Article · 1993
Prestige, distinction, and competition: the anatomy of socioeconomic complexity in fourth to second millennium B.C.E. Cyprus
Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 292 35-58
An article on the emergence of social complexity in Cyprus from the fourth to the second millennium BCE, centred on the Chalcolithic to Early Bronze Age change and on prestige goods and elite competition.
Manning examines how social complexity emerged in prehistoric Cyprus, concentrating on the change from the Chalcolithic to the Early Bronze Age. He reviews chronology and settlement, the scale of social organisation, subsistence, the secondary products revolution and the symbols of value and power, then develops an explanation resting on competition within the island and contact beyond it.
The evidence includes settlement distributions and estimated populations, radiocarbon dates from Sotira Kaminoudhia, tomb assemblages, metalwork, pottery, imported goods and iconography. Manning weighs the limits of survey data, uncertain contexts and the scarcity of secure sequences spanning the Late Chalcolithic and Early Cypriot periods. His phases are the Late Chalcolithic, the Philia culture, Early Cypriot and Middle Cypriot, with Philia overlapping the end of the Late Chalcolithic and possibly the earlier Early Cypriot; he stresses that the transition is poorly documented and that the relationship between Philia and Early Cypriot assemblages is uncertain. He reads the Vounous Tomb 22 model as a seated male with authority within a group and a ritual scene.
Manning challenges explanations that treat foreign demand or technological change as the first cause of Cypriot complexity. He describes social development as episodic, with periods of larger settlements followed by collapse or reorientation, and argues that emergent elites in the northwest used contact with southern Anatolia and the wider eastern Mediterranean to compete for prestige. That competition, in his account, encouraged surplus production, plow agriculture and new forms of power. He proposes that a northwest core adopted foreign goods and practices, expanded prestige exchange and surplus production, and passed new fashions and economic arrangements on to other parts of the island (pp. 46–49).
What it records
- Sotira Kaminoudhia places Late Chalcolithic sherds, transitional architecture, Philia culture tombs and an Early Cypriot settlement in close spatial association, Manning reports.p. 37
- Manning notes that later studies found no diagnostic Philia culture material in the tombs at Bellapais Vounous.p. 38
- Manning states that no site unequivocally offers a stratigraphic sequence from the Late Chalcolithic to the Early Cypriot.p. 39
- Manning argues that access to foreign prestige goods and fashions gave the emergent elite of northern Cyprus a strong incentive to invest in long-distance trade.p. 47
- Manning concludes that the northwest became the core from which prestige goods and secondary products economies spread across Cyprus.p. 49
- At Lapithos Vrysi tou Barba, 34 of 97 excavated burial chambers had no metal finds, while nine held 446 of the cemetery's 701 copper and bronze artifacts.p. 51
Where to read
- Philia culture and Early Cypriot chronologypp. 36–39
- Settlement size, population estimates and social organisationpp. 40–44
- Prestige goods, trade and the secondary products revolutionpp. 44–49
Contents
- Introduction35
- Chronology and Settlement36
- Magnitude of the Social Dimension41
- Subsistence and Circumscription43
- The Secondary Products Revolution and Social Context44
- Value and Symbols: the Chalcolithic/bronze Age Divide44
- Metal Artifacts44
- Foreign Influences45
- Collective Burials45
- New Vessel Forms45
- Secular Holders of Power45
- The Dead Speak: Prestige, the Plow, Wealth, and Hierarchy48
- Conclusions49
- Acknowledgments49
- Notes49
- Bibliography52
People, places and institutions
People
- Dikaiosargued for Philia and Early Cypriot overlap
- Stewartargued for overlap at Vounous
- Peltenburgdiscussed settlement and social evidence
- Knappdiscussed models of social development
- Swinydiscussed settlement and chronology evidence
- Herscherexcavated and published Lapithos evidence
- Hennessyco-authored the Ayia Paraskevi report
- Erikssonco-authored the Ayia Paraskevi report
- Kehrbergco-authored the Ayia Paraskevi report
- Graham Philipdiscussed metal artifacts and chronology
Places
- Bellapais Vounouscemetery discussed for Philia material
- Sotira Kaminoudhiasite with transitional evidence
- Kissonerga MosphiliaChalcolithic settlement
- Nicosia Ayia Paraskevicemetery with Philia and Early Cypriot tombs
- Dhenia Kafkallacemetery with Philia and Early Cypriot tombs
- Marki Tavaricemetery with Philia and Early Cypriot tombs
- Lapithos Vrysi tou Barbacemetery compared with Philia sites
- Lembasettlement with population estimates
- ErimiChalcolithic settlement
- Alambra MouttesMiddle Cypriot settlement
Extent pp. 35–58, 4 figures
ChalcolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeChronology and DatingSettlementsTradeKingship and PoliticsBurial
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
3 pagesMentioned in
10 mentionsTomb records · 7
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 105
Discussion · 1993 · p. 49
[Stewart and Stewart 1950: Tombs 96, 105, 107, 111, 161, 164A]
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 107
Discussion · 1993 · p. 49
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 111
Discussion · 1993 · p. 49
ox bones in several of the select tombs with metal objects at Vounous Cemetery A for example [Stewart and Stewart 1950: Tombs 96, 105, 107, 111, 161, 164A]
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 114
Discussion · 1993 · p. 44
pottery imitations of those metal types occur (e.g., Tomb 114 at Vounous Cemetery A [Stewart and Stewart 1950: 152–55])
- Bellapais-Vounous, BSA Tomb 96
Discussion · 1993 · p. 49
ox bones in several of the select tombs with metal objects at Vounous Cemetery A for example [Stewart and Stewart 1950: Tombs 96
- Bellapais-Vounous, Dikaios Tomb 22
Discussion · 1993 · p. 45
- On Ancient Cyprus · 3listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.