Lawyer / legislator
Joseph H. Choate
1832–1917 · United States
New York lawyer and Metropolitan Museum trustee who spoke at the museum's 1880 opening and led Luigi Palma di Cesnola's defence in Gaston Feuardent's libel suit of 1883-84.
Biography
Joseph H. Choate was a New York lawyer and trustee of the Metropolitan Museum of Art who led the defence of Luigi Palma di Cesnola in the 1883-84 libel suit over the Cesnola Cypriot antiquities6.
He was born in Salem, Massachusetts, on 24 January 1832, the son of Dr George Choate, a physician, and Margaret Manning Hodges7,8. Choate graduated from Harvard in 1852, fourth in his class, and from the Cambridge Law School in 1854, and was admitted to the bar in 18559,10. By 1856 he was in the New York office of Butler, Evarts and Southmayd, which became Evarts, Southmayd and Choate three years later7. In 1861 he married Caroline Dutcher, daughter of Frederick A. Sterling10.
The museum and the 1880 address
Choate sat on the sub-committee of thirteen that drew up a plan for a Metropolitan art museum, and on its first Executive Committee11. He drafted the lease of the Central Park building, recorded on 24 December 187811. At the opening on 30 March 1880, with President Rutherford B. Hayes present, Choate gave the address "The History and Future Plans of the Museum"11,12. In it he said that "the world-renowed Cesnola Collection is now for the first time so arranged and exhibited that its real merits and beauty can be understood and appreciated", and called its archaeological and historical value "undisputed"13. He declined to discuss its artistic value, which "many learned men in many languages" had examined, and hoped to show it beside casts of the masterpieces of Greek sculpture, "to which it will serve as an introduction"13. He also quoted the Duke of Argyll telling Cesnola that the British Museum had not accomplished so much in thirty years13. The same speech urged "ye millionaires of many markets" "to convert pork into porcelain"11.
Feuardent against Cesnola
Gaston Feuardent charged that the statues and other objects had been so restored and doctored as to be of little or no value as antiquities, and claimed $25,000 damages3,6. The trial began on 31 October 1883, with Allen W. Evarts, Albert Stickney and Choate for Cesnola and Francis N. Bangs, with Oakley, for Feuardent6,11. The trustees insisted on bearing the expense11. During the trial Choate joked in a November speech that the Federal Court had been converted into "the ruins of the temple of Golgos", where he studied gods of Cyprus "until their very identity is brought in question"13. Robert Underwood Johnson says Choate tried to discount Richard Watson Gilder's damaging testimony by treating him good-humouredly as merely a poet14.
The New York Times reported that Choate began his summing-up on 28 January 1884 and talked for four hours that day15. Anna G. Marangou says he spoke for nine hours16. He told the jury that if they had all stayed a little longer "we should have all become antiquities", and that Bangs had asked a question for each object in the collection, 35,553 in Martin's text and 35,543 in the Times6,15. The jibe at the critic Clarence Cook also survives in two wordings: "the false and fleeting but not quite perjured Clarence" in Martin, "False, fleeting, perjured Clarence" in the 1903 Choate Story Book6,17.
The sources disagree on the verdict. The Times reported that the jury found for Cesnola on two counts and could not agree on the third, and the Cyclopaedia of American Biography says the jury disagreed18,19. Marangou calls the verdict a complete vindication rejecting all Feuardent's accusations, and Martin says Choate won the case6,16. Johnson wrote that "legally Cesnola won", but that the collection's integrity was later established "by elimination"14.
Theron G. Strong says the case largely increased Choate's reputation as "probably the greatest jury lawyer of his time", and that it was thought at the time he needlessly goaded Bangs20. According to Marangou, Cesnola owed Choate $32,000 for the trial, of which the trustees contributed $21,00016.
In 1899 President McKinley appointed Choate to succeed John Hay as ambassador to Great Britain9. Howe lists him as a vice-president of the museum from 191011. He died in New York on 14 May 19177,8.
Life and work
1880
30 March
Spoke at the opening of the Metropolitan Museum's new building in Central Park; the opening was declared by President Hayes. Marangou calls him 'the young eloquent lawyer'.New YorkA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 295
1883
31 October
Named with Mr. Stickney as counsel for the defendant, L. P. Di Cesnola, in Feuardent's libel action before Judge Shipman in the US Circuit Court, New York; the plaintiff's side was Oudin and Oakley (attorneys) and F. C. Bangs (counsel). The trial began on 31 October 1883; the plaintiff claimed $25,000 (five counts of $5,000).New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23; (1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement). The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b, p. 4a
1883–1884
Led the museum's lawyers in the Feuardent libel action (nine and a half weeks, from the end of 1883 into early 1884, Judge Nathaniel Shipman); sat next to Cesnola, opposite Feuardent and Francis Bangs. Marangou has him tell Bangs, who asked to pick up a small stone dog from the Museum, 'Certainly, if you are strong enough', and has him sum up for the defence for nine hours: restoration took two weeks rather than two months, ridicule of Feuardent, and the trustees standing by Cesnola because he was the object of 'malignant persecution'. Bangs's summing-up took two days.New YorkA. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 323
1883–1884Civil suit
Counsel for Cesnola and the museum in the libel suit brought by Gaston Feuardent (US Circuit Court, New York, from 31 October 1883). Outcome per the Art Amateur: jury for the defendant on two of three counts, no agreement on the third; per Marangou: complete vindication of Cesnola.(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23; (1884). The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97, p. 96; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 323
1884
- Cesnola owed Choate $32,000 for the trial; the trustees, since the charges had also been against the museum, contributed $21,000. Cesnola confided to Hitchcock in 1884 that he did not know how he would meet the rest.
A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 331
by 1 March 1884
Outcome. The Art Amateur (quoting no figure for the date) says the judge's charge ignored the archaeological questions and confined itself to libel; the jury found for the defendant on two of the three counts put to it and disagreed on the third (whether Cesnola's accusation about cartage charges and failure to sell the collection in London entitled Feuardent to damages). Marangou says instead that the jury rejected all Feuardent's accusations as malicious and without foundation after 28 hours.New York(1884). The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97, p. 96; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 328
Connections
5 peopleSales, gifts & bequests
- Agent for Luigi Palma di CesnolaFeuardent libel trial; Feuardent trial Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 323; Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola, p. 295, p. 331, p. 3771883–1884
Fieldwork & employment
- Employed by Luigi Palma di Cesnolalibel suit against Feuardent; Feuardent-di Cesnola libel case Theron George Strong, Joseph H. Choate: New Englander, New Yorker, Lawyer, Ambassador (1917); Choate, Joseph Hodges, 1832-1917, The life of Joseph Hodges Choate : as gathered chiefly from his letters (1920)1881–1884
- Employed Luigi Palma di CesnolaJames E. Homans, The Cyclopaedia Of American Biography (1918)
Disputes & the law
- Rival of Luigi Palma di CesnolaFeuardent versus di Cesnola trial over Cypriote antiquities Timothy Dwight , Julian Hawthorne, The World's great classics (1899)1870–1880
- Rival of Francis Bangsstatue No. 14; libel trial of Feuardent; Feuardent-di Cesnola libel case The New York Times 1884-01-12: Vol 33 Iss 10095 (1884); Strong, Theron G. (Theron George), 1846-1924, Joseph H. Choate : New Englander, New Yorker, lawyer, ambassador (1917); Choate, Joseph Hodges, 1832-1917, The life of Joseph Hodges Choate : as gathered chiefly from his letters (1920)1880–1884
- In litigation with Francis Bangsopposing counsel in the Feuardent-Cesnola trial Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904, p. 3251883–1884
- In litigation with Gaston Louis FeuardentCesnola's counsel Edward Sandford Martin (ed.), 1920, The Life of Joseph Hodges Choate, as gathered chiefly from his letters, p. 349; Theron G. Strong, 1917, Joseph H. Choate: New Englander, New Yorker, Lawyer, Ambassador, pp. 197-1981883–1884
- Rival of Gaston Louis Feuardentphoto 22, Cesnola statuary William MacLeod, Corcoran Curator's Journal [transcription] (1883)1883
- Subject of testimony by Lucy W. MitchellCesnola collection The New York Times 1883-11-17: Vol 33 Iss 10047 (1883)1883
Colleagues & contacts
- Worked with Gaston Louis FeuardentFeuardent versus di Cesnola trial over Cypriote antiquities Timothy Dwight , Julian Hawthorne, The World's great classics (1899)1870–1880
- Worked with Luigi Palma di Cesnolalibel suit over Cyprus antiquities; libel trial; libel suit against Gaston Feuardent James E. Homans, The Cyclopaedia Of American Biography (1918); Winifred Eva Howe , Henry Watson Kent, A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art: With a Chapter on the Early ... (1913); Strong, Theron G. (Theron George), 1846-1924, Joseph H. Choate : New Englander, New Yorker, lawyer, ambassador (1917)1880–1884
- Connected with Luigi Palma di Cesnolalibel suit over Cypriot antiquities; Cesnola collection of ancient statuary Wilson, James Grant, 1832-1914; Fiske, John, 1842-1901; Dick, Charles, 1858-, The Cyclopaedia of American biography. New enl. ed. of Appleton's cyclopaedia of American biography, originally edited by James Grant Wilson and John Fiske. Rev (1918); Herringshaw, Thomas William, 1858- ed, Herringshaw's encyclopedia of American biography of the nineteenth century. Accurate and succinct biographies of famous men and women ... of the United States . (1907)1882–1884
- Worked with Mr. Stickneyco-counsel for Cesnola in the Feuardent libel trial 1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial, p. 231883–1884
- Connected with Gaston Louis FeuardentFenardent-Cesnola suit Thomas B. Reed, Modern Eloquence Vol-X (1900); Thomas B. Reed, Modern Eloquence Vol-x (1900)1900
Mentioned in
11 mentionsDocuments · 6
- A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, with a chapter on the early institutions of art in New York
Howe 1913
- Joseph Hodges Choate
- The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds
Marangou 2000
- The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial
1884
- The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial
1883
- The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement)
1883
Institutions · 1
- Rollin et Feuardent
1880
Gaston Feuardent attacks the authenticity and restoration of Cesnola's sculptures at the Metropolitan Museum (Art Amateur, August 1880); the 'Feuardent v…
Tatton-Brown 2001; Masson 1992, p. 153
- People · 4listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
- 2.“Joseph Hodges Choate”. Wikipedia. Online
- 3. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24. Online
- 4. (1884). “The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97. Online
- 5. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement)”. The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b. Online
- 6.Edward Sandford Martin (1921). The Life of Joseph Hodges Choate, as Gathered Chiefly from His Letters.
- 7. (1918). “Choate, Joseph Hodges”. The New International Year Book for the Year 1917.
- 8. (1928). “[Biographical note on Joseph H. Choate]”. American Bar Association Journal, vol. 14, no. 4 (April 1928).
- 9. (1900). “Joseph Hodges Choate [biographical sketch]”. Orations of American Orators, including biographical and critical sketches.
- 10.William Richard Cutter (ed.) (1916). “Choate, Joseph H., Diplomatist, Orator”. Encyclopedia of Massachusetts, Biographical-Genealogical, vol. 2. American Historical Society.
- 11.Winifred E. Howe (1913). A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, with a Chapter on the Early Institutions of Art in New York. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
- 12. (1880). “[Opening of the Metropolitan Museum of Art]”. The American Art Review, vol. 1.
- 13.Joseph H. Choate; Frederick C. Hicks (ed.) (1926). Arguments and Addresses of Joseph Hodges Choate. West Publishing Co..
- 14.Robert Underwood Johnson (1923). Remembered Yesterdays.
- 15. (1884). “[Report of Choate's summing-up in the Feuardent-Cesnola libel case]”. The New York Times, 29 January 1884.
- 16.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
- 17. (1903). The Choate Story Book, with a Biographical Sketch of Hon. Joseph H. Choate.
- 18. (1884). “[Editorial on the verdict in Feuardent v. Cesnola]”. The New York Times, 3 February 1884.
- 19. (1918). “Choate, Joseph Hodges”. The Cyclopaedia of American Biography, new enlarged edition, ed. James Grant Wilson and John Fiske, vol. 8.
- 20.Theron G. Strong (1917). Joseph H. Choate: New Englander, New Yorker, Lawyer, Ambassador.
- 21.Edward Sandford Martin (ed.), 1920, The Life of Joseph Hodges Choate, as gathered chiefly from his letters, p. 349; Theron G. Strong, 1917, Joseph H. Choate: New Englander, New Yorker, Lawyer, Ambassador.
- 22.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904.
- 23.The New York Times 1884-01-12: Vol 33 Iss 10095 (1884).
- 24.Strong, Theron G. (Theron George), 1846-1924, Joseph H. Choate : New Englander, New Yorker, lawyer, ambassador (1917).
- 25.Choate, Joseph Hodges, 1832-1917, The life of Joseph Hodges Choate : as gathered chiefly from his letters (1920).
- 26.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
- 27.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial.
- 28.Wilson, James Grant, 1832-1914; Fiske, John, 1842-1901; Dick, Charles, 1858-, The Cyclopaedia of American biography. New enl. ed. of Appleton's cyclopaedia of American biography, originally edited by James Grant Wilson and John Fiske. Rev (1918).
- 29.Timothy Dwight , Julian Hawthorne, The World's great classics (1899).
- 30.James E. Homans, The Cyclopaedia Of American Biography (1918).
- 31.Winifred Eva Howe , Henry Watson Kent, A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art: With a Chapter on the Early ... (1913).
- 32.Theron George Strong, Joseph H. Choate: New Englander, New Yorker, Lawyer, Ambassador (1917).
- 33.Herringshaw, Thomas William, 1858- ed, Herringshaw's encyclopedia of American biography of the nineteenth century. Accurate and succinct biographies of famous men and women ... of the United States . (1907).
- 34.Thomas B. Reed, Modern Eloquence Vol-X (1900).
- 35.Thomas B. Reed, Modern Eloquence Vol-x (1900).
- 36.William MacLeod, Corcoran Curator's Journal [transcription] (1883).
- 37.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola.
- 38.The New York Times 1883-11-17: Vol 33 Iss 10047 (1883).
- 39.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(p. 323); Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(p. 331).
- 40.1928, Joseph H. Choate (obituary notice), obituary of Choate; James Grant Wilson; John Fiske; Charles Dick (eds), 1918, Cyclopaedia of American Biography, Choate entry.
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.