Curator · Cataloguer

Alexander D. Savage

fl. 1870–1893 · United States

Greek scholar who ran the Cesnola antiquities at the Metropolitan Museum in 1879-81, wrote their first guide, found restored statues, resigned and testified for Feuardent.

Biography

Alexander Duncan Savage had charge of classical antiquities at the Metropolitan Museum of Art from 1879 to 1881, wrote the first guide to them, and then published the restorations he found in the statues18,19.

Training and appointment

Who's Who in America gives his birth as 1 December 1848 at Sumterville, Alabama, to Thomas Stoughton and Elizabeth (Rutherford) Savage20. He took the B.Litt. at the University of Virginia in 1870 and studied philology at Bonn and Leipzig from 1871 to 187320. B. L. Gildersleeve, who had taught him for four years at Virginia, nominated him for a fellowship in Greek at Johns Hopkins19. Ernest Sihler lists him among the first five Fellows in Philology there, and the only one who had studied under Gildersleeve before13. Who's Who gives his fellowship as 1876 to 1879, while Gildersleeve wrote that he held it for two years; Savage received an honorary A.M. from Yale in 1876, and was acting librarian at Johns Hopkins in 187919,20. The Rev. Howard Crosby wrote that he recommended Savage to Luigi Palma di Cesnola as assistant "because of his archæological scholarship"19.

Guide and inscription

His title at the Metropolitan is given three ways: curator of antiquities in Who's Who, assistant director in his obituary, and First Assistant Director in the 1884 trial report1,18,20. At that trial he said he prepared the museum's descriptive catalogues and had charge of the potteries1. His Handbook No. 3, Sculptures of the Cesnola Collection, appeared in 18805. Thomas Davidson called it "a model of a guide-book", "concise, exhaustive, and well arranged"21. Davidson reported that Savage was inclined to trace the Oriental influence in Cyprus mainly to the Phoenicians, settling as early as 2000 BC, a date Davidson would not accept, and he praised the grouping that showed the passage from Orientalism to Hellenism21. J. L. Myres later judged the guide "brightly written" and more instructive than Isaac H. Hall's inventory that replaced it in 18955.

In 1881 Savage published in the American Journal of Philology a limestone group of a seated woman with a small standing figure, whose Greek inscription names the sculptor8. He wrote, on Cesnola's information, that it was found in 1875 in the cemetery at Hagios Georgios and stayed packed until 18798. Antoine Hermary places the find in 1875 in the Golgoi necropolis on the information Cesnola gave Savage22.

The restorations

In the 1881 inquiry into Feuardent's charges, the Century called Savage the most important witness for Cesnola19. The American wrote that his statement that there were no restorations rested on Cesnola's assurance, not on examination23. He resigned, but the Trustee holding the resignation persuaded him to wait for Cesnola's return19. While Cesnola was in Europe in 1881, Savage examined the collection and found at least eight restored statues1. In his letter to the Times, Savage wrote that Cesnola assured him the restorations had been made without his knowledge, probably during his absence in Cyprus in 1872-7724. Savage also wrote that Cesnola reproved him for spending museum time looking for restorations19.

The sources give two dates for his departure: Savage wrote that he left on 30 November 1881, when they could not agree on a date to publish24. The trial report says he left on 3 December, three days after his resignation took effect1. He did not accept the Trustees' report of 13 February 1882 as publication, since it specified no restoration24. His letter acknowledging restorations in statues on exhibition appeared in the New York Times on 12 March 188225. The sources count them differently: the Century gives twenty-nine restorations in seventeen stone pieces and one in a terracotta, while one of his letters describes some sixteen statues, and Anna G. Marangou also gives sixteen4,19,24. He wrote that two janitors were dismissed solely for telling him of restorations19.

Judgements split. The Critic wrote that thirteen months to make the discoveries "seems an absurdly long time"26. In 1881 a writer in the Times had said that before the committee he "preferred a prudent silence and to consult his own safety"27. The American wrote that "if any man's word is to be believed, his is"23. In July 1882 Savage called one portion of Cesnola's archaeological work "in shocking confusion"28. At the Feuardent-Cesnola trial he said he had not thought Cesnola would make him first assistant, put him in charge of the antiquities, have him write guide books, "and then conceal such restorations from me"1.

Later work

Savage lectured on the history of art from 1880 and translated The Stone Sculptures of Copan and Quirigua from the German20,29. He was reference cataloguer at Princeton in 1906-07 and assistant curator of fine arts at the Brooklyn Institute Museum from 23 February 190720. He served the Hispanic Society of America from 1915 to 1935 and was its palaeographer18,30. Who's Who records him as unmarried20. He died aged 86 at Bernardsville, New Jersey, on 15 August 193518.

Life and work

  1. 1880

    1. Wrote the Metropolitan Museum's little guide Sculptures of the Cesnola Collection (Handbook No. 3), described by Myres as 'brightly written' and more instructive to students than the later inventory by I. H. Hall that superseded it in 1895.

      New YorkJ. L. Myres (1914). Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art, p. xix

    2. 21 May

      On Cesnola's instruction wrote to Feuardent (letter of 21 May 1880) answering his charge that a mirror had been carved onto the Aphrodite/Elpis statuette: said the mirror had always been there, that washing had made it look cleaner, and that it was 'utterly false' that the repairer had said anyone carved lines around it. Feuardent had first told Savage of the alteration.

      New YorkA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 307-308

    3. July

      Wrote to Cesnola at Richfield Springs (letter dated July 1880, read at the trial) about the publication in the New York Herald of Feuardent's Art Amateur charges, saying he detested Feuardent, was sorry the days of horsewhipping were past and hoped Feuardent would be crushed. At the trial he said he wrote it believing Cesnola had spoken truly: 'I did not think that he would make me his first assistant, put me in charge of the antiquities, and have me write guide books, and then conceal such restorations from me.'

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 56

    4. c. 1880

      Cesnola, writing from Richfield Springs in the summer of 1880, ordered Savage to refuse sketching access in the museum to anyone working for Feuardent and forbade him to talk to any city newspaper except The Evening Post, which was friendly to the museum; Savage obeyed. Cesnola also told Savage that the museum authorities had engaged a Mr. Ripley as 'special and secret journalist' and wrote giving him leave to talk with Ripley.

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 55

    5. c. 1880

      Preparing one of his catalogues, Savage noticed that a finger on the 'bearded Venus' was plaster and told Cesnola; by Cesnola's orders Balliard removed it. (Cox, in the same report, credits the finding of 'one finger too many' to Mr. Earl Shinn, whom Cox says told Cesnola.)

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 55

    6. 1880–1881

      Told the Evening Post, relying on Cesnola's assurance that all restorations had been undone after Balliard discovered them in 1880, that there were no restorations in the collection (the interview he later said was based on that assurance).

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 56

  2. 1881

    1. Published in the American Journal of Philology a note on a Greek inscription concerning Golgoi (the Roman-period stele signed by an artist Golgios, Met inv. 1381 per Counts, citing Myres 1914).

      M. K. Toumazou (ed.), P. N. Kardulias (ed.), D. B. Counts (ed.) (2011). Crossroads and Boundaries: The Archaeology of Past and Present in the Malloura Valley, Cyprus, p. 48 ; p. 75

    2. 29 November

      Wrote to Cesnola recalling that on his return in the second week of October Cesnola had said he knew nothing of the alterations Savage had found, and warning that if Cesnola discharged the janitor (Alley) and his assistant (Henkel) for answering Savage's question 'Were there restorations and what are they?', 'everything, and more than I told you I had discovered, shall be revealed and published wide.' The two men were discharged nonetheless (the report says for telling Savage of the restorations they had witnessed).

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, pp. 55-56

    3. First Assistant Director of the Met, wrote its Cypriot catalogues and translated Doell; found restorations, resigned 31 Aug 1881 (left 3 Dec); testified that Cesnola lied about them.

      Art Amateur 10 (Dec. 1883), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 23-24; Art Amateur 10 (Dec. 1883), Editorial Supplement, 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 4a-4b; Art Amateur 10 (Jan. 1884), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 55-56

  3. 1882

    1. April

      Lectured to the Ladies' Art Association, New York, on the 'Sculptures of the Cesnola Collection' and on 'Greek Pottery' (announced 19-23 April 1882) after resigning; the 22 April 1882 Times has the headline 'Duncan Savage will lecture'.

      New YorkNew York Times (1882-04-22). Duncan Savage will lecture; New York Times (1882-04-19/21/23). Notices of Savage's lectures

  4. 1883

    1. October 1883 – January 1884

      Witness for Feuardent in Feuardent v. Cesnola (US Circuit Court, Judge Shipman). Called on the third day of the Hutchins evidence to identify the copious translations of Johannes Doell's memoir on the collection, to be used later; the Dec. 1883 supplement adds that he swore that the Golgoi sarcophagus re-carving was superintended by J. Q. A. Ward, later a member of the investigating committee. His main testimony (reported Jan. 1884) was that Cesnola had him prepare the pottery and catalogues, denounced Feuardent, ordered the plaster finger removed, said he had had no restorations made because Europe's museums had abandoned them and later admitted some, and claimed Feuardent had stolen a Cypriote vase, which a museum album photograph in Cesnola's hand showed to be the Berlin Museum's property. Under cross-examination he agreed he had written a July 1880 letter hoping Feuardent would be crushed.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23; (1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement). The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b, p. 4b; (1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, pp. 55-56

    2. 28 December

      In the Feuardent trial the statuette that Di Cesnola and Savage called Venus (Feuardent: Elpis; Prime: a dancing girl) was washed in court by Prime.

      New YorkNew York Times (1883-12-29). Report of the Feuardent-Di Cesnola case, 28 December

  5. 1893

    1. The Critic (1893) reported: Formerly an assistant in the Museum, by whose evidence the charges were proved at the Feuardent-Cesnola trial: «the charges, proved on the Feuardent-Cesnola trial, by Mr. A, Duncan Savage, formerly an assistant in the Museum»

      «Dr. Richter on Cesnola», The Critic 19 no. 587 (20 May 1893), pp. 332-333, p. 333

  6. Undated

    n.d.

    1. Worked at the Metropolitan Museum in charge of the Cypriote antiquities and resigned after discovering restorations in the collection.

      The Art Amateur, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (1884), p. Pl. 315

    2. Wrote letters to Di Cesnola and Johnston about his resignation from the Metropolitan Museum.

      The Art Amateur, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (1884), p. Pl. 315

Connections

12 people

Recording and study

1 record
Employed by1

Mentioned in

19 mentions

Institutions · 1

Sources

  1. 1. (1884). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56. Online
  2. 2. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24. Online
  3. 3. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement)”. The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b. Online
  4. 4.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  5. 5.J. L. Myres (1914). Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  6. 6.M. K. Toumazou (ed.), P. N. Kardulias (ed.), D. B. Counts (ed.) (2011). Crossroads and Boundaries: The Archaeology of Past and Present in the Malloura Valley, Cyprus.
  7. 7.A. D. Savage (1880). Sculptures of the Cesnola Collection (Handbook No. 3). New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  8. 8.A. D. Savage (1881). “A Greek Inscription Concerning Golgoi”. American Journal of Philology 2, 223-224.
  9. 9. (1884). “The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97. Online
  10. 10.New York Times (1882-04-22). “Duncan Savage will lecture”.
  11. 11.New York Times (1883-12-29). “Report of the Feuardent-Di Cesnola case, 28 December”.
  12. 12.Leonard; Marquis (eds) (1900). Who's who in America.
  13. 13.Ernest G. Sihler (1930). From Maumee to Thames and Tiber: the Life-Story of an American Classical Scholar.
  14. 14.S. R. Koehler (1880). “American Art Chronicle (American Art Review)”.
  15. 15.New York Times (1884-01-24). “Report of the Feuardent-Cesnola trial”.
  16. 16.New York Times (1882-04-19/21/23). “Notices of Savage's lectures”.
  17. 17.The Critic (1882-07-29). “Note on the resignation of Cesnola's assistant”.
  18. 18. (1935). “Art Authority Dead”. The Art Digest 9 (20), 1 Sept. 1935.
  19. 19. (1882). “The Cesnola Collection (Topics of the Time) and Open Letters on the Cesnola Collection”. The Century Magazine 24 (4), August 1882.
  20. 20.John W. Leonard (ed.) (1908). Who's Who in America.
  21. 21.Thomas Davidson (1880). “[Review of] Metropolitan Museum of Art, Handbook No. 3: Sculptures of the Cesnola Collection of Cypriote Antiquities”. American Art Review.
  22. 22.Antoine Hermary (2004). “Autour de Golgoi : les cités de la Mesaoria aux époques hellénistique et romaine”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 34, 47-68.
  23. 23. (1882). “[The Cesnola controversy]”. The American (Philadelphia) 4 (102), 22 July 1882.
  24. 24. (1882). “[Editorial: Mr. Savage's letters on the restorations]”. The Art Amateur 6 (5), April 1882.
  25. 25. (1882). “What Feuardent Has to Say about the Cypriote Collection in the Metropolitan Museum”. The New York Times 13 March 1882.
  26. 26. (1882). “[Note on Savage's list of restorations]”. The Critic 2, 25 March 1882.
  27. 27. (1881). “[The Cesnola investigation: Savage's letter on G. C. Cox]”. The New York Times 10 April 1881.
  28. 28. (1882). “[Mr. Savage on the Cesnola publications]”. The New York Times 21 July 1882.
  29. 29.Edinburgh University Library (1918). Catalogue of the Printed Books in the Library of the University of Edinburgh.
  30. 30. (1972). “[The Hispanic Society of America: manuscripts and documents]”. Apollo April 1972.
  31. 31.Art Amateur 10 (Dec. 1883), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 23-24; Art Amateur 10 (Dec. 1883), Editorial Supplement, 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 4a-4b; Art Amateur 10 (Jan. 1884), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial'.
  32. 32.The Art Amateur, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (1884).
  33. 33.«Dr. Richter on Cesnola», The Critic 19 no. 587 (20 May 1893).
  34. 34.A. G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  35. 35.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (continued), pp. 55-56; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  36. 36.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  37. 37.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (continued).
  38. 38.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
  39. 39.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4b; 1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (continued).
  40. 40.[Editorial] (1882).
  41. 41.Fleischer, Richard. Red., Zeitschrift für die Gebildete Welt über das Gesammte Wissen Unserer Zeit und über Alle Wichtigen Berufszweige. Bd. 1, 1883.
  42. 42.Bursian, Konrad, 1830-1883, [from old catalog] ed; Müller, Iwan Philipp Eduard, Ritter von, 1830-1917, [from old catalog] ed; Seyffert, Oskar, 1841-1906, [from old catalog] ed, Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft (1885).
  43. 43.The Century illustrated monthly magazine (1871).
  44. 44.The New York Times 1881-01-06: Vol 30 Iss 9151 (1881).
  45. 45.Samuel R. Crocker , Edward Abbott , Nicholas Paine Gilman , Madeline Vaughan Abbott Bushnell, Bliss Carman, Herbert Copeland, The Literary world (1882).
  46. 46.Sihler, E. G. (Ernest Gottlieb), 1853-1942, From Maumee to Thames and Tiber; the life-story of an American classical scholar ... (1930).
  47. 47.Samuel R. Crocker, Edward Abbott, Nicholas Paine Gilman, Madeline Vaughan Abbott Bushnell, Bliss Carman, Herbert Copeland, The literary world (1870).
  48. 48.New Publications (1883).
  49. 49.Paulys Real-Encyclopadie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft volume 14 (Glykyrrhiza-Helikeia).
  50. 50.The New York Times 1883-11-15: Vol 33 Iss 10045 (1883).
  51. 51.Feuardent, Gaston L., Tampering with Antiquities (1880).
  52. 52.The Art Amateur 1880-08: Vol 3 Iss 3.
  53. 53.The Art Amateur 1884-01: Vol 10 Iss 2 (1884).
  54. 54.The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (1883).
  55. 55.Books Received (1884).
  56. 56.The Critic 1882-03-25: Vol 2 (1882).
  57. 57.Repertorium für kunstwissenschaft (1876).
  58. 58.The New York Times 1883-11-14: Vol 33 Iss 10044 (1883).
  59. 59.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
  60. 60.The Literary World, 1882.
  61. 61.The New York Times 1883-11-10: Vol 33 Iss 10041.
  62. 62.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904.
  63. 63.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(p. 307); Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(p. 324).
  64. 64.Lang 1878, Cyprus: its History, its Present Resources, and Future Prospects, pp. 36-37, 213, 332-338; G. L. Feuardent, 'The Cesnola-Baillard Sarcophagus', Art Amateur 4 (May 1881).
  65. 65.The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (1884).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Dates of birth and death unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.