Chapter · 2019
The Middle Chalcolithic to Middle Bronze Age chronology of Cyprus: refinements and reconstructions
C. Paraskeva; edited by C. Kearns and S. W. Manning
In New Directions in Cypriot Archaeology, 45-74. Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press
A chapter on the radiocarbon chronology of Cyprus from the Middle Chalcolithic to the Middle Bronze Age, with 149 dates run through four Bayesian models to propose revised period boundaries.
Paraskeva reviews recent approaches to absolute chronology in Cyprus and sets out revised boundaries for the Middle Chalcolithic through the Middle Bronze Age. Newly published radiocarbon dates are added to an existing dataset, the design of the data and of the models is evaluated, and four Bayesian models are compared.
The argument
Paraskeva argues that chronological models should compare different assumptions, examine the contexts of samples closely, and avoid treating calculated boundaries as precise representations of cultural change. He names the risks of assigning samples to phases from excavators' labels, of excluding data by rigid criteria, and of nesting site models inside regional ones; a simulated-data experiment points to nesting as able to shift the boundaries of the overarching model, so he recommends testing its effect (pp. 47–51).
For the new models cultural periods serve as practical groupings of data. Contiguous phases, which allow short transitions, are compared with overlapping phases, and Paraskeva rejects sequential models because they assume gaps between phases. Outliers are found by comparing calibrated dates with period ranges and extension zones, and suspect dates are then assessed in OxCal (pp. 55–62).
The evidence
The 35 new samples come from Politiko Troullia, Pyrgos Mavorarchi, the Erimi Laonin tou Porakou cemetery, Lophou Kolaouzou and Episkopi Phaneromeni. They include charcoal, seed and human bone collagen, dated by AMS and liquid scintillation counting, and Paraskeva notes that several of the source publications give little stratigraphic or contextual information (pp. 51–54).
Of the 149 dates, 21 are rejected as extreme outliers. Four models are run in OxCal 4.2.3 with the IntCal13 curve, from the same starting data, and differ in whether phases are contiguous or overlapping and in whether outliers are kept after the first analysis (pp. 56–60).
Dating
The re-run models give higher agreement indices than the first runs. Paraskeva takes Model 1+ as the best fit overall and Models 2 and 2+ as better guides where the evidence points to overlap, as between the Middle and Late Chalcolithic and at the transition into Middle Bronze Age II–III (pp. 63–65).
Dated in calendar years BCE, his boundaries give the Middle Chalcolithic a start of 3550/3525–3500 and an end of 2850–2750, and the Late Chalcolithic 2900–2850/2800 to 2510–2480. The Philia Culture Phase runs from 2510/2480–2450 to 2210/2205–2190, EBA I–III/MBA I from 2210/2205–2185/2175 to 2025–1950/1930, and MBA II–III from 2060–1970/1935 to 1740–1690/1650. He allows 50 to 150 years of overlap between the Middle and Late Chalcolithic and nearly a century at the transition from EBA I–III/MBA I to MBA II–III (pp. 65–70).
Paraskeva cautions that the end of MBA II–III is less securely modelled, since radiocarbon dates from the lower part of the phase are absent (pp. 69–71).
What it records
- In Paraskeva's simulated-data experiment, the first boundary of the overarching phase was consistently lower when a nested version was used.p. 50
- Paraskeva adds 35 newly identified radiocarbon samples from five sites to the dataset.p. 51
- Politiko Troullia supplies three charcoal and six seed samples.p. 52
- The Politiko samples fall between about 2140 and 1875 BCE at the one-sigma confidence interval.p. 52
- Paraskeva argues that the Politiko East dates may raise the calendar ranges of phase E1, because they come from carbonised pine wood.p. 53
- The radiocarbon dates from Erimi tombs 228, 230 and 248 derive from undisturbed tombs, Paraskeva states.p. 53
- The Lophou dates come from tombs 8, 15, 20 and 21, which Paraskeva says are probably looted.p. 53
- A Pyrgos Mavorarchi sample is charcoal from the central perforation of a Philia Culture Phase spindle whorl.p. 54
- The charcoal from the Pyrgos spindle whorl has a calibrated range of about 2855–2340 BCE.p. 54
- The dataset contains 149 samples, of which 128 are assigned to cultural periods for modelling.p. 58
- The absence of radiocarbon data from the lower part of MBA II–III prevents a sufficiently reliable model of its ending, Paraskeva states.p. 69
- Paraskeva proposes that the Middle Chalcolithic ended between 2850 and 2750 BCE.p. 70
- Paraskeva proposes that the Late Chalcolithic ended between 2510 and 2480 BCE.p. 70
- Paraskeva proposes that the Philia Culture Phase ended between 2210/2205 and 2190 BCE.p. 70
- The chapter was prepared in early 2014; Paraskeva says his position on the Late Chalcolithic to Philia Culture Phase transition later changed.p. 71
Where to read
- Recent studies of absolute chronology and problems of modelling thempp. 45–51
- New radiocarbon samples and their contextspp. 51–54
- OxCal model design and outlier assessmentpp. 55–62
- Model results compared and period boundaries proposedpp. 63–70
- Future work and the study's stated limitspp. 70–71
Contents
- Introduction45
- The Absolute Chronology of Prehistoric Cyprus: A Review of Recent Studies45
- Data and Methodology51
- Results and Discussion63
- Future Prospects70
- Endnote71
- References71
People, places and institutions
People
- Manningcited for chronological proposals
- Merrilleescited on dating White Painted Pendent Line Style
Institutions
- ARCANE projectearlier radiocarbon chronology project
Places
- Politiko Troulliasource of new radiocarbon samples
- Pyrgos Mavorarchisource of new samples, including a spindle whorl
- Erimi Laonin tou Porakou Cemeterybone collagen dates from undisturbed tombs
- Lophou Kolaouzoubone collagen dates from probably looted tombs
- Episkopi Phaneromenicharcoal dates from disturbed contexts
- Kissonerga Mosphiliacomparison for chronology and stratigraphy
- Politiko KokkinorotsosMiddle to Late Chalcolithic transition
- Souskiou LaonaMiddle to Late Chalcolithic transition
- Ktima Lowland sitesLate Chalcolithic transition
- LembaChalcolithic dating evidence
- Marki AloniaPhilia Culture Phase dating evidence
- Sotira Kaminoudhiacharcoal dates and model parameters
Extent pp. 45–74, figs 1.1–1.8; map; bibliography
Defines Middle Chalcolithic, Late Chalcolithic, Philia Culture Phase, Early Bronze Age I-III/Middle Bronze Age I, Middle Bronze Age II-III
ChalcolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeChronology and DatingSettlements
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.