Article · 1983

The Antiquities Market

Ellen Herscher

Journal of Field Archaeology 10(3) 349-369

A regular journal feature on the antiquities market, covering U.S. cultural-property law, a disputed gift of Cypriot pottery to the University of Virginia, and reports on trafficking and recoveries.

Herscher's feature combines news, commentary and reports on the illicit antiquities trade. It prints Title III of Public Law 97-446, the U.S. act implementing the Convention on Cultural Property, with section-by-section comment on definitions, import restrictions, forfeiture, exemptions and the Cultural Property Advisory Committee, and traces U.S. implementation of the UNESCO Convention from Senate consent to ratification in 1972 to the signing of the law on 12 January 1983.

The University of Virginia case, which Herscher presents as a test of the legal and ethical claims surrounding antiquities from the occupied north of Cyprus, draws on the donation of October 1982 and on Karageorghis's examination of the pottery in January 1983, with correspondence and a faculty inquiry. She contrasts the committee's recommendation to return the pottery with the president's decision to return only two pieces, and discusses the limits of U.S. law and the UNESCO Convention in the case (pp. 362–363).

An interview with Karageorghis, held on 26 January 1983, covers export permits, museum security, markets and recovery work. Other reports describe an exhibition of objects returned to Peru, the recovery of an Ecuadorian collection, a regional meeting on archaeological cultural patrimony and a Syracuse symposium on jurisdiction and cultural-property controls.

What it records

  • Public Law 97-446, including Title III implementing the Convention on Cultural Property, was approved on 12 January 1983.p. 358
  • The United States ratified the 1970 UNESCO Convention on Cultural Property and was described as its 51st ratifying country.p. 361
  • In October 1982 the University of Virginia's Bayly Museum in Charlottesville accepted a donation of 20 pieces of ancient Cypriot pottery from the northern Cypriot administration.p. 362
  • Two pieces in the donation retained the numbers of the Harvard University-Museum of Fine Arts expedition to Toumba tou Skourou, where 240 objects had been reported missing.p. 362
  • A faculty committee headed by Malcolm Bell recommended that the pottery be returned to the Republic of Cyprus.p. 363
  • President Frank L. Hereford, Jr., decided that 18 pieces would be returned to the donors, and the two pieces from Toumba tou Skourou were sent to the Cypriot Embassy in Washington.p. 363
  • The Hadjiprodromou Collection of Famagusta has been completely dispersed, Karageorghis said, and only 40 or 50 of its approximately 2,000 items had been recovered.p. 364
  • Objects legally acquired and registered by 31 December 1973 and not needed by the Cyprus Museum can be exported with a Department of Antiquities permit, Karageorghis said.p. 364
  • The Ecuadorian government received approximately 800 objects on 30 November 1982 after U.S. Customs confiscated the collection.p. 366

Where to read

  • U.S. implementation of the UNESCO Convention and section-by-section commentarypp. 350–360
  • University of Virginia pottery donation and Karageorghis interviewpp. 362–365
  • Recoveries and reports on antiquities trafficking in Peru and Ecuadorpp. 365–367

Contents

  • Editorial349
  • Market Alert350
  • Theft from University of Minnesota350
  • The United States Implements the UNESCO Convention350
  • Public Law 97-446: Title III, Implementation of Convention on Cultural Property351
  • Commentary358
  • The Post-UNESCO Era Begins360
  • Formation of the U.S. Cultural Property Advisory Committee360
  • Consultation Held in Paris361
  • University of Virginia Accepts Disputed Antiquities362
  • Interview with Dr. Vassos Karageorghis, Director of Antiquities, Republic of Cyprus363
  • Exhibition on Looting365
  • Ecuadorian Antiquities Returned366
  • Latin American Conference on Crimes against Archaeological Cultural Patrimony367
  • Symposium at Syracuse University367
  • Recent Publications369

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

  • University of Virginiaaccepted a donation of Cypriot pottery
  • Bayly Museumaccepted the pottery donation
  • Department of Antiquitiesadministered export permits and sales
  • Cyprus Museumcustodian of antiquities in Cyprus
  • Turkish Federated State of Cyprusgave the pottery to the Bayly Museum
  • Harvard University-Museum of Fine Artsled the Toumba tou Skourou expedition
  • Hadjiprodromou Collectioncollection reported dispersed
  • UNESCO1970 Convention on cultural property

Places

  • Republic of Cyprusclaimed the pottery and sought its return
  • Toumba tou Skourouexcavation storerooms reported missing objects

Also named: Kenan Atakol, Norman J. Knorr, Vamik D. Volkan, Andrew J. Jacovides, Emily Vermeule, Famagusta, University of Minnesota, University of Virginia Medical School.

Extent pp. 349–369, 3 figures

Defines archaeological or ethnological material, cultural property

ModernEarly Bronze AgeLooting and the LawTradeMuseumsCollecting

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

3 pages

Excavations it is cited for

1 project

Who did what

5 records

Buying, selling and giving 2

  • Frank L. Hereford, Jr.Received fromTurkish Federated State of Cyprus

    Frank L. Hereford, Jr. accepted a donation of 20 pieces of ancient Cypriot pottery from the northern Cypriot administration on behalf of the university.

    Charlottesville

    1982 · p. 362
  • Frank L. Hereford, Jr.Connected withTurkish Federated State of Cyprus

    Frank L. Hereford, Jr. announced that 18 pieces would be returned to the donors.

    18 pieces of ancient Cypriot pottery

    1983 · p. 363

Excavation 1

Recording and study 1

  • Vassos KarageorghisStudied

    Vassos Karageorghis traveled to Charlottesville to examine the donated pottery.

    20 pieces of ancient Cypriot pottery

    1983 · p. 362

Posts and family 1

  • Vassos KarageorghisEmployed byMusée de Chypre

    Vassos Karageorghis held the position of Curator of the Cyprus Museum in Nicosia from 1952 until his appointment as Director of Antiquities in 1963.

    1948–1963 · p. 363

People it is cited for

1 person

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.