Book · 2010

Pietre da macina, macine per mulini. Definizione e sviluppo delle tecniche per la macinazione nell'area del Vicino Oriente e del Mediterraneo orientale antico

L. Bombardieri

Oxford: Archaeopress

A study of grinding technology in the ancient Near East and eastern Mediterranean, classifying millstones and mills by form, material and operation and tracing their development.

Grinding equipment of the ancient Near East and eastern Mediterranean is classified here by stone form and by the mills those stones formed. Bombardieri draws on material from more than 40 sites, among them unpublished collections from Nimrud/Kalhu and Tell Barri/Kahat, and sets archaeological, epigraphic and iconographic evidence side by side. Materials, operation, distribution and development are followed from the Neolithic through the Bronze and Iron Ages into the Classical period.

How it is organised

An introduction reviews earlier scholarship, the geology and sources of stone (limestone and basalt, with regional sourcing studies in the Habur area, the Negev, the southern Levant and Cyprus), and ancient written references to millstone materials and their procurement. A morphological classification of millstones comes before the main part on mills. There each type is treated for its technology, archaeological contexts, distribution and chronology: the handstone mill, the simple quern mill, the Assyrian grooved mill, the Olynthus hopper mill and the mortar-mill, then other mills and mixing bowls. The hopper-quern discussion distinguishes two forms and the mortar-mill classification seven types (pp. 85–117).

The conclusion takes up the diffusion and development of grinding technology. Appendix A sets out the full typology, Appendices B and C catalogue the Tell Barri and Nimrud material, and a bibliography, a list of illustrations and 166 plates close the book.

The evidence

Stone morphology is compared with archaeological contexts, associated finds and installations found in situ. Bombardieri classifies the individual stones first, then uses morphological correspondences to match upper and lower stones and reconstruct working pairs (pp. 16–20).

Tell Barri and Nimrud supply substantial collections. Comparison beyond them draws on installations, assemblages and secondary-use contexts at sites across the region, with Tell Barri, Ebla, Hama and Tell Brak among those that supply examples of installations and assemblages.

Images add evidence for how mills were operated. Palace reliefs from Nineveh and the bronze bands from Balawat, which include campaign scenes of Shalmaneser III, show grinding in use (pp. 53–55).

Cyprus figures in the review of stone sources and in the discussion of iconography. The review cites Xenophontos, Malpas and Elliott on the provenance of Cypriot basalt, with samples from Kition, Maa/Palaeokastro, Kouklia/Evreti and, for a Classical mill, Paphos. In the discussion of iconography, Karageorghis's reading of Cypriot terracotta models as grinding scenes is set beside examples in the Louvre and in the Cesnola collection at the Metropolitan Museum in New York, with Episkopi, near Kourion, as the probable find area of one model (pp. 56–57).

The argument

Bombardieri argues that the development of grinding technology can be understood as a gradual reduction of operating variables. Variation in direction, pressure, amplitude, speed and continuity limits how a mill works, and each successive form constrains these further. Older and newer forms nonetheless coexist as a recurring pattern. At Tell Barri the grooved mill carried on beside the hopper mill, a persistence Bombardieri relates partly to smaller domestic requirements (pp. 137–140).

On the transfer of technology, Bombardieri regards the process as complex and holds that models devised for prestige technologies do not fully explain a subsistence technology used in routine food preparation. Merchants and soldiers are suggested as possible carriers of new mill forms, a hypothesis that he states needs further evidence (pp. 134–137).

Dating

Bombardieri places the introduction of the Assyrian grooved quern around the ninth century BCE and its use at least into the fifth or fourth century BCE, and dates the development of the Olynthus hopper mill to around the middle of the first millennium BCE. Mechanical mills of the Roman period are also discussed (pp. 78–85, 138–140).

The catalogue

Appendix B catalogues the Tell Barri finds by excavation number, covering Areas B, G, J and A, and Appendix C lists the Nimrud finds from Areas A1–A3, the Fort Shalmaneser and the survey (pp. 191–218). Each entry gives excavation number, structure and layer, dating, dimensions, stone, typological classification and mill type. Tell Barri inventory numbers carry the prefix E., and other numbering systems also occur.

What it records

  • Material from more than 40 sites is examined, including unpublished collections.
  • Millstones are classified hierarchically into families, series, groups, classes, primary types and secondary variants.p. 16
  • Five mill types are distinguished: handstone, simple quern, Assyrian grooved quern, hopper mill and mortar-mill.p. 19
  • Tell Maghzaliyah has three fragmentary lower stones and three handstones for handstone mills, reported in compact basalt.p. 24
  • Reused simple-quern stones make up 36% of the upper stones and 28% of the lower stones at Tell Barri.p. 49
  • A terracotta model of unknown provenance, discussed by Bombardieri, was bought in Cyprus in 1899 and is now in the Louvre.p. 56
  • In the simple-quern classification, Bombardieri associates type A with finer flour and types B and C with coarser, less refined flour.p. 74
  • Tell Barri yielded 21 active grooved stones and eight flat lower stones for Assyrian grooved querns.p. 81
  • Bombardieri dates the introduction of the Assyrian grooved quern to around the ninth century BCE and its use to at least the fifth or fourth century BCE.p. 81
  • Bombardieri argues that the standard hopper quern probably developed through contact between the Assyrian grooved quern and an Aegean hopper-mill system.p. 92
  • Direction, pressure, amplitude, speed and continuity are identified as the variables affecting mill operation.p. 139
  • At Tell Barri the Assyrian grooved mill remained in use for at least two centuries after the hopper mill was introduced.p. 139
  • Bombardieri argues that the later introduction of new mills did not cause earlier models to be abandoned.p. 140

Where to read

  • Basalt sourcing studies in the Habur, the southern Levant and Cypruspp. 7–11
  • Ancient stone terms and records of millstone procurementpp. 11–15
  • Classification of millstones and the three artefact familiespp. 16–18
  • Mechanical models and the five mill typespp. 19–21
  • Handstone-mill installations and their distributionpp. 22–33
  • Simple-quern morphology, types A–C and proposed flour gradespp. 33–35
  • Secondary reuse of simple-quern stones at Tell Barripp. 48–52
  • Images of simple querns, including Cypruspp. 53–60
  • Simple querns in Iron Age contexts and flour gradespp. 70–77
  • Assyrian grooved quern: form, operation and chronologypp. 78–85
  • Mortar-mill typology and installations at Tell Barripp. 93–104
  • Technology transfer and the coexistence of mill typespp. 134–140

Contents

  • I. Introduzione1
  • 1. La storia degli studi1
  • 2. Cenni sul contesto geomorfologico e degli areali di distribuzione delle materie prime litiche utilizzate5
  • 3. Natura e localizzazione degli affioramenti basaltici e degli altri giacimenti7
  • 4. Natura e approvvigionamento della pietra per macine nelle fonti antiche11
  • 5. L'approvigionamento delle materie prime litiche. Considerazioni generali14
  • II. Le pietre da macina16
  • III. I mulini19
  • 4. Il mulino a macinello21
  • 5. Il mulino a macina semplice33
  • 6. Il mulino assiro a scanalatura78
  • 7. Il mulino di Olinto a tramoggia85
  • 8. Il mulino a mortaio93
  • 9. Altri mulini e mixing bowls118
  • IV. Conclusion134
  • Appendice A - Classificazione tipologica142
  • Appendice B - Tell Barri. Schedatura dei manufatti per la macinazione (Aree B, G, J, A)191
  • Appendice C - Nimrud. Schedatura dei manufatti per la macinazione delle Aree A1-A3, dal Forte Salmanassare e dalla survey212
  • Bibliografia219
  • Elenco delle illustrazioni236

Objects published here

6
  • Lower quern 68-567B, found beneath its upper stone, northeast postern gate, Korucutepe, 68-567B, Tav. 45: 2 (p. 46)
  • Lower quern for a simple quern mill, with a doubly concave working surface, Tell Barri, room 399, platform 401, E.5333, Tav. 50: 2 (p. 48)
  • Upper quern reused as a small mortar, Tell Barri, pit near the southeast settlement area, E.3241, Tav. 57: 1 (p. 51)
  • Half of an upper basalt quern placed in a Middle Bronze I burial, Tell Barri, burial 1097, E.3280, Tav. 58: 1–3 (p. 52)
  • Fragmentary grooved quern stone, with its flat lower stone E.2132, Tell Barri, Area J, north room 57, E.2128, Tav. 93: 1 (p. 80)
  • Hopper mill stones in a Parthian-period installation, Tell Barri, room 203, Area H, E.3963; E.3964, Tav. 103 (p. 245)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Paolo Emilio Pecorellaencouraged the work; built the Tell Barri mill house
  • Fabio Martinidiscussed in the typological classification
  • Rafael Frankeldiscussed in the typological classification
  • L. Moritzanalysed mill forms and limiting factors
  • C. Xenophontosstudied the provenance of Cypriot basalt
  • J. Malpasstudied the provenance of Cypriot basalt
  • C. Elliottstudied ground stone and basalt sourcing
  • V. Karagheorghisproposed a grinding reading of Cypriot models
  • Salmanassar IIIshown in the Balawat campaign scenes

Institutions

  • Centro Scavi e Ricerche per il Vicino Oriente e l'AsiaNimrud excavation collection
  • C.N.R.-Istituto per gli studi Micenei ed Egeo-AnatoliciTell Barri excavation collection
  • Museo del Louvreholds a Cypriot terracotta model
  • Metropolitan Museum di New Yorkholds a model in the Cesnola collection
  • British Museumholds Balawat bands and models

Places

  • Tell Barri/Kahatmajor millstone assemblage and sequence
  • Nimrud/Kalhuexcavated stone-tool collection
  • Tell Brakmill installations and assemblages
  • Tell Mardikhpalace and domestic grinding installations
  • Hamaquerns and mortar-mills across periods
  • Tell Maghzaliyahearly handstone and simple querns
  • Korucutepequern assemblage and installations
  • Marki-AloniaCypriot ground-stone classification
  • KitionCypriot basalt-sourcing sample site
  • Maa/PalaeokastroCypriot basalt-sourcing sample site
  • Kouklia/EvretiCypriot basalt-sourcing sample site
  • Nea Paphosbasalt-sourcing sample for a Classical mill
  • Ninivepalace reliefs depicting grinding
  • Balawatbronze bands depicting mill use
  • Episkopiprobable find area of a model
  • Kourionnear the probable model find area

Also named: Università di Firenze.

Extent 166 plates; bibliography pp. 219–235

Defines mulino a macinello, mulino a macina semplice, mulino assiro a scanalatura, mulino a tramoggia (o mulino di Olinto), mulino a mortaio, recipienti, macine piane, macinatoi, mortai, ciotole, macinelli, pestelli, frizione assiale, frizione circolare, mulino a macina semplice A, mulino a macina semplice B, mulino a macina semplice C, mixing bowls, limiting factors

NeolithicChalcolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanTechnologyCraft ProductionFood and FarmingTradeForeign Contacts

Who did what

1 record

Buying, selling and giving 1

  • D. SparkesOwned

    The D. Sparkes Collection in Southampton included a terracotta figurine.

    Figurina fittile

    p. 4

Mentioned in

1 mention

Tomb records · 1

  • Kalavasos-Village, Brandeis Tomb 36

    Objects from the tomb · 2010 · p. 57

    Da una delle sepolture del periodo Medio Cipriota (Tomb 36) è stato recuperato un bacino configurato in Red Polished III mottled

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.