Book · 1997
The Image of Orpheus in Roman Mosaic: An exploration of the figure of Orpheus in Graeco-Roman art and culture with special reference to its expression in the medium of mosaic in late antiquity
Oxford: British Archaeological Reports
A study of Orpheus in Graeco-Roman art and culture, centred on the composition, style, context and interpretation of Roman mosaics, with a geographic catalogue of Orpheus mosaics.
Jesnick studies Orpheus in Graeco-Roman art and culture, with most attention to the animal-charming figure in mosaic. The inquiry starts from questions raised by the Great Pavement at Woodchester and compares Romano-British mosaics with examples elsewhere in the Empire and with Orpheus images in other media. The scenes are treated as decorative works with pictorial structures and cultural meanings, and a geographic catalogue of examples is assembled.
How it is organised
An introduction sets out the research questions and approach. Part I, on Orpheus in Graeco-Roman culture, has five chapters, on the myth, visual depictions, literary accounts of the animal-charming scene, Orpheus in antique thought, and his relations with the gods. Part II, on the mosaics, has eight chapters, on design and composition, compartmental mosaics, repertories and style, iconography, animals, pendent and associated scenes, inscriptions and locations, and definition and interpretation. A conclusion reviews the range of possible meanings. Appendix One considers the history and limits of mosaic cataloguing, and Appendix Two is the catalogue; a distribution table, illustrations, abbreviations, a bibliography and an index of mosaics follow (pp. 117–165).
The argument
Jesnick treats Orpheus as a multivalent image whose meanings could include music, cultural authority, religion, protection and good fortune. The meaning of a particular mosaic, she argues, depends on its genre, style, location and accompanying imagery, as well as on the cultural codes available to its ancient viewers. She cautions against reading the mosaics as automatically Christian.
Rigid design typologies and a simple model of copy-book transmission are both questioned. Jesnick finds that mosaics share recognisable conventions while keeping local differences, and comparing stylistic and iconographic repertories, including those that accompany Orpheus, gives her a way to discuss relationships and possible diffusion. She also considers the choices made by patrons and the practices and capabilities of mosaicists (pp. 45–71).
She concludes that no single interpretation accounts for the Orpheus image in mosaic, since adjacent scenes could qualify its meaning, and she finds no evidence for an Orphic sect in the Empire (pp. 106–119).
The evidence
Jesnick draws on mosaics and other ancient objects, literary texts, inscriptions, earlier catalogues and published descriptions. Her visual analysis covers composition, perspective, pose, costume, musical instruments, animal species and the relationship between central and surrounding scenes (pp. 45–105).
Examples come from across the Roman world. African mosaics are discussed in relation to animal spectacle, hunting, fishing and marine imagery, and eastern examples through their figure styles and repertories. Romano-British works, above all Woodchester and Littlecote, receive sustained attention alongside comparative examples such as Paphos, Piazza Armerina, Djemila, Volubilis and Chahba (pp. 45–116).
The Paphos mosaic from the House of Orpheus, catalogue no. 68, is discussed under the eastern repertory and in the treatment of Orpheus's pose and costume (pp. 63–71).
The catalogue
Appendix Two is arranged geographically, running from Italy, Sardinia and Sicily through Libya, Tunisia, Algeria and Morocco, Spain, Portugal, France, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Serbia, Croatia, Greece and Asia Minor to Cyprus, the East, Cyrenaica and Britain. Entries are numbered, with letter-suffixed entries for additional or disputed examples, and each is marked definite, probable, possible or not Orpheus. An entry gives the original location in the building, the place and date of discovery, the present location, bibliography, measurements, design type and notable iconographic features (pp. 124–147).
Dating
The visual survey runs from early Greek images through late antiquity and early Byzantine examples. Jesnick describes Orpheus mosaics as primarily a Late Antique phenomenon, with few surviving examples before AD 200. She dates the mosaic sequence from the mid-second century and includes later works such as the Jerusalem example. Catalogue dates are given as available and often record approximate or disputed datings (pp. 124–147).
What it records
- Jesnick's book began as a dissertation submitted for a Doctor of Philosophy degree in April 1992.p. i
- Demetrios Michaelides corresponded with Jesnick about Orpheus mosaics, especially the Paphos example, and helped obtain pictures.p. ii
- Jesnick's catalogue lists 103 entries, of which 85 are definite or probable Orpheus mosaics.p. 3
- The catalogue includes six mosaics that possibly depicted Orpheus and 12 entries Jesnick considers erroneous citations.p. 3
- Mosaic designs fall into two principal types in Jesnick's scheme, panel pictures and compartmental mosaics.p. 45
- Jesnick lists Paphos, Cyprus, among examples associated with the eastern Mannerist style.p. 63
- Jesnick distinguishes three forms of Orpheus in mosaic: Apolline or Greek, Thracian, and Phrygian or Oriental.p. 67
- Piazza Armerina has 56 whole or partial animals in Jesnick's count, with the total possibly reaching about 60.p. 78
- Jesnick's count of animals in Orpheus mosaics rests on a 65% sample of the corpus.p. 80
- Jesnick defines pendent scenes as those directly attached to the depiction of Orpheus.p. 91
- Jesnick argues that a date later than AD 250 does not by itself make an Orpheus image Christian.p. 110
- Jesnick dates the Woodchester Orpheus mosaic to AD 293–300.p. 146
- The distribution table lists two Type II mosaics for Cyprus.p. 148
- The Paphos Orpheus mosaic is captioned as in situ in Cyprus.p. 152
Where to read
- Research aims, scope and catalogue totalspp. 1–4
- Orpheus in visual art and development of the animal-charming scenepp. 8–19
- Orpheus in Graeco-Roman literature and religious thoughtpp. 20–44
- Panel and compartmental mosaic designspp. 45–56
- Regional repertories, eastern Mannerist style and animal modelspp. 57–66
- Orpheus’s poses and costume in mosaic, including Paphospp. 67–71
- Pendent scenes, inscriptions and architectural locationspp. 91–105
- Identifying Orpheus mosaics and evaluating Christian readingspp. 106–119
Contents
- Introduction
- Part I: Orpheus in Graeco-Roman Culture
- Chapter One. The Story of Orpheus
- Chapter Two. Themes in the Visual Depiction of Orpheus
- Chapter Three. The Scene of Orpheus Charming the Animals in Greek and Roman Literature
- Chapter Four. Orpheus in the Antique Imagination
- Chapter Five. Orpheus and the Gods
- Part II: The Mosaics
- Chapter Six. Design and Composition
- Chapter Seven. Compartmental Mosaics
- Chapter Eight. Repertories and Style
- Chapter Nine. The Iconography of Orpheus in Mosaic
- Chapter Ten. The Animals
- Chapter Eleven. Pendent and Associated Scenes
- Chapter Twelve. Inscriptions and Locations
- Chapter Thirteen. Definition and Interpretation106
- Conclusion117
- Appendix One: The Cataloguing of Mosaics120
- Appendix Two: Catalogue of Orpheus Mosaics124
Objects published here
5- Orpheus mosaic from Paphos, House of Orpheus, Nea Paphos, House of Orpheus, Nea Paphos, Cyprus, 68, Fig. 141 (p. 140)
- Orpheus mosaic from a tomb at Edessa, with Syriac inscription, In situ, Burial cave, necropolis south of the city walls, Edessa, 71, Fig. 115 (p. 141)
- Orpheus mosaic at Jerusalem with the inscriptions THEODOSIA and GEORGIA, Archaeological Museum, Istanbul, Turkey, Courtyard of a Jewish house to the north-west of the Damascus gate, Museum Inv. 1604, 73, Fig. 117 (p. 141)
- Orpheus mosaic at Poljanice, with Greek inscription, In situ, Seven-roomed building, luxurious villa, Poljanice-Glavnik, 57, Fig. 145 (p. 138)
- Woodchester Orpheus panel, Buried in situ, Woodchester, Gloucestershire, England, 91, Fig. 163 (p. 146)
People, places and institutions
People
- Demetrios Michaelidescorresponded about the Paphos mosaic
- Apollocounterpart of Orpheus in music and religion
- Dionysusreligious counterpart of Orpheus
- EurydiceOrpheus's wife in the myth
- Herculescompared with Orpheus as culture hero
- Mithrasiconographic comparison for Orpheus
- Clement of AlexandriaChristian writer on Orpheus
- Virgilpoetic account of Orpheus and Eurydice
- Ovidpoetic account of Orpheus and animals
- Frontointerpreted Orpheus as a model of concord
Places
- PaphosOrpheus mosaic and eastern repertory
- Woodchestersite of the principal Orpheus pavement
- Piazza ArmerinaOrpheus mosaic and animal imagery
- DjemilaOrpheus within a marine mosaic ensemble
- VolubilisOrpheus mosaic and animal repertory
- Chahbaeastern mosaic and style comparison
- LittlecoteBritish mosaic and interpretive case
- La ChebbaOrpheus and marine imagery
- Jerusalemlate Orpheus mosaic
- Blanzy-lès-Fismesmosaic used in design comparison
- Perugiaearly Orpheus mosaic
- Tarsuspanel mosaic and costume comparison
- Miletuseastern mosaic and repertory comparison
- Cosmosaics and eastern repertory
- Palermomosaics combining regional features
- EdessaOrpheus tomb mosaic and inscription
- PoljaniceOrpheus mosaic with inscription
Also named: Pausanias, Philostratus, Cyprus Museum, Goldsmiths' College, British Library, Department of Antiquities, Cyprus.
Extent 276 pp., 163 illustrations, 2 maps; bibliography, index
Defines panel pictures, compartmental mosaics, Gestural Repertory, Later Eastern Repertory, Mannerism, Apolline or Greek, Thracian, Phrygian or Oriental, pendent scenes, associated scenes
HellenisticRomanLate AntiqueSculptureReligion and CultArchitectureAnimalsIconography
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.