Other
Frederick A. P. Barnard
fl. 1880–1913 · United States
President of Columbia College who chaired the Metropolitan Museum committee of 1880-81 that found the charges against Cesnola's Cypriot collection without foundation.
Biography
Frederick A. P. Barnard, president of Columbia College, chaired the committee of 1880-81 that examined the charges against Luigi Palma di Cesnola's collection of Cypriot antiquities at the Metropolitan Museum6.
He was born at Sheffield, Massachusetts, on 5 May 18097,8. His father, Colonel Robert Foster Barnard, was a lawyer who several times sat in the senate of Massachusetts7. The military engineer General John Gross Barnard was his brother8. Barnard was at Yale College from 1824 to 18287. His biographer John Fulton writes that while at the Hartford Grammar School he found he was gradually becoming deaf, and that the affliction was hereditary7. Barnard was professor in the University of Alabama from 1837 to 1854, president of the University of Mississippi from 1856, and president of Columbia College from 1864 to 18898. In 1869 he was one of the vice-presidents of the meeting of 23 November that began the movement to found a museum of art in New York6.
The committee of 1880-81
At Cesnola's express wish, Winifred Howe writes, the trustees named two of their number, J. Q. A. Ward and William C. Prime, to join with themselves three men from outside the Board6. Barnard wrote to Gaston L. Feuardent, who had brought the charges, on 4 December 1880 to explain this arrangement9. With Charles P. Daly and Roswell D. Hitchcock he accepted the invitation, and he was made chairman6,9. Howe's "three chosen" are the three from outside the Board, and Anna Marangou writes that the trustees "appointed three men" but goes on to name five; The Art Amateur and the signed report list five members1,6,10,11.
When Feuardent asked to name a member, Barnard replied that the request was not one proper to put to the committee, "since they had nothing to do with their own appointment"10. The Art Amateur complained in January 1881 that Feuardent had not been allowed to nominate a single member10. According to The Century, the committee answered that it had no power to add to its numbers, and Feuardent "finally consented to appear"12. The Art Amateur wrote in December 1883 that when the committee's purposes "became manifest" he "absented himself from the meetings"18.
The committee met several times with Barnard in the chair, taking testimony and examining the objects13. On the evening of 5 January 1881, at Prime's house at 38 East Twenty-third Street, Cesnola read a long printed statement answering Feuardent14. Barnard asked him whether it was not sometimes a duty to make restorations, and whether he had made the repairs himself; Cesnola answered that they were made under his supervision and that he was responsible for them12. The photographer George C. Cox appeared on 22 January15.
The report, dated 26 January 1881, was signed by all five11. It says the committee soaked some repaired objects, took them apart and checked the fractured surfaces6. It found Cox's charges about the sarcophagus and a statue "without the slightest foundation"16. It judged that if Cesnola had erred at all, it was "in too rigidly refraining from making repairs whose correctness was reasonably certain", and found nothing "to cast a shadow" on the collection's reputation16. Howe writes that the report might well have seemed enough to silence the detractors, "but not so"6.
The trial of 1883
At the trial of Feuardent's suit against Cesnola in December 1883, Barnard was called as a witness for the prosecution and brought a large ear trumpet to the stand17. The New York Times wrote that the weight of his name had been depended upon to settle the controversy17. He testified, according to the Times, that he had read considerably about ancient art but was not an expert in archaeology, and had never seen or studied any collection of Cypriot antiquities except Cesnola's17. He said he had not studied that collection until the investigation began, and that the repairs did not show as they do on figures in European museums17. He had judged the head of the left sphinx to belong to the figure "because it happened to fit"17. Shown the Egyptian warrior, which had been soaked apart for the committee, he failed to recognise it, and said the head now did not seem to belong to the body17.
Cox testified that Prime had put an arm about Barnard's neck and assured him on his word of honour that the statue with a ball was as it came from the earth, a day after Prime had seen it in the repair-room with its head off3. The Art Amateur called the investigation "a farce" and said the committee had suppressed testimony offered for Feuardent18. In March 1884 it printed the view that the trial had shown the Barnard committee's investigation to be "a sham", its conclusions on the seven statues erroneous "in nearly every case"4.
The Century had already written in August 1882 that the report "followed minutely" Cesnola's defence, and that the committee examined only the few statues charged and did not call the repairer Gehlen or the two janitors12. Marangou judges that the members were not specialists in restoration1.
The Cyclopaedia article and last years
Barnard was editor-in-chief, with Arnold Guyot, of Johnson's Universal Cyclopaedia19. The article on Cesnola there is signed by Barnard19. It says the committee reported in January 1881 that all the charges were "totally groundless", and that the jury's verdict was one "completely vindicating Gen. Di Cesnola"19. Barnard closed the article by saying that later aspersions were "written by persons of no consideration with the public"19.
On 7 May 1888 he resigned the presidency of Columbia College, citing "advancing years and unstable health"7. Barnard died at his residence on the College grounds on 27 April 18897,8. His funeral was held at St Thomas' Church, and he was buried at Sheffield7.
Life and work
1880
October
Cesnola, in October 1880, asked the Executive Committee of the trustees for an investigation of Feuardent's charges (published Aug 1880 in The Art Amateur); at the trustees' request the inquiry was undertaken by President F. A. P. Barnard (head, per Marangou; Columbia College), Dr Roswell D. Hitchcock, Judge Charles P. Daly, J. Q. A. Ward and William C. Prime. Feuardent was invited but not allowed to nominate a member, and stopped attending when the committee's purpose, in his and the magazine's view, became clear.New York(1884). The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97, p. 96; (1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement). The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b, p. 4a; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, p. 309
- President of Columbia College; member of the 1880-81 committee that found Feuardent's charges groundless; Prime assured him a restored statue was unaltered.
1881
5 January
Committee hearing at which Cesnola, per the Art Amateur, declared: 'In the entire collection I have not made a single restoration of any object or part of any object in stone.' (Lawrence Kane, a Times reporter, testified that Cesnola read a reply to the committee at W. C. Prime's house in East 23rd Street and handed out printed slips.) The committee 'unanimously reported that the charges were without foundation'; Cesnola sent Newton a printed copy of the report on 27 Jan 1881.New York(1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement). The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b, pp. 4a-4b; (1883). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24, p. 23; A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds, pp. 309-311
February
The Mar. 1884 report quotes the committee's finding that 'each and all of the charges are without foundation' and that if Cesnola had erred it was 'in too rigidly refraining from making repairs where correctness was reasonably certain'; The Sun, reprinted there after the 1884 verdict, said the testimony at trial had 'conclusively demonstrated that the investigation of the Barnard committee was a sham', that its conclusions on the seven statues it specially examined were in nearly every case wrong (statue 22's hand is attached by a wooden dowel; the reunion of No. 39 doubtful; the mirror of the 'Venus' cut into the ancient surface).New York(1884). The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97, p. 96
c. 1881
Trial witnesses for Feuardent, as reported: the photographer George C. Cox said Prime took President Barnard of Columbia College to the statue with a ball in its hand and, with an arm round Barnard's neck, said 'I'll show you a statue which, on my word of honor as a man, is just as it was taken from the earth', the day after Cox had seen that statue in the repair-room with its head off; Cox also said the committee declined his offer to show restorations he had seen. Dickson B. Alley said only statue No. 40 was soaked, and that Alley, Henkel and Lennon were never called.New York(1884). The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56, p. 55
Connections
7 peopleColleagues & contacts
- Worked with Charles Patrick Dalycommittee of inquiry (Barnard chaired) Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904, p. 3091880–1881
- Connected with Gaston Louis Feuardentcommittee examining Feuardent's charges; Feuardent was invited, could not nominate a member and absented himself 1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4a1880–1881
- Worked with John Quincy Adams Wardcommittee of inquiry 1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4a; 1884, End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (what has been proved; Mr. Russell Sturgis contradicts Mr. Di Cesnola), p. 961880–1881
- Connected with Luigi Palma di Cesnolachaired the committee that examined Feuardent's charges against the Director's restorations and found them without foundation 1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4a; 1884, End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (what has been proved; Mr. Russell Sturgis contradicts Mr. Di Cesnola), p. 96; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904, p. 3091880–1881
- Worked with Roswell Dwight Hitchcockcommittee of inquiry 1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4a; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904, p. 3091880–1881
- Worked with William Cowper PrimeMetropolitan Museum trustees' committee of inquiry 1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4a; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904, p. 3091880–1881
- Worked with Percy E. NewberryAnnals of Archaeology and Anthropology Vol. V Annals of Archaeology and Anthropology 1913: Vol 51913
Mentioned in
14 mentionsDocuments · 6
- A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, with a chapter on the early institutions of art in New York
Howe 1913
- The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds
Marangou 2000
- The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial
1884
- The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial
1883
- The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial
1884
- The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement)
1883
Institutions · 2
- Metropolitan Museum of Art
Head of the trustees' committee of inquiry · 1880
Marangou 2000, p. 309
- Columbia University
President
Marangou 2000, p. 309
- People · 6listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.A. G. Marangou (ed.) (2000). The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds.
- 2. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement)”. The Art Amateur 10, 4a-4b. Online
- 3. (1884). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 55-56. Online
- 4. (1884). “The End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 96-97. Online
- 5. (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur 10, 23-24. Online
- 6.Winifred E. Howe (1913). A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, with a chapter on the early institutions of art in New York. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
- 7.John Fulton. Memoirs of Frederick A. P. Barnard, tenth president of Columbia College in the city of New York.
- 8.Benjamin E. Smith (ed.). The Century Dictionary and Cyclopedia: The Century Cyclopedia of Names. The Century Co..
- 9. (1895). “[Retrospect of the Feuardent charges and the 1880-81 committee]”. The New York Times 44.
- 10. (1881). “[Editorial on the committee of inquiry into the Cesnola collection]”. The Art Amateur 4.
- 11. (1881). “[Text of the committee's report on the Cesnola collection]”. The New York Times 30.
- 12.The Century Magazine (1882). “[On the Cesnola collection controversy]”. The Century Illustrated Monthly Magazine, vol. 2 (n.s.).
- 13. (1881). “The inquiry into the charges against General di Cesnola”. The American Art Review 2.
- 14. (1881). “[Report of the committee session of 5 January 1881 on the Cesnola collection]”. The New York Times 30.
- 15. (1881). “[Mr. Cox's testimony before the committee]”. The New York Times 30.
- 16.F. A. P. Barnard, J. Q. A. Ward, Charles P. Daly, W. C. Prime, Roswell D. Hitchcock (1881). “[Report of the committee on the charges against the Cesnola collection, 26 January 1881]”. bound with Metropolitan Museum of Art, Hand-book No. 3: Sculptures of the Cesnola Collection of Cypriote Antiquities.
- 17. (1883). “Mr. Barnard on the stand: work of the investigating committee at the Metropolitan Museum”. The New York Times 33.
- 18.The Art Amateur (1883). “The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial”. The Art Amateur, vol. 10 no. 1, December 1883, editorial supplement.
- 19.Frederick A. P. Barnard and Arnold Guyot (eds) (1886). Johnson's (Revised) Universal Cyclopaedia. A. J. Johnson & Co..
- 20.Art Amateur 10 (Dec. 1883), Editorial Supplement, 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 4a-4b; Art Amateur 10 (Jan. 1884), 'The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 55-56; Art Amateur 10 (Mar. 1884), 'End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial', pp. 95-97 (with The Sun editorial, Sturgis's letter and extracts of the defendant's printed testimony).
- 21.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904.
- 22.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4a; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904.
- 23.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4a; 1884, End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (what has been proved; Mr. Russell Sturgis contradicts Mr. Di Cesnola).
- 24.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883), p. 4a; 1884, End of the Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (what has been proved; Mr. Russell Sturgis contradicts Mr. Di Cesnola), p. 96; Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904.
- 25.1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883).
- 26.Annals of Archaeology and Anthropology 1913: Vol 5.
- 27.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904: Life and Deeds(p. 309).
- 28.Anna G. Marangou, 2000, Life and Deeds: The Consul Luigi Palma di Cesnola 1832-1904, p. 309; 1883, The Feuardent-Cesnola Trial (Editorial Supplement, December 1883).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Dates of birth and death unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.