Scholar
Judy Birmingham
fl. 1957–1981
Sydney archaeologist whose 1963 revision of the Cypriot Iron Age chronology challenged Gjerstad's system, and who edited a volume of Australian work on the Cypriot Bronze Age.
Biography
Judy Birmingham is an archaeologist whose 1963 revision of the chronology of Cyprus became, in Nicola Schreiber's words, "the main challenge to Gjerstad's views for the latter part of the century"9. The sources differ on when she was born. The Australasian Society for Historical Archaeology marked her 90th birthday on 19 March 2021, while Wikidata gives 1 January 1932, in Essex10,11. She studied under Max Mallowan at the Institute of Archaeology in London and did fieldwork in the Middle East, Cyprus, Greece and Britain12.
Myrtou, Sydney and the fibulae
She wrote the chapter "The Terracotta and Limestone Figures", pp. 80-85, in Joan du Plat Taylor's Myrtou-Pigadhes: A Late Bronze Age Sanctuary in Cyprus (Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, 1957)13,14. Reviewing the book, J. R. Stewart of the University of Sydney called the figurines "dreary", but said they had "an historical and archaeological value far beyond their intrinsic worth"15.
She arrived in Australia from the United Kingdom in 1961 as a specialist in Mediterranean and West Asian archaeology, appointed at Sydney on Mallowan's recommendation10,16. That year, signing as "Mrs. J.M.Birmingham, Senior Lecturer", she wrote to C. F. A. Schaeffer as "a new member of the Sydney Archaeology department" and told him that Robert Merrillees seemed to be "doing a very good job on your Vounous pottery"17. Schaeffer replied from Enkomi on 15 October 1961 that for fibulae from Bérard's excavations at Ktima she might write to Bérard's widow, or else to M. Deshaye, who had worked with him there, and that on the Enkomi fibulae she should write to him again in January 196217. On 3 July 1962 Alexander Cambitoglou told Schaeffer that the Sydney staff now numbered three, "including a Near Eastern specialist, Mrs. Birmingham"18.
Her 1961 paper in Anatolian Studies, "The Overland Route across Anatolia in the Eighth and Seventh Centuries B.C.", already spoke of "the Cypro-Levantine cultural province" as the main source of orientalizing influence on Greece19. In "The Development of the Fibula in Cyprus and the Levant" (1963) she set out to show that the known Cypro-Levantine types "can be dated rather more closely than hitherto" and that they shed light on the island's relations with its neighbours7. The paper includes an Enkomi fibula excavated by Schaeffer in 1961, and uses one from Bamboula Tomb 19 to argue for unbroken development at Kourion from the late 13th century into the Iron Age7. Valérie Cook counts the paper among those that attributed Aegean fibulae in Cyprus to a movement of Achaeans, and objects that the Aegean fibulae are too imprecisely dated to be proved earlier than the Cypriot ones20.
The 1963 chronology
In the American Journal of Archaeology in 1963 she argued that the Swedish Cyprus Expedition's chronology left Cyprus "culturally a century and a half behind" the mainland, and that the pottery from Al Mina, Samaria and Hazor showed the expedition's pottery series must itself be revised6. She proposed an Early Iron Age of 1050-900, a Middle Iron Age of 900-600 and a Late Iron Age from 600 to the Hellenistic period6. Joanna Smith notes that she also proposed moving the start of Type III to 900 BCE and of Type IV to 800 BCE21. Her conclusion was that Cyprus "must be considered part of a homogeneous Cypro-Levantine cultural province from ca. 925 to ca. 600"6.
The American Expedition to Idalion's first report called it "the most radical onslaught", suggesting "the almost complete abandonment" of Einar Gjerstad's system1. Gjerstad at first rejected her date of 800 BC for the start of Cypro-Archaic I, and most contemporaries did not consider it, according to a chapter in Beyond Cyprus22. Ron Tappy records that Gjerstad answered her only in 1974, in Acta Archaeologica, and that D. Saltz called that reply "so ridiculous, supercilious, false, and unfair that it is almost not worth responding"23.
Schreiber judges her conclusions "essentially correct" and her work "generally perspicacious", but notes that the stratified mainland evidence available in 1963 "was still minimal", that the article was never developed into a major study, and that its chief result was "unfortunately" to let mainland scholars support 10th-century dates for Black-on-Red with evidence from Cyprus9. Smith calls it "the most comprehensive revision to Gjerstad's system"; its Levantine names were not generally adopted, but her ideas on Type IV, together with a study by Andreas Demetriou, have led scholars to place its start at 750 BCE21. Andres Reyes notes that the Syrian and Palestinian strata used by Birmingham and others are "less well-defined than had been previously thought"24. Peter James argues that by working only with the high Palestinian dates she raised the divisions of Middle Iron Age pottery "in an entirely unrealistic way"25.
The Bronze Age seminar and Australia
Her preface to The Cypriot Bronze Age: Some Recent Australian Contributions to the Prehistory of Cyprus records that the papers were given at a seminar at the University of Sydney in July 1972, and that David Frankel's contribution came from an MA thesis written under her supervision8. She was general editor, with J. B. Hennessy, Frankel and Merrillees as contributors; the volume, dated 1973, was first published in 19748. In the discussion Merrillees credited her with suggesting that Early Cypriot II was "a sort of 'palace style'" exclusive to Vounous8.
Frankel says her excavations at Irrawang drew her away from the Near East and the Mediterranean26. She was a central figure in founding the Australian Society for Historical Archaeology in 1970 and the major instigator of the first Australian course in historical archaeology, at Sydney in 1973/7416. She retired as associate professor in 1996 and was made a Member of the Order of Australia in 2017 for "significant service to higher education, particularly to historical archaeology"16.
Life and work
1961
- Senior Lecturer, Department of Archaeology, University of Sydney; writes on Cypriot fibulae in Claude Schaeffer's papers (Collège de France), 1 document, 1961.
1963
- Published 'The Chronology of Some Early and Middle Iron Age Cypriot Sites' (AJA 67); the AEI first report (1974) calls it 'the most radical onslaught' on Gjerstad's system, suggesting almost complete abandonment of it.
L. E. Stager (ed.), A. Walker (ed.), G. E. Wright (ed.) (1974). American Expedition to Idalion, Cyprus: First Preliminary Report, Seasons of 1971 and 1972. Cambridge, Mass., American Schools of Oriental Research, p. 34; L. E. Stager (ed.), A. Walker (ed.), G. E. Wright (ed.) (1974). American Expedition to Idalion, Cyprus: First Preliminary Report, Seasons of 1971 and 1972. Cambridge, Mass., American Schools of Oriental Research, p. 42
- Published 'The Development of the Fibula in Cyprus and the Levant', Palestine Exploration Quarterly 95: 80-112.
- Near Eastern specialist on the academic staff, University of Sydney in Claude Schaeffer's papers (Collège de France), 1 document, 1963.
1972
- In the Medelhavsmuseet Bulletin of 1972: «J. Birmingham, who gives very early dates for the Ajia Irini terracotta sculpture, writes in "Tli* Chronology of Some Early and Middle Iron Age Cypriot sites"»
1973
- Edited The Cypriot Bronze Age: Some Recent Australian Contributions to the Prehistory of Cyprus (Australian Studies in Archaeology 1, 1973; Sydney), to which R. S. Merrillees contributed pp. 44-57.
SydneyJoanna S. Smith, Despo Pilides, Jay Stratton Noller, Allan S. Gilbert (2008). Views from Phlamoudhi, Cyprus. Boston, American Schools of Oriental Research, p. 136; C. J. Tully (2018). The Cultic Life of Trees in the Prehistoric Aegean, Levant, Egypt and Cyprus. Leuven-Liège, Peeters, p. 204
In the Archive
1 itemConnections
5 peopleSales, gifts & bequests
- Gave to Joan du Plat Taylornotes on material in the Antioch Museum The Cypriot and Syrian Pottery from Al Mina, Syria (1959), p. 621959
Scholarship
- Wrote with Basil HennessyThe Cypriot Bronze Age: Some recent Australian contributions to the prehistory of Cyprus Birmingham et al., The Cypriot Bronze Age: Some recent Australian contributions to the prehistory of Cyprus, 19731973
- Wrote with David FrankelThe Cypriot Bronze Age: Some recent Australian contributions to the prehistory of Cyprus Birmingham et al., The Cypriot Bronze Age: Some recent Australian contributions to the prehistory of Cyprus, 19731973
- Published material of Robert Stuart Merrilleeseditor of The Cypriot Bronze Age (1973), Merrillees's chapter pp. 44-57 J. S. Smith et al., 2008, Views from Phlamoudhi, Cyprus (Annual of ASOR 63), p. 1361973
- Wrote with Robert Stuart MerrilleesThe Cypriot Bronze Age: Some recent Australian contributions to the prehistory of Cyprus Birmingham et al., The Cypriot Bronze Age: Some recent Australian contributions to the prehistory of Cyprus, 19731973
Colleagues & contacts
- Worked with Joan du Plat TaylorMyrtou-Pighades Edificios de culto y prácticas religiosas en Chipre durante el Bronce Reciente (1989), p. 371957–1967
- Connected with Max Mallowanrecommended her for a Sydney lectureship J. Powell, 2013, Love's Obsession: The Lives and Archaeology of Jim and Eve Stewart1960
Mentioned in
14 mentionsDocuments · 9
- The Cypro-Phoenician Pottery of the Iron Age
2003
argued for Phoenician production
Schreiber 2003
- American Expedition to Idalion, Cyprus, 1973-1980
Stager & Walker 1989
- American Expedition to Idalion, Cyprus: First Preliminary Report, Seasons of 1971 and 1972
Stager et al. 1974
- Aphrodite's Island: The Cypriot Collection of the Nicholson Museum
Barker 2012
- Archaeology, Artifacts and Antiquities of the Ancient Near East: Sites, Cultures, and Proveniences
Muscarella 2013
- Edificios de culto y prácticas religiosas en Chipre durante el Bronce Reciente (I)
Holgado 1989
On Ancient Cyprus · 1
- People · 4listed under Connections
- Archivelisted under In the Archive
Sources
- 1.L. E. Stager (ed.), A. Walker (ed.), G. E. Wright (ed.) (1974). American Expedition to Idalion, Cyprus: First Preliminary Report, Seasons of 1971 and 1972. Cambridge, Mass., American Schools of Oriental Research.
- 2.Lawrence E. Stager (ed.), Anita M. Walker (ed.) (1989). American Expedition to Idalion, Cyprus, 1973-1980. Chicago, Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago.
- 3.Joanna S. Smith, Despo Pilides, Jay Stratton Noller, Allan S. Gilbert (2008). Views from Phlamoudhi, Cyprus. Boston, American Schools of Oriental Research.
- 4.C. J. Tully (2018). The Cultic Life of Trees in the Prehistoric Aegean, Levant, Egypt and Cyprus. Leuven-Liège, Peeters.
- 5.Craig Barker (2012). Aphrodite's Island: The Cypriot Collection of the Nicholson Museum. Sydney, Nicholson Museum, University of Sydney.
- 6.J. Birmingham (1963). “The Chronology of Some Early and Middle Iron Age Cypriot Sites”. American Journal of Archaeology 67, 15-41.
- 7.J. Birmingham (1963). “The Development of the Fibula in Cyprus and the Levant”. Palestine Exploration Quarterly 95, 80-112.
- 8.J. Birmingham (ed.) (1973). The Cypriot Bronze Age: Some Recent Australian Contributions to the Prehistory of Cyprus. Sydney, Southwood.
- 9.Nicola Schreiber (2003). “The Cypro-Phoenician Pottery of the Iron Age”. Culture and History of the Ancient Near East. Brill.
- 10.Australasian Society for Historical Archaeology (2021). Judy Birmingham's 90th Birthday. Online
- 11.Wikidata. Judy Birmingham (Q6304341). Online
- 12.Australasian Society for Historical Archaeology (2017). Upcoming event: In Conversation with Judy Birmingham. Online
- 13.[Arediou survey report]. “[Survey at Arediou-Vouppes, bibliography]”. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research.
- 14.[reviewer not read] (1960). “[Review of J. du Plat Taylor, Myrtou-Pigadhes]”. Bibliotheca Orientalis 17.
- 15.James R. Stewart (1960). “[Review of J. du Plat Taylor, Myrtou-Pigadhes: A Late Bronze Age Sanctuary in Cyprus]”. American Journal of Archaeology 64.
- 16.Australasian Society for Historical Archaeology (2017). Judy Birmingham AM, Queens Birthday 2017 Australian Honours. Online
- 17.J. M. Birmingham (1961). “[Letter from J. M. Birmingham to Claude Schaeffer on M. Bérard's excavations at Ktima]”. Collège de France, Fonds Claude Schaeffer, 34 CDF art. 188.
- 18.A. Cambitoglou (1963). “[Letter from A. Cambitoglou to Claude Schaeffer about the Vounous collections]”. Collège de France, Fonds Claude Schaeffer, 34 CDF art. 188.
- 19.J. M. Birmingham (1961). “The Overland Route across Anatolia in the Eighth and Seventh Centuries B.C.”. Anatolian Studies 11, 185-195.
- 20.Valérie Cook. Cyprus during the Transition from the Bronze to the Iron Age.
- 21.Joanna S. Smith (2009). Art and Society in Cyprus from the Bronze Age into the Iron Age. Cambridge University Press.
- 22.[chapter in] AURA Supplement 9. “Beyond Cyprus: Investigating Cypriot Connectivity in the Mediterranean”. AURA Supplement 9.
- 23.Ron E. Tappy. The Archaeology of Israelite Samaria, Volume 1: Early Iron Age through the Ninth Century BCE.
- 24.Andrés T. Reyes (1994). Archaic Cyprus: A Study of the Textual and Archaeological Evidence. Oxford, Clarendon Press.
- 25.Peter James (1993). Siglos de oscuridad: desafío a la cronología tradicional del mundo antiguo.
- 26.David Frankel (2021). “Judy Birmingham: impressions and influences”. AWAWS blog (first posted on the AAIA blog, March 2021). Online
- 27.Sylvia Törnkvist, «Arms, Armour and Dress of the Terracotta Sculpture from Ajia Irini, Cyprus», Medelhavsmuseet Bulletin 6 (1972).
- 28.Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 188, «[Correspondance entre Schaeffer et Birmingham à propos des fouilles de M. Berard à Ktima]», 29 September 1961of 4. Online
- 29.Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 188, «[Lettre de Cambitoglou à Schaeffer à propos des collections concernant Vounous]», 3 July 1963of 2. Online
- 30.The Cypriot and Syrian Pottery from Al Mina, Syria (1959).
- 31.Edificios de culto y prácticas religiosas en Chipre durante el Bronce Reciente (1989).
- 32.J. S. Smith et al., 2008, Views from Phlamoudhi, Cyprus (Annual of ASOR 63).
- 33.Nina R. Thompson, Cumulative Book Index 1957-1958 (1959).
- 34.Birmingham et al., The Cypriot Bronze Age: Some recent Australian contributions to the prehistory of Cyprus, 1973.
- 35.J. Powell, 2013, Love's Obsession: The Lives and Archaeology of Jim and Eve Stewart.
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Date of birth unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.
