Book · 2024
After 1177 B.C.: The survival of civilizations
E. H. Cline
Princeton University Press
A study of how eight societies of the Aegean and Eastern Mediterranean, Cyprus among them, responded to the Late Bronze Age Collapse, read through archaeology, texts, climate research and resilience concepts.
Cline traces what happened to eight societies after the Late Bronze Age Collapse, from Egypt and the southern Levant to Assyria, Babylonia, Phoenicia, Cyprus, Anatolia, northern Syria and the Aegean. He combines archaeological finds and written evidence with climate research and modern approaches to societal resilience, and asks how survivors coped, adapted or transformed and how outcomes differed between regions.
How it is organised
A prologue asks whether the centuries after the Collapse should be called a Dark Age. Five chapters then proceed geographically: Egypt, Israel and the southern Levant; Assyria and Babylonia; Phoenicia and Cyprus; Anatolia and northern Syria; and the Aegean. Chapter Six, From Collapse to Resilience, compares the regional accounts through resilience concepts and categories, and an epilogue, End of a Dark Age, returns to the period label. Acknowledgments, a dramatis personae, notes, references and an index complete the book (pp. 201–314).
The argument
Cline holds that a geographical arrangement best shows how societies responded over time. He presents the aftermath as several regional histories, since societies faced different conditions and made different choices about coping, adapting or transforming. Particular objects, above all inscriptions and other artefacts, carry the account, and Cline notes that the surviving record is much fuller for some societies than for others (pp. xxiv–xxvi).
For Cyprus he describes a resilient, reorganising island instead of an islandwide collapse. He considers the evidence for abandonment and relocation, for new or growing centres, for ironworking and for overseas exchange, and treats the degree of disruption as unresolved because the archaeological record does not settle how severely Cyprus was affected (pp. 84–94, 109–110).
Settlement shifted during the transition. Hala Sultan Tekke and Enkomi were left, while Idalion and Amathous were founded or grew, and Cline suggests that political reorganisation eventually produced the island's city-states, visible by the ninth and eighth centuries BCE (pp. 90–91).
In the comparison of chapter six, Cline places Cyprus and the central Canaanites, whom he identifies with the Phoenicians, in his highest resilience category. He ties Cyprus to continued trading, ironworking, and changes in settlement and political organisation, and stresses that the ranking is tentative and rests on fragmentary evidence. Across his wider account, recovery follows a period of disruption, with reintegration and renewed interconnection beginning from the ninth century BCE (pp. 158–160, 171–173).
The evidence
The regional chapters draw on inscriptions, written accounts, burials, pottery, settlement patterns and environmental evidence. Written inscriptions give abundant information for societies such as Assyria, Babylonia and Egypt, Cline says, while many individual details about the Mycenaeans, Minoans and Cypriots are unavailable. For Cyprus he discusses changes in graves and grave goods, pottery, settlement abandonment and new foundations, and pollen evidence for arid conditions near Hala Sultan Tekke (pp. xxv, 89–90).
Metalwork links Cyprus to exchange. Cline considers the earliest worked iron objects, including knives with bronze rivets found at sites around the Aegean, and reviews proposals that Cypriot metalworkers helped develop or spread ironworking. He also takes up copper production, exports of bronze vessels and stands, iron knives and swords, and contacts reaching Crete, the Greek mainland, the Levant and the western Mediterranean (pp. 85–88, 93–94).
So-called warrior burials occur in Cyprus, Crete and mainland Greece. Cline describes the Opheltas obelos from Tomb 49 at Palaepaphos-Skales and the bronze vessels, weapons and other goods from that grave. He uses the Tale of Wenamun, a narrative preserved on papyrus, to discuss contacts among Egypt, Dor, Byblos and Cyprus, and distinguishes the tale from independently established historical events (pp. 91–97).
Dating
Cline calls the Collapse the end of the Late Bronze Age and generally names the following centuries the Iron Age. For Cyprus he places disruption and change in the twelfth century BCE, movement of settlement toward the end of that century and in the early eleventh, and warrior burials from the mid-eleventh to the early tenth century BCE. In the epilogue he argues that Dark Age is an unsuitable general label for the period (pp. 195–199).
What it records
- Cline argues that arranging the book by region better shows how separate societies responded to the Collapse over time.p. xxv
- Cline states that it is now generally agreed that Cyprus did not undergo an overall islandwide collapse.p. 89
- Hala Sultan Tekke was abandoned when its harbour silted up, and its inhabitants are thought to have moved to nearby Kition.p. 90
- Enkomi's inhabitants relocated to Salamis after its harbour silted up at the beginning of the eleventh century BCE.p. 90
- Tomb 49 at Palaepaphos-Skales held three bronze obeloi, one of them inscribed for Opheltas.p. 92
- Warrior burials occur in cemeteries at Palaepaphos-Skales, Salamis, Lapithos-Kastros, Kourion-Kaloriziki and Amathous.p. 93
- Iron knives occur in larger quantities in eleventh-century BCE contexts outside Cyprus, in Crete, Greece, Syria and the southern Levant.p. 93
- Cyprus was incorporated into the Neo-Assyrian Empire without evidence of physical conquest, Cline states.p. 109
- A stele set up at Kition names seven Cypriot kingdoms, and an Esarhaddon prism names ten.p. 109
- Cline argues that Cyprus and the Phoenicians came through the post-Collapse transformation more successfully than the other societies he discusses.p. 110
Where to read
- Iron technology and Cypriot exports of knives, swords and bronze objectspp. 85–93
- Cyprus after the Late Bronze Age Collapse and the debate over continuitypp. 88–91
- Tomb 49 at Palaepaphos-Skales and the Opheltas obelospp. 91–92
- Warrior burials on Cyprus and in the Aegeanpp. 92–93
- Cypriot trade and contacts with Phoenicians and the Aegeanpp. 93–110
- The adaptive cycle and its application to the Late Bronze Age Collapsepp. 160–171
- Resilience categories and Cline’s assessment of Cypruspp. 171–173
- The argument for calling the period the Iron Age rather than a Dark Agepp. 195–199
Contents
- Prologue: Welcome to the Iron Age1
- Chapter One: The Year of the Hyenas, When Men Starved (Egypt, Israel, and the Southern Levant)7
- Chapter Two: Conqueror of All Lands, Avenger of Assyria (Assyria and Babylonia)42
- Chapter Three: The Mediterranean Became a Phoenician Lake (Phoenicia and Cyprus)80
- Chapter Four: King of the Land of Carchemish (Anatolia and Northern Syria)111
- Chapter Five: In the Shadow of the Ruined Palaces (Aegean Region)134
- Chapter Six: From Collapse to Resilience157
- Epilogue: End of a Dark Age195
- References251
- Index305
Objects published here
6- Bronze obelos inscribed with the name Opheltas, Tomb 49, Skales cemetery, Palaepaphos (p. 91)
- Bronze grave goods from Tomb 49, including the Opheltas obelos, Tomb 49, Skales cemetery, Palaepaphos (p. 92)
- Warrior vase from Mycenae, Mycenae, fig. 10 (p. 134)
- Bronze bowl with Phoenician inscription, Tomb J, Tekke cemetery, Knossos (p. 141)
- Iron knife and weapons from Knossos Tomb 201, Tomb 201, North Cemetery at Knossos (p. 145)
- Bronze amphora of Cypriot manufacture from the Hero of Lefkandi burial, Toumba building, Lefkandi (p. 148)
People, places and institutions
People
- Vassos Karageorghisexcavated Tomb 49 at Palaepaphos
- Opheltasname inscribed on a bronze obelos
- Maria Iacovouargues for continuity on Cyprus
- Vasiliki Kassianidouwrites on Cypriot metallurgy
- Nota Kourouwrites on Cypriot and Phoenician contacts
- Carol Bellwrites on Phoenician and Cypriot trade
- Jan Paul Crielaardwrites on Cypriot elite trade links
- Sargon IIset up a stele at Kition
- Esarhaddonten Cypriot kingdoms named on his prism
- WenamunEgyptian priest in a travel tale
Places
- Palaepaphos-Skalescemetery with Tomb 49 and warrior burials
- Tomb 49burial containing the Opheltas obelos
- Hala Sultan Tekkeabandoned port settlement
- Enkomisettlement whose people relocated to Salamis
- KitionCypriot city and Assyrian stele findspot
- Salamissettlement near Enkomi
- Idalioncity founded during the transition
- Amathousport city and warrior burial site
- Paphoscity and foundation tradition
- Knossossite with Cypriot and Phoenician material
- Lefkandisite of the Hero burial
- Creteregion in the Iron Age transition
- Greecepost-palatial region
Also named: Lapithos-Kastros, Kourion-Kaloriziki, Hatiba, University of Cyprus.
Extent Figs 1–14, 6 maps; references pp. 251–303; index pp. 305–314
Defines Iron Age, adaptive cycle, resiliency, coping, adapting, transforming, anti-fragile
Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricPotteryCopperTradeSeafaringWarfare
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
2 pages- Arms and Armour of Iron Age CyprusCompendium
- Cypro-Geometric CyprusCompendium
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1979–1980Palaepaphos-Skales: the Department's emergency excavationDirected by Vassos KarageorghisRescue excavation
Who did what
3 recordsExcavation 1
- p. 91
Vassos KarageorghisFound
Vassos Karageorghis discovered Tomb 49 in the Skales cemetery at Palaepaphos.
Recording and study 1
- p. 145
Hector CatlingStudied
Hector Catling examined warrior burials and grave goods at Knossos and compared the objects with Cypriot finds.
warrior burials and Cypriot grave goodsNo. Tombs 186 and 201
Posts and family 1
- p. 59
Ernest Alfred Thompson Wallis BudgeEmployed byBritish Museum
E. A. Wallis Budge was a curator at the British Museum.
People it is cited for
1 personMentioned in
4 mentionsTomb records · 1
- Palaepaphos-Skales, Karageorghis Tomb 49
Discussion, passing mention · 2024 · p. 91
- On Ancient Cyprus · 2listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
- Excavations · 1listed under Excavations it is cited for
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.