Article · 2010

Paul Marguerite de La Charlonie, collector and connoisseur

R. Merrillees

Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 40 23-28

An article on Paul Marguerite de La Charlonie's collection, will and travels, and on how the Cypriote antiquities came to the Musée in Laon and may have been acquired.

La Charlonie's collection reached the Musée in Laon in 1937 by bequest. Merrillees follows the donor's museum plans, the conditions of his will and the evidence for how the Cypriote antiquities were acquired, and corrects the account that La Charlonie was born and raised in Laon, stating that he was born and brought up in Paris.

The will first left the antiquities to the Louvre on condition that they be put on public display with the name of the donor, then redirected the collection to the Musée Guimet, with a small group of objects reserved for the Louvre. Merrillees argues that these terms explain why neither museum received it and why it went to Laon instead, which stood fourteenth on a handwritten list of preferred destinations (pp. 24–25).

Merrillees notes that the Cypriote Bronze Age pieces have no provenance, and there is no evidence that La Charlonie excavated in the eastern Mediterranean. Merrillees reports that the Paris dealers Evangelos Triantaphyllos and Georges Manolakos acquired Cypriote artefacts at the Boysset auction sale in 1900, and suggests that Edmond Pottier's teaching and advice may have influenced the type and quality of the Bronze Age vases (pp. 26–27). Three Mycenaean vases went to the Musée National de Céramique.

La Charlonie's papers in Laon include five photographs of Cypriot buildings and places. Two bear the stamp of J.P. Foscolo, a photographer in Limassol, and Merrillees suggests that La Charlonie may have stopped there and possibly acquired antiquities (pp. 26–27).

What it records

  • The Cypriote antiquities in the Musée municipal d'Art et d'Archéologie at Laon entered its collections in 1937 through a bequest from Joseph Eugène Paul Marguerite de la Charlonie.p. 23
  • Jean-Yves Marc reports that La Charlonie assembled 1,700 antiquities, including vases, terracotta figurines and marble sculptures.p. 23
  • La Charlonie's will first left his antiquities to the Louvre, then redirected the collection to the Musée Guimet, with a small group of objects reserved for the Louvre.p. 24
  • The Musée in Laon was fourteenth on La Charlonie's handwritten list of preferred destinations for his collection.p. 24
  • None of the Cypriote Bronze Age items at Laon has a provenance, and La Charlonie is not known to have excavated in the eastern Mediterranean.p. 26
  • Merrillees suggests that La Charlonie acquired his Cypriote antiquities by purchase in France and perhaps in Cyprus.p. 26
  • Evangelos Triantaphyllos and Georges Manolakos, both Paris dealers, acquired Cypriote artefacts at the Boysset auction sale in 1900.p. 26
  • La Charlonie's papers include five photographic prints showing Bellapais abbey, St Hilarion castle, Kyrenia harbour, and the cathedrals of St Nicholas in Famagusta and St Sophia in Nicosia.p. 26
  • Two of the Cypriot photographs, of Bellapais and St Hilarion, bear the stamp of J.P. Foscolo, photographer in Limassol.p. 26

Where to read

  • The collection's bequest, La Charlonie's will, and the intended museum destinationspp. 23–25
  • Possible acquisition routes for the Cypriote antiquities and the dealers namedp. 26
  • La Charlonie's travels and photographs of Cypruspp. 26–27

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

Places

  • Limassollocation of Foscolo's photography business

Also named: Caroline Jorrand, M. Émile Bourguet, Mondry Beaudouin, Musée National de Céramique, Académie des Sciences of the Institut de France, Bellapais abbey, St Hilarion castle, Kyrenia harbour, Nicosia.

Extent pp. 23–28, with fig. 2

ModernCollectingMuseumsHistory of ArchaeologyPottery

Who did what

10 records

Buying, selling and giving 9

Recording and study 1

People it is cited for

3 people

Institutions it is cited for

2 institutions

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.