Edited volume · 2019

Early Christianity in Asia Minor and Cyprus: From the Margins to the Mainstream

S. Mitchell and P. Pilhofer (eds.)

Leiden and Boston: Brill

A collection of nine papers on early Christianity in Asia Minor and Cyprus, from a workshop held in June 2018, using literary, epigraphic and archaeological evidence.

Papers from a workshop held in June 2018 trace the spread of Christianity across Asia Minor and Cyprus through regional studies of Cappadocia and Armenia Minor, episcopal authority in Constantinople, Sagalassus in Pisidia, inscriptions in Caria and the Christian epigraphy of Cyprus. Mitchell and Pilhofer, the editors, present them as an enquiry into the differing evidence for Christianization in each region. The chapters draw on Christian literary sources and hagiography alongside inscriptions and archaeological contexts, and for Cappadocia on church art. The introduction sets the relatively abundant funerary epigraphy of central Anatolia against the varied sources of the eastern and western regions, asks how far the visibility of inscriptions reflects Christianization and how far local practices of commemoration, and stresses that change came at different times in different places.

How it is organised

After the editors' introduction, which outlines the research project with its inscription database and regional monographs, nine chapters follow. Cassia writes on early Christianity in Cappadocia before the Council of Nicaea, with sections on chronology, Jewish presence and Judaeo-pagan syncretism. Mitchell treats hagiography and the Great Persecution in Sebastea and Armenia Minor, Arena martyrs, monks and heretics in Rocky Cappadocia, and Busine the cults of Saint Gordius and Saint Mamas. Zimmermann turns to Gregory of Nazianzus and village poetry, Kaçar to ecclesiastical jurisdiction between Constantinople and Asia Minor in the fourth century, Talloen to Sagalassus, Sitz to Caria and Summa to Cyprus. Indexes of sources, names, places and subjects close the volume.

The papers

Cassia gathers the evidence for Christians in Cappadocia from the origins of Christianity to the Council of Nicaea, in a survey that updates Harnack, and sets it beside the Jewish presence and Judaeo-pagan syncretism in the region. Mitchell examines the Forty Martyrs of Sebaste, including the Testament of the Forty Martyrs and its proposed burial place at Sareim, then the passiones of Athenogenes of Pedachthoe and Eustratius of Arauraka, and finally Diocletian's persecution on the Euphrates frontier. Arena follows the cult of Saint Hieron from vine dresser to warrior patron, with the Göreme and Çavuşin churches that show him, and moves on to caves, monks and hermits, heretical communities and the idea of Cappadocia as a holy land. Busine considers the evidence for Gordius and Mamas and their place in Caesarean civic and religious life (pp. 109–125).

Zimmermann reads Gregory of Nazianzus alongside Christian sepulchral epigrams, comparing Cappadocia and Lycaonia. Kaçar surveys jurisdictional disputes and appointments in the fourth century, where Nectarius and John Chrysostom appear, and asks whether canon 3 of the Council of Constantinople in 381 changed ecclesiastical jurisdiction.

Talloen follows Sagalassus from the Roman imperial period, when the city held the titles neokoros and proteia, through the fourth-century conversion of the Tychaeum and the question of Christian triumph to the sixth century, using excavation, inscriptions, sculpture and pottery. Sitz studies inscribed temples in Caria, at Labraunda, Lagina, Mylasa, Aphrodisias and elsewhere, and how their texts were kept on display, reused or altered in late antiquity; at Aphrodisias the Temple of Aphrodite became a church, and at Euromus a Carian inscription was shown in a chapel hagiasma (pp. 202–225).

Cyprus

Summa's preliminary study of Christian inscriptions begins with earlier scholarship and the Christian tradition on the island, in which Paul and Barnabas figure, and then sorts the inscriptions into funerary, building, honorific and other types (pp. 226–280). Salamis and its neighbourhood supply around fifty, and Paphos, Curium, Amathus, Soli, Chytri and Toumballos also yield texts. A sandstone block with the name of Paul, a cross and a palm frond was used as a step in the monastery of St Barnabas near Salamis, and a funerary cippus with staurograms from Kofinou is in the Larnaka museum. Among the building inscriptions, a mosaic in the basilica at Trimithus names Spyridon as its commissioner, and Eustorgios and Eustolios appear as benefactors, Eustolios at Curium.

What it records

  • Papers on early Christianity in Asia Minor and Cyprus were presented at a workshop held in June 2018.p. 2
  • Contributions treat Cappadocia, Armenia Minor, Constantinople, Caria, Pisidia and Cyprus.p. 2
  • Mitchell and Pilhofer note that estates, villages and small towns in inner Anatolia produced almost all early Christian epigraphic evidence from Asia Minor before Constantine.p. 6
  • An inscription from Kemerhisar, identified as Tyana, attests a Jewish presence in the imperial period, as reported by Cassia.p. 30
  • The authentic kernel of the Testament of the Forty Martyrs suggests that the original number of martyrs was three.p. 61
  • Mitchell argues that the trial records in the Passio of Athenogenes largely preserve the original exchanges.p. 66
  • Seven Christian epigrams are among the twenty-five epigrams known from Cappadocia, in Zimmermann's count.p. 131
  • The Council of Constantinople in 381 gave the bishop of Constantinople precedence in honour after the bishop of Rome.p. 156
  • Talloen dates the rise of Christianity at Sagalassus as a process extending from the early fourth to the middle of the sixth century.p. 196
  • Six of the eight probable examples of priest lists inscribed on temples come from Caria, according to Sitz.p. 209
  • A new marble anta block from the Temple of Zeus at Labraunda was uncovered in Andron A during excavations in 2014.p. 213
  • Around fifty Christian inscriptions come from Salamis and its vicinity, Summa reports.p. 227
  • An inscription on a cippus kept in the Larnaka museum has been dated to the early third century, Summa reports.p. 232

Where to read

  • Early Christian evidence and Jewish presence in Cappadociapp. 13–32
  • Cappadocian cults of Theos Hypsistos and Hypistarianspp. 33–39
  • The *Testament of the Forty Martyrs* and the proposed burial at Sareimpp. 54–61
  • The trials of Athenogenes and evidence for the 303 persecutionpp. 62–68
  • Hieron’s passio, Cappadocian sites and warrior-saint imagespp. 78–95
  • The Tychaeum conversion and de-sacralization at Sagalassuspp. 173–180
  • Temple inscriptions at Labraunda and late antique reusepp. 206–215
  • Cypriot building inscriptions, benefactors and bishopspp. 232–242

Contents

  • IntroductionStephen Mitchell, Philipp Pilhofer1
  • Between Paganism and Judaism: Early Christianity in CappadociaMargherita Cassia13
  • A Chronological Survey of the Evidence for Christians in Cappadocia—Harnack UpdatedMargherita Cassia15
  • From the Origins of Christianity to NervaMargherita Cassia15
  • From Trajan to the Reign of CommodusMargherita Cassia15
  • From the Severan Age to the Council of NicaeaMargherita Cassia17
  • Jewish Presence in CappadociaMargherita Cassia27
  • Judaeo-Pagan Syncretism in CappadociaMargherita Cassia32
  • ConclusionMargherita Cassia38
  • Hagiography and the Great Persecution in Sebastea and Armenia MinorStephen Mitchell49
  • The Forty Martyrs of SebasteStephen Mitchell54
  • The Passio of Saint Athenogenes of PedachthoeStephen Mitchell62
  • The Passio of Eustratius of AraurakaStephen Mitchell69
  • Diocletian's Persecution on the Euphrates FrontierStephen Mitchell73
  • Martyrs, Monks, and Heretics in Rocky CappadociaGaetano Arena78
  • From Vine Dresser to Warrior: Saint Hieron as Patron SaintGaetano Arena78
  • Caves, Monks and HermitsGaetano Arena93
  • Heretics and TrogodytesGaetano Arena100
  • The Holy Land of Rocky CappadociaGaetano Arena103
  • The Origins and Development of the Cults of Saint Gordius and Saint Mamas in CappadociaAude Busine109
  • Faith and Verse: Gregory of Nazianzus and Early Christian Village PoetryChristiane Zimmermann126
  • Early Christian Sepulchral EpigramsChristiane Zimmermann128
  • Constantinople and Asia Minor: Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction in the Fourth CenturyTurhan Kaçar148
  • Introduction148
  • Matters of Jurisdiction in the Fourth Century: A Brief Documentation149
  • Did Canon 3 of Constantinople in 381 Make Any Change to Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction?155
  • Conclusion161
  • The Rise of Christianity at SagalassusPeter Talloen164
  • Introduction164
  • The Introduction of Christianity165
  • Sagalassus during the Roman Imperial Period: Neokoros and Proteia166
  • The Fourth Century: An Age of Change173
  • Christian Triumph?180
  • The Sixth Century: The Age of Christianity187
  • Conclusion196
  • Inscribing Caria: The Perseverance of Epigraphic Traditions in Late AntiquityAnna M. Sitz202
  • Ancient Caria203
  • Inscribing Temples in Ancient Caria205
  • Diachronic Texts210
  • Inscribed Temples in Late Antiquity212
  • Conclusion218
  • The Christian Epigraphy of Cyprus: A Preliminary StudyDaniela Summa226
  • Earlier Studies226
  • The Christian Tradition on Cyprus228
  • The Main Epigraphic Categories230
  • Conclusions246

Objects published here

6
  • Altar to Zeus Gordios, the listener, with its dedication, Caesarea, 4.1 (p. 113)
  • Round relief flask showing Dionysus between Ares and Aphrodite, potters' workshop east of the Neon Library, Sagalassus, SA2013LE-129-210, 7.11 (p. 186)
  • Terracotta figurine of a warrior on horseback, sixth-century workshop near the south-west gate of Claudius, Sagalassus, SA2010CG-102-162, 7.15 (p. 195)
  • Marble anta block with I.Labraunda 137, Andron A, Labraunda, I.Labraunda 137, 8.5; 8.6 (p. 213)
  • Funerary cippus with staurograms, Archaeological Museum of Larnaka, Kofinou, MAA 1331, 9.4 (p. 233)
  • Block with the name of Paul, a cross and a palm frond, step in the monastery of St Barnabas near Salamis, 9.3 (p. 230)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Adolf Harnackhistorian of Christian expansion
  • OrigenChristian teacher in Cappadocia
  • Firmilianbishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia
  • Serenianusgovernor during persecution
  • Basil of Caesareabishop and author of homilies
  • Gregory of NazianzusCappadocian writer and bishop
  • Gregory of NyssaCappadocian writer and bishop
  • Julianemperor who visited Cappadocia
  • Peterbishop said to recover martyrs' remains
  • Meletiusmartyr and writer in the text on the Forty Martyrs
  • Agricolagovernor linked to the martyr trials
  • Athenogenescountry bishop and martyr
  • Eustratiusmilitary staff officer and martyr
  • Hieronlocal martyr of Cappadocia
  • Gordiusmartyr honoured in Caesarea
  • Mamasshepherd-martyr of Caesarea
  • John Chrysostomintervened in episcopal appointments
  • Nectariusbishop of Constantinople
  • Eusebius of Nicomediatransferred to the see of Constantinople
  • Macedoniusmade appointments around Constantinople
  • Paullinked to the early Christian tradition of Cyprus
  • Barnabaslinked to the founding of the Cypriot church
  • Epiphaniusbishop and local saint of Cyprus
  • Sp(h)yridonbishop who commissioned a basilica mosaic
  • Eustorgiosbenefactor named in Cypriot inscriptions
  • Eustoliosbenefactor at Curium

Institutions

  • Topoihosted the research programme and workshop
  • Inscriptions Christianae Graecaedatabase of early Christian inscriptions
  • Council of Nicaeachurch council of 325
  • Council of Constantinopleissued canons on jurisdiction in 381

Places

  • Asia Minorregion studied across the volume
  • Cappadociaregion of several chapters
  • Armenia Minorregion treated in the martyr study
  • Sagalassuscity whose Christianization is studied
  • Constantinopleseat of episcopal authority and jurisdiction
  • Cariaregion of temple inscriptions in late antiquity
  • Sebasteaprovincial centre and martyr setting
  • CaesareaCappadocian metropolis and cult centre
  • ZelaPontic community named in the Forty Martyrs text
  • Sareimproposed burial place of martyrs' remains
  • Pedachthoehome of Athenogenes and martyr site
  • Araurakafrontier settlement and home of martyrs
  • Göremerock-cut churches with Hieron traditions
  • Tokal Kilise 1church with a Hieron fresco
  • Çavuşinchurch with a Hieron fresco
  • Sakh Kiliserock church with a Hieron fresco
  • Kılıçlar Kilisechurch with a Hieron fresco
  • Labraundainscribed temple structures reused in late antiquity
  • LaginaTemple of Hecate with late antique graffiti
  • Mylasalate antique temple inscriptions
  • AphrodisiasTemple of Aphrodite converted into a church
  • Salamissource of Christian inscriptions and building texts
  • Paphussource of inscriptions and Christian buildings
  • Curiummosaic inscriptions and Christian patronage
  • TrimithusAgios Spyridon basilica mosaic inscription
  • Amathussource of inscriptions and ritual evidence
  • Chytrifindspot of a fragmentary inscription
  • Solisource of a raid inscription
  • Toumballosfindspot of an inscription fragment
  • EuromusCarian inscription displayed in a chapel hagiasma
  • AmyzonTemple of Artemis with inscribed structures

Also named: Berlin Academy.

Extent 280 pp., figs 0.1–9.10; bibliography, index

Defines Christianization, φιλοκτίστης, κτίστης, portable epigraphy

RomanLate AntiqueMedievalReligion and CultWritingArchitectureChronology and Dating

Who did what

4 records

Recording and study 4

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.