Book · 1977
The Church of the Panagia Kanakaria at Lythrankomi in Cyprus: Its Mosaics and Frescoes
A. H. S. Megaw and E. J. W. Hawkins
Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks
A study of the church of the Panagia Kanakaria at Lythrankomi, covering its building history, its apse mosaic, its frescoes and an appendix on a Cypriot wonderworking image.
Megaw and Hawkins study the church of the Panagia Kanakaria at Lythrankomi through its architecture, its apse mosaic, its fresco decoration and the documentary record. The book relates each alteration of the building to the decoration that survives and assesses the mosaic's iconography, style, lettering and technique.
Part One describes the exterior and interior and reconstructs the structural history from the original basilica through successive restorations. Part Two analyses the mosaic, moving from its borders and central composition to theme, iconography, style, inscriptions, technique and conclusions. Part Three describes the frescoes by period. An appendix reviews accounts of a wonderworking image in Cyprus and asks whether it can be identified with the Lythrankomi mosaic, and a select index closes the volume.
The evidence
The building history rests on masonry, structural joints, measurements, reused blocks and capitals, earlier plans and observations made during repair work. A probe on the north side of the apse in 1961 exposed the original wall face and an immured column (pp. 23–30).
The mosaic is documented through surviving tesserae, plaster beds, pigment traces and detached fragments, with photographs and drawings and comparison with other early Christian monuments. Cleaning and consolidation left the mosaic in place (pp. 132–136).
The fresco evidence includes an early painted inscription and cross, twelfth-century figures of Gabriel and St. Barbara, two superimposed images of St. George, fragments assigned to a Last Judgment and a later cycle in the bema and nave (pp. 147–159).
The argument
Megaw and Hawkins reconstruct the first church as a column-basilica with a timber roof and place it in the last years of the fifth century, citing the apse masonry, reused architectural members and comparison with other basilicas. They propose a first restoration around 700, when pier arcades replaced the colonnades, and a second, probably in the twelfth century, when a dome and vaults were introduced. They place the rebuilding of the south aisle in the thirteenth century and a third major restoration around 1500, which rebuilt the central dome and brought extensive redecoration (pp. 23–36).
The mosaic's central image shows the enthroned Theotokos with the Christ Child, attended by archangels and enclosed by a mandorla. An outer border, an iridescent border, an apostle medallion band and an ornamental intermediate border frame it, and the authors identify thirteen intended apostle medallions, several now lost. They argue that the mosaic was set around 526–530 and that the apse and mosaic survived the later rebuilding, although the mosaic is fragmentary and partly obscured by structural work. The early treatment of the Theotokos and Child, the archangels and the Paradise setting, together with the border designs, the choice of apostles, the letterforms and stylistic comparisons, support that date. They regard the design as metropolitan in theme and composition, while allowing that its iconographic conservatism and stylistic mixture may reflect a local Cypriot hand and treating the exact source of the workmanship as unresolved (pp. 137–145).
Marina Sacopoulo proposed a Chalcedonian reading of the mandorla; the authors consider it and note that the evidence does not establish it (pp. 77–85).
In the appendix they conclude that the Lythrankomi apse mosaic cannot be securely identified as the image of the wonderworking legend, whose location and appearance the surviving accounts do not establish. The appendix compares manuscript accounts and later retellings and separates their claims from the evidence for the surviving mosaic (pp. 161–170).
Dating
Megaw and Hawkins date the frescoes by their relation to the building phases and by stylistic comparison: the cross and inscription to the ninth or tenth century, the Gabriel and Barbara decoration to the later twelfth century, the first St. George panel to the thirteenth century and the Last Judgment scenes to the fourteenth (pp. 27–36, 147–159).
What it records
- The Panagia Kanakaria stands beside Lythrankomi on the Carpas peninsula.p. 1
- Megaw directed work in 1950 that exposed a substantial area of the previously concealed mosaic.p. 2
- Cleaning and consolidation removed no part of the mosaic from the church structure.p. 2
- The main apse of the Panagia Kanakaria has an external radius of 6.50 metres.p. 13
- Megaw and Hawkins assign the original basilica to the last years of the fifth century.p. 30
- Megaw and Hawkins hold that the mosaic must be set somewhat later than the original construction of the basilica.p. 30
- Megaw and Hawkins consider the original wood-roofed basilica unlikely to have survived the Arab incursions of the mid-seventh century, which places the first restoration after them.p. 30
- Megaw and Hawkins consider the second restoration reasonably assignable to the twelfth century.p. 34
- Megaw and Hawkins associate the damage preceding the second restoration with a possible mid-twelfth-century earthquake.p. 35
- The Apostle Border was designed to contain thirteen medallions.p. 40
- The central composition of the apse mosaic includes the enthroned Virgin and Child, with attendant archangels.p. 49
- Megaw and Hawkins propose that the mosaic was set between 526 and 530.p. 140
- An earlier painted inscription may refer to work involving an archbishop, a reading the authors present as tentative.p. 148
- Megaw and Hawkins date the earlier panel of St. George probably within the thirteenth century.p. 153
- A graffito beside the later St. George panel bears the date 1598.p. 158
- Megaw and Hawkins reject a secure identification of the apse mosaic with the image in the wonderworking legend.p. 169
Where to read
- Structural sequence and first basilica planpp. 23–36
- Apostle medallions and border designpp. 38–49
- Central image, mandorla and iconographic interpretationpp. 49–84
- Mosaic dating and metropolitan or provincial connectionspp. 109–146
- Painted inscription and crosspp. 147–150
- Twelfth-century frescoes and St. George panelspp. 150–153
- Last Judgment scenes and later church decorationpp. 153–159
- Accounts of the wonderworking Cypriot imagepp. 161–170
Contents
- Part One: The Church and Its Structural History11
- The Exterior11
- The Interior14
- The Nave15
- The Aisles18
- The Bema20
- The Plan of the Original Basilica24
- The Date of the Original Basilica26
- The First Restoration30
- The Second Restoration34
- The Third and Later Restorations35
- Part Two: The Mosaic37
- Description37
- The Theme61
- Iconography85
- Style115
- The Paleography of the Inscriptions121
- Column Writing127
- Technique132
- Conclusions137
- Part Three: The Frescoes147
- The Early Fragments147
- Redecoration Following the Second Restoration150
- The Earlier Panel of St. George152
- The Last Judgment Scenes153
- The Last Redecoration155
- Appendix: A Wonderworking Mosaic in Cyprus161
- Select Index171
People, places and institutions
People
- K. Papageorghiouinvestigated the church in 1966
- Jakov Smirnovfirst studied the mosaic in 1895
- Chrysanthosabbot named in a 1779 inscription
- Marina Sacopouloproposed a doctrinal reading of the mandorla
- Leontios Makhairaschronicler who refers to Kanakaria
Institutions
- Cyprus Department of Antiquitiesconducted church investigations and repairs
- Dumbarton Oakssupported fieldwork and publication
Places
- Panagia Kanakariachurch and apse mosaic studied
- Lythrankomivillage beside the church
- Carpas peninsulalocation of the church
- Kitichurch mosaic used for comparison
- Panagia tis Kyraschurch with another apse mosaic
- Salamis-Constantiabasilicas and mosaics for comparison
- Ayia Triasbasilica in the Carpas for comparison
- AphentrikaCarpas basilicas for comparison
- St. Polyeuktoschurch with sculptural borders for comparison
- Bawitmonastery frescoes for comparison
- Saqqaramonastery frescoes for comparison
- Salonicamosaics and sculpture for comparison
- Ravennaearly Byzantine mosaics for comparison
- Monastery of St. Catherinemosaic and icon for comparison
- Church of the Nativity at Bethlehemcomparison for Incarnation imagery
Also named: Cyprus Museum.
Extent 143 plates; linecuts A–O; plans and sections; select index
Defines Apostle Border, Intermediate Border, Irisated Border, Outer Border, kionedon
Late AntiqueMedievalModernArchitectureReligion and CultIconographyHistory of Archaeology
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageWho did what
16 recordsExcavation 3
Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawRecorded
Megaw and Hawkins subsequently supervised investigations carried out for the Department during church repairs.
investigations carried out during repair of the churchPanagia Kanakaria
Athanasios PapageorghiouExcavated
Papageorghiou excavated in the church, where fallen mosaic fragments were found.
fallen fragments of mosaicsPanagia Kanakaria, Lythrankomi
Theophilus MogabgabRecorded
Mogabgab initially supervised investigations carried out for the Department during repair of the church.
investigations carried out during repair of the churchPanagia Kanakaria, Lythrankomi
Recording and study 12
- 1895 · p. 1
Jakov SmirnovStudied
Icons and church artSmirnov first studied the church and its surviving mosaic fragments during a visit to Cyprus.
church and mosaicPanagia Kanakaria, Lythrankomi
- 1950 · p. 2
Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawRecorded
Icons and church artMegaw directed work that exposed a substantial area of the previously concealed mosaic.
Panagia Kanakaria
- 1952–1966 · p. 2
Ernest HawkinsRestored
Icons and church artHawkins completed the mosaic's conservation during visits to Cyprus in 1952, 1961, and 1966.
Panagia Kanakaria
- 1966 · p. 2
Kostas ZaferiadesHelpedErnest Hawkins
Icons and church artZaferiades assisted Hawkins during his later conservation work.
mosaicPanagia Kanakaria
- 1970 · p. 2
Ernest HawkinsRestored
Icons and church artHawkins finalized the treatment of the mosaic's lost areas.
Panagia Kanakaria
- p. 2
Christos TsourtsosHelpedErnest Hawkins
Icons and church artTsourtsos assisted Hawkins throughout his later conservation work.
mosaicPanagia Kanakaria
- p. 2
Yiannis MakridesHelpedErnest Hawkins
Icons and church artMakrides assisted Hawkins during his later conservation work.
mosaicPanagia Kanakaria
Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawSurveyed
Megaw jointly surveyed the structure of the church with Hawkins.
Panagia Kanakaria
Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawPublished
Icons and church artMegaw published a study of the church, its mosaics, and its frescoes with Hawkins.
church, mosaics, and frescoesPanagia Kanakaria, Lythrankomi
Ernest HawkinsSurveyed
Hawkins jointly surveyed the structure of the church with Megaw.
Panagia Kanakaria
Ernest HawkinsStudied
Icons and church artHawkins prepared descriptions of the mosaic, its technique, and the frescoes.
mosaic and frescoesPanagia Kanakaria
Ernest HawkinsPublished
Icons and church artHawkins published a study of the church, its mosaics, and its frescoes with Megaw.
church, mosaics, and frescoesPanagia Kanakaria, Lythrankomi
Posts and family 1
- 1935–1960 · p. 2
Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawEmployed byDept. of Antiquities of Cyprus
Mr. A.H.S. Megaw directed the Department of Antiquities during most of the colonial period.
Cyprus
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.