Article · 1966
Composition and provenance: a challenge
A. Millett and H. W. Catling
Archaeometry 9 92-97
A note on emission-spectrographic analyses of Mycenaean pottery from Cyprus, testing compositional identifications against 25 numbered fragments whose findspots were sealed in an envelope.
Millett and Catling return to their compositional study of painted Aegean Late Bronze Age pottery and answer criticism of its conclusions about Mycenaean pottery found in Cyprus. Karageorghis had questioned how the samples were selected and had argued that chemical analysis alone could not settle where Mycenaean pottery in the Levant came from. The authors answer with a challenge in which analysts worked from serial numbers while the findspots stayed sealed, to see whether composition could tell Cypriot from Aegean pottery.
Each fragment's emission-spectrographic analysis is compared with the composition ranges already established for Types A, B, L and M. Table I gives concentrations of nine elements with the mean and ranges for the 22 homogeneous samples, and sample 17 is set apart as a rogue (pp. 93, 95).
When the envelope was opened, the Cyprus finds among the fragments proved not to have been made on the island, and the authors conclude that the results accord with their earlier findings. They acknowledge that the challenge included no locally made Cypriot pottery, describe the two apparent Cretan imports as uncommon in Cyprus at this date, and state that a reappraisal of Type M is under way (p. 97).
What it records
- The earlier study analysed 20 pottery samples each from Hala Sultan Tekke, Arpera Chiflik and Enkomi.p. 92
- All 20 Hala Sultan Tekke samples were chosen because they matched a type that some authorities considered imported from Greece.p. 92
- The ten comparable samples from Enkomi and the ten from Arpera gave the same Type A result as the Hala Sultan Tekke samples.p. 92
- The challenge consisted of 25 Mycenaean pottery fragments identified only by serial numbers, with their findspots sealed.p. 93
- Samples 5 and 22 corresponded to Type B, which had previously been identified as prevalent in central Crete.p. 93
- Sample 17 matched none of the composition types already defined.p. 93
- The other 22 challenge samples corresponded to Type A, which the authors associate with many sites in the Peloponnese.p. 93
- Millett and Catling conclude that Karageorghis's selection consisted of pottery found in Cyprus but not made there, apart from the unclassifiable sample 17.p. 97
- Two fragments are identified as apparently made in Crete, and Cretan imports to Cyprus at this date are described as uncommon.p. 97
Where to read
- Earlier sample selection at Hala Sultan Tekke, Arpera and Enkomip. 92
- Challenge fragments and compositional analysispp. 93–95
- Challenge results and findspotsp. 97
Contents
- Analysis93
- Comment on the Analyses93
- Literature97
People, places and institutions
People
- Dr. Vassos Karageorghiscriticised the sampling and set the challenge
Places
- Hala Sultan Tekkesource of earlier pottery samples
- Arpera Chifliksource of earlier pottery samples
- Enkomisource of earlier pottery samples
- Peloponneseregion associated with Type A composition
- Cretesource attributed to the Type B fragments
Also named: Kition, Mycenae-Tiryns, Argolis, Research Laboratory, Ashmolean Museum.
Extent pp. 92–97, pl. I, fig. 1a–e
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
2 pagesWho did what
1 recordRecording and study 1
- p. 93
A. MillettStudied
A. Millett was to analyse and evaluate the pottery fragments before the find-spots were revealed.
Twenty-five fragments of Mycenaean potteryNo. Serial numbers 1 to 25
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.