Article · 2003
The Location of Alashiya: New Evidence from Petrographic Investigation of Alashiyan Tablets from El-Amarna and Ugarit
Y. Goren, S. Bunimovitz, I. Finkelstein and N. Na'aman
American Journal of Archaeology 107(2) 233-255
An article on the clay of the Alashiya letters from Amarna and Ugarit, using petrography and chemical analysis to place their origin in Cyprus and to locate the political centre of Alashiya.
Goren and colleagues trace the clay of the Alashiya letters to ask where the Late Bronze Age political centre of Alashiya stood. They examine four Amarna letters, EA 33, 34, 37 and 38, and the Ugarit letter RS L.1, and compare them with Cypro-Minoan documents from Enkomi and Kalavasos Ayios Dhimitrios, geological data and sampled Cypriot clays. Petrography is the main method, supplemented by ICP-AES/MS elemental analysis and micropaleontological examination of the clay's age and possible geological origin.
Against proposals for Cilicia or northwest Syria, the authors argue that the fabrics of the letters indicate Cyprus. EA 37 is associated with the Moni Mélange, EA 33, 34 and 38 with Pakhna marls, and RS L.1 has a different, dolerite-derived fabric. The combination of clay sources may point to a single inland centre on the southeastern margins of the Troodos Mountains. The candidate centres are Kalavasos Ayios Dhimitrios and Alassa Paliotaverna/Pano Mandilaris, and the authors favour Alassa, while Bunimovitz leaves the precise identification open (pp. 240–250).
Three options for Late Bronze Age Cypriot political organisation are set out: a long-lived central authority, a centre whose location changed, and a federation of competing polities. The choice among them is left unresolved. The Amarna correspondence is read in the context of the 14th century BCE and the Ugarit letter as later evidence, and the account of political organisation spans the 16th–13th centuries BCE, relating changes in settlement and authority to Late Cypriot IIC, the 13th century BCE (pp. 251–252).
What it records
- Cyprus is the source of EA 37 and RS L.1 and, by extension, of the other Alashiya tablets, in the authors' argument.p. 242
- EA 37 is associated with the Moni Mélange clay of the southeastern Troodos foothills.p. 243
- EA 33 and EA 34 were most closely related to sample CY-10, collected above Alassa Paliotaverna.p. 245
- The chemical composition of Pakhna marl across southern Cyprus prevents a precise provenance for EA 33 and EA 34, the authors report.p. 245
- The Enkomi documents examined have a homogeneous composition across a period of about 300 years.p. 249
- Kalavasos Ayios Dhimitrios and Alassa are the strongest candidate sites within the area of the relevant clay sources, in the authors' view.p. 249
- Kalavasos Ayios Dhimitrios is described as an administrative centre near the Kalavasos copper mines.p. 250
- Alassa Paliotaverna/Pano Mandilaris had evidence of metallurgical activity and ashlar architecture.p. 250
Where to read
- Petrographic and chemical evidence for the letters’ Cypriot clay sourcespp. 242–245
- Candidate political centres at Kalavasos Ayios Dhimitrios and Alassapp. 249–251
- Alternative models of Late Bronze Age Cypriot political organisationpp. 251–252
Contents
- Methods234
- Results235
- The Alashiya Letters from Amarna235
- Comparative Study of Cypro-Minoan Texts from Enkomi and Kalavasos Ayios Dhimitrios236
- An Alashiya Letter from Ugarit (RS L.1; AO 21087)238
- The Origin of the Alashiya Letters240
- Petrography and the Cilician and North Syrian Theories for the Location of Alashiya240
- The Origin of the Alashiya Letters Within Cyprus242
- Chemical Analyses of the Alashiya Letters and Selected Cypriot Clays244
- Discussion245
- The Government of Cyprus in the Late Bronze Age: An Overview of Current Opinions245
- The Political Center of Alashiya during the 14th–13th Centuries B.C. according to the Analytical Results248
- Conclusions: The Origin of the Alashiya Tablets250
- Sociopolitical Organization of LBA Cyprus251
Objects published here
3- Alashiya letter from Amarna, distinguished by reddish-brown fabric and large inclusions, Amarna, EA 37, figs. 2–3 (p. 235)
- Alashiya letter from Amarna, British Museum, Amarna, EA 34, fig. 4 (p. 236)
- Alashiya letter from Ugarit, Ugarit, AO 21087, RS L.1, fig. 5 (p. 238)
People, places and institutions
Places
- Alashiyakingdom and territory discussed
- Amarnafindspot of Alashiya letters
- Ugaritfindspot of RS L.1
- Enkomisource of comparative documents
- Kalavasos Ayios Dhimitrioscomparative documents and candidate centre
- Alassa Paliotaverna/Pano Mandilariscandidate political centre
- Troodos Mountainsgeological source area
- Carchemishalternative proposed origin for RS L.1
- Ciliciaalternative proposed location of Alashiya
- Northwest Syriaalternative proposed location of Alashiya
- Kouklia Paleopaphossource of comparative clay samples
Also named: V. Karageorghis, Singer, Yamada, Eshuwara, Kushme shusha.
Extent pp. 233–255, 6 figs, 1 map; bibliography
Defines scattered petrographic analysis (SPA)
Late Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeCopperTradeWritingChronology and DatingKingship and Politics
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
6 pages- The Search for Alashiya: Tracing the Lost Kingdom of CyprusArticle
- Copper Metallurgy in Ancient CyprusCompendium
- EgyptCompendium
- Ugarit and the LevantCompendium
- AlassaSite
- EnkomiSite
Who did what
4 recordsRecording and study 4
- p. 234
Israel FinkelsteinStudied
Examined four Amarna Alashiya letters and one Ugarit letter in a petrographic investigation.
Four Alashiya letters from Amarna and one from UgaritNo. EA 33, EA 34, EA 37, EA 38; RS L.1
- p. 234
Nadav Na'amanStudied
Examined four Amarna Alashiya letters and one Ugarit letter in a petrographic investigation.
Four Alashiya letters from Amarna and one from UgaritNo. EA 33, EA 34, EA 37, EA 38; RS L.1
- p. 234
Shlomo BunimovitzStudied
Examined four Amarna Alashiya letters and one Ugarit letter in a petrographic investigation.
Four Alashiya letters from Amarna and one from UgaritNo. EA 33, EA 34, EA 37, EA 38; RS L.1
- p. 234
Yuval GorenStudied
Examined four Amarna Alashiya letters and one Ugarit letter in a petrographic investigation.
Four Alashiya letters from Amarna and one from UgaritNo. EA 33, EA 34, EA 37, EA 38; RS L.1
People it is cited for
4 people- Nadav Na'aman4 citations
- Yuval Goren3 citations
- Shlomo Bunimovitz2 citations
- Israel Finkelstein
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.