Scholar

Lucy W. Mitchell

1845–1888

American historian of ancient sculpture who criticised the restorations in the Cesnola collection in 1882, testified on them in Feuardent v. Cesnola in 1883 and wrote on Cypriot sculpture.

Biography

Lucy M. Mitchell was an American writer on ancient sculpture who, in the early 1880s, questioned the restorations and the missing find-places of Luigi Palma di Cesnola's Cypriot collection at the Metropolitan Museum, in print and in court3,4. Stephen L. Dyson writes that she produced the first book on classical sculpture published by an American and was one of the first women to study classical archaeology seriously5.

A missionary childhood and study in Europe

She was born at Orumiyeh in north-western Iran on 20 March 1845, the daughter of Austin Hazen Wright (1811-1865) and Catherine Myers Wright (1821-1888)2,5. Her parents were missionaries to the Nestorian Christians in Persia, according to Wikipedia6. In 1854 she was sent to the United States for her education5. The Dictionary of Art Historians places her at Mount Holyoke Seminary in Massachusetts from 1859 to 1864 and says its records list her as a non-graduate2.

Her father died suddenly in 1865, and she decided to give up the missionary life5. The sources disagree on her husband's middle initial: Dyson writes that in 1867 she married Samuel S. Mitchell of Morristown, New Jersey, while the Dictionary of Art Historians calls him the artist Samuel P. Mitchell (1846-1925)2,5. After a brief stay in Lebanon, where Samuel studied language and Lucy began to explore archaeological sites, the couple settled in Germany, first at Leipzig and then at Berlin5. At Leipzig in 1872-3 she attended Johannes Overbeck's lectures on ancient art2,5.

By 1876, Dyson writes, she was lecturing on ancient sculpture in the Roman galleries, and the American ambassador in Rome, George Perkins Marsh, suggested that she expand the lectures into a book5. The Christian Union says she lectured in Rome for two winters, with Marsh as her mentor and friend7. Preliminary studies appeared in the Century Magazine, and she also wrote for The New York Times on archaeological discoveries5. Her brother was the classical scholar John Henry Wright, whose career, in Dyson's account, went from Dartmouth through Johns Hopkins to Harvard5,6.

The Century and the Cesnola restorations

The Century had obtained permission in the autumn of 1881 to photograph objects in the Cesnola collection to illustrate her history of ancient sculpture, then running in its pages3. When A. D. Savage wrote that four of the photographed objects held five restorations, word was sent to Mitchell, who had gone abroad to continue her essays near the British and Berlin museums3. Her reply, printed by the magazine and reprinted in The Art Amateur in 1882, said that in New York she had tried to learn where pieces came from, "temple? tomb?", and how they stood3. "It was always in vain," she wrote3. She had "felt unhappy" studying "the stainless collection, so monotonous in its whiteness," and hoped that Cesnola would "be made to feel the great wrong he has done science and the American people in thus imposing upon them patched-up restorations of homeless figures"3.

Cyprus in A History of Ancient Sculpture

She finished the manuscript at Marion, on the south shore of Massachusetts, in September 1883, and Dodd, Mead and Company published A History of Ancient Sculpture under the name Lucy M. Mitchell5,8.

Her pages on Cyprus name the British consul Lang and the brothers Cesnola among those who had collected Cypriot sculpture in great numbers8. She wrote that no exact records of the discovery of the New York pieces appeared to have been kept, finds from temple and tomb not having been held apart nor the localities accurately given, and that restorations made at different times had increased the confusion8. She judged the island's coarse, soft limestone unsuited to fine carving8. In her view the intermixture of races and the island's political fortunes "may doubtless, in part, explain the unpleasant mongrel character of nearly every thing Cypriote"8. She discussed a winged, bearded man carved back to back with a lion, Metropolitan Museum No. 156, which was "said to have been untouched by modern" restoration8. The Greeks, she wrote, never remoulded the older Cypriot style into "any thing better than a very second-rate provincial art"8.

The witness of November 1883

The New York Times reported that on 16 November 1883 "Mrs. Lucy M. Mitchell, of Staunton, Va., who has in press a volume on ancient sculpture," appeared as the first expert witness in the Feuardent-Di Cesnola case4. According to the Times, she said she had studied archaeology in the museums of Europe for ten years and had been astonished by the dazzling whiteness of the Metropolitan collection, which differed from the Cypriot collections in Berlin, the Louvre and the British Museum4. Her doubt of its authenticity, the paper reported, came from the many noses on the figures, when only about half a dozen well-authenticated noses of such antiques were known4.

She testified that the large Hercules had been restored, since its inferior feet seemed the work of a different artist from its head4. Soaking a statue, she said, would remove the colours seen on eyes, hair and ornament of Cypriot antiquities in Europe, which did not appear on the New York statues4. She told the court that the incrustations the defence cited could not have come from earth or air and must have been applied by hand, and that the collection was of no use to students until its repairs and restorations were made apparent4. Under cross-examination by Joseph H. Choate she said that noses had been restored to statues found in the two previous centuries but that of late years the rule had been not to restore them4. The Art Amateur reported that Richard Watson Gilder and "Mrs. Lucy W. Mitchell, an expert in archæology" gave evidence on the injury done to the collection by improper restorations1.

Reviews, Curium and the last years

The Christian Union called the book "the most important contribution to the history of sculpture that has yet appeared among us," though it found her earlier Century articles scholarly but lacking in imagination7. The Literary World thought it "in every way creditable to American scholarship" and "highly remarkable" for having been written by a lady, while it faulted the careless French of many notes and the gathering of all notes at the end of the book9. Dyson writes that the only negative review was by William J. Stillman in The Nation, and that behind some of his criticisms lay their disagreement over the worth of the Cesnola collection5. Dyson judges her view of the virtues and limits of that collection "balanced and fair"5. Olien calls her survey one of the most detailed discussions of Cypriot sculpture of the period, but argues that her descriptions signal a tradition "not one to be admired" and that one aim of her treatment was to show that the Cypriot style was not Greek10.

In 1884 she became the second woman elected to the Imperial German Archaeological Institute2,5. In January 1886 The Art Amateur reported her letter to The Times with the news "No Golgoi temple! no Curium treasure!"11. She named Ferdinand Dümmler as her authority, from excavations of the disputed sites, for her view that much of Cesnola's account of his discovery was "the fantastic play of a Southern fancy"11. Her letter said that Dümmler, Colonel Falk Warren, Max Ohnefalsch-Richter and others had begun work at Cesnola's Curium on 13 September, and quoted Dümmler's conviction that no treasure vaults, treasure or temple of Curium had ever been proved by Cesnola11.

Wen Li Teng, after Dyson, writes that Mitchell prepared the first lists of cast purchases for the Elbridge G. Hall Collection at the Art Institute of Chicago12. She had begun research for a book on Greek vase painting, consulting Adolf Furtwängler5. In the winter of 1886 her health suddenly collapsed; a rest in Switzerland proved futile, and she died at Lausanne on 10 March 18882,5.

Life and work

  1. 1883

    1. December 1883 – January 1884

      Gave evidence in Feuardent v. Cesnola, with Richard Watson Gilder, 'as to the general injury to the Cypriote collection resulting from improper restorations', described as 'an expert in archaeology'.

      New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 56

    2. 1883–1884Named

      Witness (for the plaintiff side as reported) in the Feuardent v. Cesnola libel suit; the report says she testified on injury to the Cypriote collection from improper restorations.

      (1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 56

  2. Undated

    n.d.

    1. 'An expert in archaeology' who testified in Feuardent v. Cesnola on the harm of improper restorations to the Cypriot collection.

      Art Amateur 10 (Jan. 1884), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 55-56

Connections

4 people

Mentioned in

5 mentions

Sources

  1. 1. (1884). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56. Online
  2. 2.Dictionary of Art Historians. Mitchell, Lucy Wright Myers. Online
  3. 3.The Art Amateur (quoting The Century) (1882). “"The Century" Condemns Cesnola”. The Art Amateur 7 (no. 3), August 1882.
  4. 4.The New York Times (1883). “The Altered Antiquities: An Archaeological Expert's Views on Restoration”. The New York Times 33 (no. 10047), 17 November 1883.
  5. 5.Stephen L. Dyson. “Lucy Wright Mitchell, 1845-1888”. Breaking Ground: Women in Old World Archaeology (Brown University). Online
  6. 6.Wikipedia (2026). Lucy Myers Wright Mitchell. Online
  7. 7.The Christian Union (unsigned review) (1883). “[Review of Mrs. Mitchell, A History of Ancient Sculpture]”. The Christian Union 28 (no. 23), 6 December 1883.
  8. 8.Lucy M. Mitchell (1883). A History of Ancient Sculpture. Dodd, Mead, and Company.
  9. 9.[Anonymous] (1884). “[Review of Lucy M. Mitchell, A History of Ancient Sculpture]”. The Literary World (Boston).
  10. 10.Olien. “Exploring the legacy of imperialist logic [in the historiography of Cypriot art]”. Empire and Excavation.
  11. 11.The Art Amateur (unsigned) (1886). “"No Temple! No Treasure!"”. The Art Amateur 14 (no. 2), January 1886.
  12. 12.Wen Li Teng (2020). “Grant Park and the Globe: Lucy Mitchell, Bessie Bennett, and the Art Institute of Chicago”. The Virginia Tech Undergraduate Historical Review 9, 17-27. Online
  13. 13.Art Amateur 10 (Jan. 1884), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial'.
  14. 14.1884, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (continued).
  15. 15.Books Received (1882).
  16. 16.Treatment of the Supplement Designs (1882).
  17. 17.The Art Amateur 1882-08: Vol 7 Iss 3 (1882).
  18. 18.The Costume of Men (1882).
  19. 19.The Christian Union 1883-12-06: Vol 28 Iss 23 (1883).
  20. 20.The New York Times 1883-11-17: Vol 33 Iss 10047 (1883).
  21. 21.The Art Amateur 1886-01: Vol 14 Iss 2 (1886).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.