Edited volume · 2018

Change, Continuity, and Connectivity: North-Eastern Mediterranean at the Turn of the Bronze Age and in the Early Iron Age

Łukasz Niesiołowski-Spanò and Marek Węcowski (eds.)

Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz Verlag

A collection of 23 papers on relations between the Aegean and the Levant around 1300–900 BCE, incorporating the main results of three workshops held in Warsaw in 2014–2016.

Relations between the Aegean and the Levant around 1300–900 BCE and slightly beyond are the subject of 23 papers drawing on regional archaeology, cross-cultural studies, linguistic research and scientific analysis. They take up regional political and settlement change, exchange, the movement and interpretation of objects and people, language contact and scientific approaches to migration. The editors, Niesiołowski-Spanò and Węcowski, describe the contributions as differing in method and in the strength of the conclusions they draw. The project and its publication were supported by the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education.

How it is organised

Part I, on regional reassessments, opens with Taracha on Mycenaean-Hittite interconnections and Oreshko on Aegean ethnic groups, under the names Ahhiyawa and Danu(na), in Hieroglyphic-Luwian evidence. Pfoh follows on socio-political change in the Levant, Emanuel on whether naval warfare can be told apart from piracy, and Killebrew on Cyprus and the southern Levant. Middleton and Núñez treat the Sea Peoples, in the Aegean and in the central Levant respectively; Ben-Shlomo and Maeir turn to Philistia, and Bürge and Fischer to Tell Abu al-Kharaz in the Jordan Valley (pp. 7–193).

Part II, on cross-cultural approaches, begins with Crielaard on individuals with multiple identities as go-betweens. Murray follows with eastern objects on the Greek mainland and Bourogiannis with the transmission of the alphabet to the Aegean. Vlachou writes on funerary and cult imagery, Martin on the marzeah, and Ekroth on holocaustic sacrifice in Greek religion and its ritual relations to the Levant (pp. 195–326).

Part III, on linguistic approaches, has five papers: Piwowarczyk on the chronology and dating of linguistic corpora, Rosół on early Semitic loanwords in Greek, Dardano on Semitic influences in Anatolian languages, Simon on Anatolian influences on Greek, and Watson on Anatolian influences in Semitic languages (pp. 327–441).

Part IV, on scientific perspectives, pairs a paper by Chyleński, Grynberg and Juras on using ancient DNA to approach the Sea Peoples with Nafplioti's paper on isotope ratio analysis for reconstructing past life-histories (pp. 443–465).

The papers

Taracha compares the share of Mycenaean-type pottery at Miletus, Panaztepe and Troy, and Miletus is also given as Millawanda and Milawata (pp. 11–15).

Pfoh argues for continuity in Levantine political structures after the twelfth-century crisis, and Núñez argues from the central Levant's pottery that local traditions carried through the Early Iron Age.

Killebrew's paper starts from the pottery that Cyprus sent to the Levant and then follows settlement change at the end of the Late Bronze Age. Kalavasos-Ayios Dhimitrios and Maroni-Vournes are named as abandoned urban centres, whereas Hala Sultan Tekke and Alassa were occupied through the transition. Kition flourished in the twelfth century, Palaepaphos continued into the Iron Age, and Maa-Palaeokastro and Pyla-Kokkinokremos were newly established. The paper also looks at Aegean-style material at the Philistine centres of Ashdod, Ashkelon, Gath and Ekron, and uses Late Cypriot IIC, IIIA and IIIB and Cypro-Geometric IA as its phases (pp. 81–88).

Ben-Shlomo sorts Philistine pottery into the groups he calls Philistine 1, 2 and 3 and describes forms and cooking vessels, with figurines from Ekron (pp. 141–157).

Bürge and Fischer read the Phase IX compound, finds and radiocarbon dates at Tell Abu al-Kharaz as evidence for trade, migration and changed cooking practice (pp. 170–179).

Crielaard takes ambiguous burials as evidence for mixed identities, among them Tomb 40 at Kourion-Kaloriziki, the Toumba burials at Lefkandi and Fondo Artiaco Tomb 104 at Kyme (pp. 196–201).

Murray places the eastern objects on the Greek mainland in their contexts at Mycenae and Tiryns, and Bourogiannis dates the origin of the Greek alphabet and follows its contact with Phoenician writing on Crete (pp. 221–254).

Vlachou's funerary material runs from the Aghia Triada sarcophagus and the painted larnakes of Gephyra and Tanagra to the Ahiram sarcophagus at Byblos and a Proto-White Painted pyxis of Late Cypriot IIIB in the Cyprus Museum (pp. 258–293).

Martin sets out the textual evidence for the marzeah and its proposed relation to the symposion, and Ekroth turns to burnt-bone deposits at Kommos, the Apollo Hylates altar at Kourion and the sacrificial calendar of Erchia (pp. 296–326).

Rosół, Dardano and Simon each weigh proposed borrowings between languages, from Semitic into Greek and Anatolian and from Anatolian into Greek, and Dardano also traces how Mesopotamian culture reached Central Anatolia (pp. 334–418).

On Naxos, Nafplioti tests strontium isotope ratios from the Late Helladic burials at Aplomata and Kamini against the hypothesis that they are those of migrants from the Argolid (pp. 451–457).

What it records

  • Three international workshops held in Warsaw between 2014 and 2016 supplied the results collected in the volume.p. 1
  • The editors set the volume's main chronological scope at about 1300–900 BCE and slightly beyond.p. 1
  • Locally produced Mycenaean-type wares make up over 95% of the ceramic material at Miletus V, according to Taracha.p. 11
  • Mycenaean-type pottery is under 1% of the material at Panaztepe and 2% at Troy, Taracha reports.p. 11
  • Pfoh argues that hierarchical territorial structures based on kinship and patronage persisted in the Levant after the twelfth-century crisis.p. 64
  • Base Ring II, White Shaved and White Slip II wares make up most Cypriot pottery imports in the Levant, Killebrew reports.p. 82
  • Enkomi and Sinda were rebuilt and reoccupied after violent destructions at the end of Late Cypriot IIC, Killebrew reports.p. 84
  • Núñez defines the central Levant as the stretch between Rass Naqura in the south and Rass Chekka in the north.p. 118
  • Núñez argues that Early Iron Age local ceramic traditions in the central Levant grew from principles rooted in the region as far back as the Middle Bronze Age.p. 121
  • Philistine cooking jugs stand about 20 cm high and hold about 2–3 litres, Ben-Shlomo describes.p. 144
  • Iron I levels at Ekron yielded more than forty fragments of undecorated zoomorphic figurines.p. 147
  • Phase IX at Tell Abu al-Kharaz included a compound of 46 m by 8 m with 21 rooms.p. 170
  • Fifteen samples from Tell Abu al-Kharaz went to radiocarbon analysis, thirteen from the basement and two from the upper storey.p. 170
  • Closed cooking pots make up 25% of cooking vessels in Phase IX at Tell Abu al-Kharaz.p. 177
  • Bürge and Fischer suggest that individuals or small groups came to Tell Abu al-Kharaz and intermingled or married with local people.p. 178
  • Late Helladic IIIB, a span of roughly 125 years, yields 121 securely dated eastern exotica in Murray's count.p. 223
  • Bourogiannis considers the end of the ninth century BCE or the early eighth century BCE the most likely time for the origin of the Greek alphabet.p. 242
  • Tomb 6 at Gephyra in the Tanagra area is reported to have held sixteen painted and unpainted larnakes.p. 258
  • The Ahiram sarcophagus was found in tomb V, one of nine tombs in the royal necropolis of Byblos.p. 261
  • N. Platon found the Episkopi chamber tomb and its larnax in 1946, and M. Platonos later published the find.p. 266
  • Martin estimates that marzeah and its cognates occur about 45 times in Near Eastern literary records.p. 296
  • Martin concludes that the marzeah and the symposion share only the broad feature of elite occasions with wine drinking.p. 303
  • Four of the 46 sacrifices in the Erchia calendar are specified as holocausts.p. 311
  • The Kommos deposit at Altar U held almost 40 kg of heavily burnt cattle, sheep and goat bones, mainly thighbones and tails.p. 321
  • Rosół estimates approximately 50–80 Semitic loanwords in early Greek, depending on the certainty given to individual etymologies.p. 342
  • More than 30,000 tablet fragments, representing about 10,000 tablets, have been recovered from the Hittite capital at Hattuša, Dardano reports.p. 347
  • Mesopotamian culture reached Central Anatolia by direct import from Assyria and Babylonia and through Hurrian intermediaries, in Dardano's account.p. 369
  • Fewer than 30 of nearly 160 Greek words proposed as Anatolian loans withstand Simon's critical analysis.p. 380
  • Seven human enamel samples from the Aplomata and Kamini cemeteries were analysed for strontium isotope ratios.p. 455
  • Human enamel from the Naxos cemeteries gave a mean strontium isotope ratio of 0.70953 ± 0.00044, with values from 0.70904 to 0.71047, Nafplioti reports.p. 455
  • Nafplioti concludes that the isotope results do not support identifying the richly furnished Aplomata and Kamini burials as those of mainland Mycenaean refugees.p. 456

Where to read

  • Mycenaean pottery shares at Miletus, Panaztepe and Troypp. 11–15
  • Oreshko on Ahhiyawa, Hiyawa and the Cilician inscriptionspp. 23–30
  • Pfoh on patronage and political continuity in the Levantpp. 57–64
  • Cypriot imports and Late Bronze Age exchangepp. 81–83
  • Cypriot settlement change and Aegeanizationpp. 83–88
  • Philistine pottery groups, forms and cooking vesselspp. 142–145
  • Tell Abu al-Kharaz Phase IX compound, finds and radiocarbon datespp. 170–171
  • Tell Abu al-Kharaz evidence for trade, migration and cooking practicepp. 175–179
  • Ambiguous tombs at Kourion, Lefkandi and Kyme as evidence for mixed identitiespp. 196–201
  • Proto-White Painted pyxis and ritual drinking imageryp. 267
  • Marzeah texts and its proposed relation to the symposionpp. 296–303
  • Naxos isotope method, samples, results and conclusionspp. 451–457

Contents

  • Part I: Change, Continuity, and Connectivity: Regional Reassessments7
  • Approaches to Mycenaean-Hittite Interconnections in the Late Bronze Age8
  • Ahhiyawa - Danu(na). Aegean ethnic groups in the Eastern Mediterranean in the Light of Old and New Hieroglyphic-Luwian Evidence23
  • Socio-Political Changes and Continuities in the Levant (1300-900 BCE)57
  • Differentiating Naval Warfare and Piracy in the Late Bronze–Early Iron Age Mediterranean: Possibility or Pipe Dream?68
  • From “Global” to “Glocal”: Cultural Connectivity and Interactions between Cyprus and the Southern Levant during the Transitional Late Bronze and Early Iron Ages81
  • ‘I would walk 500 miles and I would walk 500 more’: The Sea Peoples and Aegean migration at the end of the Late Bronze Age95
  • The impact of the Sea Peoples in Central Levant. A Revision116
  • Pottery and Terracottas in Philistia during the Early Iron Age: Aspects of Change and Continuity141
  • The Philistines be upon thee, Samson (Jud. 16:20): Reassessing the Martial Nature of the Philistines – Archaeological Evidence vs. Ideological Image?158
  • The Early Iron Age at Tell Abu al-Kharaz, Jordan Valley, and its Relations to the Eastern Mediterranean: Trade, Migration, Hybridization, and Other Phenomena169
  • Part II: Cross-Cultural Approaches195
  • Hybrid go-betweens: the role of individuals with multiple identities in cross-cultural contacts in the Late Bronze Age and Iron Age central and eastern Mediterranean196
  • Imported Objects in the Aegean beyond Élite Interaction: A Contextual Approach to Eastern Exotica on the Greek Mainland221
  • The Transmission of the Alphabet to the Aegean235
  • New Images, Old Practices? An Imagery of Funerary Rituals and Cult in the Aegean and the Eastern Mediterranean258
  • Eastern Mediterranean Feasts: What Do We Really Know About the Marzeah?294
  • Holocaustic sacrifices in ancient Greek religion and the ritual relations to the Levant308
  • Part III: Linguistic Approaches327
  • Chronology and dating of linguistic corpora328
  • Early Semitic Loanwords in Greek334
  • Semitic influences in Anatolian languages345
  • Anatolian influences on Greek376
  • Anatolian Influences in Semitic Languages419
  • Part IV: Scientific Perspectives443
  • Late Bronze Age migrations in the Mediterranean. Prospects for approaching the problem of Sea Peoples using ancient DNA444
  • Isotope ratio analysis as a tool for reconstructing past life-histories451

Objects published here

9
  • Proto-White Painted pyxis of Late Cypriot IIIB, Cyprus Museum, Cyprus, 1968/5–30/113, fig. 12 (p. 267)
  • Frying pan with longboat, National Archaeological Museum of Athens, P5053, fig. 10 (p. 287)
  • Ahiram sarcophagus, tomb V, royal necropolis of Byblos, fig. 4a-b (p. 261)
  • Painted larnax from a chamber tomb, Ierapetra Archaeological Museum, chamber tomb at Episkopi, figs 11a-b (p. 266)
  • Limestone sarcophagus from tomb 4, Herakleion Archaeological Museum, tomb 4 at Aghia Triada, 396, fig. 1 (p. 259)
  • Ivory with a celebration scene, Israel Museum, Megiddo, IAA 1938-781, fig. 3 (p. 302)
  • Metal bowl with a reclining-feast scene, Cesnola collections, Cyprus (likely), New York 74.51.4555, Cy 13 (p. 300)
  • Metal bowl with a reclining-feast scene, Cesnola collections, Cyprus (likely), New York 74.51.4557, Cy 6 (p. 300)
  • Metal bowl with a reclining-feast scene, Cyprus (likely), London 1982/5-19/1, Cy 5 (p. 300)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Mursili IIHittite king
  • Piyamaraduanti-Hittite leader
  • Ramesses IIIEgyptian ruler in Sea Peoples accounts
  • N. Platonfound the Episkopi tomb in 1946
  • M. Platonospublished the Episkopi sarcophagus
  • Herodotussource for travel and cultural contact

Institutions

  • Cyprus Museumholds a Proto-White Painted pyxis
  • Herakleion Museumholds the Aghia Triada sarcophagus
  • Ierapetra Archaeological Museumholds the Episkopi larnax
  • National Archaeological Museum of Athensholds the longboat frying pan
  • Israel Museumholds the Megiddo celebration ivory

Places

  • Levantregional interactions and political change
  • Tell Abu al-KharazPhase IX compound and migration evidence
  • AplomataLate Helladic cemetery on Naxos
  • KaminiLate Helladic cemetery on Naxos
  • Chora of Naxoscemeteries and isotope baseline
  • Naxosisotope study of Late Bronze Age burials
  • MiletusMycenaean centre and port
  • Panaztepesite with Mycenaean-type pottery
  • Troysite discussed in Hittite texts
  • Çine-TepecikLate Bronze Age settlement and trade site
  • Enkomirebuilt after destruction at Late Cypriot IIC end
  • SindaCypriot settlement rebuilt after destruction
  • KitionCypriot centre flourishing in the twelfth century
  • PalaepaphosCypriot settlement continuing into the Iron Age
  • Maa-Palaeokastronewly established Late Bronze Age settlement
  • Pyla-Kokkinokremosnewly established Late Bronze Age settlement
  • Tel Miqne-EkronPhilistine settlement and exchange site
  • AshdodPhilistine centre with Aegean-style material
  • AshkelonPhilistine centre and pottery findspot
  • GathPhilistine centre with varied Aegeanization
  • Jordan Valleyregional setting of Tell Abu al-Kharaz
  • Kourion-KalorizikiTomb 40 discussed as an ambiguous burial
  • LefkandiToumba burials and imported objects
  • KymeFondo Artiaco Tomb 104
  • Mycenaedistribution of eastern imports
  • Tirynsimports in ritual and workshop contexts
  • Creteearly alphabet and Phoenician contact
  • Aghia Triadasarcophagus and funerary imagery
  • Gephyraburial ground with painted larnakes
  • TanagraMycenaean larnax burial grounds
  • ByblosAhiram royal necropolis
  • Episkopichamber tomb and painted larnax
  • Kommossanctuary with burnt-bone deposits
  • KourionApollo Hylates sanctuary and altar
  • Erchiademe with a sacrificial calendar
  • HattušaHittite capital and tablet archives
  • Argolidproposed source region for migrants

Also named: Uhha-ziti, Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education, University of Warsaw, National Oceanography Centre, Warsaw, Kalavasos-Ayios Dhimitrios, Maroni-Vournes, Hala Sultan Tekke, Alassa.

Extent 477 pp.

Defines Philistine 1, Philistine 2, Philistine 3, marzeah, thysia, boustrophedon, calque

Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicEarly Bronze AgePotteryTradeSeafaringBurialReligion and Cult

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

3 pages

Who did what

2 records

Excavation 1

Recording and study 1

  • Francisco J. NúñezStudied

    Francisco J. Núñez was in charge of studying the Early Iron Age levels at Chhim.

    p. 119

Mentioned in

7 mentions

Tomb records · 4

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.