Article · 1973
The Origin of the 'Palestinian' Bichrome Ware
M. Artzy, F. Asaro and I. Perlman
Journal of the American Oriental Society 93(4) 446-461
An article on the origin of “Palestinian” Bichrome Ware, using neutron-activation analysis and stylistic comparison on samples from Cyprus and Palestinian sites.
Artzy, Asaro and Perlman ask where “Palestinian” Bichrome Ware was made, setting chemical analysis beside comparison of vessel forms and decoration. They argue that most of the Bichrome Ware they analysed came from Cyprus, chiefly the eastern part of the island. The repertory resembles the Cypriote White Painted sequence in its jugs, tankards, bowls and geometric decoration, but they treat the stylistic evidence cautiously, since the pictorial designs are innovative and do not by themselves establish a single place of origin.
Neutron activation analysis compares trace elements in the pottery fabrics, with the largest Bichrome samples coming from Tell el-'Ajjul and Milia and further comparisons drawn from local wares and from other Cypriote and Palestinian sites (pp. 452–460). The main chemical groups from Tell el-'Ajjul and Milia are statistically similar, and differ from the Tell el-'Ajjul plain ware and the southern coastal Palestinian comparison groups. Other pieces match further eastern Cypriote groups, including samples associated with Paleoskoutella, and some Tell el-'Ajjul pieces are classed as locally made.
Artzy, Asaro and Perlman place Bichrome Ware in Palestinian contexts chiefly in Late Bronze I and in Cypriote contexts at the beginning of Late Cypriote I. The authors cite Bichrome sherds from Kalopsidha Trench 9, which they regard as at least as early as comparable Palestinian material, and note uncertainty in absolute dates and in the classification of two-colour Late Bronze pottery (pp. 451, 460–461).
What it records
- Artzy, Asaro and Perlman argue that eastern Cyprus was the source of most pottery classified as “Palestinian” Bichrome Ware.p. 446
- 54 Bichrome pieces from Tell el-'Ajjul and 39 from Milia were analysed.p. 452
- 36 Tell el-'Ajjul pieces and 27 Milia pieces fall into the principal chemical groups compared in the study.p. 452
- The neutron-activation analysis of pottery in the study uses about 100 mg of material removed from a sherd.p. 452
- Analysed Bichrome groups from Tell el-'Ajjul and Milia likely shared a provenience, the authors argue.p. 453
- Six Bichrome pieces from Tell el-'Ajjul are identified as locally made, although the authors state that they cannot assign them specifically to that site.p. 460
- Five of the six Bichrome pieces analysed from Beth-El match the large Milia and Tell el-'Ajjul groups in composition.p. 460
- All four Bichrome samples analysed from Lachish and Tell el-Hesi have an eastern Cypriote composition.p. 460
Where to read
- Chemical comparison of the main Tell el-'Ajjul and Milia groupspp. 452–454
- Evidence for Bichrome production in other parts of Cypruspp. 456–460
- Contexts and chronology in Cyprus and Palestinep. 451
Contents
- Introduction446
- Antecedents and association of the Bichrome style448
- Origins of Pottery — Methodology451
- Origins of the Bichrome Ware452
- Tell el-’Ajjul and Milia Main Groups452
- Pottery of southern coastal Israel453
- Pottery of eastern Cyprus453
- ’Ajjul Bichrome and other groups from eastern Cyprus456
- ’Ajjul locally-made Bichrome460
- Bichrome Ware from other Palestinian sites460
- Beth-El460
- Lachish and Tell el-Hesi460
- Tel Mor460
- Megiddo461
People, places and institutions
People
- W. A. Heurtleyproposed a Palestinian origin for Bichrome
- Claire Epsteincriticised Heurtley's stylistic interpretation
- P. Dikaiosreported Enkomi pottery finds
- Paul Åströmreported Cypriote site contexts
- Sir Flinders Petrieexcavated the Tell el-'Ajjul pottery
Institutions
- Lawrence Berkeley Laboratorylaboratory of the authors' pottery analysis
Places
- Miliasource of pottery samples
- Tell el-'Ajjulsite providing the largest sample
- EnkomiCypriote context for wheel-made pottery
- Kalopsidhasite with Bichrome Ware in Trench 9
- Megiddosite with two-colour pottery
- Deir el-Balachsouthern coastal comparison site
- Tel Ashkelonsouthern coastal comparison site
- Tel Ashdodsouthern coastal comparison site
- Paleoskoutellasource group for two 'Ajjul sherds
- Beth-Elsite with six analysed Bichrome pieces
- Tel Morseaport settlement with imported wares
Also named: Einar Gjerstad, Department of Antiquities, Republic of Cyprus, Nitovikla, Lachish, Tell el-Hesi.
Extent pp. 446–461, figs 1–3
Middle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgePotteryChronology and DatingTrade
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
5 pages- Handmade by Choice in the Late Bronze AgeArticle
- Base Ring WareCompendium
- Bichrome WareCompendium
- The Pottery of Ancient CyprusCompendium
- White Slip WareCompendium
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1948–1958Enkomi: the Department of Antiquities excavations under DikaiosDirected by Porphyrios DikaiosExcavation
Who did what
1 recordExcavation 1
- p. 451
Porphyrios DikaiosFound
Dikaios found Bichrome Ware in a Level I context at Enkomi.
Mentioned in
9 mentionsTomb records · 3
- Enkomi, Dikaios Tomb 10
Discussion · 1973 · p. 448
- Enkomi, Dikaios Tomb 2
Discussion · 1973 · p. 448
In Enkomi Tomb 2, Dikaios $ ^{12} $ reports 8 specimens of Black Slip Ware, all wheel-made.
- Milia-Vikla Trachonas, SCE Tomb 10
Discussion · 1973 · p. 449
- On Ancient Cyprus · 5listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
- Excavations · 1listed under Excavations it is cited for
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.