Book · 2002

Mysteries of the Snake Goddess: Art, Desire and the Forging of History

K. Lapatin

Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin

A study of the Boston Snake Goddess and the making of Minoan history, tracing the statuette's uncertain origins and the part played by excavation, restoration, forgery and museum collecting.

Lapatin's study centres on the Boston Snake Goddess, a gold-and-ivory statuette that reached the Museum of Fine Arts in 1914. He follows it through the competing accounts of its origin, its association with Arthur Evans's excavations at Knossos and the later debate over its authenticity, and sets it beside excavated Minoan objects and other unprovenienced figures. Interpretation, restoration, collecting and the art market are the forces he traces in modern pictures of Minoan society and religion, and the discussion extends to Evans's reconstruction of the Palace of Minos and the work of the Gilliérons.

How it is organised

A prologue introduces Seager's letters about the Lady. Eight chapters then move from the Boston statuette and the Palace of Minos to Minoan religion, the ivory Boy-Gods and bull-leaper figures, Evans and the Gilliérons, the Goddess's road to Boston, the group of putative Minoan statuettes, and scientific testing. Three appendices give a cast of characters, a list of unprovenienced statuettes and Richard Newman's analytical report. Notes, bibliography, acknowledgments, illustration credits and an index follow.

The argument

Lapatin argues that documentary evidence alone cannot settle the Goddess's authenticity, because its archaeological context is uncertain and its route to Boston disputed. He reconstructs its 1914 passage through Seager, Bert Hodge Hill and the Museum of Fine Arts from letters and datebooks, and keeps that record apart from later shipboard stories. The claim, advanced by Evans and repeated by others, that the statuette came from the Knossos Ivory Deposit rests on an unrecorded findspot rather than an excavated context (pp. 140–152).

Reconstructions of Minoan religion and culture, in his wider case, were shaped by the interests and assumptions of their modern makers. He examines Evans's Mother Goddess interpretation, contemporary ideas about matriarchy and cultural evolution, and the parallels drawn between Minoan and modern art, dress and social life. Unprovenienced statuettes and restored images, he argues, could reinforce one another as evidence, above all where their subjects matched expectations Evans had already promoted (pp. 30–90).

Lapatin concludes that Evans's work at Knossos passed from conservation into substantial rebuilding, and that the Gilliérons' restorations and replicas gave fragmentary finds a more complete appearance. He describes the result as a modern vision of the past that shaped how visitors and readers imagined Minoan life (pp. 120–139).

For the Goddess itself he concludes that it cannot be established as an excavated Minoan object and should not serve as evidence for Aegean Bronze Age art, religion or culture. History, style, imagery, construction and scientific analysis taken together point, in his view, towards a modern work, though he states that absolute proof remains elusive. He treats the statuette as evidence for modern interpretations of the Minoan past and for the influence of restoration and collecting on its reception (pp. 176–188).

The evidence

Lapatin sets descriptions of the statuettes beside museum correspondence, excavation records, private letters, diaries, memoirs, published accounts and photographs of objects before and after restoration. The record includes Evans's Knossos daybooks, Seager and Hill's 1914 correspondence, the Museum of Fine Arts files and the accounts of dealers and collectors. Unprovenienced pieces are compared with excavated ivories and faience figures from Knossos and with the composite ivory youth from Palaikastro (pp. 21–29).

The final chapter assesses style, iconography, construction and materials, comparing the Goddess's facial features, gold ornament and joins with those of excavated figures. Newman's appendix describes the statuette's restoration history and reports tests on loose ivory fragments and gold attachments, with a discussion of the limits of both radiocarbon dating and alloy comparison (Appendix 3, pp. 196–204).

Dating

Lapatin describes Evans's scheme of Early, Middle and Late Minoan periods, with tripartite subdivisions such as Middle Minoan IIIB, and gives the Temple Repositories and their statuettes as Middle Minoan III material in Evans's discussion. He reports the standard dating of the later Knossos tablets to c. 1450–1350 BC and separates the Minoan material from the Mycenaean phase that follows at Knossos (pp. 50–51).

What it records

  • Evans inherited Gregori, a former tomb robber from Cyprus, from David Hogarth in 1902, Lapatin reports.p. 170
  • The Boston Goddess stands 16.1 centimetres tall and was given to the Museum of Fine Arts by Mrs. W. Scott Fitz.p. 5
  • Henrietta G. Fitz paid $950 for the Cretan statuette in 1914.p. 12
  • The Boston Goddess has no established archaeological provenience, Lapatin argues.p. 16
  • Duncan Mackenzie's Knossos daybooks, kept as Evans's assistant, contain no record of disturbed earth in the area associated with the ivory leapers.p. 22
  • Thomas B. Sandwith arranged for a Knossian pithos excavated by Minos Kalokairinos to be sent to the British Museum.p. 40
  • Thomas B. Sandwith reported that a factory in Candia produced false antiquities, and distinguished its clay from the figurines supplied by his excavator.p. 43
  • Arthur Evans's Knossos excavations began on 23 March 1900.p. 45
  • Evans employed as many as three hundred workmen at Knossos at one time.p. 45
  • Evans's system divides Minoan chronology into Early, Middle and Late Minoan periods with tripartite subdivisions.p. 50
  • David G. Hogarth reported that a bull relief from the Palace at Knossos was hardly inferior to Myron's work.p. 59
  • Evans excavated the Knossos faience statuettes in two stone-lined pits in 1903.p. 60
  • The Temple Repositories at Knossos contained fragments of at least five faience statuettes.p. 61
  • Richard Seager transported the Boston Goddess to the United States in June 1914, on Lapatin's reconstruction from correspondence and datebooks.p. 143
  • Bert Hodge Hill took the statuette by train from New York to Boston on 25 June 1914.p. 143
  • The combined evidence suggests that the Boston Goddess is a modern work, though absolute proof is elusive, Lapatin concludes.p. 187
  • Radiocarbon tests of associated ivory fragments gave calibrated dates between 1420 and 1535 or between 1545 and 1635, Newman reports.p. 200
  • The scientific tests did not establish the authenticity of the Boston Goddess, Newman concludes.p. 203

Where to read

  • Acquisition of the Goddess, Seager's letters and Hill's 1914 trip to Bostonpp. 140–152
  • Knossos excavations, the Ivory Deposit and the Temple Repositoriespp. 45–64
  • Evans’s Mother Goddess interpretation and its intellectual backgroundpp. 66–90
  • The Walters, Seattle, Fitzwilliam and Toronto statuettespp. 92–119
  • Knossos restoration and Gilliéron replicaspp. 120–139
  • Cretan statuettes and the evidence for forgerypp. 153–175
  • Style, construction and scientific testing of the Boston Goddesspp. 176–204
  • List of unprovenienced statuettes with museum and inventory detailspp. 194–195

Contents

  • Prologue1
  • The Boston Goddess4
  • The Palace of Minos30
  • The Divine Mother66
  • Boy-Gods, Bull Leapers, and Corseted Goddesses91
  • Evans and the Gilliérons: Making and Marketing the Past120
  • The Road to Boston140
  • Snake Goddesses, Fake Goddesses?153
  • The Uncertainties of Science176
  • Appendix 1: The Cast of Characters191
  • Appendix 2: Some Unprovenienced Cretan Statuettes194
  • Appendix 3: Analytical Report on the Ivory Snake GoddessRichard Newman196
  • Notes205
  • Bibliography227

Objects published here

8
  • Boston Snake Goddess, gold and ivory statuette, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, Said to be from the Ivory Deposit in the Palace of Minos at Knossos, 14.863, Frontispiece; Figs. 1.1, 1.11, 1.12, 8.3 (p. 194)
  • Baltimore Snake Goddess, gold and ivory, Walters Art Gallery, Baltimore, Said to be from the Palace of Minos at Knossos, 71.1090, Figs. 4.2, 4.3, 4.4 (p. 194)
  • Ivory Goddess known as the Chess Queen, Walters Art Gallery, Baltimore, Said to be from the Palace of Minos at Knossos, 71.1091, Fig. 4.5 (p. 194)
  • Seattle Boy-God, ivory, Seattle Art Museum, Said to be from the Ivory Deposit in the Palace of Minos at Knossos, 57.56, Figs. 4.6, 4.7, 4.8, 4.9 (p. 194)
  • Oxford Boy-God, ivory, Ashmolean Museum, Said to be from southern Crete, 1938.692, Figs. 4.13, 7.11 (p. 194)
  • Ivory figure known as Our Lady of the Sports, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Believed to come from Knossos, 931.21.1, Fig. 4.14 (p. 194)
  • Fitzwilliam Goddess, stone statuette, Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge, Said to be from the harbor town of Knossos, GR 1.1926, Fig. 4.12 (p. 195)
  • Tylissos Goddess, stone statuette, Ashmolean Museum, Said to be from Tylissos, 1938.693, Fig. 7.8 (p. 195)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Arthur Evansexcavated and reconstructed Knossos
  • Richard Berry Seagerarchaeologist who carried the Goddess to Boston
  • Thomas B. SandwithBritish consul who collected Cretan antiquities
  • Émile Gilliéron pèreartist and restorer at Knossos
  • Émile Gilliéron filsartist who restored and reproduced Minoan finds
  • Lacey Caskeycurator who published the Boston Goddess
  • Arthur Fairbanksdirector of the Museum of Fine Arts
  • Henrietta G. Fitzfunded the purchase of the Boston Goddess
  • Bert Hodge Hillcarried the statuette to the Boston museum
  • Minos Kalokairinosfirst excavator of Knossos
  • Duncan MackenzieEvans's assistant at Knossos
  • Georg Karoarchaeologist who recalled Gilliéron's offer
  • Ernest A. Gardnercritic of the Goddess's style and authenticity
  • Harriet Boyd Hawesarchaeologist who excavated in Crete
  • Halvor Baggerestored the Knossos faience statuettes
  • Richard Newmanauthor of the analytical report in Appendix 3
  • Minosmythical king of Crete
  • Jane Harrisonclassicist writing on Greek religion
  • Sir James George Frazerclassicist whose theories Evans used
  • Johann Jakob Bachofentheorist of matriarchy
  • Stephanos Xanthoudidesarchaeologist who identified a statuette as fake
  • Sir Leonard Woolleyreported a Cretan forgers' workshop
  • Doro Levireported on the production of Cretan statuettes
  • William J. Youngrestored the Boston Goddess
  • Ron Phillipstraced Seager's letters about the Goddess

Institutions

Places

  • Knossossite of Evans's excavations and restorations
  • Palaikastrofindspot of an excavated ivory youth
  • Candiacity of the Cretan antiquities trade

Also named: David G. Hogarth, David Pickman, Diodoros of Sicily, British Museum, Mochlos, Pseira, Gournia, Tylissos.

Extent Numbered figures 1.1–8.6 and a frontispiece; plan of the Palace of Minos (Fig. 2.5) and of the Throne Room (Fig. 2.11); bibliography pp. 227–247; index pp. 256–274

Middle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeModernSculptureReligion and CultCollectingMuseumsHistory of Archaeology

Who did what

2 records

Posts and family 2

People it is cited for

2 people

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.