Scholar
Frederik Poulsen
1876–1950 · Denmark
Danish archaeologist and author (1876-1950), later director of the Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek, who in 1911 re-dated the Enkomi graves and in 1912 gave the Oriental metal bowls to the Phoenicians.
Biography
Frederik Poulsen, a Danish archaeologist and author, argued in 1911 that the Enkomi cemetery had been in use for four to five centuries2,8. He was born Poul Frederik Sigfred Poulsen at Dalsgård in Hvilsager parish on 7 March 1876, and his father, a landowner, died when he was about five8. After his school-leaving examination in 1894 he went to Copenhagen to study classical languages, and in Munich he came upon Adolf Furtwängler8. His doctoral thesis, on the Dipylon graves and Dipylon vases, appeared in 19048. On 24 April 1908, at Frogner in Norway, he married Ellen Nonny Ørting Møller8.
Enkomi
Carl Jacobsen created a post for him in 1910 as assistant in the antiquities collection of the Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek8. In the next year "Zur Zeitbestimmung der Enkomifunde" took up the necropolis dug by the English in 1896, which Poulsen thought could most probably be referred to Teucer's Salamis2. Alexander Stuart Murray, who led the excavation, had held the graves to be roughly contemporary and dated the finds to about 800 BC2. Poulsen himself records that Furtwängler and Arthur Evans had at once opposed that late date2. His method was to date graves by scarabs and by stylistic comparison with Egyptian, Phoenician and early Archaic material2. An Egyptian faience plate from Tomb 66 he put in the 18th Dynasty on the advice of Hall, and against Fimmen he kept two handled jugs inside one grave2. A bronze miniature tripod, matched with one from an Athenian Dipylon grave, kept another grave not much before about 1000 BC2. He regretted that no exact observations had been made at the dig, and hoped that Evans would use the vase inscriptions to trace the Cypriot script from the Minoan2.
Eduard Meyer wrote that the dating of the Enkomi graves was established by Poulsen and Fimmen against Murray9. Julius Beloch accepted Poulsen's range, from the 15th-14th to the 12th-11th century, but called the reading of Cypriot towns in the Medinet Habu lists pure arbitrariness and faulted Evans and Poulsen for treating it as fact10. E. H. Hall said he wrongly called the Enkomi tripod a miniature, as it is 0.43 m high, and that his claim of its likeness to the Dipylon piece "bis in die kleinsten Details" was obviously an exaggeration11. In 1935 Evans credited him with showing that an ivory casket fragment came from Tomb 2 with a scarab of Rameses III12.
The Phoenician bowls
Tandrup calls Der Orient und die frühgriechische Kunst (1912) his chief archaeological work, and judges it epoch-making8. In it Poulsen held the metal bowls Phoenician, and objected that René Dussaud declared them Cypriot without explaining why their inscriptions were exclusively in a Syrian language7. His catalogue included a bowl from Amathus7. The sources disagree on where the bowls were made: a reviewer in Classical Philology (1914) found his case for the Phoenician origin of most of these objects, the bowls among them, convincing, while the Ancient Egypt review of Dussaud's book (1915) set Dussaud's reasons for a Cypriot origin against Poulsen's view5,13. David Randall-MacIver in 1924 called him more moderate than Helbig, and held the question undecided until Ionia and the Levant were better explored14.
Max Ohnefalsch-Richter wrote an article in the Orientalisches Archiv inspired by the book and under its title15. He denied that any independent Phoenician art had existed, said the "excellent book" gained its full value only if the centre of the metal and ivory work was moved to Cyprus, and complained that Poulsen had not cited him16. John Linton Myres wrote in 1933 that Poulsen clearly had not seen the Amathus Bowl, since he placed it in New York17. Annie Caubet in 2019 credited him with bringing out the role of Oriental ivories in the making of Orientalising Greek art18.
The Glyptotek
His 1914 supplement to the Glyptotek catalogue has a section on Archaic and Cypriot art19. There he argued that, Cyprus being half-oriental, a Cypriot ruler might, like an Assyrian or Persian king, have had his image made of superhuman size, and read the column-round necks of the heads as a sign of the slow development of Cypriot art19. He became inspector in 1915, was secretary of the Ny Carlsberg Foundation from 1915 to 1926, and was director of the Glyptotek from 1926 until 19438. In 1926 and 1928 he dug at Kalydon in Aetolia with Rhomaios8. Tandrup says he felt hampered by increasing deafness8. He died at Hellerup on 8 November 1950 and was buried there8.
Life and work
1911
- Published 'Zur Zeitbestimmung der Enkomifunde' (Jahrbuch des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts 26, pp. 215-248, 31 figs.): re-examined the contents of the Enkomi graves, found them of many dates from the early second millennium BCE to c. 1000 BCE, with many Egyptian and Cretan objects, and no ground for the Assyrian analogies behind A. S. Murray's date of about 800 BCE
1912
- Published Der Orient und die frühgriechische Kunst, on Oriental metal bowls and early Greek art; reviewers report that he gave the bowls with Assyrian and Egyptian imitations to the Phoenicians rather than Cyprus, against Dussaud
(1915). [Review of R. Dussaud, Les civilisations préhelléniques, 2nd ed.]. Ancient Egypt 2; Frederik Poulsen (1912). Der Orient und die frühgriechische Kunst. B. G. Teubner
Undated
n.d.
- Poulsen studied the class of engraved Oriental bowls to which the Amathus Bowl belongs.
J. L. Myres, 1933, The Amathus Bowl: A Long-Lost Masterpiece of Oriental Engraving, p. 27
Connections
3 peopleDisputes & the law
- Rival of Spyridon MarinatosMinoan origin of Encomi faience American Journal of Archaeology 1930: Vol 34 Iss 4 (1930)1911
- Rival of René Dussaudgriffin combat interpretation A ‘new’ mirror handle from Cyprus (1992), p. 21912–1914
- Rival of Alexander Stuart MurrayEnkomi objects Bibliothèque des écoles françaises d'Athènes et de Rome - Vol. 110 (1877)1914
Colleagues & contacts
- Connected with Alexander Stuart MurrayEncomi necropolis dating American journal of archaeology : the journal of the Archaeological Institute of America (1897)1911
- Connected with René Dussaudbowls with rows of imitations of Assyrian and Egyptian subjects Petrie, Flinders, Ancient Egypt Vol.2 (1915)
Mentioned in
6 mentionsDocuments · 3
- A 'new' mirror handle from Cyprus
Krzyszkowska 1992
- The Inscriptions of Kourion
Mitford 1971
- Ugarit, Zypern und Ägäis: Kulturbeziehungen im zweiten Jahrtausend v.Chr.
Buchholz 1999
- People · 3listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.Authority record (Wikidata / GND). Online
- 2.Frederik Poulsen (1911). “Zur Zeitbestimmung der Enkomifunde”. Jahrbuch des Kaiserlich Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts 26, 215-248.
- 3.William N. Bates (1912). Archaeological Discussions (American Journal of Archaeology, notice of Poulsen's article). 253.
- 4.Revue de philologie (1912). Revue de philologie, de littérature et d'histoire anciennes 36.
- 5. (1915). “[Review of R. Dussaud, Les civilisations préhelléniques, 2nd ed.]”. Ancient Egypt 2.
- 6. (1923). American Journal of Archaeology 27.
- 7.Frederik Poulsen (1912). Der Orient und die frühgriechische Kunst. B. G. Teubner.
- 8.Leo Tandrup. “Frederik Poulsen”. Dansk Biografisk Leksikon, 3rd ed. (online at lex.dk). Online
- 9.Eduard Meyer. Geschichte des Altertums, vol. I.2 (3rd ed.).
- 10.Julius Beloch (1912). Griechische Geschichte, vol. I.2 (2nd ed.).
- 11.Edith H. Hall (1914). “Excavations in Eastern Crete: Vrokastro”. University of Pennsylvania, The Museum, Anthropological Publications 3.3.
- 12.Arthur Evans (1935). The Palace of Minos at Knossos, vol. IV, part II.
- 13. (1914). “[Review of F. Poulsen, Der Orient und die frühgriechische Kunst]”. Classical Philology 9.1.
- 14.David Randall-MacIver (1924). Villanovans and Early Etruscans.
- 15. (1989). “[Bibliography of Max Ohnefalsch-Richter]”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 11 (1989). Online
- 16. (1912). “Der Orient und die frühgriechische Kunst”. Orientalisches Archiv 3 (1912-1913), ed. Hugo Grothe.
- 17.J. L. Myres (1933). “The Amathus Bowl: a long-lost masterpiece of Oriental engraving”. Journal of Hellenic Studies 53.
- 18.Annie Caubet (2019). “[Chapter on the ivories of Salamis]”. Salamis of Cyprus: History and Archaeology from the Earliest Times to Late Antiquity.
- 19.Frederik Poulsen (1914). Tillæg til Katalog over Ny Carlsberg Glyptoteks antike Kunstværker. Nielsen & Lydiche.
- 20.J. L. Myres, 1933, The Amathus Bowl: A Long-Lost Masterpiece of Oriental Engraving.
- 21.A ‘new’ mirror handle from Cyprus (1992).
- 22.W. M. F. Petrie (ed.), 1915, Ancient Egypt 1915.
- 23.Bibliothèque des écoles françaises d'Athènes et de Rome - Vol. 110 (1877).
- 24.Orientalistische Literaturzeitung 16.1913+17.1914.
- 25.Petrie, Flinders, Ancient Egypt Vol.2 (1915).
- 26.Petrie, W. M. Flinders (William Matthew Flinders), Sir, 1853-1942, The mysterious Zêt (1914).
- 27.American Journal of Archaeology 1930: Vol 34 Iss 4 (1930).
- 28.American journal of archaeology : the journal of the Archaeological Institute of America (1897).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.