Museum director · Antiquities official · Scholar
Philipp Dethier
Philipp Anton Dethier
d. 1881 · Germany
Director of the Imperial Museum in Constantinople in the 1870s who went to Cyprus in 1874 and returned with some eighty packages of antiquities from Cesnola's finds.
Biography
Philipp Anton Dethier directed the Imperial Museum in Constantinople in the 1870s, went to Cyprus on an official mission in 1874 and returned with some eighty packages of antiquities from the finds of Luigi Palma di Cesnola and others1,13.
Constantinople
Dethier was born at Kerpen near Cologne14. The sources disagree on the year of his birth: the German National Library gives 1803, while two newspaper notices of 1881 say he died aged 7914,15,16. After his studies in Germany he taught for a long time in Paris, then took over the Austrian school in Pera, which he headed for many years14. Donkow says he was educated in classics, philology, archaeology and art history at Berlin University17. In January 1856 the German archaeologist Otto Frick examined the bronze Serpent Column with him, and Dethier published a facsimile of its inscription from a plaster cast18. With Mordtmann he published Epigraphik von Byzantion in the Denkschriften of the Vienna Academy in 18644,19.
Writers call him by different nationalities: Larfeld calls him "dem Kölner", and Shaw and Donkow call him a German17,19,20. Georges Perrot thought him Austrian, "si nous ne nous trompons", and an article of 1883 in the Revue des deux mondes calls him "un archéologue autrichien"21,22. The Athenaeum in 1889 called him "Dethier the Hungarian"23.
Ahmed Vefik Pasha re-established the post of Director of the Imperial Museum and appointed Dethier to it1. Doğançay dates the appointment to 187224. In March 1875 Dethier obtained imperial permission to install the collection in the Tchinli Mosque1. Shaw says he kept up the policy of hiring agents in the provinces to collect antiquities for the museum20.
The colossus from Amathus
In February 1874 a colossal statue from Cyprus reached Constantinople by Lloyd steamer, was unloaded with the crane of the artillery yard at Tophane and was taken across the Galata bridge to the museum of St Irene25. Dethier wrote that the lower piece, three feet high, had been found and sent with the upper piece, nine feet high to the knee25. The Jahresbericht says this colossus and a second one were both found by Cesnola at Amathus near Limassol and both reached the museum26. Dethier published it in La Turquie in February 1874 as "Statue chyprienne colossale, Hercule ou Silène Kéraste?", and L'Orient illustré reprinted the notice with changes in July as a "Bacchus primitif"27,29. Albert Sorlin-Dorigny says the engraver misread Dethier's sketches for the reprint27. Dethier also wrote to the Kölnische Zeitung of 27 March 1874, and regretted the loss of the animal's head that had formed the spout of the fountain28.
He read the chevrons on the statue's arms as signs of tattooing, like those of the Tamahu chief at Medinet Habu, Sorlin-Dorigny reports27. The Jahresbericht reviewer called his conjectures on the date and nationality of the work "unzulänglichen und vagen"26. Perrot later named the essay on the "colosse antiquissime chyprien", "comme il dit en son jargon", among the memoirs that showed how poorly Dethier knew classical antiquity, and regretted that Dethier had not kept to Greek Byzantium and Christian Constantinople21.
The eighty-eight packages
The sources disagree on the year of the Cyprus mission and the 88 packages: the Gazette archéologique in 1884 and Shaw give 1873; The Academy of November 1874, Doğançay, Schmid, and Bursa and Pitarakis give 18749,13,20,24,29,30. Doğançay, citing an Ottoman archive file, says he was sent to supervise Cesnola's work on the spot and report24.
In a letter printed in 1905 Cesnola gives his account: "le vieux Dr Dethier" landed at Larnaca, went on incognito to the capital, and carried a letter to the Governor saying he had come to make a division of Cesnola's antiquities31. Cesnola says he threw Dethier out with his letters and orders, and that the Governor and Dethier then made "les excuses les plus abjectes"; he let Dethier choose in his house, and Dethier took 88 packages31. In Cesnola's account the American Minister Boker had the packages confiscated at Constantinople, then gave them to the museum on condition of a letter of thanks from the Porte and the renewal of Cesnola's firman; the letter came late and the firman never31.
The Gazette archéologique tells it differently: Dethier chose the objects in the Larnaca house and filled 88 cases, which reached St Irene "après des incidents"; the Porte thanked Cesnola, and Dethier proclaimed him one of the museum's benefactors9. The Gazette believed, "croyons-nous", that this was the first of the archaeological divisions later fixed in Ottoman law9. The Academy, citing the Levant Herald, said the packages were chiefly the parts of Cesnola's and other antiquaries' finds ceded under the recent law on treasure-trove, among them a bearded Venus and Greek pottery and glass13. On the same journey Dethier completed his decipherment of an inscription found by Frank Calvert at Troy13. Doğançay says he brought only 88 pieces to Istanbul24. Bursa and Pitarakis say most of the Cypriot objects in the Istanbul Archaeological Museums came in these 88 chests30.
Cesnola wrote in 1877 that Dethier held the "so-called museum" at a high salary, with a duty that, "as he told me, amounts next to nothing"32. In his 1878 book he called the museum "that lumber-room styled the Imperial Museum"3.
The law of 1874
The 1883 article in the Revue des deux mondes says the law of 24 March 1874 was due to Dethier's initiative, and gave a third of finds to the government, a third to the finder and the rest to the landowner22. The article found it sad that a European archaeologist had drafted such a law, since finds made together form series that cannot be divided22. Salomon Reinach wrote in his Chroniques d'Orient of 1891 that England had left in force in Cyprus "l'ancienne loi turque rédigée par Déthier", under which the museum at Nicosia took a third of finds on private land and two thirds on public land4. Stanley-Price adds that under his successor, Osman Hamdi Bey, its liberal export terms were repealed by a new law of 18841.
The Cypriot collection and his death
Reinach's catalogue of 1882 says the museum held a manuscript inventory of the pottery "rédigé avec beaucoup de soin" by Dethier, about 1,500 pieces classed by shape33. Gustave Mendel describes Dethier's label catalogue of March 1880, written in the hand of his secretary Ch. Vollers, as rudimentary, with provenances that "paraissent écrites de mémoire"34. To 1,788 pieces in fourteen sections Dethier added about 1,200 Cypriot numbers34.
Perrot, who had known him, called him "un homme excellent, actif, curieux" who saved many monuments, but also said he left works "presque tous à refaire"21. The 1883 article says that, like all foreigners in the Porte's service, he tried to prove his zeal by being "plus Turc que le Grand-Turc"22. Edwin Pears called him "an entirely honest man, but somewhat of a crank"35. Reporting the museum's opening, at which Dethier spoke as director, the Kölnische Zeitung of 23 August 1880 wrote that its founding and ordering were "recht eigentlich sein Werk"36.
The sources disagree on when he died: Shaw and Stanley-Price give 18801,20. The Schwäbischer Merkur reported from Constantinople on 1 March 1881 that he had died "gestern", and the Hallische Zeitung reported on 4 March that he had died "gestern" after a painful illness14,16. He left a widow and two sons, Karl, director of the Danube Commission at Tulcea, and Oskar, a music and piano teacher in Constantinople14. His Études archéologiques, a volume of his articles, appeared after his death in 188121,37.
Life and work
1864
- Co-author with Mordtmann of 'Epigraphik von Byzantion' (Denkschriften of the Vienna Academy, 1864), as cited by Reinach.
1873
1873–1875
Sent by the Porte to Larnaca to select from Cesnola's collection of duplicates. Cesnola's letter says he threw Dethier out, then allowed him to choose and Dethier took 88 boxes, which the American minister Boker confiscated on arrival in Constantinople and later released on conditions (an official letter of thanks and renewal of the firman, which was never renewed).
1874
- Published 'Statue chyprienne colossale, Hercule ou Silène-Kéraste' in La Turquie, Constantinople (pp. 1-44).
- According to Reinach, the 1874 Ottoman antiquities law (the one the British left in force in Cyprus: one third of finds on private land and two thirds on public land to the government, per Reinach) was drawn up by Dethier.
ConstantinopleSalomon Reinach (1891). Chroniques d'Orient; Veronica Tatton-Brown (ed.) (2001). Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction. Oxford, Oxbow
1875
1875–1878
Accompanied Cesnola and the American Minister through the Imperial Museum to look for two cases Cesnola had sent earlier by way of the Governor of the Dardanelles; none was found. Cesnola calls Dethier the man who 'has charge of that lumber-room styled the Imperial Museum'.ConstantinopleL. P. di Cesnola (1878). Cyprus: Its Ancient Cities, Tombs, and Temples
1880
- Died; Osman Hamdi Bey was named Director of the Imperial Museum and charged Salomon Reinach with classifying and cataloguing the collection.
1881
- Posthumous Etudes archeologiques (Constantinople), with an annex 'Histoire du Musee central ottoman de Stamboul et son programme'.
Through their hands
1 record- 1874Note
NoteDethier and Cesnola made an agreement in Larnaca in 1874 after which 88 chests of Cypriot antiquities were brought to Istanbul.
Connected with Luigi Palma di CesnolaAntiquities from various sites in Cyprus, in 88 chestsBursa & Pitarakis 2005, p. 29
Connections
6 peopleSales, gifts & bequests
- Received from Luigi Palma di Cesnola88 crates of Cypriot objects from Larnaca house; 88 crates of Cypriot antiquities from Larnaca; 88 crates of objects from the Larnaca house Dulau, De Witte Et Lenormant (gazette Archeologique) Neuvieme Annee 1884 (1884); Gazette archéologique : recueil de monuments pour servir à la connaissance et à l'histoire de l'art antique (1884), p. 329; Gazette Archéologique 18841873
Fieldwork & employment
- Employed by Ahmed Vefik PashaAhmed Vefik Pasha re-established the Director post and appointed Dethier as Director of the Imperial Museum. Stanley-Price 2001, p. 268
Disputes & the law
- Rival of Luigi Palma di Cesnolaselection of 88 boxes from Cesnola's Larnaca collection for the Imperial Museum; Cesnola collection Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904, pp. 135-136; Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola, p. 135, p. 1361873
Colleagues & contacts
- Connected with Ahmet Kaiserli PashaRevue archéologique (1905-01), p. 9071869–1870
- Connected with George Henry Bokerconfiscation of Dethier's 88 boxes, Cesnola's account; 88 colis of antiquities; 88 colis Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904, p. 136; Revue archéologique (1905-01), p. 907; Ernest Leroux, Revue Archeologique (quatrieme Serie Tome.5) (1905)1871–1873
- Connected with Luigi Palma di CesnolaDethier and Cesnola made an agreement in Larnaca in 1874 after which 88 chests of Cypriot antiquities were brought to Istanbul. Bursa & Pitarakis 2005, p. 291873–1875
- Worked with Luigi Palma di Cesnola88 chests of Cypriot antiquities A group of bronze jugs in the Istanbul Archaeological Museums and the issue of their Cypriot origin (2005), p. 11874
- Connected with Albert Sorlin-DorignyAmathus colossus and the bearded-goddess statuette in the Constantinople museum Al. Sorlin-Dorigny, 1879, Statue colossale découverte à Amathonte (Cypre), pp. 230-2361879
- Preceded Osman Hamdi BeyDirectorship of the Imperial Museum N. Stanley-Price, 2001, The Ottoman Law on Antiquities (1874) and the founding of the Cyprus Museum; Stanley-Price 2001, 'The Ottoman Law on Antiquities (1874) and the founding of the Cyprus Museum', in Tatton-Brown (ed.), Cyprus in the 19th century, pp. 267–2751880
- Succeeded by Osman Hamdi BeyOsman Hamdi Bey succeeded Dethier as Director of the Imperial Museum. Stanley-Price 2001, p. 2681880
Recording and study
3 records- Employed by1
Philippe Anton Dethier was director of the Imperial Ottoman Museum.
Employed by Imperial Ottoman MuseumBursa & Pitarakis 2005, p. 29
- Other work2
1875Dethier obtained Imperial permission to install the collection in the Tchinli Mosque.
1875Dethier obtained Imperial permission to install the collection in the Tchinli Mosque.
Mentioned in
15 mentionsDocuments · 6
- A group of bronze jugs in the Istanbul Archaeological Museums and the issue of their Cypriot origin
Employed · 1874 · p. 29
Dethier and Cesnola made an agreement in Larnaca in 1874 after which 88 chests of Cypriot antiquities were brought to Istanbul.
Bursa & Pitarakis 2005
- Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction
1875 · p. 268
Dethier obtained Imperial permission to install the collection in the Tchinli Mosque.
Tatton-Brown 2001
Also in Stanley-Price 2001
- Chroniques d'Orient
Reinach 1891
- Cypriote antiquities in Late Ottoman Istanbul and Smyrna - II: Cypriote antiquities in the Greek Evangelical School Museum and their Trading in Late Ottoman Smyrna (Modern Izmir)
Merrillees 2017
- Cyprus: Its Ancient Cities, Tombs, and Temples
Cesnola 1878
- The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds
Marangou 2000
On Ancient Cyprus · 1
Institutions · 2
- Istanbul Archaeology Museums
Director (c. 1872–1880) · 1872
The 36-article Règlement sur les antiquités replaces the seven-article 1869 regulation: one third of finds to the Government, one third to the finder, one…
Tatton-Brown 2001; Tatton-Brown 2001, p. 268; Stanley-Price 2018
- United States Legation, Constantinople
1873
After Cesnola's return from the United States (1873) the Turks were more hostile and he had trouble obtaining a new firman. By his own letter he agreed with…
Marangou 2000, p. 135-136; Cesnola 1878
- People · 6listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.Veronica Tatton-Brown (ed.) (2001). Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction. Oxford, Oxbow.
- 2.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
- 3.L. P. di Cesnola (1878). Cyprus: Its Ancient Cities, Tombs, and Temples.
- 4.Salomon Reinach (1891). Chroniques d'Orient.
- 5.Robert S. Merrillees (2017). “Cypriote antiquities in Late Ottoman Istanbul and Smyrna - II: Cypriote antiquities in the Greek Evangelical School Museum and their Trading in Late Ottoman Smyrna (Modern Izmir)”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 47, 121-164. Online
- 6.P. A. Dethier (1874). “Statue chyprienne colossale, Hercule ou Silène-Kéraste”. La Turquie, 1-44. Constantinople.
- 7.P. A. Dethier (1881). Études archéologiques (œuvre posthume).
- 8.Gazette archéologique (1879). Gazette archéologique, 5th year. p. 240; leaf 234 note 4.
- 9.Gazette archéologique (1884). “[Note on the Cypriot heads in the Imperial Museum, Constantinople]”. Gazette archéologique 9.
- 10.Philologischer Anzeiger (1869). Philologischer Anzeiger.
- 11.Harper's Magazine (1877). Harper's Magazine, 13 January 1877.
- 12.Gallica newspaper bpt6k3952982q (n.d.). Newspaper note on the new Imperial Museum at Djinliskiosk.
- 13.The Academy (1874). “[Note from the Levant Herald on Dr Dethier's mission to Cyprus]”. The Academy, 14 November 1874 6, 545.
- 14.Schwäbischer Merkur (1881). “[Death notice of Dr Philipp Anton Dethier, Constantinople, 1 March]”. Schwäbischer Merkur (Stuttgart), 12 March 1881, 4. Online
- 15.Deutsche Nationalbibliothek. GND 100106587: Dethier, Philipp Anton (1803-1881). Online
- 16.Hallische Zeitung (1881). “[Death notice of Dr Philipp Anton Dethier, Constantinople, 4 March]”. Hallische Zeitung (Halle), 12 March 1881, 9. Online
- 17.I. Donkow (2004). “The Ephesus excavations 1863–1874, in the light of the Ottoman legislation on antiquities”. Anatolian Studies 54, 109-117.
- 18.C. T. Newton (1865). Travels and Discoveries in the Levant.
- 19.W. Larfeld (1914). Griechische Epigraphik.
- 20.W. M. K. Shaw (2012). “From Mausoleum to Museum: Resurrecting Antiquity for Ottoman Modernity”. Scramble for the Past: A Story of Archaeology in the Ottoman Empire, 1753-1914 (ed. Z. Bahrani, Z. Çelik, E. Eldem). SALT.
- 21.G. Perrot (1882). “[Review of Ph. A. Dethier, Études archéologiques]”. Revue archéologique n.s. 44, 254-255.
- 22.S. Reinach (1883). “Le vandalisme moderne en Orient”. Revue des deux mondes 56.
- 23.The Athenaeum (1889). “[Article on the Imperial Museum at Constantinople]”. The Athenaeum 3220.
- 24.S. Doğançay (2022). “Amerika Konsolosu Cesnola'nın Kıbrıs'taki Arkeolojik Çalışmaları”. Gaziantep University Journal of Social Sciences 21(3), 1680-1698.
- 25.Philologischer Anzeiger (1874). “[Report from Cologne, 21 February, on Dr Dethier's letter about the colossal statue from Cyprus]”. Philologischer Anzeiger 6.
- 26.Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft (1873). “[Report on Cypriot finds, including Dethier's Statue chyprienne colossale]”. Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft.
- 27.A. Sorlin-Dorigny (1879). “[On the Cypriot colossus in the Constantinople museum]”. Gazette archéologique 5, 230-236.
- 28.The Academy (1874). “[Note on Dr Déthier's letter in the Kölnische Zeitung on the colossus from Cyprus]”. The Academy 5.
- 29.S. G. Schmid (2019). “From Paul Schroeder's archives on Cyprus, I-III”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 49, 357-.
- 30.P. Bursa and B. Pitarakis (2005). “A group of bronze jugs in the Istanbul Archaeological Museums and the issue of their Cypriot origin”. Antiquité Tardive.
- 31.L. P. di Cesnola (1905). “[Letter of Cesnola on his Cyprus antiquities, printed in the Revue archéologique]”. Revue archéologique 4e série, 5.
- 32.L. P. di Cesnola (1877). “[Recent discoveries in the island of Cyprus]”. Harper's Weekly, 13 January 1877 (supplement) 21, 38.
- 33.S. Reinach (1882). Catalogue du Musée impérial d'antiquités.
- 34.G. Mendel (1912). Catalogue des sculptures grecques, romaines et byzantines (Musées impériaux ottomans).
- 35.E. Pears (1916). Forty Years in Constantinople: The Recollections of Sir Edwin Pears, 1873-1915.
- 36.Kölnische Zeitung (1880). “[Report from Constantinople on the opening of the Imperial Museum]”. Kölnische Zeitung, 23 August 1880, 2. Online
- 37.Neue Jahrbücher für Philologie und Paedagogik (1881). “[Bibliographical notice of Dethier, Études archéologiques]”. Neue Jahrbücher für Philologie und Paedagogik.
- 38.Pinar Bursa, Brigitte Pitarakis (2005). “A group of bronze jugs in the Istanbul Archaeological Museums and the issue of their Cypriot origin”. Antiquité Tardive 13, 29-36.
- 39.N. Stanley-Price (2001). “The Ottoman Law on Antiquities (1874) and the Founding of the Cyprus Museum”. Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction, 267-275. Oxford, Oxbow.
- 40.N. Stanley-Price, 2001, The Ottoman Law on Antiquities (1874) and the Founding of the Cyprus Museum.
- 41.Revue archéologique (1905-01).
- 42.Al. Sorlin-Dorigny, 1879, Statue colossale découverte à Amathonte (Cypre).
- 43.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904.
- 44.Ernest Leroux, Revue Archeologique (quatrieme Serie Tome.5) (1905).
- 45.Pinar Bursa et al., 2005, A group of bronze jugs in the Istanbul Archaeological Museums and the issue of their Cypriot origin.
- 46.N. Stanley-Price, 2001, The Ottoman Law on Antiquities (1874) and the founding of the Cyprus Museum.
- 47.Stanley-Price 2001, 'The Ottoman Law on Antiquities (1874) and the founding of the Cyprus Museum', in Tatton-Brown (ed.), Cyprus in the 19th century.
- 48.Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft.
- 49.Jahresbericht über die Fortschritte der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft (1873).
- 50.Dulau, De Witte Et Lenormant (gazette Archeologique) Neuvieme Annee 1884 (1884).
- 51.Gazette archéologique : recueil de monuments pour servir à la connaissance et à l'histoire de l'art antique (1884).
- 52.Gazette Archéologique 1884.
- 53.A group of bronze jugs in the Istanbul Archaeological Museums and the issue of their Cypriot origin (2005).
- 54.Marangou 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola.
- 55.1905, Letter of L. P. di Cesnola, New York, 26 November 1882, printed with an editor's note.
- 56.2005, A group of bronze jugs in the Istanbul Archaeological Museums and the issue of their Cypriot origin.
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Date of birth unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.