Chapter · 2007
Contexts in the discovery of White Slip I and the Thera controversy
A chapter on White Slip I rim styles and their contexts in Cyprus, Canaan, Egypt and the Aegean, used to assess Late Cypriot I chronology and the date of the Thera eruption.
White Slip I (WS I) is sorted by rim decoration into five groups, Rope Lattice, Ladder Band, Double Line Framed, Parallel Line and Undecorated, and followed through its contexts in Cyprus, Canaan, Egypt and the Aegean. Three questions run through the survey: when WS I first appears, how its styles relate to the phases of Late Cypriot I, and what the contexts imply for the date of the Thera eruption. Eriksson rejects "early-style WS I" and "Thera style" as names for the Rope Lattice group, because the first implies a chronology and the second gives undue prominence to a lost vessel.
The evidence
Published tomb groups and stratified deposits supply the comparisons, with White Slip motifs read alongside the associated pottery and imported objects. At Toumba tou Skourou the survey takes Tomb VI, Tomb I Chambers 1–3, Tomb II Chambers 1 and 3, and Tomb IV, and stresses that reuse and disturbance limit what some of these groups can show about date (pp. 88–91).
At Palaepaphos Teratsoudhia, Tombs 104 and 105 and the wells yield Rope Lattice, Framed Lozenge and Framed Cross-hatching forms, which Eriksson sets beside material from Ayia Irini, Enkomi and Episkopi Bamboula. Ayia Irini offers a sequence of six strata from Proto White Slip through the later WS I styles, though its tomb held multiple interments and mixed material (pp. 91–101).
Outside Cyprus the evidence comes from Tell el-Ajjul, Tell el-Dab'a and 'Ezbet Helmi, with further material from Phylakopi, Thera and Knossos. Petrie's excavation record at Tell el-Ajjul is set against the stratified evidence from Tell el-Dab'a, and pumice and Aegean pottery are brought into the chronology (pp. 99–106).
The argument
Eriksson argues that the Cypriot evidence does not establish a long delay between Rope Lattice and the other WS I motifs. He disputes Manning's "intra-island barrier" explanation for the differences between Cypriot pottery assemblages abroad, and holds that a break in trade during the siege of Avaris better explains why WS I is relatively abundant at Tell el-Ajjul and scarce at Tell el-Dab'a. Manning's early date for the eruption, in his view, needs chronological changes that the material evidence presented here does not support (pp. 104–119).
For Thera, the survey reviews the WS I Rope Lattice bowl, Cypriot and Egyptian pottery contexts, the pumice evidence and the relative sequences proposed for LM IA and LM IB. It sets out Warren's account of the destruction and repair phases at Akrotiri and his conclusion that the eruption fell within LM IA. Eriksson argues that LM IA extended into the early New Kingdom and places the eruption within that period, leaving a more exact date unresolved (pp. 112–120).
Dating
The Cypriot sequence used runs from Proto White Slip Phase 2 through WS I to WS II, with LC IA divided into LC IA:1 and LC IA:2 and LC IB distinguished from LC IIA. Eriksson starts WS I some 20–30 years before the fall of Avaris and lets it develop across LC IA:2 and LC IB. He suggests that Rope Lattice could overlap with the other WS I styles instead of forming a separate, much earlier phase. Much of LC IA:2 then runs from shortly before Ahmose to before Thutmosis III, and LC IB begins around Thutmosis III (pp. 114–123).
What it records
- WS I is classified into five broad groups on the evidence of rim motifs.p. 81
- Eriksson uses "Rope Lattice" as the name of the WS I group that includes the bowl from Thera.p. 84
- Eriksson argues that trade between Cyprus and Tell el-Ajjul probably continued while Avaris was under siege.p. 86
- Tomb VI at Toumba tou Skourou held two WS bowls, one undecorated and one WS I 'RLFL'.p. 89
- Tomb I Chamber 2 at Toumba tou Skourou held nine WS I vessels.p. 89
- Eriksson reports that the tomb at Ayia Irini had six strata and at least 37 burials.p. 93
- The intact burial in Enkomi (French) Tomb 1851 held three classic WS I 'FWL' vessels.p. 98
- The WS I 'FLMet' bowl from 'Ezbet Helmi lay at the top of the lowest floor level of H/I-k/25.p. 100
- Eriksson argues that the context of the 'Ezbet Helmi bowl is best dated to the mid-18th Dynasty, towards the end of Thutmosis III's reign.p. 102
- Stratum H 5 at Tell el-Ajjul held 23 WS I sherds and was dated by its excavators to LC IA:2/B.p. 104
- Fischer concluded that the Thera volcano erupted before Level H5 at Tell el-Ajjul.p. 104
- The WS I assemblage from Tell el-Dab'a includes 'LFL', 'FLMet' and 'FL' motifs, and sherds with Rope Lattice designs.p. 106
- Eriksson suggests that the Thera eruption fell in the period of Thutmosis II and Hatshepsut.p. 118
- Eriksson dates LC IB from the first part of Thutmosis III's reign through the first part of Amenhotep II's reign.p. 120
- Warren places the Thera eruption within LM IA, before the LM IB destruction of Crete.p. 120
- Eriksson proposes that the late Framed Wavy Line and Framed Cross-hatching styles first appear during LC IB.p. 123
Where to read
- WS I rim-motif groups and the chapter’s terminologypp. 81–84
- Toumba tou Skourou tomb groups and the PWS to WS I sequencepp. 88–90
- Ayia Irini tomb strata and WS I stylespp. 93–95
- The ‘Ezbet Helmi WS I ‘FLMet’ bowl and Cypriot parallelspp. 99–102
- Tell el-Ajjul, Tell el-Dab'a and the intra-island barrier argumentpp. 103–112
- Arguments about the Thera eruption date and LC IB chronologypp. 112–123
Contents
- The ‘Rope Lattice’ Group and the First Appearance of WS I81
- The Significance of the WS I ‘Rope Lattice’ at Toumba tou Skourou87
- Some specific tomb groups from Toumba tou Skourou89
- WS I ‘RL’ at Palaepaphos Teratsoudhia Tombs 104 and 10591
- Other Key WS I Sites in Cyprus: Ayia Irini, Enkomi and Episkopi Bamboula93
- WS I in Egypt: The Significance of the Bowl from ‘Ezbet Helmi99
- WS I and the Aegean Civilization102
- Stratified White Slip from Tell el-Dab'a and Tell el-Ajjul: Identification of a Problem103
- Critique of Manning's ‘Intra-Island Barrier’ Thesis107
- White Slip, the Thera Eruption and Manning's ‘A Test of Time’112
- Critique of Manning's Claims on WS I114
- Warren on the Minoan Evidence for the Eruption119
- The Distinctive Features of the LC IB Period120
Objects published here
6- WS I 'FLMet' bichrome spouted bowl, ‘Ezbet Helmi, H/I-k/25, 7949, Fig. 21
- WS I 'RL' hemispherical bowl, Enkomi Tomb 19, Tomb 19:146, Fig. 14
- WS I 'RLFL' bowl, Ayia Irini tomb, Stratum V, no. 241, Fig. 17
- WS I 'RL' bowl, Palaepaphos Teratsoudhia, Tomb 104 Chamber E, Tomb 104 E. 11, 16a
- WS I 'RLFL' jug, Palaepaphos Teratsoudhia, Tomb 104 Chamber K, Tomb 104 K. 41, 16b
- WS I 'FWL' bowl, Enkomi (French) Tomb 1851, 27, 20a
People, places and institutions
People
- Celia Bergoffenstudied WS I chronology and Tell el-Ajjul
- Manningproposed an early eruption date
- BietakEgyptian chronology and WS I contexts
- Orenevidence for trade at Tell el-Ajjul
- Pophamclassified WS I motifs
- Merrilleesstudied WS I and the Thera bowl
- Wienercriticised Manning's chronology
- Peter WarrenMinoan evidence for the eruption date
- Ahmoseconquered Avaris and Sharuhen
- Thutmosis IIIreign used to date LC IB
Places
- Toumba tou Skourousource of the WS I tomb groups
- Ayia Irinitomb with six strata of WS I
- Palaepaphos TeratsoudhiaTombs 104 and 105 with WS I
- Enkomisettlement and tomb evidence for WS I
- Tell el-AjjulCanaanite site with WS I contexts
- Tell el-Dab'aEgyptian site with stratified White Slip
- Therafindspot of a WS I bowl
- Episkopi Bamboulastratified WS I sequence
- ‘Ezbet Helmifindspot of WS I bowls
- Phylakopifindspot of WS I sherds
- CreteMinoan sequence and eruption evidence
- Avarisbesieged city, context for trade
- Stephaniacemetery sequence discussed
- Hala Sultan Tekkeevidence for the spread of WS I
Also named: Knossos.
Extent pp. 81–123, Figs 12–27 and further figures cited in the text
Defines White Slip I (WS I), Rope Lattice (RL), Ladder Band (LBD), Double Line Framed Group, Framed Cross-hatching (FXH), LC IB
Middle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgePotteryChronology and DatingForeign Contacts
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- White Slip WareCompendium
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1934–1974Enkomi: the French MissionDirected by Claude F. A. Schaeffer, Olivier Pelon, Jacques-Claude Courtois (sector director) and othersExcavation
Who did what
3 recordsExcavation 2
- p. 93
Lorenzo QuiliciExcavated
Quilici excavated the Ayia Irini tomb stratigraphically and six strata were identified.
- p. 97
Claude Frédéric-Armand SchaefferExcavated
Schaeffer excavated French Tomb 4 at Enkomi, which contained two WS I bowls with bichrome decoration.
Recording and study 1
- p. 104
Celia BergoffenStudied
Celia Bergoffen researched the Cypriot pottery recovered in earlier excavations at Tell el-Ajjul.
Cypriot pottery from earlier excavations at Tell el-Ajjul
Mentioned in
24 mentionsTomb records · 22
- Enkomi, French Mission Tomb 1851
Discussion · 2007 · p. 98
and the tomb as a whole was dated to this period by the excavators (Lagarce 1985, 50–1)
- Enkomi, French Mission Tomb 240
Discussion · 2007 · p. 109
- Enkomi, French Mission Tomb 4
Restudy · 2007 · p. 97
- Episkopi-Bamboula, Penn Tomb 13
Restudy · 2007 · pp. 99, 100, 101
- Kalavasos-Village, Brandeis Tomb 51
Discussion · 2007 · p. 101
- Kouklia-Teratsoudhia, Department of Antiquities Tomb 104
Restudy · 2007 · pp. 91, 92, 103, 122, 123
- On Ancient Cyprus · 1listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
- Excavations · 1listed under Excavations it is cited for
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.