Article · 1991

The Trade of Indo-Pacific Shells into the Mediterranean Basin and Europe

D. S. Reese

Oxford Journal of Archaeology 10(2) 159-196

An article cataloguing Indo-Pacific shells from more than 160 Mediterranean and European sites, with the contexts of the finds and a discussion of how the shells moved and were used.

Reese surveys worked and unmodified Indo-Pacific shells reported from Mediterranean and European sites at least 250 km from the Gulf of Suez or the Gulf of Eilat/Aqaba. A catalogue arranged by country records more than 160 sites, and a separate section sets out the reports he considers incorrect. The finds range from Upper Paleolithic and Epipaleolithic contexts to recent times, and Reese uses the period labels and dates reported for each site, grouping his summary table by broad archaeological periods.

The evidence

The catalogue draws on published excavation reports, museum collections, communications and Reese's own identifications. Entries describe species, modification, quantities, context and dating where these are available, and figures illustrate shell forms and worked examples (pp. 160–187).

Reese rejects sixteen reports as incorrect identifications, among them shells identified as Tridacna that Reese regards as bone, stone, ivory or Mediterranean species. He cautions that the totals are minimum counts, because excavation recovery and identification methods varied and some identifications cannot be checked against published descriptions.

Cyprus

Reese records cowries and other shells at Kition, Amathus and Salamis, and worked Pinctada valves from tombs and other contexts at Kourion, Paphos and several further Cypriot sites (pp. 167–169).

The argument

Reese separates long-distance transport from trade. For early Epipaleolithic and Natufian sites near the Red Sea, mobile occupants may have gathered the shells themselves. For the Chalcolithic, Early and Middle Bronze Ages he proposes down-the-line or trickle exchange, as shells turn up farther from their source, and he finds the find from Portugal harder to explain and questions its association with the Chalcolithic (pp. 187–188).

Reese reports that the largest totals come from Jordan, Israel, Syria and Cyprus. Italy's count largely derives from Pompeii and Greece's from engraved Tridacna at sanctuaries; money cowries are widely represented as beads, while the larger Tiger and Panther cowries occur in Roman and later European graves. Worked Pinctada and Tridacna appear in graves, sanctuaries and, in some cases, inlay or ceremonial contexts.

Reese argues that graves and sanctuaries account for many finds, and that the small quantities point to the occasional movement of people or of rare shells. Reese offers possible uses for cowries, including beads, fertility-related objects and protection against the Evil Eye (pp. 188–190).

What it records

  • Kition Bothros 1, dated 600–450 BC, produced 25 holed Cypraea annulus, one modified Nerita and two Tectus shells with cut holes.p. 167
  • Thirteen tombs at Amathus yielded 67 Cypraea annulus, dated from Cypro-Geometric IIIB to the Roman period.p. 168
  • Three tombs at Amathus produced five Pinctada valves, all lacking the exterior brown layer.p. 168
  • Tomb 8 at Kourion, dated to the late third century BC, produced a Pinctada valve with two rows of punched holes.p. 168
  • Four tombs at Paphos yielded five worked Pinctada valves.p. 168
  • Reese's country totals give Cyprus 114 shells from five sites.p. 188
  • The catalogue covers more than 160 sites with reported Indo-Pacific shells, dated from the Upper Paleolithic to recent times.p. 159
  • In Reese's assessment, reports of Indo-Pacific shells from sixteen sites rest on incorrect identifications.p. 159
  • Reese treats the shell totals as minimum counts because excavation recovery methods varied.p. 183
  • Reese suggests that the occupants of some early sites may have collected shells directly rather than obtained them through trade.p. 188
  • Cypraea annulus and Cypraea moneta, the most common shells in the Mediterranean and Europe, were used as beads, not as money.p. 188
  • Reese concludes that the movement of exotic shells is easier to demonstrate than the exchange patterns behind it.p. 190

Where to read

  • Catalogue of site finds by geographic regionpp. 160–182
  • Incorrect shell identifications and provenance claimspp. 182–183
  • Summary of finds by period and sitepp. 184–187
  • Trade, transport and proposed uses of shellspp. 187–190
  • Cypriot cowries and worked Pinctadapp. 167–169

Contents

  • Eastern Jordan160
  • Northern Jordan160
  • Northern Israel (and West Bank)163
  • Lebanon166
  • Syria166
  • Cyprus167
  • Turkey169
  • Russia169
  • Greek Islands170
  • Greek Mainland171
  • Yugoslavia171
  • Hungary171
  • Poland171
  • Libya172
  • Tunisia172
  • Italy172
  • Austria174
  • Germany176
  • Belgium176
  • Denmark176
  • Sweden (See now Johansson 1990)176
  • Norway177
  • Monaco177
  • France179
  • Spain179
  • Portugal179
  • England180
  • Incorrect Reports182
  • Conclusions183
  • References190

Objects published here

6
  • Pinctada valve with two rows of punched holes from Tomb 8, Kourion Museum, Episkopi, Ayios Ermoyenis necropolis, Kourion, Tomb 8, Mi 379 (p. 168)
  • Pinctada valve from Tomb 214, Limassol Museum, Amathus, Tomb 214, LM 728 (p. 168)
  • Pinctada shell with inscribed border and 16 holes, Paphos Museum, Paphos, Eastern Necropolis, Tomb 28/85, Chamber A, PM 2792/59 (p. 168)
  • Pinctada valve fragment with dotted decoration, Paphos Museum, Paphos, Tomb 152/84, southern ossuary, PM 2741/32 (p. 168)
  • Pinctada fragment with two rows of punched holes, Kouklia Museum, Kouklia area, Unit no. 1 (p. 169)
  • Nerita shell from Tomb A 94, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Jericho, Tomb A 94, 955.165.60 (p. 164)

People, places and institutions

Places

  • Kitionsanctuary with worked and unworked shells
  • Amathustombs with cowries and Pinctada valves
  • Salamistombs with holed cowries
  • Kouriontomb, city and basilica shell finds
  • Paphostombs with worked Pinctada valves
  • Tell Hadidimulti-period shell assemblage
  • Cyrenesanctuary with engraved Tridacna
  • PompeiiRoman site with numerous shell finds

Also named: Renfrew, Cesnola, Limassol Museum, Kourion Museum, Episkopi, Paphos Museum, Kouklia Museum, Kouklia, Jerash.

Extent pp. 159–196, figs 1–22; bibliography pp. 190–196

NeolithicChalcolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanLate AntiqueMedievalModernTradeBurialReligion and CultJewelryCraft Production

Mentioned in

4 mentions

Tomb records · 4

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.