Article · 2010

Another Cesnola Puzzle: A pair of reproduction bracelets from Kourion in the Musée-château

R. S. Merrillees

Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 40 101-123

An article on two reproduction gold bracelets in the Musée-château d’Annecy, the original bracelets attributed to Kourion, and Charles Balliard’s possible part in making and giving copies.

Merrillees investigates two bracelet copies given to the Musée-château d’Annecy and the original gold bracelets associated with Kourion, following their records through the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Tiffany & Co. and accounts of Charles Balliard’s museum work. The sources are museum catalogue entries, inscriptions and measurements, correspondence, press reports, archival letters and later descriptions, together with the Annecy collection’s other replicas and records of Balliard’s gifts and dealings on Cesnola’s behalf. The bracelets are inscribed with the name of Etewandros, king of Paphos, and assigned in cited publications to the 6th–5th century BC.

Merrillees argues that the discovery context of the originals cannot be established with certainty. He favours a tomb in the vicinity of Kourion over Cesnola’s claim that they came from the temple treasure, and distinguishes several generations of copies made for different purposes. He identifies lightweight electrotype copies made for the 1878 Paris exhibition and solid-gold replacements made by Tiffany & Co. in 1887/88 (pp. 107–112). Ayios Ermoyenis and Kaloriziki are named as possible cemetery provenances.

Balliard’s work at the Metropolitan Museum and his contacts with Feuardent are traced in the account of Balliard’s career and the Feuardent material (pp. 112–120).

What it records

  • Charles Balliard donated the bracelet copies to the Musée-château d’Annecy in July 1893.p. 101
  • Annecy Inventory No. 12090 weighs 283 grammes and No. 12091 292 grammes; Ratié gives their diameter as 10 cm.p. 102
  • Merrillees concludes that the Etewandros bracelets came from a tomb near Kourion and are genuine Cypriot artefacts.p. 107
  • Merrillees dates the theft of the original bracelets from the Metropolitan Museum to 16 September 1887.p. 108
  • The Metropolitan Museum replacements, Inventory Nos. 74.51.3552 and 74.51.3553, weigh 495 and 505 grammes respectively.p. 109
  • Merrillees suggests that the Annecy bracelets are likely mould-made reproductions, possibly made by Balliard.p. 111
  • Charles Balliard began work as a restorer at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 1879, according to the biographical account quoted by Merrillees.p. 113

Where to read

  • Bracelet records, theft and reproductionspp. 101–111
  • Charles Balliard’s museum career and Annecy giftspp. 112–116
  • Balliard and Feuardent in New Yorkpp. 117–120

Contents

  • Introduction101
  • Historical Sources102
  • Bracelets / Armlets106
  • Historical Synthesis107
  • Charles Balliard112
  • Gaston Feuardent117
  • Acknowledgements120
  • Bibliography120
  • Appendix I123
  • Appendix II123

Objects published here

2
  • Reproduction of two gold bracelets attributed to Cyprus, Musée-château d’Annecy, Cyprus (attributed), 12090 and 12091, Fig. 1 (p. 101)
  • Electrotype copies of the Etewandros bracelets, Metropolitan Museum of Art, 74.51.3552 and 74.51.3553, Fig. 2 (p. 109)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

Places

  • Kourionreported find area of the bracelets
  • Paphoskingdom named in the bracelet inscriptions

Also named: Annie Caubet, Sophie Vassogne, Joan Mertens, J.T. Johnston, Ayios Ermoyenis, Kaloriziki.

Extent pp. 101–123, 2 figs; bibliography; 2 appendices

Cypro-ArchaicModernJewelryMuseumsCollectingHistory of Archaeology

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

2 objects

Who did what

23 records

Buying, selling and giving 18

  • Charles BalliardGave toMusée-château d’Annecy

    According to Mme Sophie Vassogne, Charles Balliard donated the two bracelets to the Musée-château d’Annecy in July 1893.

    two reproduction braceletsNo. Inv. Nos. 12090 and 12091

    1893–1914 · p. 101
  • Charles TiffanyConnected withMetropolitan Museum of Art

    Tiffany offered to make a pair of gold armlets matching those stolen and present them to the Museum as a gift.

    1887 · p. 106
  • Charles TiffanyGave toMetropolitan Museum of Art

    Markowitz and Falino wrote that Charles Tiffany presented the Museum with facsimiles of the original bracelets.

    facsimiles of the original gold bracelets

    p. 106
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaAcquired

    possiblyCesnola said his foreman handed him two gold armlets during clearance at Curium.

    With his foreman

    p. 107
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toCharles Balliard

    possiblyThe exhibition catalogue said it was possible that Cesnola gave pieces from his personal collection to Balliard.

    pieces from Cesnola’s ‘fonds personnel’

    p. 114
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaSold toCharles Balliard

    possiblyThe exhibition catalogue said it was possible that Cesnola sold pieces from his personal collection to Balliard.

    pieces from Cesnola’s ‘fonds personnel’

    p. 114
  • Charles BalliardAgent forLuigi Palma di Cesnola

    Balliard wrote to Heuzey on Cesnola’s behalf, asking him to return the crate of terracottas sent to the Louvre.

    a crate of terracottas

    1884 · p. 116
  • Charles BalliardCorresponded withLéon Heuzey

    Balliard wrote to Heuzey requesting the return of a crate of terracottas sent to the Louvre.

    1884 · p. 116
  • Charles BalliardConnected withLéon Heuzey

    Balliard arranged with Heuzey an exchange of Cypriot antiquities for plaster casts.

    1889 · p. 116
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaAuctioned

    Antiquities from Cesnola’s collection were sold at auction in 1870.

    With auction buyers

    1870 · p. 117
  • Gaston Louis FeuardentIn litigation withLuigi Palma di Cesnola

    Feuardent sued Cesnola for defamation after Cesnola accused him of stealing an anthropomorphic vase.

    Accusation concerning an anthropomorphic vaseNo. 22231

    1883 · p. 118
  • Luigi Palma di CesnolaGave toNational Museum of Natural History

    Cesnola donated Cypriote antiquities to the National Museum of Natural History.

    No. Accession No. 002258Washington

    1871 · p. 119
  • Gaston Louis FeuardentGave toNational Museum of Natural History

    Feuardent presented the National Museum of Natural History with more than 150 lots of ancient artefacts.

    more than 150 lots of ancient artefacts from the Old WorldNo. Accession No. 007825Washington

    1879 · p. 119
  • Gaston Louis FeuardentDealt

    Feuardent dealt in coins and antiquities, with sale catalogues offering antiquities, coins and gems for inspection and purchase.

    No. 30 Lafayette Place, New York City

    1879–1880 · p. 119
  • Gaston Louis FeuardentOffered for sale

    Feuardent offered antiquities, coins, and gems for inspection and purchase at his New York premises.

    No. 30 Lafayette Place, New York City

    1879–1880 · p. 119
Show 3 more

Recording and study 5

  • Robert Stuart MerrilleesPublished

    Robert Stuart Merrillees published an article about reproduction bracelets from Kourion in the Musée-château d’Annecy.

    No. Inv. Nos. 12090 and 12091

    p. 101
  • Olivier MassonPublished material ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola

    Masson published research on the bracelets and their inscriptions.

    Etewandros bracelets and their inscriptionsNo. No. 176

    1961 · p. 103
  • Terence Bruce MitfordPublished material ofLuigi Palma di Cesnola

    Mitford published studies of the bracelets and examined the copies in New York.

    Etewandros bracelets and inscriptions

    1961–1971 · p. 104
  • Charles BalliardEmployed byMetropolitan Museum of Art

    Balliard was engaged as a restorer by the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

    objects of Cypriote artNew York

    1879–1897 · p. 113, 123
  • Charles BalliardRecorded

    Balliard made moulds of archaeological pieces and scale models of ancient monuments.

    archaeological pieces and models of ancient monumentsMetropolitan Museum of Art

    p. 123

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.