Museum staff · Photographer

Dickson B. Alley

fl. 1877–1884

Night watchman and later assistant janitor at the Metropolitan Museum from 1877, who testified in 1882-83 that pieces of the Cesnola Collection had been restored at the museum.

Biography

Dickson D. Alley was a member of the staff of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, known as a witness in the dispute over restorations to the Cypriot collection of Luigi Palma di Cesnola2. The sources disagree on his middle initial: The Art Amateur printed "Dickson B. Alley" in December 1883, while its January 1884 report and The New York Times give "Dickson D."1,2,4.

By his own account, he was first employed at the museum in Fourteenth Street in November 1877 as night watchman4. He later had charge of the department of curios, which held gold, jewels and bronzes, and he helped Hutchins mount some of the statues1. When the museum moved to the Park he helped Hutchins pack the small statues and pottery, and there he worked as a watchman and sold photographs and the catalogue at the door1,4. In court he described himself as a photographic printer1.

The statements of 1881-82

In a sworn affidavit printed in The Art Amateur in June 1882, Alley said that about 11 March 1881 he looked in the museum's sample album for a photograph of statue no. 22; Cesnola sent for the album, and it came back about two hours later with that page missing6. Charles Henkel swore that Alley pointed out the missing page and that next morning Henkel found fragments of photographs in the waste-basket of Cesnola's office6. The New York Times of 10 April 1882 called Henkel the janitor and Alley the assistant janitor, both "discharged quite lately"4.

Alley's statement in that report said he heard Cesnola tell the foreman of Fisher & Bird that it made no difference if the old restorations of Gehlen came apart, and that on Cesnola's orders he put the false bottom of a case before bas-relief No. 43 when the Duke of Argyll visited4. Alley said that washing the pottery took much of the decoration off part of it, and that he suspected many vases had been painted with modern colours4. He said the head found with sphinx No. 35 was too small in the neck, so the sphinx's neck "must have been thinned down"4. For statuette No. 829, Alley said, Cesnola told him to find a head or any head that came near; he chose one of four, Cesnola called it "Just the very head", and Balliard filed its neck to fit4,7. The Century printed his statement in August 18827.

The trial of 1883

Alley testified in the libel suit of Gaston Feuardent against Cesnola in the US District Court on 9 November 18838. He said that after he told Savage of the restorations, Cesnola offered to keep him if he took it all back; Alley said he was told he could stay until the first of the next month, but found another place8. Two weeks later Cesnola sent him a letter commending his honesty and industry, which was put in evidence8.

Alley testified that Cesnola was present and directed the alterations, that Balliard brightened bronzes in a bath and aged them again in a kettle, and that he saw Balliard sawing legs off statues1. Of a statuette with a mirror, he said he scratched the mirror with his knife and found plaster, and that in court it was "of stone now"8. He said neither he, Henkel nor Lennon was called before the investigating committee2. The Art Amateur, which reported the case, said his testimony "was not shaken" in cross-examination2. Savage testified that the proof of the statements of Henkel and Alley showed he had been imposed upon9.

In 1895 The New York Times quoted a critic who wrote that Cesnola had sent the janitors Henkel and Alley to look for a missing vase among the Cypriot antiquities10.

Life and work

  1. 1877

    1. Employed at the Metropolitan Museum of Art (then at Fourteenth Street): first night watchman, then put in charge of the department of curios, covering gold, jewels and bronzes. He helped H. G. Hutchins mount some of the statues. When the museum moved to the Park he was a watchman and sold photographs and the catalogue at the door.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24

  2. 1881

    1. November 1881 – February 1882

      Discharged from the Metropolitan Museum together with Charles Henkel, according to the Art Amateur, for telling Savage, First Assistant Director, of the restorations they had witnessed. Savage's letter to Cesnola of 29 Nov 1881 protests against discharging 'the janitor and his assistant for answering my question' (unnamed); Henkel said he stayed until February 1882.

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, pp. 55-56

  3. 1883

    1. October–December

      Direct testimony for the plaintiff, as summarised on p. 24: he saw Balliard take statues apart and restore them at the Park museum, Cesnola present, superintending and directing; Balliard prepared a bath for the bronzes that brightened them like new bronze, then a kettle mixture that aged them again (whitish-green verdigris); dust and stone dust from boring and sawing was used for colouring; he saw Balliard saw legs off statues and bases off objects; sphinx no. 35 arrived in fragments with plaster legs that were replaced by stone; Cesnola ordered the stumps of legs of a statuette carved off to fit a circular base; the 'Egyptian warrior' had a plaster nose that Balliard knocked off after the newspaper controversy began; brass pins were put in a face before plaster for a nose; he repeatedly saw the priest with hand and patera detached and once with the head separate in the bath room; sarcophagus and bas-relief carving; pottery dissolved in a muriatic-acid bath; and, before the Duke of Argyle's visit, headless figures were set up by employees of Fisher & Bird, marble workers of Houston Street.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24

    2. October–December

      The Venus statuette (no. 157): Cesnola told him one day a party was coming and that he should let all in except the Frenchman Feuardent; Feuardent and two others came by another door and handled the statuette; afterwards the table was wet and the mirror looked fresh; he tried it with his knife, found it plaster, and hid the scratch with tobacco juice, a trick he had seen Balliard use. On the Sunday after the Art Amateur's article Balliard took the statuette away and brought it back on Monday with the mirror less clumsy and differently coloured; on a later Sunday Alley found the mirror no longer plaster but cut into the stone, the drapery thinner. He told Balliard, jokingly, that the best way out of the scrape was to do this very carving.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24; (1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement). The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b, p. 4a-4b

    3. October–December

      Cross-examination and the photograph album: Alley said he held all the photographs on sale and none showed the priest with hand and patera detached; after The Times article he found a proof of that picture in the catalogue of negatives, the bookkeeper took the catalogue at noon and returned it three hours later with the proof removed and the leaf torn from the album; next day Henkel brought the waste basket and the torn photographs, which Alley told him to keep. Cesnola had told him to watch and keep out Feuardent and had charged him with giving information to 'that Frenchman'; 'a man named Rooney' had insinuated the same; Alley wrote a note denying it.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24

    4. December 1883 – January 1884

      Further cross-examination (Jan. 1884 report): his testimony 'was not shaken' by the defendant's lawyers (not named); he saw Prime on one occasion brush the hand and patera of the priest with a sponge and pail of water to show it was one piece, without trying to separate the bits of stone and without removing the wash; the committee soaked only one figure, no. 40; he, Henkel and Lennon were not called before the committee; Prime and Cesnola managed the investigation to suit themselves.

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 55

    5. December

      Described in the Art Amateur's account of another witness's testimony as having tried, with Lennon, to match a head that came in a box to a double sphinx being restored; Di Cesnola told Lennon not to meddle.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24

    6. October 1883 – January 1884Named

      Witness for the plaintiff in Feuardent v. Di Cesnola; not a party.

      (1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24; (1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 55

Connections

9 people

Mentioned in

12 mentions

Institutions · 1

  • Metropolitan Museum of Art

    Night watchman, then in charge of the department of curios (gold, jewels, bronzes), watchman and seller of photographs and catalogue at the door at the Central Park building, photographic printer by trade · 1877

    The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial 1883, p. 24

Sources

  1. 1. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24. Online
  2. 2. (1884). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56. Online
  3. 3. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement)”. The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b. Online
  4. 4.The New York Times (1882). “[Report on the discharged janitors of the Metropolitan Museum]”. The New York Times, 10 April 1882.
  5. 5.(newspaper) (1883). The New York Times, 13 November 1883.
  6. 6.[unsigned] (1882). “The Art Museum Controversy”. The Art Amateur 7.
  7. 7.[unsigned] (1882). “[Report on the Cesnola collection charges]”. The Century Illustrated Monthly Magazine 24.
  8. 8.The New York Times (1883). “Against Mr. Di Cesnola: Story of a Former Employe at the Metropolitan Museum”. The New York Times, 10 November 1883.
  9. 9.The New York Times (1883). “[Report of the Feuardent-Di Cesnola trial, 14 November 1883]”. The New York Times, 15 November 1883.
  10. 10.The New York Times (1895). “[Report on the Cesnola collection]”. The New York Times, 4 March 1895.
  11. 11.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (continued).
  12. 12.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
  13. 13.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
  14. 14.The Art Amateur 1884-01: Vol 10 Iss 2 (1884).
  15. 15.The Art Amateur 1882-06: Vol 7 Iss 1 (1882).
  16. 16.The Century illustrated monthly magazine (1871).
  17. 17.The New York Times 1883-11-10: Vol 33 Iss 10041.
  18. 18.The New York Times 1883-11-13: Vol 33 Iss 10043 (1883).
  19. 19.The New York Times 1882-05-18: Vol 31 Iss 9577 (1882).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.