Edited volume · 2011

The New Chronology of Iron Age Gordion

C. Brian Rose and Gareth Darbyshire (eds.)

Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology

A collection of seven chapters and an introduction on the chronology of Iron Age Gordion, weighing archaeological, textual, tree-ring and radiocarbon evidence for the date of the Early Phrygian destruction.

Rose and Darbyshire edit a volume that revises the chronology of Iron Age Gordion, above all the date of the destruction of the Early Phrygian Citadel and of the timber tomb beneath Tumulus MM. Its contributors set the earlier scheme against stratigraphy, artefact sequences, literary and Assyrian texts, tree-ring measurements and radiocarbon determinations. The revision moves the destruction to around 800 BC from around 700 BC and dates the felling of the Tumulus MM timbers to about 740 BC. The chapters trace how the older chronology arose, test the evidence for changing it and consider what follows for the construction phases of the site, its tumuli and its regional connections.

How it is organised

An introduction by DeVries, with additions by Voigt, Rose and Darbyshire, outlines the chronological changes and their background. Seven chapters follow, moving from the making of the old chronology through the doubts that arose about it, then the textual, artefactual, tree-ring and radiocarbon evidence, to a concluding chapter by Sams and Voigt. A Turkish summary and an index end the book.

The papers

DeVries follows the development of the earlier dating of the Destruction Level, Tumulus MM, the Citadel rebuilding and the Lower Town fortifications (pp. 13–22). Voigt and DeVries then review what unsettled it: early radiocarbon results, changing readings of the tumuli, imported pottery, stratigraphic observations and regional survey, ending with the decision to obtain further radiocarbon dates.

Literary accounts of Midas, Assyrian evidence for Mita and the chronology of Kimmerian activity in Anatolia make up the textual case, which DeVries sets against the Destruction Level (pp. 49–58). Sams measures carved orthostates, metalwork, glass, ivory and pottery against the revised sequence of the Destruction Level and the tumulus burials.

Tree rings come from Tumulus MM, Kızlarkayası Tumulus A and buildings on the Citadel Mound, described by Kuniholm and Newton with contributions from Liebhart (pp. 79–122). Manning and Kromer present the radiocarbon dating programme, discuss potential offsets and evaluate the dates for the destruction.

Sams and Voigt draw the results together into the revised chronology, outline a sequence of Early Phrygian construction and discuss the tumuli and possible Kimmerian involvement (pp. 155–168).

What it records

  • The volume's revised chronology places the destruction of the Early Phrygian Citadel at Gordion around 800 BC rather than 700 BC, and the felling of the juniper logs of the Tumulus MM tomb around 740 BC.p. 7
  • The 1988–89 Lower Trench Sounding in the Outer Court at Gordion was set up to build a stratigraphic sequence giving a tighter chronological framework for the Citadel Mound material Young excavated, and to investigate historical questions.p. 29
  • Survey and excavation in the 1990s showed that Gordion reached its greatest size in Middle Phrygian rather than Early Phrygian times.p. 38
  • At the Malcolm and Carolyn Wiener Laboratory, Cornell University, Kuniholm processed 256 samples from the large beams of Terrace Building 2A, and the latest preserved ring dates to 850 BC.p. 43
  • The volume dates the Tumulus MM tomb and the objects placed in it to about 740 BC, on the evidence that the juniper logs of the tomb chamber were cut for its construction.p. 94
  • New Heidelberg radiocarbon results on 15 short-lived samples from the Destruction Level give a weighted-average calibrated range of 840–805 BC at 95% confidence.p. 137
  • No signs of violence are present in the Destruction Level at Gordion, no individuals have been found in it, and the cause of the fire is unknown.p. 162

Where to read

  • Development of the earlier destruction chronologypp. 13–22
  • Stratigraphic and regional evidence challenging the old chronologypp. 23–48
  • Midas, Assyrian texts and Kimmerian accountspp. 49–58
  • Artefact sequences, orthostates and Phrygian potterypp. 59–78
  • Tree-ring chronology and Tumulus MMpp. 79–122
  • Radiocarbon dates and the destruction datepp. 123–153
  • Revised sequence of Citadel construction and tumulipp. 155–168

Contents

  • IntroductionKeith DeVries, Mary M. Voigt, C. Brian Rose, Gareth Darbyshire1
  • The Creation of the Old ChronologyKeith DeVries13
  • Emerging Problems and DoubtsMary M. Voigt, Keith DeVries23
  • Textual Evidence and the Destruction LevelKeith DeVries49
  • ArtifactsG. Kenneth Sams59
  • Dendrochronology at GordionPeter Ian Kuniholm, Maryanne W. Newton, Richard F. Liebhart79
  • Radiocarbon Dating Iron Age Gordion, and the Early Phrygian Destruction in ParticularSturt W. Manning, Bernd Kromer123
  • In ConclusionG. Kenneth Sams, Mary M. Voigt155

Objects published here

6
  • Lion-headed situla with textile remains, Gordion, Tumulus MM, B-810, Fig. 1.2 (p. 16)
  • Ivory horse frontlet, Gordion, main room of Terrace Building 2, BI-432, Fig. 4.1 (p. 60)
  • Vitreous-glaze juglet found inside a trefoil-mouthed jug, Gordion, Terrace Building 4, inside a trefoil-mouthed jug, G-224, Fig. 4.2 (p. 61)
  • Bowl with a Phrygian inscription, Gordion, Megaron 10, below the building's final floor, I-336, Fig. 4.16 (p. 67)
  • Bronze handle attachment in the form of a flying griffin, Gordion, Megaron 3, Destruction Level, B-1332, Fig. 4.14 (p. 65)
  • Painted krater in the silhouette-animal style, Gordion, Terrace Building 8, Early Phrygian Destruction Level, P-3729, Fig. 4.25 (p. 73)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

Places

  • Gordionsubject of the chronology revision
  • Tumulus MMtimber tomb dated by tree rings
  • Kızlarkayası Tumulus Asource of timbers for the tree-ring sequence
  • Carchemishsource of stylistic parallels for orthostates
  • Zincirlisource of stylistic parallels for orthostates

Also named: Ekrem Akurgal.

Extent Figures 0.1–7.10, maps and plans; Turkish summary, pp. 169–172; index, pp. 175–181

Defines Yassihöyük Stratigraphic Sequence (YHSS), wiggle-matching

Early Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalModernChronology and DatingArchitecturePotteryForeign ContactsHistory of Archaeology

People it is cited for

1 person

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.