Edited volume · 2018

The Adventure of the Illustrious Scholar: Papers Presented to Oscar White Muscarella

Elizabeth Simpson (ed.)

Brill

A Festschrift of 42 contributions on the archaeology and arts of the ancient Near East and Mediterranean, and on museum practice, collecting, repatriation and the antiquities trade.

Oscar White Muscarella is honoured in this Festschrift of 42 contributions, edited by Elizabeth Simpson. Its subjects range from the archaeology and arts of the ancient Near East and the Mediterranean to craft, materials, conservation, collecting, the antiquities trade, site plunder, forgeries and scholarly method. Simpson's preface explains the Sherlock Holmes theme that runs through it: Laurie Adams's essay opens the volume with Holmes and archaeological investigation, and Jeanette Greenfield's "Elementary" closes the contributions.

Site studies and object analyses sit beside discussion of museum practice, provenance and legal and ethical questions. Clemency Coggins's 1969 article on illicit traffic in Pre-Columbian antiquities is reprinted with a new introduction.

How it is organised

The front matter holds Simpson's biographical introduction to Muscarella, preceded by a list of his excavations and publications. Part 1, "There is Nothing like First-hand Evidence," contains chapters 1 to 7, and Parts 2 to 6 group the papers under regional, archaeological and materials headings. Muscarella's museum career, including an employment dispute, is treated at pp. 5–14.

Part 2, "Arts and Archaeology: Anatolia," has three papers, by Krysia Spirydowicz, Geoffrey and Françoise Summers, and Maya Vassileva (pp. 140–208).

Part 3, "Arts and Archaeology: Urartu," has papers by Altan Çilingiroğlu, Stephan Kroll, D.T. Potts, Veli Sevin and David Stronach (pp. 215–278).

Part 4, "Arts and Archaeology: The Near East," has papers by Pauline Albenda, Martha Sharp Joukowsky, Friedhelm Pedde, Christian Konrad Piller and Barbara A. Porter (pp. 279–405).

Part 5, "Arts and Archaeology: The Mediterranean World," has papers by Irit Ziffer with Edwin C.M. van den Brink, Orit Segal and Uzi Ad, and by Robert B. Koehl, Günter Kopcke, Mark J. Rose and Rachael Dealy Salisbury (pp. 406–526).

Part 6, "Arts-Craft-Materials-Techniques," runs from Özgen Acar on Kyme to Simpson on luxury arts of the ancient Near East (pp. 527–694).

Parts 7 and 8 follow (pp. 695–858). Part 7, "Issues and Methods," has nine contributions on antiquities, publication, collecting, repatriation, connoisseurship, teaching collections and ancient sources, and Part 8, "Leave No Stone Unturned," holds Greenfield's paper alone. A bibliography, an index and the authors' biographies close the volume.

The papers

Adams reads Muscarella's work through Sherlock Holmes, using detective reasoning to take up archaeological evidence, provenance, looting, forgery, chronology and publication (pp. 23–44). Her pages on provenance take in discussions of Ziwiye and the Oxus Treasure.

Several Part 1 chapters turn to Anatolia. Çınaroğlu, who directed the project, describes the reconstruction of six Early Bronze Age royal tombs at Alaca Höyük (pp. 67–73). Berndt examines the Midas story and its reception, Liebhart considers the labour, workforce and materials behind Tumulus MM at Gordon, and Mitten reports pithos burial EB 69.3 at Sardis, an Early Bronze Age intrusion whose finds are in the Manisa Archaeological and Ethnographic Museum. Roller takes up Phrygian identity in the Roman period through local identity, settlement and inscriptions, and defines the Neo-Phrygian phase.

Spirydowicz traces the discovery, study and conservation of the wooden fragments from Megaron 3 on the Gordon city mound, and Geoffrey and Françoise Summers write on monumental entrances, sculpture and idols at Kerkenes as aspects of Phrygian cult east of the Kizihrmak. Fibulae recur in three papers. Vassileva sets out a classification of the Gordion fibulae with their contexts and chronology, noting arched fibula parallels from Cyprus and other regions (pp. 188–208); Pedde treats fibulae in Neo-Assyrian burials; and Piller revisits Marlik chronology through fibulae, a seriation that defines Stages I to III.

Part 3 centres on Urartu and Iran. Çilingiroğlu publishes artifacts linked to Queen Qaqui and Mr. Tigursagga from a decorated quarter of Ayanis Fortress, and Kroll a fragment of a ram's head rhyton from Qalatgah. Potts places an inscribed bracelet from the Toul-e Gilan cemetery within the phases of Urartian expansion (pp. 230–255), Sevin considers Urartian burial rites at Altintepe and elsewhere, and Stronach offers architectural observations on Erebuni.

Albenda surveys Neo-Assyrian views of foreign cities, and Joukowsky treats the Petra Great Temple in its precinct, phases and architecture within Nabataean archaeology (pp. 304–350). Porter writes on a basalt stele from Hama, 6B 599, and Old Syrian cylinder seals. Ziffer and colleagues publish a Late Bronze Age human head-cup from the environs of Tel Qashish in the Jezreel Valley.

Koehl takes up memory, nostalgia and identity on Paros in the 12th century BCE, with the Mycenaean building complex at Koukounaries Hill as his subject. Kopcke contributes "Liturgy," and Rose reconsiders the bronze hunchback in the Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, Hamburg. Salisbury reassesses the balance weights from the Late Bronze Age Uluburun shipwreck, their find locations and the sets into which they may be arranged (pp. 484–513).

Part 6 begins with Acar on Kyme as a jewelry production centre, where the Izmir Archaeological Museum excavated the necropolis and the British Museum holds earlier acquisitions (p. 527). Zamir Dembin examines craft-referential pottery in ancient Greece, Gutierrez-Folch the early sources and diffusion of the neoclassical klismos chair, and Killen the furniture of the Ramesside pharaohs. Nelson studies Roman gold body chains, including the catenae from Oplontis, Rodriguez explains ivory identification through the Schreger pattern, and Simpson surveys luxury arts of the ancient Near East.

Kaye reviews the Lydian Hoard litigation and the US limitation rules that governed it (pp. 79–96). Atwood writes on the literature of loot, taking The Lie Became Great and its heirs as his starting point, and Bonfante on the publication of unprovenienced objects, with the unprovenanced Praenestine mirror as her example. Brodie looks back on the Illicit Antiquities Research Centre, Coggins's reprinted article addresses Pre-Columbian antiquities, and Field traces the history and continuing impact of the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, defining cultural affiliation as the Act uses it.

Janis discusses connoisseurship, with a visit to Hans Hofmann's studio. Root and Dixon write on a Kelsey Museum seal of unknown provenance, and Vitelli on bringing old teaching collections into the open. Von Dassow's "Figure and Ground" reads ancient Near Eastern sources, and Greenfield's "Elementary" ends the contributions.

What it records

  • Arched fibulae from Cyprus are cited by Vassileva as parallels for Gordion examples, alongside finds from several other regions.p. 201
  • 47 authors contributed papers to the Festschrift, Simpson states.p. XIV
  • By 1939, 13 Early Bronze Age royal tombs had been discovered at Alaca Höyük, according to Çınaroğlu.p. 69
  • The six reconstructed Alaca Höyük tombs are 80 cm to 1 m deep, 4–8 m long and 2–5 m wide.p. 72
  • Özgen Acar, an investigative journalist, is credited with reporting that helped establish that objects at the Metropolitan Museum came from the Uşak tombs.p. 83
  • Özgen Acar noticed similarities between the upper portion of the exhibited statue and the lower half excavated at Perge, Kaye reports.p. 93
  • The finds from pithos burial EB 69.3 are held in the Manisa Archaeological and Ethnographic Museum, Mitten states.p. 120
  • Roller discusses 114 known Neo-Phrygian texts.p. 128
  • The Destruction Level of the Gordion City Mound yielded 38 fibulae, mostly bronze, in Vassileva's count.p. 191
  • The Toul-e Gilan bracelet came from Grave 1, which its excavator describes as the burial of a wealthy family with an estimated seven individuals.p. 230
  • Excavations at Altintepe explored 46 tombs, among them chamber tombs, urn cremations and simple pit burials.p. 257
  • Piller's seriation for Marlik combines 109 find types with 30 tombs.p. 369
  • The Hama stele 6B 599 was found reused as a doorsill in the entrance area of Building III, Level E.p. 389
  • At Koukounaries Hill the building complex was built, inhabited and destroyed within one ceramic phase, which Koehl estimates may have lasted about 25 years.p. 434
  • The Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe in Hamburg acquired its bronze hunchback in 1949; the figure has no recorded context or findspot.p. 453
  • Rose argues that the Hamburg bronze hunchback more likely depicts a person with advanced tuberculosis than a fisherman or beggar.p. 460
  • The Uluburun shipwreck yielded 149 stone and metal balance weights, mainly sphendonoid and domed types.p. 486
  • Salisbury proposes that the Uluburun weights can provisionally be arranged into four international sets combining several standards.p. 509
  • The British Museum acquired the Kyme jewelry in three lots between 1876 and 1878, Acar reports.p. 527
  • The Izmir Archaeological Museum excavated 215 graves at Kyme in 2009, Acar reports.p. 529
  • Gold jewelry from the Kyme-Aliağa excavations is described as closely related in style and type to the British Museum collection attributed to Kyme.p. 529
  • The Oplontis catenae were found with skeleton 27 in Room 10 of Villa B.p. 622
  • Items from four tombs were plundered in the 1960s, and most were eventually acquired by the Metropolitan Museum, Simpson reports.p. 683
  • The Illicit Antiquities Research Centre closed in September 2007 after staff contracts expired, according to Brodie.p. 726
  • The Kelsey Museum accessioned seal KM 26830 in 1959 from Leroy Waterman's collection; its provenance is unknown.p. 807
  • BM 48508 entered the British Museum in 1772 from the collection of Sir William Hamilton; its caption gives no provenance.p. 808
  • Von Dassow notes that in each case the agreement was concluded under the king of Mittani, overlord of both parties, and infers from the treaty that the parties had been at war.p. 830

Where to read

  • Muscarella's museum career and employment disputepp. 5–14
  • Ziwiye and Oxus Treasure provenance discussionspp. 27–31
  • Lydian Hoard claim, litigation and limitation rulespp. 81–94
  • Reconstruction of six Alaca Höyük royal tombspp. 70–73
  • Tumulus MM construction, workforce and materialspp. 97–109
  • EB 69.3 pithos burial and findspp. 117–123
  • Gordion fibula classification, contexts and chronologypp. 188–208
  • Toul-e Gilan bracelet and Urartian expansion phasespp. 230–255
  • Petra Great Temple precinct, phases and architecturepp. 304–350
  • Koukounaries Hill construction, chronology and identitypp. 425–439
  • Uluburun balance weights, find locations and proposed setspp. 484–513

Contents

  • Oscar White Muscarella and Sherlock HolmesLaurie Adams23
  • The King with Donkey’s EarsSusanne Berndt49
  • The Reconstruction of the Early Bronze Age Royal Tombs at Alaca HöyükAykut Çınaroğlu67
  • The Lydian Hoard and Its Progeny: The Repatriation of Cultural PropertyLawrence M. Kaye79
  • Labors Lost and Found in Tumulus MM at GordonRichard F. Liebhart97
  • A Pithos Burial at Sardis: An Early Bronze Age IntrusionDavid Gordon Mitten117
  • Phrygian Identity in the Roman PeriodLynn E. Roller124
  • The City Mound at Gordon: The Discovery, Study, and Conservation of the Wooden Fragments from Megaron 3Krysia Spirydowicz140
  • Monumental Entrances, Sculpture, and Idols at Kerkenes: Aspects of Phrygian Cult East of the KizihrmakGeoffrey Summers, Françoise Summers160
  • Of Fibulae, Of Course!Maya Vassileva188
  • Artifacts Belonging to Queen Qaqui and Mr. Tigursagga from an Elaborately Decorated Quarter of the Ayanis FortressAltan Çilingiroğlu215
  • A Fragment of a Ram's Head Rhyton Found at Qalatgah, IranStephan Kroll225
  • Toul-E Gilan and the Urartian EmpireD.T. Potts230
  • Some Considerations on Urartian Burial RitesVeli Sevin257
  • Architectural and Other Observations Related to Erebuni in the Late Seventh/Early Sixth Centuries B.C.David Stronach266
  • Neo-Assyrian Views of Foreign Cities: A Brief SurveyPauline Albenda279
  • The Role of the Petra Great Temple in the Context of Nabataean ArchaeologyMartha Sharp Joukowsky304
  • Fibulae in Neo-Assyrian BurialsFriedhelm Pedde351
  • Fibulae, Chronology, and Related Considerations: Marlik ReloadedChristian Konrad Piller360
  • A Middle Bronze Stele from Hama and Old Syrian Cylinder SealsBarbara A. Porter388
  • A Unique Human Head-Cup from the Environs of Tel Qashish in the Jezreel Valley, IsraelIrit Ziffer, Edwin C.M. van den Brink, Orit Segal, Uzi Ad406
  • Back to the Future: Memory, Nostalgia, and Identity in the 12th Century B.C.E. on ParosRobert B. Koehl423
  • LiturgyGünter Kopcke444
  • What Did the Fisherman Catch?Mark J. Rose453
  • The Weight of Good Measure: A Reassessment of the Balance Weights from the Late Bronze Age Shipwreck at UluburunRachael Dealy Salisbury484
  • Kyme: An Ancient Center of Jewelry Production in Asia MinorÖzgen Acar527
  • Voicing the Past: The Implications of Craft-referential Pottery in Ancient GreeceEinav Zamir Dembin537
  • The Neoclassical Klismos Chair: Early Sources and Avenues of DiffusionAna Gutierrez-Folch564
  • The Furniture of the Ramesside PharaohsGeoffrey Killen599
  • Excavated Roman Jewelry: The Case of the Gold Body ChainsMeredith Nelson614
  • Ivory IdentificationAnibal Rodriguez645
  • Luxury Arts of the Ancient Near EastElizabeth Simpson662
  • The Literature of Loot: Notes on The Lie Became Great and Its HeirsRoger Atwood697
  • Oscar the Oracle: On the Publication of Unprovenienced ObjectsLarissa Bonfante708
  • The Illicit Antiquities Research Centre: Afterthoughts and AftermathsNeil Brodie719
  • Illicit Traffic of Pre-Columbian AntiquitiesClemency Chase Coggins734
  • The History and Continuing Impact of the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA)Emily Field747
  • Connoisseurship Conundrums and a Visit to Hans Hofmann's StudioCarroll Janis767
  • Blue from Babylon: Notes from the Curatorial TrenchesMargaret Cool Root, Helen Dixon780
  • “Outing” the Old Teaching CollectionsKaren D. Vitelli809
  • Figure and Ground: Reading Ancient Near Eastern SourcesEva von Dassow818
  • “Elementary”Jeanette Greenfield841
  • Bibliography865
  • Index979
  • Authors’ Biographies1017

Objects published here

12
  • Blue scaraboid, apparently of frit, obverse, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, unknown, KM 26830, KM 26830, Plate 39.1 (p. 807)
  • Green jasper scarab, obverse, British Museum, unknown, BM 48508, BM 48508, Plate 39.3 (p. 808)
  • Gold body chain with two hemispherical bosses, Villa B, Room 10, Museo Archeologico Nazionale, Naples, Villa B, Room 10, Oplontis, Plate 30.2 (p. 640)
  • Gold hippocampus brooch from the Lydian Hoard, Museum of Anatolian Civilizations, Ankara, Lydian Hoard, Plate 42.4 (p. 858)
  • Gold fan handle inscribed for Queen Qaqui, Ayanis Fortress, Area XI, Room 11, AY.50.08, Figure 11.1; Plates 11.5–11.6 (p. 216)
  • Copper alloy dagger from pithos burial EB 69.3, Manisa Archaeological and Ethnographic Museum, pithos burial EB 69.3, Eski Balkhane, 4340, Plate 6.5 (p. 123)
  • Silver ram pendant from pithos burial EB 69.3, Manisa Archaeological and Ethnographic Museum, pithos burial EB 69.3, Eski Balkhane, 167, Plate 6.6 (p. 123)
  • Pair of gold earplugs from pithos burial EB 69.3, Manisa Archaeological and Ethnographic Museum, pithos burial EB 69.3, Eski Balkhane, 168–169, Plate 6.7 (p. 123)
  • Grey spouted jug from pithos burial EB 69.3, Manisa Archaeological and Ethnographic Museum, pithos burial EB 69.3, Eski Balkhane, 7494, Plate 6.3 (p. 122)
  • Small redware tankard from pithos burial EB 69.3, Manisa Archaeological and Ethnographic Museum, pithos burial EB 69.3, Eski Balkhane, 7417, Plate 6.4 (p. 122)
  • Bronze hunchback, Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, Hamburg, 1949.40, Plate 24.1 (p. 479)
  • Bucolic zoomorphic balance weight with herdsman and calves, Uluburun shipwreck, Area 1, W 149, W 149, Plate 25.4 (p. 493)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Oscar White Muscarellahonoured by the volume; excavator and museum archaeologist
  • Özgen Acarwrote on Kyme jewelry; journalist in Lydian Hoard account
  • Elizabeth Simpsonedited the volume; wrote on luxury arts
  • Laurie Adamswrote on Muscarella and Sherlock Holmes
  • Aykut Çınaroğludirected the Alaca Höyük tomb reconstruction
  • Lawrence M. Kayewrote on the Lydian Hoard litigation
  • Krysia Spirydowiczwrote on Megaron 3 wooden fragments
  • Geoffrey Summersco-wrote on Kerkenes entrances and cult
  • Françoise Summersco-wrote on Kerkenes entrances and cult
  • Maya Vassilevawrote on Gordion fibulae
  • Altan Çilingiroğluwrote on finds from Ayanis
  • Stephan Krollwrote on the Qalatgah rhyton fragment
  • D.T. Pottswrote on Toul-e Gilan and Urartu
  • Veli Sevinwrote on Urartian burial rites
  • David Stronachwrote on Erebuni architecture
  • Pauline Albendawrote on Neo-Assyrian views of cities
  • Martha Sharp Joukowskywrote on the Petra Great Temple
  • Friedhelm Peddewrote on fibulae in Neo-Assyrian burials
  • Christian Konrad Pillerwrote on Marlik chronology
  • Barbara A. Porterwrote on the Hama stele and seals
  • Irit Zifferco-wrote on the Tel Qashish head-cup
  • Edwin C.M. van den Brinkco-wrote on the Tel Qashish head-cup
  • Orit Segalco-wrote on the Tel Qashish head-cup
  • Uzi Adco-wrote on the Tel Qashish head-cup
  • Robert B. Koehlwrote on memory and identity on Paros
  • Günter Kopckewrote "Liturgy"
  • Mark J. Rosewrote on the Hamburg bronze figure
  • Rachael Dealy Salisburywrote on Uluburun balance weights
  • Einav Zamir Dembinwrote on craft-referential pottery
  • Ana Gutierrez-Folchwrote on the neoclassical klismos chair
  • Geoffrey Killenwrote on Ramesside furniture
  • Meredith Nelsonwrote on Roman gold body chains
  • Anibal Rodriguezwrote on ivory identification
  • Roger Atwoodwrote on The Lie Became Great
  • Larissa Bonfantewrote on the unprovenanced Praenestine mirror
  • Neil Brodiewrote on the Illicit Antiquities Research Centre
  • Clemency Chase Cogginsauthor of the reprinted article on illicit antiquities
  • Emily Fieldwrote on NAGPRA
  • Carroll Janiswrote on connoisseurship and Hans Hofmann
  • Margaret Cool Rootco-wrote on the Kelsey Museum seal
  • Helen Dixonco-wrote on the Kelsey Museum seal
  • Karen D. Vitelliwrote on teaching collections
  • Eva von Dassowwrote on ancient Near Eastern sources
  • Jeanette Greenfieldwrote "Elementary"
  • Aykut Çınaroğludirected the Alaca Höyük tomb reconstruction
  • David Gordon Mittenwrote on the Sardis pithos burial
  • Lynn E. Rollerwrote on Phrygian identity in the Roman period
  • Richard F. Liebhartwrote on Tumulus MM construction and labour

Institutions

  • Metropolitan Museum of ArtMuscarella's employer; acquirer of Lydian Hoard items
  • Manisa Archaeological and Ethnographic Museumholds the EB 69.3 finds
  • British Museumacquired Kyme jewelry and other pieces
  • Illicit Antiquities Research Centreresearch centre examined by Brodie
  • Kelsey Museum of Archaeologyholds seal KM 26830
  • Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation ActUS repatriation law examined by Field
  • Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, Hamburgholds the bronze hunchback
  • Izmir Archaeological Museumexcavated the Kyme necropolis

Places

  • Gordionsite of several chapters and Muscarella's excavations
  • Alaca HöyükEarly Bronze Age royal tombs reconstructed
  • Sardissite of pithos burial EB 69.3
  • Uşakregion of the Lydian tombs
  • Phrygiasubject of a Roman-period identity study
  • Kerkenes Dağentrances, sculpture and cult installations
  • Qalatgahfindspot of an Urartian rhyton fragment
  • Ayanis FortressUrartian fortress with decorated quarter
  • Toul-e Gilancemetery yielding an inscribed bracelet
  • AltintepeUrartian cemetery and burial study
  • Erebunisubject of an architectural study
  • Petra Great TempleNabataean precinct and its excavation
  • Tepe Marlikcemetery and chronological study
  • Hamafindspot of basalt stele 6B 599
  • Tel Qashishfindspot of a Late Bronze Age head-cup
  • Parosisland containing Koukounaries Hill
  • Koukounaries HillMycenaean building complex and settlement
  • Uluburun shipwrecksource of the balance-weight assemblage
  • Kymejewelry production centre and excavation site
  • Royal Cemetery of UrEarly Dynastic royal tombs
  • NimrudAssyrian palace, tombs and ivories
  • Ziwiyeprovenance case study
  • Hasanluexcavation publication and material culture

Also named: Brill.

Extent xxvi + 1019 pp., 42 plates, numerous figures; bibliography pp. 865–977, index pp. 979–1007

Defines Neo-Phrygian, XII.7A, XII.7, Stage I, Stage IIa, Stage IIb, Stage III, sphendonoid, domed, klismos, Schreger pattern, figure and ground, Cultural affiliation

NeolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanLate AntiqueModernPotteryMetalworkCopperJewelryGlass and FaienceBurialTradeArchitectureSettlementsChronology and DatingForeign ContactsCollectingMuseumsHistory of ArchaeologyLooting and the LawCraft ProductionTechnology

Chapters in our registers

1 in our registers

Who did what

10 records

Buying, selling and giving 3

Recording and study 1

Posts and family 6

People it is cited for

1 person

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.