Article · 2007
La présence bovine dans la glyptique d'Ougarit et d'Enkomi
115-144
An article on bulls and bucrania on Late Bronze Age cylinder seals from Ougarit and Enkomi, read against celestial symbolism and the offering rituals of Ougarit.
Cluzan compares bovine images on Late Bronze Age cylinder seals from Ougarit and Enkomi: whole animals and bucrania, the motifs that accompany them, and their possible connections with celestial symbolism, sacrifice and fertility. The seal imagery is also set beside the royal offering rituals of Ougarit.
The evidence
For Ougarit, Cluzan draws on the cylinder-seal collections published by Claude Schaeffer and Pierre Amiet. For Enkomi she assembles examples scattered across publications and follows Edith Porada's classification. She treats the Late Bronze Age as a whole, because stylistic and iconographic classification, the movement of seals between regions and the limits of find contexts make narrower dating and attribution difficult (pp. 117–119).
At Ougarit she counts 42 bovine images, two of them uncertain faience examples, and 28 bucrania, all on stone. At Enkomi her tables record eight bovine images and eight bucrania among 125 cylinders. She groups the Ougarit bovine scenes as peaceful, oppositional or involving mythological beings, and finds bovine motifs closely associated with celestial signs at both sites; Cluzan reads one Enkomi seal's nested bucrania as a crescent holding a full astral body (pp. 119–125).
Ritual texts survive for Ougarit, in Denis Pardee's edition of the offering rituals, and Cluzan uses them to discuss divine recipients, types of sacrifice and the relative frequency of animal offerings. Cluzan notes that no equivalent texts are available for Enkomi, so the ritual comparison applies directly to Ougarit only (pp. 126–128).
The argument
Bovines are relatively rare in both groups of seals, Cluzan argues, yet their repeated association with astral signs suggests a particular symbolic status. She proposes that horns and bucrania could signify lunar forms, and that images combining animal remains, vegetal forms and celestial signs may express a link between sacrifice and fertility, presenting these readings as hypotheses drawn from the iconography and the ritual evidence (pp. 121–126).
In the final discussion she suggests that animal remains might have been kept and brought into rites connected with vegetation and fertility, and that stylised vegetal forms on the seals could represent an axis linking earth and sky through offerings, with the palmette expressing the return of vegetation. She relates this to the myth of Ba'al and to the bucrania and animal remains found in the sanctuary of the bucrania at Enkomi (pp. 128–130).
What it records
- Cluzan treats the Ougarit and Enkomi cylinder seals as Late Bronze Age material as a whole, without dividing it into phases.p. 118
- Less than 6% of the cylinder seals from Ougarit bear a bovine image.p. 119
- Peaceful bovine scenes number 19 at Ougarit, more than 45% of the appearances of bovines.p. 120
- 28 cylinders from Ougarit, all of stone, bear a bucranium.p. 122
- Bovines make up 6.4% of the cylinder seals from Enkomi, and caprines 18.4%.p. 123
- At Enkomi, celestial bodies surround the animals very closely on 63% of the cylinders that depict bovines.p. 123
- The Ougarit ritual texts that Cluzan cites, in Pardee's edition, comprise 80 rituals and 3,052 documented offerings.p. 126
- In Pardee's edition, the shlamim rite of wellbeing, a communion with consumption of the animal, accounts for 62% of animal-offering rites in the Ougarit ritual texts cited.p. 127
- Cluzan argues that bovine horns and vegetal motifs may link the remains of sacrifices with fertility.p. 128
Where to read
- Ougarit seal corpus, dating and material limitspp. 117–119
- Ougarit bovine scenes and astral signspp. 119–122
- Bucrania and celestial imagery at Enkomipp. 123–125
- Ougarit offering rites and animal sacrificepp. 126–127
- Animal remains, vegetal motifs and fertilitypp. 127–130
Contents
- Le contexte religieux116
- La documentation et ses limites117
- La présence bovine sur les sceaux d'Ougarit119
- L'iconographie des bovins à Ougarit120
- Les bucranes dans la glyptique d'Ougarit122
- La présence bovine sur les sceaux d'Enkomi123
- L'iconographie des bovins à Enkomi123
- Les bucranes dans la glyptique d'Enkomi124
- Bovins, astres et cornes125
- Les rites de sacrifice à Ougarit126
- L'image bovine de la glyptique permet-elle de préciser ou de compléter nos connaissances des rites ?127
- Bibliographie132
- Provenance des figures144
Objects published here
3- Stela of Ba'al with the thunderbolt, Musée du Louvre, Département des Antiquités orientales, Ougarit, AO 15.775, Fig. 1.1 (p. 144)
- Statue of the horned god, Musée de Chypre, Nicosia, Enkomi, Fig. 1.2 (p. 144)
- Cylinder seal with a small bucranium between the horns of a larger one, Enkomi, Porada 1971, no. 3b, Fig. 10.5 (p. 124)
People, places and institutions
People
- Annie Caubetscholar honoured by the article
- Claude Schaefferpublished the Ougarit cylinder seals
- Pierre Amietpublished and classified Ougarit seals
- Edith Poradaclassified the Enkomi cylinder seals
- Denis Pardeeedited the Ougarit offering rituals
Places
- Ougaritsource of one seal group and the ritual texts
- Enkomisource of the other seal group, and a sanctuary
Also named: Porphyrios Dikaios, Musée du Louvre, Musée de Chypre, Agios Iakovos, Nuzi.
Extent pp. 115–144, 12 figures; bibliography on p. 132
Late Bronze AgeAnimalsReligion and CultIconographyChronology and Dating
Who did what
2 recordsRecording and study 2
- p. 118
Edith PoradaStudied
Edith Porada’s studies and classification divided Enkomi cylinders into groups.
cylinder seals from Enkomi
- p. 118
Sophie CluzanStudied
Sophie Cluzan examined the cylinder-seal corpora of Ugarit and Enkomi for this thematic study.
cylinder seals from Ugarit and Enkomi
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
Missing from this record
- Journal not recorded
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.