Book · 2023
Earthquakes and Gardens: Saint Hilarion's Cyprus
A study of Jerome's *Life of Hilarion* and its accounts of earthquake-damaged Paphos and the hermit's Cypriot garden, read with archaeology, historical seismology, literature and art.
Burrus reads Jerome's Life of Hilarion through its pictures of Paphos, the earthquake damage there and the hermit's two Cypriot dwellings. Close readings of short passages are combined with archaeology and historical seismology, and with poems, visual art, museum displays and gardens. Hilarion's Cyprus is set alongside places and works of other periods, to ask how texts and material remains give access to a place.
How it is organised
Part One, Points of Departure, opens with Burrus's experience of the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, then sets out her reading method and introduces Jerome's Life. Part Two, on Paphos, has three sections: Poetry and Place, Curating Earthquakes and Life in Ruins. They move from literary representations of the goddess's city to earthquake evidence, museum interpretation and the afterlives of buildings.
Part Three, The Mountain, comprises Geographies of the Remote, Entropic Gardens and Literary Cartographies, and takes up remote landscapes, garden practices and proposals for the location of Hilarion's hermitage. Part Four, An Ocean of Possibility, is the coda, followed by acknowledgments, notes, a bibliography and an index.
The argument
Burrus proposes a place-centred, geocritical reading of a saint's life, treating place as active and continually shaped by human and nonhuman relations. Her close reading breaks the Life into fragments and sets them in dialogue with other texts, objects and artworks. She uses chora for a place understood as an ongoing, relational process, and argues that this approach keeps open ambiguities that a single historical reconstruction could close down (pp. 7–9, 28–34).
Earthquakes and gardens are linked as material events and as interpretive figures. Ruins show both sudden destruction and slower decay, and gardens show how life continues through relations among plants, water, soil, animals and people. Burrus resists accounts that make an earthquake a single turning point in Christianization; in her reading of Jerome, Hilarion's interventions address human vulnerability, while the ruined city and temple remain sites of continuing change.
On the hermitage, she concludes that Jerome's account does not permit a secure location. Suggested sites include Hilarion's Castle near Kyrenia, a cave near Episkopi in the Paphos district, the Aphrodite sanctuary at Old Paphos, Garrison's Camp in Nea Paphos and Agia Moni, and she treats these proposals as products of interaction between text, topography and archaeological remains, with none established by the evidence she reviews (pp. 135–142).
The closing argument presents place as an active matrix of relations in which human, animal, vegetal and material agencies shape one another. Burrus extends it to the study of religion, suggesting that attention to place, transience and shared vulnerability may inform how religious experience is understood (pp. 151–155).
The evidence
Jerome's Life supplies the central evidence: Hilarion's travel to Cyprus, his arrival at Paphos, the city's earthquake damage and the descriptions of his dwellings. Burrus compares these passages with accounts by Ammianus Marcellinus, Libanius and Sozomen, considering how chronology, location and literary purpose affect their testimony. She also discusses archaeological evidence from Kourion, including earthquake-damaged buildings, coins and human remains, and asks whether Paphos suffered damage in the same seismic sequence (pp. 12–19, 54–58).
For Paphos, the city's houses, theatre, basilica and reused architectural fragments trace repair, abandonment and repurposing. The House of Dionysos is contrasted with the rebuilt House of Theseus, and stones from the theatre were reused in the nearby Chrysopolitissa basilica, where inscriptions associated with Eustorgis connect the two buildings. Burrus also describes the Kourion Archaeological Museum, its display of earthquake victims and the history of the excavation house that holds it (pp. 58–63, 73–79).
Poetry about Aphrodite and Paphos, early modern images of ruins and contemporary installations about earthquakes and remoteness run alongside this material. The mountain chapters compare Jerome's description of Hilarion's garden with ancient agricultural writing, natural farming and post-industrial gardens, and the last of them follows efforts to locate the hermitage through historical accounts, maps, local traditions and archaeological proposals (pp. 93–147).
Dating
Burrus considers a possible earthquake sequence around 364–365 CE and distinguishes it from the wider, uncertain dating of seismic events across the eastern Mediterranean in the fourth to sixth centuries. Jerome's narrative places the tsunami at Epidaurus after Julian's death, while Ammianus dates the earthquake and tsunami to 21 July 365. She suggests that several events clustered around 365 fit the evidence better than a single earthquake affecting all the sites discussed (pp. 13–18).
Hilarion's own chronology comes from Jerome: he is said to have arrived in Cyprus around 364, spent two years near Paphos and five years at his remote retreat, and died in 371. Paphos then passes through phases of repair and reuse, among them the rebuilding of the House of Theseus after earthquake damage and the reuse of theatre materials in a Christian basilica (pp. 74–76).
What it records
- Jerome wrote the Life of Hilarion in Bethlehem around 390 CE and dedicated it to Asella.p. 9
- Ammianus Marcellinus dates the earthquake and tsunami to 21 July 365, just after dawn.p. 13
- Jerome says that Paphos had repeatedly fallen because of earthquakes and that its ruins showed its former state.p. 16
- Jerome places Hilarion's first Cypriot dwelling two miles outside Paphos.p. 16
- A reconstruction that Burrus cites places a main earthquake off Crete around 365 CE, a probably smaller one off Cyprus and possibly another between Sicily and Libya.p. 17
- The latest coins found at Kourion date the city's destructive earthquake to between March 364 and September 365.p. 18
- Jerome describes Hilarion's later retreat as twelve miles from the sea, with trees, flowing water, a garden and fruit trees.p. 23
- The remains of three earthquake victims are displayed in the Kourion Archaeological Museum in a case partly embedded in dirt.p. 59
- The House of Dionysos at Paphos was built in the late second century and, according to archaeologists, destroyed by an earthquake in the fourth century.p. 74
- The House of Theseus at Paphos was rebuilt and enlarged from the later fourth century, incorporating parts of earlier buildings.p. 74
- The theatre at Paphos was quarried after its late fourth-century destruction, and its stone was reused in the nearby Chrysopolitissa basilica.p. 75
- A Greek inscription on a reused basilica column blesses Eustorgis with a phrase about thirst.p. 77
- In Jerome's account, Hilarion's Cypriot garden was under the jurisdiction of a nearby farm.p. 114
- Jerome's narrative says that Hilarion did not eat the fruit of the trees at his mountain retreat.p. 119
- A 1953 earthquake caused part of the Episkopi monolith to collapse, and a church dedicated to Hilarion was then built on top of it.p. 140
- A church pavement inscription at Tell Umm el-'Amr invokes Hilarion, and archaeologists speculate that a chamber below it was his cell and burial place.p. 146
- Burrus dates Hilarion's arrival in Cyprus to around 364 CE, based on Jerome's account of his age and years on the island.p. 163
Where to read
- Jerome's route for Hilarion to Cyprus, the Epidaurus tsunami and the earthquake chronologypp. 12–19
- Paphos, earthquake catalogues and the Kourion Archaeological Museum displayspp. 54–71
- House of Dionysos, House of Theseus, theatre and reused stones at Paphospp. 73–89
- Jerome's description of Hilarion's garden and Roman agricultural writingpp. 114–122
- Maps, travel and later traditions concerning Hilarionpp. 131–147
- Competing proposed locations for Hilarion's Cypriot hermitagepp. 135–142
- Place, religion and chorapp. 151–155
Contents
- Part One: Points of Departure
- Memories3
- Three Notes on Method7
- Setting Out, with Jerome9
- Part Two: Paphos
- Poetry and Place37
- Curating Earthquakes54
- Life in Ruins72
- Part Three: The Mountain
- Geographies of the Remote93
- Entropic Gardens114
- Literary Cartographies131
- Part Four: Coda
- An Ocean of Possibility151
- Acknowledgments157
- Notes161
- Bibliography185
- Index197
Objects published here
6- Three earthquake victims displayed in the museum at Kourion, Kourion Archaeological Museum, Ruins of a house at Kourion, fig. 2.5 (p. 59)
- Inscribed marble column in the Chrysopolitissa basilica, Chrysopolitissa basilica, Paphos, fig. 2.11 (p. 77)
- Conical stone identified with Aphrodite's cult image, Museum of Palaipaphos, Old Paphos, fig. 2.17 (p. 87)
- Saint Paul's Pillar, a worn marble column fragment, Ruins of the Chrysopolitissa basilica, Paphos, fig. 2.18 (p. 77)
- Aphrodite of Trikomo, also known as the Lady of Trikomo, Musée du Louvre, Trikomo, fig. 2.1 (p. 49)
- Aphrodite of Soloi, marble sculpture, Archaeological Museum, Nicosia, Soloi, Cyprus, fig. 2.2 (p. 50)
People, places and institutions
People
- Jerome of Stridonwrote the *Life of Hilarion*
- Hilarionhermit whose life Jerome narrates
- Antonyhermit and Hilarion's mentor
- Epiphaniusbishop who knew Hilarion
- Hesychiusdisciple who removed Hilarion's body
- Ammianus Marcellinushistorian who dates the 365 earthquake
- Libaniusrhetorician whose speech links earthquakes with Julian
- Sozomenchurch historian on Hilarion and Cyprus
- David Sorendirected excavations at Kourion
- Emanuela Guidobonihistorical seismologist cited on earthquakes
- George McFaddenfunded and headed Kourion excavations
- Thomas Davisarchaeologist who wrote on Kourion
- Eustorgisnamed in inscriptions at Paphos
- Fikret Demiragpoet writing about Cyprus
- Stephanos Stephanidespoet writing about Cyprus
- Sissel Marie Tonnartist making earthquake installations
- Masanobu Fukuokaproponent of natural farming
- Ilona Opeltproposed locations for Hilarion's retreats
- NeophytosCypriot hermit who wrote about Hilarion
- Gennadiosvisitor who died seeking Hilarion's mountain
Institutions
- Department of Antiquities of the Republic of Cyprusauthority responsible for Cypriot antiquities
- Kourion Archaeological Museummuseum displaying earthquake victims from Kourion
- University of Pennsylvania Museumreceived objects from Kourion
Places
- Paphoscity repeatedly damaged by earthquakes
- Kourioncity and excavation site damaged by earthquake
- Old Paphossite of Aphrodite's sanctuary
- Epidaurussetting for Hilarion's tsunami miracle
- Episkopiproposed location of Hilarion's hermitage
- Hilarion’s Castlenorthern Cypriot castle linked to Hilarion
- Garrison’s Campproposed location of Hilarion's hermitage
- Agia Moniproposed site of Hilarion's hermitage
- Chrysopolitissa basilicabasilica built with reused theatre stone
- Tell Umm el-'Amrsite of a monastery associated with Hilarion
- Geroskiposlocality associated with a sacred grove
- Troodos Mountainsmountain region near proposed hermitage sites
- Constantiaisland metropolis discussed in the earthquake accounts
Also named: Asella.
Extent Figures 1.1–3.15; bibliography pp. 185–196; index pp. 197–201
Defines geocritical reading, hagiogeography, chora, periplous
Late AntiqueRomanModernChronology and DatingArchitectureReligion and CultLandscape and ClimateHistory of Archaeology
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- Earthquakes in Ancient CyprusCompendium
Excavations it is cited for
2 projects- 1934–1954Kourion: the Penn Museum excavations (Curium Expedition)Directed by George H. McFadden, Bert Hodge Hill, John Franklin Daniel and othersExcavation
- 1978–1985Kourion: the American excavation of the Sanctuary of Apollo HylatesDirected by Diana Buitron-Oliver and David SorenExcavation
Who did what
4 recordsBuying, selling and giving 1
- p. 63
George H. McFaddenAgent forUniversity of Pennsylvania Museum
McFadden's brief was to acquire objects for the University of Pennsylvania Museum, and objects from Kourion ended up in its collection.
some two thousand objects from Kourion
Excavation 3
- 1978–1987 · p. 18
David SorenDirected excavations
David Soren led excavations at Kourion.
- 1932–1953 · p. 61
George H. McFaddenDug forUniversity Museum, University of Pennsylvania
George H. McFadden supervised the excavation of tombs nos. 18 and 29 during the Kourion excavations for the Museum.
- 1934–1953 · p. 61
George H. McFaddenFinancedUniversity of Pennsylvania Museum
George McFadden funded the University of Pennsylvania Museum's excavations at Kourion.
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
Missing from this record
- Publisher not recorded
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.