Book · 2020

Trafficking Culture: New Directions in Researching the Global Market in Illicit Antiquities

Simon Mackenzie, Neil Brodie, Donna Yates and Christos Tsirogiannis

Routledge

A study of the global illicit antiquities market from looting to sale, using fieldwork in source countries, auction records and case studies of dealers and objects, with proposals for regulation.

Mackenzie and colleagues follow the illicit antiquities market as a transnational chain that links extraction, transit and destination markets. They bring archaeological and criminological approaches to the people and institutions along that chain, to the movement and re-description of objects, and to ways of reducing trafficking and looting. The evidence is Trafficking Culture Project fieldwork of 2012–16 in Bolivia, Cambodia and Thailand, Belize and Mexico, and Nepal, with earlier fieldwork and desk research, and, for the destination market, auction catalogues and sales data, published provenance information, court documents, correspondence and seized photographic and documentary archives.

Interviews, ethnographic accounts, legal records and research on satellite data inform the discussion of source and transit countries, policing, regulation and economic vulnerability. For the auction houses the authors compare provenance and prices, examine museum and dealer policies, and reconstruct the routes of particular objects, among them the Duryodhana statue and antiquities associated with Giacomo Medici.

How it is organised

Chapter 1 sets out the structure of the global market and its actors, drivers and mechanisms. Chapter 2 examines the interfaces in smuggling chains, where the boundaries between source, transit and destination market blur, using the project's fieldwork. Chapter 3 compares the trade with other transnational criminal markets and with crime-control approaches. Chapter 4 describes the destination market and the provenance and other published information that circulates in it, and Chapter 5 applies white-collar crime theory to the way legitimate actors facilitate the market, with Sotheby's and the Duryodhana statue among its subjects. Chapter 6 tests whether the destination market regulates itself, Chapter 7 assesses regulation, self-regulation and ethical consumption markets, and Chapter 8 reviews policy failure and future options.

The argument

Source, transit and destination serve the authors as analytical stages whose boundaries are often indistinct. Objects pass through overlapping networks and jurisdictions, and brokers at the transition to the open market connect illicit supply with established dealers and buyers. They call the market grey because legal and illegal objects, transactions and actors can become difficult to tell apart (pp. 20–39).

In the destination market, the authors argue, restricted or selectively presented information, plausible deniability and claims of compliance help to maintain trafficking. The criminological analysis applies creative compliance, organisational deviance, routine activities and strain theory to trading institutions and their facilitators (pp. 77–93).

Rising provenance information and prices at auction do not show, the authors conclude, that customer preferences are removing trafficked material from the market. They attribute changes in Sotheby's lots and prices chiefly to a shift towards fewer, higher-value sales, and find no evidence of autoregulation in the internet-sale data they examine (pp. 100–114).

They find the existing emphasis on site protection and recovery inadequate against global trafficking. They propose stronger regulation of destination markets, improved provenance information and independent oversight, and present an ethical consumption market as an approach for further consideration (pp. 115–131).

Appendix: Case Studies

The appendix follows dealers and objects through the market. It sets out Medici's network of dealer contacts, including Nikolas Koutoulakis, an organigram drawn by the dealer Pasquale Camera, the contents of the Geneva storerooms, and the histories of the Euphronios krater and of a kylix signed by Euphronios and painted by Onesimos (pp. 132–139).

The bronze sow, the bronze warrior and the Nikon lekythos each have a case study. The sow and the warrior, from the Medici warehouse in the Geneva Freeport, reappear at Sotheby's and later at Christie's, with the Thetis Foundation among their owners. Objects withdrawn, seized or returned to dealers can re-enter the market, and these cases show how (pp. 140–146).

What it records

  • By the late 1980s Giacomo Medici had developed commercial relations with other major antiquities dealers, among them Robin Symes, Frieda Tchacos, Nikolas Koutoulakis, Robert Hecht and the brothers Ali and Hicham Aboutaam.p. 133
  • The storerooms in Geneva associated with Giacomo Medici held 3,800 whole or fragmentary objects, more than 4,000 photographs of artefacts and 35,000 sheets of paper.p. 134
  • The trafficking chain extends from the initial looter to the final buyer, as Mackenzie, Brodie and Yates describe it, and contributes to the eventual acceptance of the illicit piece as socially acceptable.p. 1
  • Trafficking Culture Project fieldwork in 2012–16 covered locations throughout Latin America, South Asia and South East Asia.p. 20
  • The project's fieldwork in 2013 took in central and western Cambodia and the Cambodia–Thailand border region.p. 20
  • Bolivia's law of 1906 declared all pre-Conquest archaeological remains property of the state and prohibited their export without state permission.p. 24
  • In 2014 Special Constable Danny Conorquie of Belize's tourism police was murdered at the Maya site of Caracol by xate palm poachers from Guatemala, not by antiquities looters.p. 29
  • In the two 2013 auction catalogues examined, 99 per cent of lots carried provenance information, and 42 and 47 per cent respectively carried publication provenance.p. 68
  • Neither 2013 catalogue described an object's place of discovery, and for no object in either was a full, unbroken account of provenance offered.p. 69
  • The Duryodhana statue was returned to Cambodia under a settlement agreement in which all parties accepted that Sotheby's was not at fault.p. 84
  • On 3 February 2006 the Metropolitan Museum of Art reached an agreement with Italy to return twenty objects, among them the Euphronios krater.p. 138

Where to read

  • Source, transit and destination market actorspp. 1–19
  • Fieldwork on source-transit interfaces in Latin America, South Asia and South East Asiapp. 20–39
  • Other transnational criminal markets and approaches to crime controlpp. 40–57
  • Provenance and published information in the destination marketpp. 58–76
  • Sotheby's and the Duryodhana statue; white-collar crime theorypp. 77–93
  • Provenance, price and the proposed ethical consumption marketpp. 94–126
  • Giacomo Medici, the organigram and the Euphronios kraterpp. 132–139
  • The bronze sow, the bronze warrior and the Nikon lekythospp. 140–146

Contents

  • The Structure of the Global Market in Illicit Antiquities: Actors, drivers, mechanisms1
  • Interfaces and Antiquities Smuggling Chains: Blurring on the margins of 'source', 'transit', and 'destination market'20
  • The Trade in Illicit Antiquities as a Transnational Criminal Market40
  • The Destination Market58
  • White-Collar Crime and Facilitation of the Criminal Market by ‘Legitimate’ Actors77
  • Autoregulation of the Destination Market?94
  • Regulation, Self-Regulation and Ethical Consumption Markets115
  • Policy Failure, Policy Future127
  • Appendix: Case Studies132
  • References147
  • Index163

Objects published here

5
  • Euphronios (Sarpedon) krater, red-figure calyx krater, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Greppe Sant'Angelo area, Etruscan cemetery of Cerveteri, as generally believed (p. 135)
  • Attic red-figure kylix signed by Euphronios and painted by Onesimos, J. Paul Getty Museum, Etruscan cemetery of Cerveteri (p. 138)
  • Greek bronze figure of a sow, Thetis Foundation; later offered by Christie's, Medici warehouse, Geneva Freeport, lot 54 (p. 140)
  • Greek bronze figure of an archaic warrior, described as a running hero, Thetis Foundation, Medici warehouse, Geneva Freeport, lot 77; later lot 543 (p. 142)
  • Duryodhana statue, Sotheby's New York sale, Prasat Chen temple complex at Koh Ker, as alleged in the litigation, lot 27 (p. 99)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Giacomo Medicidealer whose network the appendix reconstructs
  • Nikolas Koutoulakisdealer among Medici's commercial contacts
  • Robert Hechtantiquities dealer linked to Medici and the Euphronios krater
  • Robin Symesantiquities dealer; partner of Christos Michaelides
  • Gianfranco Becchinaantiquities dealer
  • Nikolas Zirganosjournalist and researcher
  • Christos Michaelidesdealer and partner of Robin Symes
  • Marion TrueGetty Museum curator
  • Douglas Latchfordcollector and antiquities dealer
  • Emma C. Bunkerart historian and research consultant
  • Anuradha Ghosh-MazumdarSotheby's assistant vice president
  • Henry Howard-SneydSotheby's vice chairman
  • Zara Porter-Hillhead of a Sotheby's department
  • Thomas Hovingdirector of the Metropolitan Museum
  • Dietrich von BothmerMetropolitan curator of Greek and Roman art
  • Hicham Aboutaamantiquities dealer
  • Subhash Kapoorantiquities dealer
  • Nancy Weinerdealer named in allegations in a complaint
  • Danny ConorquieBelize tourism police officer murdered at Caracol
  • Sofia Paredes Maureyresearcher of looting in Guatemala
  • Doreen McBarnetcriminologist and creative compliance theorist
  • Pierre Bourdieutheorist of cultural capital
  • Robert Mertonstrain theorist
  • Diane Vaughantheorist of organisational deviance
  • John Merrymancultural property theorist
  • Pasquale Cameradealer who drew the organigram
  • Daniela Rizzoarchaeologist and researcher
  • Maurizio Pellegriniarchaeologist and researcher

Institutions

  • Sotheby'sauction house examined throughout
  • Trafficking Culture Projectresearch project that carried out the fieldwork
  • Metropolitan Museum of Artmuseum in acquisition and return cases
  • J. Paul Getty Museummuseum in acquisition and return cases
  • Christie'sauction house examined throughout
  • National Gallery of Australiamuseum buyer in the Kapoor case
  • Asian Civilisations Museummuseum in a provenance case
  • Association of Art Museum Directorspublisher of museum acquisition guidelines
  • International Association of Dealers in Ancient Artdealers' trade association and code publisher
  • UNESCOinternational cultural property body
  • CarabinieriItalian police investigating antiquities trafficking

Places

  • Koh Kertemple complex associated with Duryodhana and Bhima
  • Prasat Chentemple complex statues were allegedly removed from
  • CaracolMaya archaeological site in Belize
  • CerveteriEtruscan cemetery linked to the krater and kylix
  • Geneva Freeportlocation of Medici's storerooms and the police raid
  • SchinoussaGreek island with Robin Symes's villa
  • SuthamalliTamil Nadu temple site in the Kapoor case
  • SripuranthanTamil Nadu temple site in the Kapoor case
  • Kalmakarra caveIranian cave tied to a silver hoard
  • Belizefieldwork location and source country
  • Boliviafieldwork location and source country
  • Cambodiafieldwork location and source country
  • Guatemalalooting case study
  • Mexicofieldwork location and source country
  • Thailandfieldwork location and source country
  • Perusource country and policing case study
  • Turkeysource country and recovery case study
  • Irancountry of origin in the Kalmakarra cases

Also named: Frieda Tchacos, Ali Aboutaam, Nino Savoca, National Gallery of Victoria, Quila Quila, Nepal.

Extent Figs 4.1–4.2, 6.1–6.8, 9.1; references, pp. 147–162; index, pp. 163–170

Defines grey market, Janus figure, provenance, provenience, creative compliance, ethical consumption market

CollectingMuseumsLooting and the LawTradeHistory of Archaeology

Who did what

7 records

Buying, selling and giving 4

  • Barbara FleischmanPassed objects toJ. Paul Getty Museum

    Barbara and Lawrence Fleischman transferred the Fleischman Collection to the Getty through a combination of gift and purchase.

    $20 million

    1996 · p. 71
  • Lawrence FleischmanPassed objects toJ. Paul Getty Museum

    Barbara and Lawrence Fleischman transferred the Fleischman Collection to the Getty through a combination of gift and purchase.

    $20 million

    1996 · p. 71
  • Noriyoshi HoriuchiAgent forGianfranco Becchina

    Noriyoshi Horiuchi acted on commission as an intermediary for four Swiss-based dealers, including Gianfranco Becchina.

    1991–1996 · p. 72
  • Hicham AboutaamSold toPaula Cussi

    Hicham Aboutaam sold Paula Cussi the rhyton for $950,000 and later refunded her purchase payment.

    decorated silver rhyton in the shape of a griffin$950,000

    2002 · p. 75

Posts and family 3

People it is cited for

1 person

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.