Book · 1999

Faunal Extinction in an Island Society: Pygmy Hippopotamus Hunters of Cyprus

Alan H. Simmons

New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum

An excavation report on Akrotiri Aetokremnos, a rockshelter on the Akrotiri Peninsula, with its stratigraphy, artifacts, fauna and radiocarbon dates, assessing human presence before the Aceramic Neolithic.

Simmons and associates report the investigations at Akrotiri Aetokremnos, a collapsed rockshelter on the Akrotiri Peninsula, and ask whether its artifacts and faunal remains document human presence before the Aceramic Neolithic. Excavation results sit alongside stratigraphic, environmental, artifact, faunal, radiocarbon and comparative analyses, and the closing chapters place the site in the early occupation of Cyprus and in the extinction of the island's endemic fauna.

How it is organised

The 13 chapters move from research context and site methods to geoarchaeology, archaeological stratigraphy, features, artifacts and fauna. Later chapters treat dating, specialized analyses, additional investigations on the Akrotiri Peninsula, chipped-stone comparisons, interpretations of the site, and its function and significance. References and an index follow the main text (pp. 337–381).

The evidence

The record includes sediment and stratigraphic descriptions, cultural features and loci, chipped and ground stone, ornaments, worked bone and intrusive artifacts. The faunal chapters examine mammals, birds, reptiles, fish, marine invertebrates and land snails; the authors call this analysis preliminary, with fuller treatment planned in a separate volume by David Reese (pp. 49–161).

Specialist studies add spatial distributions, blood residues, pumice, and plant evidence from phytoliths, flotation and pollen. A 1991 survey and test excavations extend the investigation to other parts of the Akrotiri Peninsula, and a later chapter compares the Aetokremnos chipped stone with Cypriot and Levantine assemblages.

Dating

The dating chapter evaluates 31 radiocarbon determinations from different materials and discusses contamination and a proposed correction of 334 years for eastern Mediterranean marine-shell dates. On this evidence Wigand and Simmons place the occupation in the tenth millennium BCE, as a relatively short period of use, and on their account it predates the documented Aceramic Neolithic occupation of Cyprus (pp. 193–215).

The argument

Simmons and colleagues hold that the artifacts and fauna are associated in a cultural context, and they defend this reading against explanations in which the remains accumulated naturally and the artifacts arrived by chance. They interpret the bird remains as evidence for open grassland and marsh around the site, a reconstruction they limit to its immediate surroundings, and the marine shells, chiefly Monodonta and Patella, are food debris. They read Aetokremnos as a place of intensive Phanourios processing rather than a kill site, possibly also a storage base, and acknowledge uncertainty about seasonality and hunting methods (pp. 303–318).

For the extinction of Phanourios, they conclude that human predation was probably the main factor at Aetokremnos, interacting with environmental change; their speculative model of the peninsula's population, animal density, meat yield and dietary needs supports the discussion. Their discussion allows that occupation may have lasted several hundred years, perhaps less, and considers declining resources and deterioration of the rockshelter as possible reasons for abandonment.

They favour a Levantine source for the occupants, though they present the proposal as tentative, and prefer regionally defined terminology for the early assemblages until further evidence arrives (pp. 319–336).

What it records

  • David J. Nixon discovered the Aetokremnos deposit in 1961 while exploring the cliffs of the Akrotiri Peninsula.p. 1
  • The surviving interior surface of the Aetokremnos rockshelter measured less than 35 square metres.p. 37
  • The Aetokremnos excavation took place in 1987, 1988 and 1990, followed by a survey in 1991.p. 44
  • Model 2, a cultural occupation predating the documented Cypriot Aceramic Neolithic, is the project's best fit for the available data.p. 44
  • Aetokremnos has 11 documented features.p. 95
  • Feature 3 held over 62,500 Phanourios bones, representing at least 50 individuals.p. 101
  • Microflakes are defined as under 15 mm long, with characteristic debitage attributes such as tiny bulbs and platforms.p. 124
  • A pierced calcarenite disk from Stratum 2/4 in unit N98E87 measures 105 mm long and 7 mm thick.p. 150
  • David Reese suggests that the pierced calcarenite disk served as a platform for making stone and shell beads or pendants.p. 150
  • The Aetokremnos faunal summary lists 218,459 Phanourios specimens, with a minimum of 505 individuals.p. 157
  • The Aetokremnos faunal summary lists 229 pygmy elephant specimens, with a minimum of three individuals.p. 157
  • The Aetokremnos bird assemblage comprises 3,205 fragments, 529 of them identifiable, representing a minimum of 73 birds.p. 170
  • The Aetokremnos marine-shell collection comprises 73,365 fragments representing 21,576 individuals, chiefly Monodonta and Patella.p. 188
  • Wigand and Simmons place the relatively short occupation in the tenth millennium BCE, centred near calibrated 9825 BCE.p. 208
  • A correction of 334 years is proposed to bring marine-shell dates into line with charcoal dates.p. 210
  • Sandra Olsen observed no reliable evidence of butchery in the 16,601 bone fragments she examined.p. 233
  • Aetokremnos is read as the locus of intensive Phanourios processing and not as a kill site, in Simmons and colleagues' interpretation.p. 318
  • Simmons and colleagues find no chronological evidence for a direct ancestral relationship between the Akrotiri Phase and the Khirokitia Culture.p. 322
  • The Akrotiri Peninsula is estimated at roughly 108 square kilometres for the authors' speculative population model.p. 329
  • Human predation appears to have been the overriding factor in the extinction of Phanourios at Aetokremnos, the authors conclude.p. 333
  • Regionally defined characterizations such as the Akrotiri Phase are, in Simmons and colleagues' view, the most realistic solution until more data are available.p. 335

Where to read

  • Aetokremnos discovery, dating problem and archaeological backgroundpp. 1–31
  • Excavation strategy, field methods and recovery procedurespp. 37–48
  • Sediment sources, stratigraphic units and site formationpp. 49–69
  • Features, hearths, shell concentrations and locipp. 95–121
  • Chipped-stone classification and thumbnail scraperspp. 123–145
  • Faunal identifications, distribution and environmental interpretationpp. 153–191
  • Radiocarbon samples, date reliability and proposed reservoir correctionpp. 195–215
  • Human association, proposed site function and Phanourios extinctionpp. 283–336

Contents

  • Chapter 1. Introduction and Research Context1
  • The Problem1
  • Environmental and Ecological Context6
  • The Akrotiri Peninsula8
  • Paleoenvironment11
  • Chapter 2. Site Description, Research Design, and Methodology33
  • Chapter 3. Stratigraphy and SedimentologyRolfe D. Mandel49
  • Chapter 4. Archaeological StratigraphyAlan H. Simmons, Rolfe D. Mandel71
  • Chapter 5. Cultural Features and LociAlan H. Simmons, David S. Reese95
  • Chapter 6. The Artifact Assemblage from Aetokremnos123
  • Chipped Stone Artifacts123
  • Ground Stone ArtifactsStuart Swiny146
  • Stone OrnamentsDavid Reese149
  • The Pierced Calcarenite DiskDavid Reese150
  • Worked BoneDavid Reese151
  • Chapter 7. The Faunal Assemblages153
  • AvifaunaCécile Mourer-Chauviré170
  • The Dating of Akortiri AetokremnosPeter Wigand, Alan H. Simmons193
  • Specialized Analyses217
  • Additional Archaeological Investigations on the Akrotiri PeninsulaAlan H. Simmons, Michael Neeley, David S. Reese239
  • A Comparative Study of the Aetokremnos Chipped Stone259
  • Bitter Hippos of Cyprus?283
  • The Function of Akrotiri Aetokremnos and Its Place in Colonization and Extinction Events303
  • Origins and Colonization319
  • Extinction323
  • A Speculative Model for Phanourios Extinction on the Akrotiri Peninsula328
  • Conclusions332
  • Final Remarks334
  • References337
  • Index367

Objects published here

7
  • Grooved oval beach cobble, possibly a net sinker, Scree several metres below the shelter, FN 62, Fig. 6-7 (p. 147)
  • Pierced calcarenite disk, Stratum 2/4, unit N98E87, Fig. 6-10 (p. 150)
  • Worked Phanourios upper incisor, probably worn as a pendant, Stratum 4B, N96E87 (p. 151)
  • Unbroken axe or pick, Surface of the site, slightly downslope from the shelter (p. 144)
  • Picrolite pendants, bead, pendant fragment and worked piece, Aetokremnos, Figs. 6-8 and 6-9 (p. 149)
  • Genet left maxilla fragment, Stratum 4B, N95E89, northwest quadrant, FN 720, Fig. 7-9 (p. 168)
  • Thumbnail scraper positive to antihuman serum, Stratum 2, FN 984 (p. 224)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

Places

  • Akrotiri Aetokremnosexcavated rockshelter and principal case study
  • Akrotiri Peninsulasurvey area and regional setting
  • KhirokitiaAceramic Neolithic comparison site
  • Petra tou LimnitiNeolithic settlement discussed
  • Kouris Riverpossible source of lithic material
  • Akrotiri Salt Lakelocal palaeoenvironmental setting
  • Levantproposed source region for the occupants
  • Cape Andreas KastrosAceramic Neolithic comparison site
  • Kholetria OrtosAceramic Neolithic lithic comparison
  • Madagascarcomparison for island extinctions
  • Sardiniacomparison for island faunal extinction
  • Mallorcacomparison for human and Myotragus coexistence

Also named: Mark Rose, Martin R. Rose.

Extent Figures throughout; location and site maps; references pp. 337–365; index pp. 367–381

Defines Akrotiri Phase, Akrotiri rockshelter strata 1–5, thumbnail scraper, microflake, primary flake or blade, secondary flake or blade, tertiary blade or flake, casual hearth, locus, Akrotiri cores, extinction, extirpation

Cyprus Before HumansNeolithicAnimalsChronology and DatingLandscape and ClimateFood and FarmingTechnology

Chapters in our registers

2 in our registers

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

6 pages

Excavations it is cited for

1 project

Who did what

59 records

Buying, selling and giving 4

  • David J. NixonAcquired

    David J. Nixon collected several of the chipped stone artifacts he found at Aetokremnos.

    several chipped stone artifacts

    1961 · p. 1
  • David J. NixonPassed objects toBritish Museum (Natural History)

    David J. Nixon brought the objects he collected to the British Museum (Natural History).

    several chipped stone artifactsLondon

    p. 1
  • Stuart SwinyAcquired

    Stuart Swiny collected exposed marine shell and Phanourios bones during a visit to the site.

    Aetokremnos

    p. 4
  • Brian PileAcquired

    Brian Pile collected artifacts, particularly chipped stone, from most of the sites he surveyed.

    Akrotiri Peninsula

    p. 240

Excavation 20

  • David J. NixonFound

    David J. Nixon came across the Aetokremnos deposit and found bones and chipped stone artifacts.

    bones and chipped stone artifacts at the Aetokremnos depositAetokremnos, Akrotiri Peninsula

    1961 · p. 1
  • Brian PileSurveyed

    Brian Pile conducted an archaeological survey of portions of the Akrotiri Peninsula.

    1981 · p. 3, 240
  • Brian PileFound

    Brian Pile rediscovered Aetokremnos during his survey.

    Aetokremnos siteAkrotiri Peninsula

    1981 · p. 3
  • Arthur Hubert Stanley MegawSurveyed

    A. Megaw and J. Last conducted an archaeological survey of the Akrotiri Peninsula.

    Archaeological sites on the Akrotiri Peninsula

    1954 · p. 239
  • J. S. LastSurveyed

    J. Last and A. Megaw conducted an archaeological survey of the Akrotiri Peninsula.

    Archaeological sites on the Akrotiri Peninsula

    1954 · p. 239
  • Alan H. SimmonsSurveyed

    Alan H. Simmons conducted a survey of the Akrotiri Peninsula during three weeks in July.

    Akrotiri Peninsula archaeological sites

    1991 · p. 241
  • Alan H. SimmonsExcavated

    Alan H. Simmons participated in test excavations at three small sites previously recorded by Pile.

    Three small archaeological sitesAkrotiri Peninsula

    1990 · p. 243
  • David S. ReeseExcavated

    David Reese participated in test excavations at three small sites previously recorded by Pile.

    Three small archaeological sitesAkrotiri Peninsula

    1990 · p. 243
  • Michael NeeleyExcavated

    Michael Neeley participated in test excavations at three small sites previously recorded by Pile.

    Three small archaeological sitesAkrotiri Peninsula

    1990 · p. 243
  • Brian PileFormed a collection

    Pile made a 1980 surface collection at Site 2.

    1980 · p. 245
  • Alan H. SimmonsExcavated

    Alan H. Simmons's team collected material and conducted test excavations at Site 2.

    Marine shells and artifacts at Site 2

    1990 · p. 245
  • Brian PileFormed a collection

    Pile collected several chipped stone artifacts during the survey that recorded Site 2.

    Chipped stone artifacts from Site 2

    p. 245
  • Brian PileFormed a collection

    Pile's collection for Site 3 contained chipped stone artifacts, including thumbnail scrapers and exhausted cores.

    Chipped stone artifacts from Site 3

    p. 251
  • Alan H. SimmonsExcavated

    Alan H. Simmons's team conducted test operations at Site 23 and recovered a small chipped stone assemblage.

    Chipped stone assemblage from Site 23

    p. 256
  • Brian PileFormed a collection

    Pile collected artifacts labeled as Site 23b.

    Chipped stone artifacts

    p. 256
Show 5 more
  • Brian PileFormed a collection

    possiblySwiny's account was cited for Pile's apparent collection of additional tools from Site 23.

    Other tools from Site 23

    p. 256
  • Alan H. SimmonsExcavated

    Alan Simmons and his collaborators excavated nearly the entire Aetokremnos site over three years.

    1987–1990 · p. vii
  • Alan H. SimmonsExcavated withDavid S. Reese

    David S. Reese participated with Alan H. Simmons in all three excavation seasons.

    AetokremnosAetokremnos

    p. xiii
  • Alan H. SimmonsExcavated withSteve Held

    Steve Held participated with Alan H. Simmons in all three excavation seasons as field director.

    AetokremnosAetokremnos

    p. xiii
  • Steve HeldDirected excavations

    Steve Held served as field director during the Aetokremnos excavation seasons.

    Aetokremnos site

    p. xiii

Recording and study 34

  • Stuart SwinyGuidedAlan H. Simmons

    Stuart Swiny led Alan H. Simmons down the cliff to Aetokremnos.

    1985 · p. 1
  • Kenneth P. OakleyStudied

    Kenneth Oakley indicated an assessment of the flints brought to the museum.

    flints brought by David J. NixonBritish Museum (Natural History), London

    p. 1
  • David J. NixonCorresponded withCypriot Department of Antiquities

    David J. Nixon wrote to the department to inform it of his discovery.

    Nicosia

    p. 3
  • Stuart SwinyStudied

    Stuart Swiny examined Aetokremnos after Brian Pile rediscovered it.

    Aetokremnos site

    p. 3, 146
  • Stuart SwinyRecorded

    Stuart Swiny submitted three samples for radiocarbon dating.

    three samples of marine shell and boneAetokremnos

    p. 4
  • Alan H. SimmonsWorked withDeborah Olszewski

    Alan H. Simmons and Deborah Olszewski conducted detailed chipped stone analyses.

    chipped stone artifacts from AetokremnosAetokremnos

    p. 48
  • Alan H. SimmonsWorked withGeoffrey Clark

    Alan H. Simmons and Geoffrey Clark conducted detailed chipped stone analyses.

    chipped stone artifacts from AetokremnosAetokremnos

    p. 48
  • Alan H. SimmonsStudied

    Alan H. Simmons conducted detailed analyses of the Aetokremnos chipped stone artifacts.

    chipped stone artifacts from Aetokremnos

    p. 48
  • David S. ReeseStudied

    David S. Reese conducted analyses of the Aetokremnos megafauna and shells.

    p. 48, 156
  • Deborah OlszewskiStudied

    Deborah Olszewski conducted detailed analyses of the Aetokremnos chipped stone artifacts with Alan Simmons and Geoffrey Clark.

    chipped stone artifacts from Aetokremnos

    p. 48
  • Geoffrey ClarkStudied

    Geoffrey Clark conducted detailed analyses of the Aetokremnos chipped stone artifacts with Alan Simmons and Deborah Olszewski.

    chipped stone artifacts from Aetokremnos

    p. 48
  • Rolfe D. MandelStudied

    Rolfe D. Mandel investigated Aetokremnos strata and sediments to assess their sources, transport, and postdepositional modification.

    sediments and strata within and above the collapsed rockshelter

    p. 49, 287
  • Teresa SilenceStudied

    Teresa Silence studied the mineralogy, sphericity, and roundness of sand grains from Aetokremnos.

    sand grains from Aetokremnos sedimentsUniversity of Nebraska-Omaha

    p. 51
  • C. XenophontosStudied

    Xenophontos examined a sample of chipped stone from Aetokremnos.

    a sample of the Aetokremnos chipped stone

    p. 129
  • Dr. J. SheaStudied

    Shea examined a sample of three Aetokremnos artifacts.

    p. 136
Show 19 more
  • Jean-Christophe AuffrayStudied

    Jean-Christophe Auffray examined mouse remains from Aetokremnos.

    Aetokremnos mouse remainsNo. FN 978

    p. 169
  • Karel J. SteensmaStudied

    Karel Steensma compared the Aetokremnos maxilla fragment with a juvenile Genetta genetta skull.

    Aetokremnos genet maxilla fragment and comparative genet skullNo. NNML, no. 1685

    p. 169
  • Cécile Mourer-ChauviréStudied

    Cécile Mourer-Chauviré analysed the Aetokremnos avifaunal collection.

    Aetokremnos bird bone collection

    p. 170
  • Salvador BailonStudied

    Salvador Bailon studied the amphibian and reptile remains from Aetokremnos.

    Aetokremnos amphibian and reptile remains

    p. 182
  • Roger BourStudied

    Roger Bour identified the tortoise remains recovered at Aetokremnos.

    Aetokremnos terrestrial turtle remains

    p. 187
  • Rolfe D. MandelStudied

    Mandel's geological testing indicated that deposition rates near the Akrotiri cliffs could be rapid.

    Aetokremnos geological deposits

    p. 194
  • Stephen R. DurandStudied

    Stephen Durand analysed the distributions of artifacts and subsistence remains at Aetokremnos.

    Aetokremnos artifact and subsistence-remain distributions

    p. 217
  • Vincenzo M. FrancavigliaStudied

    Vincenzo Francaviglia compared two Aetokremnos pumice pieces with Mediterranean pyroclastics to investigate their provenance and age.

    No. FN 426; SFN 66

    p. 224
  • David RhodeStudied

    David Rhode performed phytolith extraction on two sediment samples from Aetokremnos.

    p. 229
  • Julie HansenStudied

    Julie Hansen examined seven flotation samples and identified small amounts of plant remains.

    Aetokremnos

    p. 229
  • Peter E. WigandStudied

    Peter Wigand examined pollen samples from Aetokremnos.

    Aetokremnos pollen samples

    p. 229
  • Sandra OlsenStudied

    Sandra Olsen examined Phanourios bones for evidence of butchery and taphonomic processes during the 1990 excavations.

    16,601 Phanourios bone fragmentsNo. FN 359, FN 367, FN 451, FN 490Aetokremnos

    1990 · p. 230
  • Alan H. SimmonsStudied

    Alan H. Simmons reclassified an artifact as a large secondary flake with some battering.

    Site 23

    p. 256
  • Alan H. SimmonsStudied

    Alan H. Simmons examined the Kyrenia material in Nicosia.

    Kyrenia materials

    p. 260
  • Alan H. SimmonsStudied

    Alan H. Simmons briefly examined chipped stone materials from Cape Andreas Kastros at the Cyprus Museum.

    Cape Andreas Kastros chipped stone materialsCyprus Museum, Nicosia

    p. 270
  • Alan H. SimmonsStudied

    Alan H. Simmons examined chipped stone from Khirokitia at the Cyprus Museum.

    Khirokitia chipped stone materials

    p. 270
  • Alan H. SimmonsStudied

    Alan H. Simmons analyzed unpublished Ortos materials while comparing chipped stone assemblages.

    Ortos chipped stone materials

    p. 271
  • Alan H. SimmonsWorked withMartin R. Rose

    Alan H. Simmons and Martin Rose worked together on a comparison of the Aetokremnos assemblage with Levantine materials.

    Aetokremnos chipped stone assemblage

    p. 276
  • Sandra OlsenStudied

    Olsen examined several thousand Phanourios bones but could not identify any clearly butchered bone to her satisfaction.

    Aetokremnos

    p. 293

Posts and family 1

  • Stuart SwinyEmployed byCAARI

    Stuart Swiny was a director of CAARI from 1980 to the time of writing.

    1980–1996 · p. 1

People it is cited for

12 people

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.