Society

American Numismatic Society

New York, United States · founded 1858

New York society that backed Feuardent against Cesnola in the 1880s, sent Stillman to examine the Cesnola Collection, pursued Gunther's Cypriot coins and published Cox's Kourion coins.

About

The American Numismatic Society, a New York learned society founded in 18581, entered the 1880s quarrel over Luigi Palma di Cesnola's Cypriot sculptures because one of its prominent members was Gaston Feuardent, the Paris dealer who had questioned them5. Feuardent was nominated for membership in 1876 and later served as the Society's Historiographer2,3. On 21 February 1881 the Trustees of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where Cesnola was director, resolved that they had always known the falsehood of Feuardent's published charges5. In May 1881 the Society's Secretary was told, on Professor Anthon's motion, to ask the Principal Librarian of the British Museum whether Feuardent enjoyed the Museum's confidence, and C. T. Newton and R. S. Poole both replied that they were satisfied with his capacity and honesty5. At its meeting of 15 November 1881 the correspondence was reported, and Feuardent told members that he had begun a libel action against Cesnola5.

The libel trial ended with the jury failing to agree, which the Metropolitan's Trustees took as a vindication of Cesnola5; Marangou writes that the jury found for Cesnola. At a special meeting on 1 March 1884 the Society unanimously passed resolutions in Feuardent's favour2; Marangou, citing Adelson, says the text sent to the press omitted two paragraphs that criticised the Metropolitan Museum's treatment of antiquities4.

On 20 January 1885 William James Stillman was elected a resident member and, the same day, on a resolution offered by Robert Hewitt, was asked to examine the evidence on the provenances of the Cesnola Collection and report, with a proposed trip to Cyprus4,5. Adelson judges that Stillman was made a member so that he could give currency to his views; Stillman later wrote from Rome that his membership was never meant to be permanent, and he was dropped from the roll5. His report was privately printed in 1885, in about 33 pages, and Adelson calls it a complete vindication of Feuardent and an indictment of Cesnola5.

Smaller Cypriot objects followed. In 1897 J. Sanford Saltus gave statuettes from Mexico, Cyprus and Egypt, listed in the Curator's report without description of the Cypriot pieces24. Dorothy Hannah Cox, who had worked on excavations for almost ten years, joined the coin-room staff in 1931 and after about a year went onto the staff of an excavation in Cyprus5. The Society later published her Coins from the Excavations at Curium, 1932-1953 as Numismatic Notes and Monographs no. 145 in 19598.

The largest Cypriot coin collection it pursued was that of Charles G. Gunther, who died in 1929 and whose coins lay in the Ottoman Bank at Nicosia. His family, including his heir Christian Gunther, offered the collection whole to the Society if its export could be arranged. Negotiations began in 1949 but the Society did not obtain control of all of it. In 1950 the Cyprus authorities agreed to release the portion duplicated in their own collections, on condition that the non-numismatic parts went to the Cyprus Museum; the rest was to stay at Nicosia as the Charles G. Gunther Memorial Collection, and by Adelson's account the best part remained there5. A. H. S. Megaw, reporting on 1949-50, wrote that the Cyprus Museum had received from the Society a substantial part of the coins, to the benefit of its series, and gave the collector's name as Godfrey C. Gunther7. Metcalf records lead seals from the same collection in New York: about 14 Byzantine seals (1952.196) and one given by Christian G. Gunther in March 1949 (1952.142), while the better seals stayed in Cyprus6.

In winter 1991 the Society's newsletter reported that John J. Slocum had given it plaster casts of over 6,000 coins of medieval Cyprus assembled by the archaeologist James R. Stewart23.

The Cypriot collection

No total for Cypriot coins or seals found. Sources show a Gunther group of about 14 Byzantine lead seals (1952.196, plus 1952.142) and a substantial part of the Gunther Cyprus coin collection, which the Society passed to the Cyprus Museum in 1949-50. Adelson (1958, p. 280) says the best part of the Gunther collection stayed at Nicosia as the Charles G. Gunther Memorial Collection; the Society received the portion duplicated in Cyprus Museum holdings. (2009)

D. M. Metcalf (2009). Byzantine Cyprus 491-1191. Nicosia, Cyprus Research Centre, p. 116; A. H. S. Megaw (1951). Archaeology in Cyprus, 1949-1950. Journal of Hellenic Studies 71, 258-260; Howard L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, p. 280

History

  1. 1876
  2. 1878
    The society invited Gaston Feuardent in March 1878 to read a paper on the Cesnola statuette, which he later published.

    (1880). Feuardent, Gaston L., Tampering with Antiquities (1880)

  3. 1881
    Edward A. Bond, Principal Librarian of the British Museum, was asked about Feuardent's character (inquiry of 9 June 1881, noted in the ANS folder guide as a noted document); the ANS held Feuardent's published 'Answer' to Cesnola in the same year.

    New YorkEdward A. BondGaston Louis FeuardentWilliam Poillon(1881-1897). Feuardent and Cesnola, 1881-1897 (ANS Early Correspondence 1858-1908). American Numismatic Society

  4. 21 February 1881
    The Metropolitan Museum's Trustees resolved that they had always known the falsehood of Feuardent's published charges against Cesnola. Adelson gives this as the background that brought the Society into the dispute, since Feuardent was one of its prominent members.

    Gaston Louis FeuardentLuigi Palma di CesnolaHoward L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, p. 88

  5. 17 May 1881
    On Professor Anthon's motion the Secretary was told to write to the Principal Librarian of the British Museum asking whether Feuardent enjoyed the confidence of the Museum's authorities. C. T. Newton (Keeper of Greek and Roman Antiquities) and R. S. Poole (Keeper of Coins and Medals) both replied that they were satisfied with his capacity and honesty (Adelson).

    New YorkGaston Louis FeuardentEdward A. BondHoward L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, p. 90

  6. 15 November 1881
    At the Society's meeting the correspondence from the British Museum supporting Feuardent was reported (New York Times of 16 November 1881, as Adelson cites it). Feuardent also told members that he had begun a libel action against Cesnola and offered any member the documentary evidence.

    Gaston Louis FeuardentHoward L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, p. 91

  7. 1 March 1884
    After the Feuardent-Cesnola libel trial the Society held a special meeting and unanimously passed resolutions supporting Feuardent. Marangou, citing Adelson, says two paragraphs criticising the Metropolitan Museum's treatment of antiquities were withdrawn from the text sent to the New York Times (published 6 March 1884). Adelson (1958) prints the motion, and says the libel trial ended indecisively because the jury failed to agree; the Metropolitan's Trustees chose to read that as a vindication of Cesnola.

    New YorkGaston Louis FeuardentA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 328; (1881-1897). Feuardent and Cesnola, 1881-1897 (ANS Early Correspondence 1858-1908). American Numismatic Society; Howard L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, pp. 95-96

  8. 1884
    At a special meeting on 1 March 1884 the society unanimously adopted resolutions praising Gaston Feuardent for his efforts over the Cypriot sculptures.

    (1884). Treatment of the Supplement Designs (1884)

  9. 1884
    The society passed resolutions of confidence in Feuardent and protested against the restorations of the Cypriot antiquities in the Metropolitan Museum.

    (1884). Fiske, Stephen, Dramatir Feuilleton (1884)

  10. 1884
    The society passed resolutions of confidence in Mr. Feuardent and protested against the restorations of the patched-up Cypriote collection in the Metropolitan Museum.

    The Art Amateur 1884-04: Vol 10 Iss 5

  11. January 1885
    William J. Stillman, elected a resident member in January 1885, was asked by resolution (offered by Robert Hewitt, 20 January 1885) to examine the evidence on the provenance of the Cesnola Collection and report, with a proposed trip to Cyprus.

    New YorkWilliam James StillmanRobert HewittA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 328, p. 337; (1881-1897). Feuardent and Cesnola, 1881-1897 (ANS Early Correspondence 1858-1908). American Numismatic Society

  12. 1885
    The Stillman report on the Cesnola Collection was privately printed (about 33 pages). Adelson, quoted by Marangou, calls it the Society's last broadside in Feuardent's defence and a full vindication of Feuardent; this is Adelson's judgment as quoted, ; Adelson himself says neither side had won a clear victory in the courts (the jury had failed to agree).

    New YorkWilliam James StillmanA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 328; Howard L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, pp. 97-98

  13. 1885
    The society commissioned W. J. Stillman's report on the Cesnola collection during the controversy over its restorations.

    (2013). Art Histories Society, Art History Supplement, vol.2, no. 2, March 2012 (2013)

  14. 20 January 1885
    William J. Stillman was elected a resident member and, on the same day, the Society resolved that he be asked to examine the evidence on the provenances of the Cesnola Collection and report, so that it could decide whether to investigate further. Adelson calls the election a plan to give Stillman a platform; Stillman later wrote from Rome that his membership was never meant to be permanent and he was dropped from the roll.

    William James StillmanRobert HewittHoward L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, pp. 97-98

  15. 1885
    The society commissioned W. J. Stillman, decided on 20 January 1885, to investigate the authenticity of the Cesnola collection and excavation reports.

    André Vayson de Pradenne (1932). Les fraudes en archéologie préhistorique : avec quelques exemples de comparaison en archéologie générale et sciences naturelles, p. 1640

  16. 1897
    J. Sanford Saltus gave the Society's archaeological collection statuettes from Mexico, Cyprus and Egypt, along with other items, as listed in the Curator's report (Edward Groh); the Cypriot pieces are not described.

    J. Sanford SaltusAmerican Numismatic and Archaeological Society (1897). Proceedings of the American Numismatic and Archaeological Society, 1896-1902

  17. 1924
    The society wrote to Gunther in Nicosia in October 1924 asking about rare Cypriot coins and hoards and whether its president might visit Cyprus to acquire coins.

    American Numismatic Society, Gunther, ____, Esq., October 21, 1924 (American Copper Company, Nicosia, Cyprus) [ANS Curator Howland Wood correspondence and other material, ca. 1913-1937]

  18. 1931–1932
    Dorothy H. Cox, who had been on excavations for almost ten years, joined the Society's coin-room staff in 1931 and after about a year joined the staff of an excavation in Cyprus. Adelson presents this as the Society helping her continue numismatic studies. He also says a scholar trained in the Society's coin room prepared the numismatic part of the University Museum (Philadelphia) excavations at Lapithos in Cyprus.

    Dorothy Hannah CoxHoward L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, pp. 247-248

  19. 1937
    Two Cypriots offered the society more than a hundred pieces from the Larnaca hoard; it bought none.

    (1938). American Numismatic Society, ANS Numismatic Notes and Monographs, nos. 79-82 (1938)

  20. 1947
    The Society bought Sir Ronald Storrs's cabinet of Alexander the Great coins (322 tetradrachms, 120 drachms, two triobols and a didrachm), largely Demanhur Hoard material from Egypt and not Cypriot-provenanced; the Society's Museum Notes of 1948 describe it.

    New YorkRonald Storrs(1948). The Sir Ronald Storrs Collection (Greek coins acquired by the American Numismatic Society in 1947). A. N. S. Museum Notes 3-5, pp. 1-2, pp. 1-2; Howard L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, p. 260

  21. March 1949
    Christian G. Gunther gave one lead seal from his father's collection to the Society (accession 1952.142, recorded by Metcalf as the gift of March 1949).

    Charles Godfrey GuntherD. M. Metcalf (2009). Byzantine Cyprus 491-1191. Nicosia, Cyprus Research Centre, p. 116

  22. 1949–1950
    Adelson's account of the Gunther collection: Charles G. Gunther (d. 1929) left a collection chiefly of ancient Cypriot coinage, kept for years in a Venetian chest in the Ottoman Bank at Nicosia. The family, including the heir Christian Gunther, offered it whole to the Society if its export could be negotiated with the Cyprus government. Negotiations began in 1949 but control of the whole collection was not obtained. In 1950 the Cyprus authorities agreed to hand over the portion duplicated in their own collections, on condition that the non-numismatic parts went to the Cyprus Museum; the coins not in the Museum were to stay at Nicosia as the Charles G. Gunther Memorial Collection until duplicates were found. The Society accepted with slight modifications, and by Adelson's account the best part of the collection remained at Nicosia.

    NicosiaCharles Godfrey GuntherChristian G. GuntherHoward L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society, p. 280

  23. 21 April 1949
    Letter of 21 April 1949: «I have been asked by the American Numismatic Society to represent them with regard to the acquisition of the Gunther collection»

    Kourion Expedition records (PU-Mu 1050). Philadelphia, Penn Museum Archives, Box 2, folder 1, p. 54

  24. 28 April 1949
    Letter of 28 April 1949: «had decided to present the coin collection to the American Numismatic Society, if the greater part of it is permitted to leave the Island.»

    Kourion Expedition records (PU-Mu 1050). Philadelphia, Penn Museum Archives, Box 2, folder 1, p. 58

  25. 1950
    The American Numismatic Society gave the Cyprus Museum a substantial part of the ancient coin collection of the late Godfrey C. Gunther.

    Charles Godfrey GuntherColonial Office (1950). Report on Cyprus for the Year 1950. London, His Majesty's Stationery Office, p. 53

  26. 1952
    The Charles G. Gunther bequest brought some 14 Byzantine lead seals from Cyprus to the Society (accession 1952.196). The better seals had been kept by the Cyprus Museum. Metcalf thinks some come from the Petrakides archive.

    Charles Godfrey GuntherD. M. Metcalf (2009). Byzantine Cyprus 491-1191. Nicosia, Cyprus Research Centre, p. 116, p. 117

  27. 1952
    The society gave the Cyprus Museum seventy-one coins missing from its collections.

    (1952). American Journal of Archaeology 1952-04: Vol 56 Iss 2 (1952)

  28. 1959
    Dorothy H. Cox's Coins from the Excavations at Curium, 1932-1953 appeared as Numismatic Notes and Monographs 145, published by the Society (Kourion excavations of the University of Pennsylvania Museum).

    KourionDorothy Hannah CoxS. Rogge (ed.), C. Ioannou (ed.), T. Mavrojannis (ed.) (2019). Salamis of Cyprus: History and Archaeology from the Earliest Times to Late Antiquity. Münster, Waxmann

  29. 1959
    The society published D. H. Cox's catalogue of the coins from the excavations at Curium, 1932-1953, in its Numismatic Notes and Monographs.

    George Frederick Kolbe, The Numismatic Bookseller: Vol. 5 Nos. 1-3, Spring 1988

  30. 1967
    The society received from Mrs Newell in 1967 a unique overstruck Cypriot stater (ANS 1967.152.548).

    American Journal of Numismatics (Second Series), vols.16-17

  31. 1969
    The society published H. Troxell's catalogue of the Norman Davis collection, which includes a stater of Azbaal of Kition.

    (2015). Michel Amandry, Chronique numismatique chypriote (V), 2008-2015 (2015), p. 437

  32. 1991
    John J. Slocum, an ANS Councillor, gave the Society plaster casts of over 6,000 coins of medieval Cyprus assembled by the archaeologist James R. Stewart; a student was ordering them in winter 1991.

    John J. SlocumJames Rivers Barrington StewartAmerican Numismatic Society (1991). ANS Newsletter, Winter 1991. p. 9, p. 9

  33. 1998
    The society bought a silver grosso of Caterina Cornaro, queen of Cyprus 1474-1489 (ANS 1998.127.1).

    (2007). American Numismatic Society Magazine: Winter 2007 (2007)

  34. Undated
  35. Undated
    The society acquired part of the Gunther collection of coins formed in Cyprus, including eight coins of Augustan type.

    (1987). Michel Amandry, Le monnayage Julio-Claudien à Chypre. I -Auguste (1987), p. 30

  36. Undated
  37. Undated
    Gave a substantial part of the coin collection made in Cyprus by Godfrey C. Gunther to the Cyprus Museum.

    A. H. S. Megaw (1951). Archaeology in Cyprus, 1949-1950. Journal of Hellenic Studies 71, 258-260, p. 259

  38. Undated

Acquisitions and dealings

5 records

Gifts, purchases, bequests and loans

  1. 1949

    GiftChristian G. Gunther

    Christian G. Gunther gave the American Numismatic Society a lead seal from Mr Gunther's collection.

    one lead seal from Mr Gunther's collectionNo. 1952.142Metcalf 2009, p. 119

  2. 1952

    BequestCharles Godfrey Gunther

    Some 14 of Gunther's lead seals were received by the American Numismatic Society and accessioned under 1952.196.

    some 14 lead sealsNo. 1952.196New YorkMetcalf 2009, p. 119

  3. n.d.

    GiftKit Gunther

    Kit Gunther donated most of the coin collection to the American Numismatic Society of New York.

    Pilides 2008, p. 8

People’s work with it

  • P. van AlfenPublished material of

    P. van Alfen published an account of acquisitions for the society's collection.

    statère d'un atelier incertainNo. ANS 2004.18.6New YorkAmandry 2008, p. 238

  • W.S. BubelisPublished material of

    W.S. Bubelis published an overstruck Salamis stater in the society's collection.

    statère de SalamineNo. ANS 1967.152.548New YorkAmandry 2008, p. 238

People

24 people

Staff and members · 7

Donors and lenders · 9

Others connected · 8

Objects

Mentioned in

28 mentions

Documents · 12

Institutions · 3

  • People · 13listed under People

Sources

  1. 1.“American Numismatic Society”. Wikipedia. Online
  2. 2. (1881-1897). “Feuardent and Cesnola, 1881-1897 (ANS Early Correspondence 1858-1908)”. American Numismatic Society.
  3. 3.American Numismatic and Archaeological Society (1896). Proceedings of the American Numismatic and Archaeological Society, 1887-1896.
  4. 4.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
  5. 5.Howard L. Adelson (1958). The American Numismatic Society, 1858-1958. New York, American Numismatic Society.
  6. 6.D. M. Metcalf (2009). Byzantine Cyprus 491-1191. Nicosia, Cyprus Research Centre.
  7. 7.A. H. S. Megaw (1951). “Archaeology in Cyprus, 1949-1950”. Journal of Hellenic Studies 71, 258-260. Online
  8. 8.S. Rogge (ed.), C. Ioannou (ed.), T. Mavrojannis (ed.) (2019). Salamis of Cyprus: History and Archaeology from the Earliest Times to Late Antiquity. Münster, Waxmann.
  9. 9. (1880). Feuardent, Gaston L., Tampering with Antiquities (1880).
  10. 10. (1884). Treatment of the Supplement Designs (1884).
  11. 11. (1884). Fiske, Stephen, Dramatir Feuilleton (1884).
  12. 12. (2013). Art Histories Society, Art History Supplement, vol.2, no. 2, March 2012 (2013).
  13. 13.American Numismatic Society, Gunther, ____, Esq., October 21, 1924 (American Copper Company, Nicosia, Cyprus) [ANS Curator Howland Wood correspondence and other material, ca. 1913-1937].
  14. 14. (1938). American Numismatic Society, ANS Numismatic Notes and Monographs, nos. 79-82 (1938).
  15. 15. (1952). American Journal of Archaeology 1952-04: Vol 56 Iss 2 (1952).
  16. 16.George Frederick Kolbe, The Numismatic Bookseller: Vol. 5 Nos. 1-3, Spring 1988.
  17. 17.American Journal of Numismatics (Second Series), vols.16-17.
  18. 18. (2015). Michel Amandry, Chronique numismatique chypriote (V), 2008-2015 (2015), p. 437.
  19. 19. (2007). American Numismatic Society Magazine: Winter 2007 (2007).
  20. 20. (1899). Bowker, R. R. (Richard Rogers), 1848-1933, Publications of societies; a provisional list of the publications of American scientific, literary, and other societies from their organization (1899).
  21. 21. (1987). Michel Amandry, Le monnayage Julio-Claudien à Chypre. I -Auguste (1987), p. 30.
  22. 22. (1948). “The Sir Ronald Storrs Collection (Greek coins acquired by the American Numismatic Society in 1947)”. A. N. S. Museum Notes 3-5, pp. 1-2.
  23. 23.American Numismatic Society (1991). ANS Newsletter, Winter 1991. p. 9.
  24. 24.American Numismatic and Archaeological Society (1897). Proceedings of the American Numismatic and Archaeological Society, 1896-1902.
  25. 25.Colonial Office (1950). Report on Cyprus for the Year 1950. London, His Majesty's Stationery Office.
  26. 26.The Art Amateur 1884-04: Vol 10 Iss 5.
  27. 27.André Vayson de Pradenne (1932). Les fraudes en archéologie préhistorique : avec quelques exemples de comparaison en archéologie générale et sciences naturelles.
  28. 28.Sanne Houby-Nielsen (ed.) (2009). “Finds and Results from the Swedish Cyprus Expedition 1927–1931: A Gender Perspective”. Medelhavsmuseet. Focus on the Mediterranean 5. Medelhavsmuseet.
  29. 29.Kourion Expedition records (PU-Mu 1050). Philadelphia, Penn Museum Archives.
  30. 30.A. H. S. Megaw (1951). “Archaeology in Cyprus, 1949-1950”. Journal of Hellenic Studies 71, 258-260. Online
  31. 31.M. Alram (ed.), J. Bodzek (ed.), A. Bursche (ed.) (2022). Survey of Numismatic Research 2014-2020. Warsaw, Kraków and Winterthur, International Numismatic Council.

Corrections and additions

Work here, or visited recently?

Institutions can send their own description, and anyone can tell us when something has changed.

We would like to hear about

  • Opening hours, closures or a new address
  • What the collection holds
  • Contact details and website
  • A description from the institution itself

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.