Numismatist · Scholar · Collector

Charles Theodore Seltman

1886–1957 · United Kingdom

Cambridge numismatist (1886-1957) who sold coins from the Dali find to Boston, published a hoard from Side with Cypriote pieces, and wrote on Cypriot coins and copper ingots.

Biography

Charles Theodore Seltman was a British historian of ancient Greece and numismatist4.

Life

Seltman was born in 1886, the son of Ernest John Seltman, who gave him his enthusiasm for ancient Greece and Greek coins54. Wikipedia gives his birth as 4 August 1886 in Paddington3. He married Isabel Dane in 1917, entered Queens' College, Cambridge, the following year, and graduated with honours in classical archaeology in 19225. The Dictionary of Art Historians records that he became a lecturer at Queens' in 1926 and was Norton lecturer of the Archaeological Institute of America in 1929-19305. He was elected a Fellow of Queens' in 1933, lived in college after his wife died in 1935, and became its librarian in 19365. According to Wikipedia, the Royal Numismatic Society gave him its medal in 1945, and he died in Cambridge on 28 June 19573. The Times printed his obituary on 29 June 19575.

Coins from Dali and the Side hoard

On 2 October 1919 the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, bought three coins, 19.1333-19.1335, from C. T. Seltman for $101.25 in all6. Museum files say that two of them, a tetrobol of Idalion and a stater of Paphos, came from the find at Dali made by Sir R. Hamilton Lang67.

In the autumn of 1922 a refugee from Eski-Adalia, the ancient Side, brought to Greece a small hoard of mainly fifth-century coins, which he said had held 26 silver pieces and a gold and carbuncle bracelet "of Cypriote type"8. Seltman studied the bracelet and 18 of the coins in Athens, and published them in 1924 with the American Numismatic Society8. He picked out two Cypriote pieces: a rare stater of Ba'alram, king of Citium, and a silver finger-ring of "Cypriote fabric" with lion-head ends9. The Ba'alram stater was held by Petsalis of Athens, while two other staters of the hoard were listed under Seltman, Cambridge98. Seltman showed that it was overstruck on an Aeginetan "tortoise" that cannot have been issued before 404 BC, and said it "may possibly be the latest coin in the find"9. Sydney P. Noe recorded in 1925 that the hoard was dispersed10.

Writing on Cyprus

His 1909 Synopsis of the Coins of Antigonus I and Demetrius Poliorcetes recalls that after Demetrius's naval victory off Salamis in 306 BC Antigonus took the title of king11. In Athens, its History and Coinage (1924) Seltman held it "very probable" that the copper ingots of Cyprus and Hellas were base-metal equivalents of the gold talent, and reckoned that in Cyprus 37,000 grammes of copper were given for a gold talent12.

The editors of the first Cambridge Ancient History volume of plates (1927) credited Seltman with its collection and arrangement; it shows a vase from Cyprus in the Fitzwilliam and a gold "dump" from Old Salamis as Bronze Age currency2. In Greek Coins (1933) he saw an intermingling of art traditions on Cypriot coins, with Egyptian signs such as the ankh beside Ionian Greek types, and noted that the Greeks of Cyprus kept the "clumsy old Cypriote syllabary"13. In The Twelve Olympians (1952) he wrote that Aphrodite's worship was carried "certainly by Phoenicians" from Cyprus to Cythera14.

Judgements

Edward T. Newell (1927) called the 1909 Synopsis an advance, but only a synopsis, some of whose conclusions "must be accepted with great care" because they rest on assumptions that cannot be proved15. Newell also found that a tetradrachm Seltman published in 1909 was an ordinary Alexander coin with the name re-engraved in modern times15. The Antiquity reviewer of Greek Coins called it the clearest handbook available at a modest price, but found Seltman "a little dogmatic" in some matters and, in one Athenian attribution, "frank theory posing as fact"16.

On the ingots, George F. Bass (1961) set out the currency view, citing Seltman, and found another explanation "more likely", noting that Seltman had also explained their rough surfaces by casting17. Gale and Stos-Gale (1986) say Bass showed that the ingots were not an early form of currency18. The Dictionary of Art Historians, citing H. J. Rose, says his popular articles were modestly researched and sometimes held factual errors5.

In 1926 Seltman also helped sell a marble "Minoan goddess" to the Fitzwilliam Museum; Butcher and Gill (1993) judge that he had "a personal financial interest" in it and "wanted to sell it", and say the debate over its authenticity is over519. Kenneth Lapatin writes that Seltman acquired the Toronto ivory "goddess" from Feuardent in Paris and sold it to Currelly for £275020.

Life and work

  1. 1919

    1. Sold 2 objects (among them 'Tetrobol of Idalion with seated sphinx, struck under Stasikypros', inv. 19.1334) to Museum of Fine Arts, Boston in 1919; now in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

      Museum of Fine Arts, Boston collection online, inv. 19.1334; 19.1335

  2. 1922

    1. October

      Studied in Athens a small hoard of fifth-century silver coins from Side (Pamphylia), brought to Greece by a refugee from Eski-Adalia in autumn 1922, with a gold and carbuncle bracelet of Cypriote type; he later published it as 'A Hoard from Side'.

      AthensC. T. Seltman (1924). A Hoard from Side. American Numismatic Society, Numismatic Notes and Monographs, nos. 16-23

  3. 1924

    1. 'A Hoard from Side' published in the American Numismatic Society's Numismatic Notes and Monographs (volumes 16-23 bound together); lists coins held by Seltman in Cambridge among the specimens.

      C. T. Seltman (1924). A Hoard from Side. American Numismatic Society, Numismatic Notes and Monographs, nos. 16-23

  4. Undated

    n.d.

    1. Owned 2 objects ('Tetrobol of Idalion with seated sphinx, struck under Stasikypros', 'Stater of Paphos with standing bull, struck under Pny[...]'; inv. 19.1334 and others), now in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

      Museum of Fine Arts, Boston collection online, inv. 19.1334; 19.1335

Mentioned in

1 mention

Sources

  1. 1.C. T. Seltman (1924). “A Hoard from Side”. American Numismatic Society, Numismatic Notes and Monographs, nos. 16-23.
  2. 2.C. T. Seltman (preparer) (1927). The Cambridge Ancient History: Volume of Plates I. Cambridge University Press.
  3. 3.Wikipedia. Charles Seltman. Online
  4. 4.British Museum. Charles Theodore Seltman [biographical record BIOG98301]. Online
  5. 5.Dictionary of Art Historians. Seltman, Charles Theodore. Online
  6. 6.Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Tetrobol of Idalion, accession 19.1334 [collection record]. Online
  7. 7.Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Stater of Paphos, accession 19.1335 [collection record]. Online
  8. 8.C. T. Seltman (1924). “A Hoard from Side”. Numismatic Notes and Monographs. American Numismatic Society.
  9. 9.C. T. Seltman (1924). “A Hoard from Side”. Numismatic Notes and Monographs 22. American Numismatic Society.
  10. 10.Sydney P. Noe (1925). “A Bibliography of Greek Coin Hoards”. Numismatic Notes and Monographs. American Numismatic Society.
  11. 11.Charles T. Seltman (1909). “A Synopsis of the Coins of Antigonus I and Demetrius Poliorcetes”. Numismatic Chronicle 4th series, 9, 264-273.
  12. 12.Charles T. Seltman (1924). Athens, its History and Coinage before the Persian Invasion. Cambridge University Press.
  13. 13.Charles Seltman (1933). Greek Coins: A History of Metallic Currency and Coinage down to the Fall of the Hellenistic Kingdoms. Methuen.
  14. 14.Charles Seltman (1952). The Twelve Olympians: Gods and Goddesses of Greece.
  15. 15.Edward T. Newell (1927). The Coinages of Demetrius Poliorcetes.
  16. 16. (1933). “[Review of Charles Seltman, Greek Coins]”. Antiquity 7, 358.
  17. 17.George F. Bass (1961). “The Cape Gelidonya Wreck: Preliminary Report”. American Journal of Archaeology 65.
  18. 18.N. H. Gale and Z. A. Stos-Gale (1986). “Oxhide Copper Ingots in Crete and Cyprus and the Bronze Age Metals Trade”. Annual of the British School at Athens 81, 81-100. Online
  19. 19.Kevin Butcher and David W. J. Gill (1993). “The Director, the Dealer, the Goddess, and Her Champions: The Acquisition of the Fitzwilliam Goddess”. American Journal of Archaeology 97, 383-401. Online
  20. 20.Kenneth Lapatin. Mysteries of the Snake Goddess: Art, Desire, and the Forging of History.
  21. 21.Museum of Fine Arts, Boston collection online.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.