Article · 1961
Cattle egrets and bustards in Greek art
S. Benton
Journal of Hellenic Studies 81 44-55
An article identifying cattle egrets and bustards on Cypriot Bronze Age pottery and later Greek vases and coins, from their shape, behaviour and ancient references.
Benton surveys birds represented on Cypriot Bronze Age pottery and on later Greek vases, coins and other objects, identifying cattle egrets and bustards from their size, shape and depicted behaviour. The examples run from Late Bronze Age Cypriot pottery to archaic and later Greek art, with vase paintings from Enkomi, Klaudia and other Cypriot sites set beside later pottery from Greece and the eastern Mediterranean, coins, terracottas and a seal. She compares the painted features with bird anatomy and with modern bird observations, and draws on ancient authors including Aristophanes, Aristotle and Xenophon. She also discusses birds on fifth-century coins.
Benton argues that many birds conventionally treated as decorative or mythical can be identified as species seen in the region. She reads the scenes as episodes of country life, with birds feeding among cattle and bustards in flight or display, and she challenges interpretations of oversized birds as supernatural figures, urging that the whole vase scene be considered. She identifies cattle egrets on several Cypriot Bronze Age vases, suggests that great bustards appear on Cypriot and mainland Greek pottery, and takes some large water creatures for possible natural features of the scene, while acknowledging uncertainty in several identifications.
What it records
- A bird with long neck, legs and beak, hunting insects on the neck of a bull, is in Benton's view a cattle egret.p. 44
- Benton suggests that Enkomi may once have stood on an estuary.p. 44
- A krater from Klaudia near Larnaka shows a bull, with three diamonds in the air round its head, approaching a sleeping bird on the ground.p. 45
- A bird on a Cypriot oinochoe is, Benton argues, a cattle egret reappearing in Cyprus in the seventh century.p. 46
- Benton considers the great bustard a possible identification for the large bird flying behind a chariot on a krater from Enkomi.p. 48
- Birds with heavy bodies reappear in the fabric that E. Gjerstad calls Bichrome IV.p. 51
Where to read
- Cattle-egret identifications on Cypriot vasespp. 44–46
- Phrygillos, coins and marsh birdspp. 46–48
- Bustards in Greek vase painting and ancient textspp. 48–55
Contents
- I. Cattle Egret44
- II. Bustard48
Objects published here
1- Krater from Klaudia depicting a bull approaching a bird, British Museum, Klaudia near Larnaka, C402, Plate I 5 (p. 45)
People, places and institutions
People
- V. Karageorghisinterpreted Cypriot vase scenes
- E. Gjerstadnamed the Bichrome IV fabric
- Aristophanessource for ancient bird terminology
- Xenophonancient account of bustards cited
Institutions
- British Museumholds several of the vases discussed
Places
- Enkomisource of Bronze Age vases discussed
- Klaudiasource of kraters discussed
- Mycenaefindspot of pottery fragments
- Syracusemint of a coin-maker discussed
- Thouriasource of coins and a place-name discussion
- Argossource of geometric and orientalising pottery
- Thebessource of an amphora discussed
- Boiotiasetting for bustard comparisons
- Tel Defennehfindspot of a Fikellura amphora
- Kameirossource of pottery discussed
Also named: Larnaka, Ras Shamra, Sybaris, Pitt-Rivers Museum.
Extent pp. 44–55, pls I–V
Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalAnimalsIconographyPotteryChronology and Dating
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- BirdsCompendium
Who did what
1 recordRecording and study 1
- p. 49
Claude Frédéric-Armand SchaefferPublished
Schaeffer published a depiction of the two birds but split their scene in two.
two birds on the reverse of the Zeus vaseEnkomi
Mentioned in
3 mentionsTomb records · 2
- Enkomi, SCE Tomb 18
Discussion · 1961 · p. 49
- Enkomi, SCE Tomb 17
Objects from the tomb · 1961 · p. 49
- On Ancient Cyprus · 1listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.