Collector

Joly de Bammeville

d. 1893 · France

Paris collector of antiquities whose collection, with a Cypriot group, was sold at the Hôtel Drouot in 1881 and, after his death, in 1893; his inscribed column to Opaon Melanthios is in the Louvre.

Biography

Joly de Bammeville was a Paris collector whose antiquities, among them a group of Cypriot heads, terracottas and an inscribed column, were sold at the Hôtel Drouot in 1881 and again in 1893 after his death72.

Name and collecting

A modern sale catalogue, Aguttes's of 2023, calls him Arthur Joly de Bammeville and gives his dates as 1820-1892, and it is the only source found that gives his dates or ties the forename Arthur to the collector8. A man named Arthur Joly de Bammeville was a member of a Paris club in 18649. On 6 July 1858 an Arthur Joly de Bammeville married Louis-Germaine (so printed), born at Clairac10. The Gotha of 1881 names Caroline-Julie-Henriette, married in Paris on 30 November 1871, as the daughter of Arthur Joly de Bammeville and Sophie-Louise-Françoise née Coulomb11. These are the collector's family only if he is the Arthur that Aguttes names8.

Writing on pictures, Apollo in 1985 names an "E. Joly de Bammeville" of Paris, and whether he is the same man is not known12. It calls E. Joly de Bammeville a friend of Cardinal Newman and a convert to Catholicism, and "an enterprising, if rapacious collector"12. The same article says a Pintoricchio fresco in Siena was taken off the wall in 1842 or 1844 on his instruction12. Roberts records a Christie's sale of 57 pictures of E. J. de Bammeville on 12 June 185413. Beazley says a pair of Etruscan vases belonged to a Joly de Bammeville by 184314. Waterfield writes that Monsieur Joly de Bammeville, "a great linguist and connoisseur of art", stayed with the Duff Gordons in 185515.

A terracotta bust from Camiros had just entered, the Gazette archéologique reported, the "riche cabinet" of M. de Bammeville16. At the Paris Exposition universelle of 1878 his case held Greek terracotta statuettes, painted vases, marbles, bronzes and "sculptures cypriotes"5. Olivier Rayet singled out the red-figure kylix signed by Brygos that he showed there17. Le Figaro in 1885 called him "un amateur fervent" whose cases had great success in 187818.

The 1881 sale and the Opaon column

The sale opened on Wednesday 20 April 1881, with Delestre as auctioneer and Rollin and Feuardent as experts7. Their preface calls him one of the oldest Paris collectors, who had owned cup no. 216 for more than thirty years7. The Cypriot lots included limestone heads and a relief fragment "trouvé en Chypre" (nos. 94-98) and terracotta heads (nos. 100, 142-143)7. Lot 93 was a very archaic veiled female head set on a column shaft whose Greek inscription to Opaon Melanthios the catalogue transcribed7.

Salomon Reinach wrote in 1889 that the catalogue was plainly the work of a man who knew Greek badly, and that provenances were almost never given, "peut-être" because the owner, "plus artiste qu'archéologue", had not troubled to establish them19. Reinach judged that lot 93 joined a head and a column arbitrarily, and he treated only the column19. He reported on it at the Académie des inscriptions on 16 August 1889, showing that it came from near Paphos and that the god was Apollo2021.

The sources disagree on how the Louvre got the column, now MNB 306422. Reinach says the Louvre acquired no. 93, and Seymour de Ricci wrote in 1911 that it was bought at the Bammeville sale and held since 1881194. The Louvre's record gives a purchase in 1889 and lists the dealer Jean Henri Hoffmann, Luigi Palma di Cesnola and Joly de Bammeville as previous owners22. Olivier Masson wrote in 1971 that the Louvre acquired it at the dispersal of the collection "en 1889"23.

The find-place is also disputed: Reinach says Colonna-Ceccaldi gave the Salines near Larnaca, wrongly, and that Cesnola was right to give Palaeo-Paphos19. The Louvre gives Paphos, "sans doute Amargetti"22. De Ricci showed that an inscription Breccia published from Alexandria was the 1881 catalogue's transcription cut in stone4.

A second Cypriot piece of his, a Hellenistic limestone veiled female head, came to the Louvre as MNB 3231 by the bequest of Jacques-Edouard Gatteaux, dated 28 April 188124.

The 1893 sale

He was dead by June 1893, when "feu M. Joly de Bammeville"'s collection was sold at Drouot on 12-16 June with a catalogue by W. Froehner21. Its Cypriot lots included a terracotta Minerva head, a votary, a sleeping youth and limestone heads such as a laurel-crowned bearded head, no. 564, and a veiled priestess, no. 5652. Lot 66 was marked "Chypre, 1869"2. The Revue archéologique noted fake terracottas beside excellent pieces, and mediocre prices25. On 15 June 1893 Froehner bought a Cypriot head at the sale for Barracco; Hellmann says it became no. 67 of the Barracco catalogue, a "testa di sacerdote (?) coronato"1. Furniture, pictures and books were sold at his home, 26 rue Cambon, from 22 June 189326.

Life and work

  1. 1878

    1. Showed a case of Greek terracotta statuettes, painted vases, marbles, bronzes and Cypriot sculptures among the Champagne lenders at the Paris Exposition universelle (Trocadéro)

      Paris(1878). L'archéologie champenoise à l'Exposition universelle de 1878. Revue de Champagne et de Brie, p. 455

  2. 1881

    1. 20 April

      Collection sold at the Hôtel Drouot (Delestre, commissaire-priseur; Rollin and Feuardent, experts): 311 numbers in a 62-page catalogue without illustrations or author. No. 93, a veiled female head set on an inscribed column shaft (p. 23, under 'Pierres calcaires', followed by five Cypriot objects), went to the Louvre.

      ParisSalomon Reinach (1905). Cultes, mythes et religions, vol. 2: Apollon Opaon à Chypre. 284-287. Paris, pp. 285-286

  3. 1889

    1. 16 August

      Salomon Reinach reported to the Académie des inscriptions, from the sale catalogue, an inscription of the Paphos region dedicated to Opaon Melanthios; he showed the catalogue's transcription to be garbled and the column to be Colonna-Ceccaldi's 'Salines' text, which Cesnola gives as from Palaepaphos

      Paris(1889). Comptes rendus des séances de l'Académie des inscriptions et belles-lettres, séance du 16 août 1889. Comptes rendus de l'Académie des inscriptions et belles-lettres; Salomon Reinach (1905). Cultes, mythes et religions, vol. 2: Apollon Opaon à Chypre. 284-287. Paris, pp. 285-287

  4. 1893

    1. 12 June 1893 – 16 June 1893

      Posthumous sale of the collection ('feu M. Joly de Bammeville') at the Hôtel Drouot, 12-16 June 1893, Paul Chevallier commissaire-priseur, Rollin and Feuardent experts, catalogue by W. Froehner with 22 plates; Froehner bought a Cypriot head for Barracco (diary, 15 June 1893)

      ParisW. Froehner (1893). Collection de feu M. Joly de Bammeville: Antiquités égyptiennes, grecques, romaines, etc.. Paris, Hôtel Drouot (Chevallier; Rollin et Feuardent); Marie-Christine Hellmann (1991). W. Froehner et Chypre. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 16, 17-28, n. 36

  5. After 1893

    1911

    1. Seymour de Ricci showed that an inscription published by Breccia in Alexandria was the 1881 catalogue's garbled transcription of no. 93, cut on stone; he notes the Louvre has had the white marble colonnette since 1881

      Seymour de Ricci (1911). [Review of E. Breccia, Bulletin de la Société archéologique d'Alexandrie, fasc. 12]. Revue archéologique, 4e série 17, p. 853

  6. Undated

    n.d.

    1. Owned 2 objects ('statue ; objet votif', 'base'; inv. MNB 3231 and others), now in Musée du Louvre.

      Musée du Louvre collection online, inv. MNB 3231; MNB 3064

Connections

6 people

Objects

Mentioned in

8 mentions

Documents · 2

Sources

  1. 1.Marie-Christine Hellmann (1991). “W. Froehner et Chypre”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 16, 17-28. Online
  2. 2.W. Froehner (1893). Collection de feu M. Joly de Bammeville: Antiquités égyptiennes, grecques, romaines, etc.. Paris, Hôtel Drouot (Chevallier; Rollin et Feuardent).
  3. 3.Salomon Reinach (1905). Cultes, mythes et religions, vol. 2: Apollon Opaon à Chypre. 284-287. Paris.
  4. 4.Seymour de Ricci (1911). “[Review of E. Breccia, Bulletin de la Société archéologique d'Alexandrie, fasc. 12]”. Revue archéologique, 4e série 17.
  5. 5. (1878). “L'archéologie champenoise à l'Exposition universelle de 1878”. Revue de Champagne et de Brie.
  6. 6. (1889). “Comptes rendus des séances de l'Académie des inscriptions et belles-lettres, séance du 16 août 1889”. Comptes rendus de l'Académie des inscriptions et belles-lettres.
  7. 7.[Rollin et Feuardent, experts] (1881). Catalogue d'une collection de vases peints, marbres, pierres gravées, bronzes, terres cuites, objets du Moyen Âge, de la Renaissance, etc.. Paris, Hôtel Drouot (Delestre).
  8. 8.Aguttes (2023). Arts classiques, 6 décembre 2023. Aguttes, Neuilly-sur-Seine.
  9. 9.Charles Yriarte (1864). Les cercles de Paris, 1828-1864.
  10. 10.Vicomte Albert Révérend (1906). Titres, anoblissements et pairies de la Restauration, 1814-1830.
  11. 11. (1881). Gothaisches genealogisches Taschenbuch.
  12. 12. (1985). “[Article on early Italian paintings in English collections]”. Apollo, August 1985.
  13. 13.William Roberts (1897). Memorials of Christie's: a record of art sales from 1766 to 1896.
  14. 14.J. D. Beazley. Etruscan Vase-Painting.
  15. 15.Gordon Waterfield (ed.). Lucie Duff Gordon, Letters from Egypt 1862-1869 (enlarged centenary edition).
  16. 16.“[Buste estampé en terre cuite de Camiros, collection de M. de Bammeville]”. Gazette archéologique.
  17. 17.Olivier Rayet (1888). Études d'archéologie et d'art. Paris, Firmin-Didot.
  18. 18. (1885). “[Article on the Gréau sale and Paris collectors of antiquities]”. Le Figaro.
  19. 19.Salomon Reinach (1889). “Apollon Opaon à Chypre”. Revue des études grecques 2, 225-233.
  20. 20. (1889). “Académie des inscriptions (16 août)”. Le Temps.
  21. 21. (1889). “Académie des inscriptions et belles-lettres: séance”. Revue archéologique, 3e série 14.
  22. 22.Base (colonne votive, dédicace à Opâon Melanthios), inv. MNB 3064. Musée du Louvre, Département des Antiquités orientales. Online
  23. 23.Olivier Masson (1971). “Inscriptions chypriotes retrouvées ou disparues”. Syria 48. Online
  24. 24.Statue; objet votif (tête de femme), inv. MNB 3231. Musée du Louvre, Département des Antiquités orientales. Online
  25. 25. (1893). “[Note on the catalogue of the collection of the late Joly de Bammeville]”. Revue archéologique, 3e série 22.
  26. 26. (1893). Meubles anciens et de style ... provenant de la collection de feu M. Joly de Bammeville. Paris (Chevallier; Féral; Mannheim).
  27. 27.Musée du Louvre collection online.
  28. 28.Marie-Christine Hellmann, 1991, W. Froehner et Chypre, n. 36.
  29. 29.Revue Archeologique January-June 1911: Vol 17 (1911).
  30. 30.W. Froehner, 1893, Collection de feu M. Joly de Bammeville: Antiquités égyptiennes, grecques, romaines, etc., title page.
  31. 31.Salomon Reinach, 1905, Cultes, mythes et religions, vol. 2: Apollon Opaon à Chypre, p. 285; W. Froehner, 1893, Collection de feu M. Joly de Bammeville: Antiquités égyptiennes, grecques, romaines, etc., title page.
  32. 32.Salomon Reinach, 1905, Cultes, mythes et religions, vol. 2: Apollon Opaon à Chypre.
  33. 33.Le Matin : derniers télégrammes de la nuit (1889-08-17).
  34. 34.Association pour l'encouragement des études grecques en France, Revue des études grecques : publication trimestrielle de l'Association pour l'encouragement des études grecques (1889-07).
  35. 35.S. Reinach, 1889, Apollon Opaon à Chypre.
  36. 36.Journal des débats politiques et littéraires (1889-08-18).
  37. 37.La Chronique des arts et de la curiosité : supplément à la Gazette des beaux-arts (1889-09-28).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.