was the Cesnola collection4. In 1908 the Department of Classical Art rearranged the terracottas, including those of the Cesnola collection16.

The Trustees' report for 1909 says that, since the collection had long been disputed among archaeologists, it was Robinson's wish that it be examined under a disinterested authority, and the Trustees secured John L. Myres of the University of Liverpool17. Myres's preliminary note of June 1909 reported a survey of some twelve working days with results "in the highest degree reassuring", while finding some classes of objects "not of exceptional interest"18. The Trustees wrote that his work confirmed the early Trustees' judgment in buying the collection17. A Duluth newspaper of November 1910 went further and said the examination confirmed Cesnola's claim that the collection was genuine19. In a letter of April 1909, Joseph H. Choate described a dinner at Robinson's house to meet "Prof. Meyer late of Oxford, now of Liverpool", who had come to study the Cesnola Collection11.

He was elected Director on 31 October 1910, after the resignation of Sir Caspar Purdon Clarke13. That month The New York Times reported him showing the newly arranged Cesnola room, whose classification let a visitor trace the development of Cypriot art20. In 1911 Richard Meister thanked him for two paper squeezes and a photograph of a Cesnola inscription, and for a plaster cast of another inscribed stone7. He remained Curator of Classical Art until 192515.

In 1928 Cesnola objects and other duplicates were auctioned at the Anderson Galleries on 30-31 March and 19-20 April21. The New York Times reported that the director, Edward Robinson, had announced the sale and said it was made necessary by the crowded condition of the museum, while the letter printed in the Bulletin says "the Trustees have determined" to sell21,22. Howe records that this first public auction in the Met's history brought slightly over $100,000, and that John Ringling bought extensively15.

Licia Collobi called him "the only well-trained American archaeologist"23. Karageorghis, Mertens and Rose wrote that as directors such as Robinson and Herbert E. Winlock widened the museum's perspectives to Greece, Rome and Egypt, interest in the Cesnola Collection waned12. Robinson died at his home on 18 April 1931, after an illness of several months, still Director13.

Life and work

  1. 1894

    1. Published the Boston Museum of Fine Arts Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases. In the case of Cesnola's Cyprus vases he noted that on Nos. 193-196 the principal decorations were wholly or partly modern, the vases and minor decoration genuine; The Art Amateur read this as confirming its long-held doubts about Cesnola and suggested inviting him to make a truthful catalogue of the Cesnola collections in New York.

      Boston(1894). [Note on E. Robinson's Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases]. The Art Amateur 30(6), p. 4-5

  2. 1904

    1. Told Ballentine, who wrote of him as director of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, that the whole appearance of an inscribed Cesnola terracotta figure (the 'Nymph' of Cyprus, an inscription invoking a rain-deity) told against its genuineness.

      BostonFloyd G. Ballentine (1904). Some Phases of the Cult of the Nymphs. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 15, p. 79

  3. 1909

    1. Described as assistant director of the Metropolitan Museum with special oversight of the Classical Department, whose nucleus was the di Cesnola collection of Cypriote objects.

      New YorkDavid C. Preyer (1909). The Art of the Metropolitan Museum of New York

  4. 1910

    1. Chosen Director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art by its trustees (a newspaper of 15 November 1910 says 'last week'); the article reviews the museum's beginnings under Cesnola.

      New York(1910-11-15). Interpreter and guardian of the aesthetic treasures of the greatest American city. Fort Wayne Sentinel

    2. The Revue archeologique notes that Robinson, when curator of antiquities at the Metropolitan Museum, had planned to submit the Cesnola collection to the revision of a competent judge; the work was recently done by J. L. Myres of Liverpool.

      New York(1910). Chronique: La collection Cesnola a New-York. Revue archeologique, 4th series, 15

  5. 1911

    1. As Director sent the philologist Richard Meister paper squeezes and a photograph of the inscribed Cesnola 'bank' (a stone with a chimaera relief) and a plaster cast of an agate scaraboid seal, both from the Cesnola collection; Meister studied the originals in New York.

      New YorkRichard Meister (1911). Griechische Epigraphik und Dialektologie X. Berichte über die Verhandlungen der Sächsischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig, phil.-hist. Klasse 63, p. 17-18

  6. 1918

    1. Gave a Proto-Corinthian lekythos to the Metropolitan Museum's Department of Classical Art (the Trustees' report for 1918).

      New YorkRobert W. de Forest (1918). Report of the Trustees for the Year MCMXVIII. Metropolitan Museum of Art

  7. 1928

    1. 14 February

      Named as Director on the Metropolitan Museum letterhead of the letter, signed by the President, to Mitchell Kennerley of the Anderson Galleries announcing the Trustees' decision to auction duplicates of the Cesnola Collection and other material in March and April 1928. Nothing in the letter names him as acting.

      New YorkAnderson Galleries (1928). Cypriote & Classical Antiquities: Duplicates of the Cesnola & Other Collections, Part One (sale number 2253, New York, 30-31 March 1928). New York, Anderson Galleries

Connections

4 people

Recording and study

1 record
Employed by1

Objects

Mentioned in

11 mentions

Institutions · 2

  • Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

    Curator of Classical Antiquities, later director (Pach: curator from 1887, director 1902) · 1885

    Edward Robinson's Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases noted that on Cesnola vases Nos. 193-196 the principal decorations were wholly or partly modern…

    Pach 1948; [Note on E. Robinson's Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases] 1894, p. 4-5; [Note on E. Robinson's Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases] 1894

  • Metropolitan Museum of Art

    Curator of antiquities, assistant director (1909), director · 1905

    Preyer 1909; Interpreter and guardian of the aesthetic treasures of the greatest American city 1910; Galleries 1928

Sources

  1. 1.Anderson Galleries (1928). Cypriote & Classical Antiquities: Duplicates of the Cesnola & Other Collections, Part One (sale number 2253, New York, 30-31 March 1928). New York, Anderson Galleries.
  2. 2. (1894). “[Note on E. Robinson's Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases]”. The Art Amateur 30(6).
  3. 3.Floyd G. Ballentine (1904). “Some Phases of the Cult of the Nymphs”. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 15.
  4. 4.David C. Preyer (1909). The Art of the Metropolitan Museum of New York.
  5. 5. (1910). “Chronique: La collection Cesnola a New-York”. Revue archeologique, 4th series, 15.
  6. 6. (1910-11-15). “Interpreter and guardian of the aesthetic treasures of the greatest American city”. Fort Wayne Sentinel.
  7. 7.Richard Meister (1911). “Griechische Epigraphik und Dialektologie X”. Berichte über die Verhandlungen der Sächsischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig, phil.-hist. Klasse 63.
  8. 8.Robert W. de Forest (1918). “Report of the Trustees for the Year MCMXVIII”. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  9. 9.Walter Pach (1948). The Art Museum in America.
  10. 10.Henry Johnson (1906). Descriptive Catalogue of the Art Collections of Bowdoin College.
  11. 11.Edward Sandford Martin (1920). The Life of Joseph Hodges Choate, as Gathered Chiefly from His Letters.
  12. 12.Vassos Karageorghis; Joan R. Mertens; Marice E. Rose (2000). Ancient Art from Cyprus: The Cesnola Collection in the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  13. 13.Joseph Breck; Trustees of the Metropolitan Museum of Art (1931). “In Memoriam: Edward Robinson”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 26(5).
  14. 14.Edward Robinson (1893). Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.
  15. 15.Winifred E. Howe (1946). A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, vol. 2: 1905-1941. Columbia University Press for the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  16. 16. (1909). “[Annual report for 1908: Classical Art]”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 4(3).
  17. 17.Robert W. de Forest (1910). “Fortieth Annual Report of the Trustees of the Museum for the Year Ending December 31, 1909”. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  18. 18.J. L. Myres (1909). “The Cesnola Collection: Preliminary Note”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 4(6).
  19. 19. (1910). “[Note: Edward Robinson succeeds Sir Caspar Purdon Clarke]”. The Duluth Herald, November 1910.
  20. 20. (1910). “[Art notes: the newly arranged Cesnola room at the Metropolitan Museum]”. The New York Times, 16 October 1910.
  21. 21. (1928). “Auction Sales of Classical Antiquities”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 23(3).
  22. 22. (1928). “Anderson Galleries Issues Its Catalogue of First Metropolitan Sale of Duplicates”. The New York Times, 9 March 1928.
  23. 23.Licia Collobi (1978). “The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York”. Great Museums of the World.
  24. 24.C. C. Vermeule, M. B. Comstock (1972). Greek, Etruscan & Roman Art: The Classical Collections of the Museum of Fine Arts. Boston.
  25. 25.Edward Sandford Martin, 1920, The Life of Joseph Hodges Choate as Gathered Chiefly from His Letters, p. 342; 1910-10-19, The Jeweler's Circular, vol. 61, no. 12 (19 October 1910); S. Reinach, 1910, Chronique d'Orient / nouvelles (note on the Cesnola collection).
  26. 26.Revue archéologique (1910-01).
  27. 27.1894, [Note on E. Robinson's Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases].
  28. 28.1910, Chronique: La collection Cesnola a New-York, Chronique, La collection Cesnola.
  29. 29.Ernest Leroux, Revue Archeologique (quatrieme Serie Tome.15) (1910).
  30. 30.Ballentine, Floyd G., Some Phases of the Cult of the Nymphs (1904).
  31. 31.Fort Wayne Sentinel (1910-11-15) (1910).
  32. 32.Brown, Katharine Reynolds, Dafydd Kidd, and Charles T. Little, eds., with essays by William D. Wixom, Katherine Reynolds Brown, Fran�oise Vallet, Elke Nieveler, Andrew Oliver, Barbara Deppert-Lippitz, Horst B�hme, Volker Bierbrauer, Inciser G�r�ay Damm, Wilfried Menghin, Lidia Paroli, Otto Prinz von Hessen, �va Garam, Csan�d B�lint, Gisela Ripoll L�pez, Birgit Arrhenius, Max Martin, Patrick P�rin, Vera I. Evison, John Hines, Helmut Roth, Jan Peder Lamm, and Victor H. Elbern, From Attila to Charlemagne: Arts of the Early Medieval Period in The Metropolitan Museum of Art (2000).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.