Curator · Museum staff

Henry G. Hutchins

fl. 1870–1884 · United States

Early Metropolitan Museum officer who watched the first Cesnola sculptures being restored in 1873 and testified to it for Feuardent in 1883.

Biography

H. G. Hutchins was an officer of the young Metropolitan Museum of Art who was its Assistant Superintendent when the first Cesnola collection reached New York in 1873, and who ten years later testified against Luigi Palma di Cesnola in the libel suit brought by Gaston Feuardent1.

He was one of the five children of Ephraim and Caroline Hutchins of Concord, New Hampshire5. Major Ephraim Hutchins was landlord of the Phoenix Hotel and later Concord's eighth postmaster6. A sister, Mrs. Augustus Schutz, was the wife of the United States consul at Coquimbo, Chile7.

By his own testimony Hutchins entered the museum's service in 1871, when it was at 681 Fifth Avenue8. Winifred E. Howe says he was taken on as caretaker and janitor and made Assistant Superintendent, and that for several years he and Thomas Bland were the only paid staff9. Isaac H. Hall thanked "Mr. H. G. Hutchins, curator" in 18742, and a passage from a letter Hall wrote to him from Larnaca on 16 November 1875 was later printed in the Courrier de l'art10. The sources disagree on when his service ended: Howe says he held office until Cesnola's appointment, Feuardent that he was Superintendent until 18799,11.

Hutchins said that the 1873 shipment arrived badly broken, partly boxed and partly on the floor1. In his account, the repairer Feodor Gehlen prepared it in the basement of the Fourteenth Street building under Cesnola's direction, gave a priest with a patera a new forearm and hand, and built a leg for a Hercules from sawn fragments on an iron rod1. He also received letters from Cesnola about paying "the German" for his glue and mending another lot1. One of two former museum janitors interviewed by the New York Times in 1882 said he had helped Hutchins pack the small statues and pottery for the move to Central Park12.

He then lived in Arizona, and in 1883 said he had been there four years and was in mining8. Letters of 1880-84 from a Gordon Hutchins at the San Carlos Indian Agency, among them some on the Feuardent case, are evidently his5,7. In April 1882 Feuardent published his comments, which stated that Gehlen made arms, legs and feet by Cesnola's direction11.

At the trial in November 1883 the whole third day went to his cross- and redirect examination13. When Joseph H. Choate objected that he was no archaeologist, Bangs answered that he was one "in plastering up old statues"8. Handling the disputed statuette in court, he said it looked smaller, with drapery lines "as if they had been picked out"13. The New York Times wrote that Gehlen's evidence confirmed his14, and the Repertorium für Kunstwissenschaft named him first among museum officials whose statements it called of the gravest kind and impossible ever to deny15.

Hutchins was back in Concord by 1891, as an usher at the reception and banquet the city gave George A. Pillsbury after the dedicatory exercises16, and in March 1893 assisted on an excursion party to New Orleans and California17. He had died by 1908, when Concord's accounts record a burial fee paid by his estate18.

Life and work

  1. 1870

    1. 1870–1879

      Howe and Kent's history of the Museum says H. Gordon Hutchins was employed first as a caretaker and janitor when the Fifth Avenue building was leased, proved so capable that he was made Assistant Superintendent, and with the Assistant Secretary, Thomas Bland, conducted the Museum's affairs as the only paid members of staff.

      New YorkW. E. Howe; H. W. Kent (1913). A history of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, with a chapter on the early institutions of art in New York

  2. 1873

    1. Was Assistant Superintendent of the Metropolitan Museum when the first instalment of the Cesnola collection arrived in New York; it was partly boxed, partly on the floor, badly broken (statues missing legs or arms, loose heads).

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23

    2. 1873–1876

      Testified that the collection was prepared for exhibition in the basement workshop of the Fourteenth Street building by the repairer Feodor Gehlen, employed by the Museum Association, under Cesnola's direction and supervision and with Cesnola a daily visitor who 'repeatedly and effusively complimented' him; materials were plaster, fragments of old statues, a glue and a secret tinting wash. He described the priest with a patera (no right forearm on arrival; Gehlen supplied forearm and hand under Cesnola's direction; the hand came off two or three times after a leaky roof drenched the statue and Hutchins had Gehlen replace it), the figure with a cow's head (no. 19), nos. 40 and 22, the 'bearded Venus' and a tailless dove given a wooden-and-plaster tail, the sarcophagus of Plate 11 in Cesnola's Cyprus (one end knocked out, the hunting side cracked in three, filled with plaster), Hercules (missing part of the right leg and an arm; leg built from sawn fragments on an iron rod, nut above the hip) and the largest head (nose, face and beard found built up when dripping water exposed them; Gehlen re-restored the nose at his direction). He said all this was done before Cesnola went to Cyprus.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, pp. 23-24

  3. 1874

    1. 28 October

      Isaac H. Hall, presenting his study of the Cypriote inscriptions of the Cesnola collection to the American Oriental Society, thanked Mr. Thomas Bland, assistant secretary, and 'Mr. H. G. Hutchins, curator' for continual assistance and for making the objects more readily accessible.

      New YorkIsaac H. Hall (1874). The Cypriote Inscriptions of the Di Cesnola Collection in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, in New York City. Journal of the American Oriental Society 10, 201-218, p. 203

  4. 1877

    1. Met Gaston Feuardent, introduced by the Secretary of the Museum Association, and at Cesnola's request showed him statuette No. 157 ('Venus' for Cesnola, 'Elpis or Hope' for Feuardent).

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23

  5. 1883

    1. October–December

      Second witness of the trial (after the Times reporter Lawrence Kane), for the plaintiff Feuardent: direct testimony on his time as Assistant Superintendent in 1873 and on the restorations; the whole of the third day went on his cross- and redirect examination by Mr. Stickney (for Cesnola), when he said the statuette no. 157 shown in court 'looks different' from the one he showed Feuardent in Fourteenth Street (smoother, with a mirror, cleaner, smaller; the drapery lines more distinct as if picked out; the lines on the left side gone). A second Cypriote Elpis statuette 'from one of the finest collections in France' was introduced by the plaintiff to show the drapery's original form. He also identified the museum album of photographs taken by Pach at Fourteenth Street, from which a leaf (pp. 105-106) bearing the handless priest had been torn; the note on p. 107 'Pages 105 to 106 detached' was in a hand he said was not his, and he had kept custody of the book until he left the museum.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23

    2. Five letters from Cesnola in Cyprus to Hutchins were put in evidence: asking him to get the restorer's glue and directions for use, to watch that the restoration cement did not start in cold weather, and to tell 'the German artist' there would be more restoration work when Cesnola returned.

      (1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23

    3. Dickson B. Alley, a museum employee in 1877, testified he helped Hutchins mount some of the statues.

      (1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 24

    4. October–December

      Hutchins said that in 1877 he was introduced to Feuardent by the Secretary of the Museum Association and, at Cesnola's request, showed him statuette no. 157 (Venus to Cesnola, Elpis or Hope to Feuardent): he had examined it at least four times and each time there was nothing in the left hand, which rested against the drapery, and three diverging lines on the drapery below it; in May 1883 at the Central Park museum he saw many changes and a mirror 'cut in or added'.

      New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23

  6. Undated

    n.d.

    1. Curator at the Metropolitan Museum who assisted Isaac H. Hall's study of the Cesnola Cypriote inscriptions.

      Hall 1872

Connections

7 people

Mentioned in

12 mentions

Institutions · 1

  • Metropolitan Museum of Art

    Assistant Superintendent (his testimony), styled 'curator' by Hall (1874) · 1873

    The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial 1883, p. 23; Hall 1874, p. 203

Sources

  1. 1. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24. Online
  2. 2.Isaac H. Hall (1874). “The Cypriote Inscriptions of the Di Cesnola Collection in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, in New York City”. Journal of the American Oriental Society 10, 201-218. Online
  3. 3. (1884). “The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97. Online
  4. 4.W. E. Howe; H. W. Kent (1913). A history of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, with a chapter on the early institutions of art in New York.
  5. 5.Arizona Historical Society (2006). MS 1282 Gordon Hutchins Letters, 1880-1884 [finding aid]. Online
  6. 6.Henry McFarland (1899). Sixty years in Concord and elsewhere: personal recollections of Henry McFarland, 1831-1891.
  7. 7.Library of Congress (1975). “The National Union Catalog of Manuscript Collections”. Catalog 1973-74 and Index 1970-74 12.
  8. 8.[unsigned] (1883). “[Report of the Feuardent-Di Cesnola libel suit, second day]”. The New York Times, 2 November 1883.
  9. 9.Winifred E. Howe (1913). A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, with a chapter on the early institutions of art in New York. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  10. 10.[unsigned] (1885). “[Report on the Cesnola collection and the Curium earrings]”. Courrier de l'art.
  11. 11.Gaston L. Feuardent (1882). “[Letter on the Cesnola collection, with comments by H. G. Hutchins]”. The New York Times, 6 April 1882.
  12. 12.[unsigned] (1882). “[Statements of Metropolitan Museum employees on the Cesnola collection]”. The New York Times, 10 April 1882.
  13. 13.[unsigned] (1883). “More about the manufacture of antiquity to order”. The New York Times, 3 November 1883.
  14. 14.[unsigned] (1883). “[Report of the Feuardent-Di Cesnola libel suit]”. The New York Times, 8 November 1883.
  15. 15.[unsigned] (1884). “[Report on Cesnola's forgeries]”. Repertorium für Kunstwissenschaft 7.
  16. 16.City of Concord (1891). Three dedications: Soldier's Monument at South Sutton, Pillsbury Free Library at Warner, Margaret Pillsbury General Hospital at Concord.
  17. 17.Erie Morning Dispatch (1893). “[Report of an excursion party passing through]”. Erie Morning Dispatch, 15 March 1893.
  18. 18.City of Concord, N.H. (1909). Annual report of the receipts and expenditures of the city of Concord [for the year 1908].
  19. 19.Hall 1872.
  20. 20.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
  21. 21.G. L. Feuardent, 'The Cesnola-Baillard Sarcophagus', Art Amateur 4 (May 1881), pp. 113-114; Art Amateur 10 (Dec. 1883), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial'.
  22. 22.1885, Article on the Kourion treasure and the earrings (prints Hall's letter of 16 Nov 1875).
  23. 23.Courrier de l'art : chronique hebdomadaire des ateliers, des musées, des expositions, des ventes publiques... (1885-01-02).
  24. 24.I. H. Hall, 1874, The Cypriote Inscriptions of the Di Cesnola Collection in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, in New York City.
  25. 25.The Century illustrated monthly magazine (1871).
  26. 26.The Art Amateur 1882-04: Vol 6 Iss 5 (1882).
  27. 27.The Art Amateur 1883-12: Vol 10 Iss 1.
  28. 28.The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (1883).
  29. 29.The New York Times 1883-11-02: Vol 33 Iss 10034 (1883).
  30. 30.The New York Times 1882-04-06: Vol 31 Iss 9541 (1882).
  31. 31.The New York Times 1884-01-23: Vol 33 Iss 10104 (1884).
  32. 32.The New York Times 1883-11-03: Vol 33 Iss 10035 (1883).
  33. 33.Art Amateur 10 (Dec. 1883), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial'.
  34. 34.I. H. Hall, 1872.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Dates of birth and death unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.