Article · 1993
Inter- and intrasite variability and social interaction in prehistoric Bronze Age Cyprus: Types, ranges, and trends
Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 59-72
An article on how pottery classification and attribute-based recording shape readings of variation and social interaction in Bronze Age Cyprus, tested on Red Polished Ware from Marki Alonia.
Frankel sets out ways of measuring similarities and differences within and between Cypriot Bronze Age sites, using preliminary pottery data from the first excavation season at Marki Alonia. He compares typological classification with attribute-based recording and asks what each allows researchers to say about social interaction.
Predefined pottery types, he argues, can exaggerate differences between categories and hide variation within them, which encourages models of bounded regional groups. Recording independent attributes and comparing assemblages instead shows degrees of similarity and variation at different scales, although classification and recording methods alike shape the patterns that researchers perceive (pp. 60–62).
The Marki Alonia analysis covers diagnostic Red Polished Ware sherds from 1991–1992, recorded for shape, dimensions, fabric, slip, colour and decoration and treated with statistical tests and correspondence analysis. Fabric attributes vary widely without groupings that would justify defining a series of wares. Intersite colour comparisons add material from Alambra Mouttes and Kalavasos Village, and Frankel relates the differing fabric colours to local raw materials (pp. 62–66).
The period is the Early to Middle Cypriot Bronze Age. Frankel places a change in interaction spheres and settlement patterns at about 4500 years ago and associates it with local copper production and the introduction of work animals.
What it records
- Detailed recording of the 1991–1992 season at Marki Alonia covered 2,285 diagnostic sherds, 11.5% of the total sample.p. 62
- Red Polished Ware made up over 90% of the sherds excavated at Marki Alonia in 1991 and 1992.p. 63
- At Marki Alonia, 75% of small open vessels, generally hemispherical bowls, combine three rim attributes: incurved, thinning rims with rounded ends.p. 63
- Frankel finds no basis for saying that the Marki Alonia assemblage shows potters selecting clays to produce particular fabric qualities.p. 64
- Surface-colour ranges and proportions at Marki Alonia, Alambra Mouttes and Kalavasos Village do not differ significantly, while fabric colours do.p. 66
- Frankel favours occasional movement of potters between villages as one possible way of maintaining a common ceramic tradition.p. 70
Where to read
- Recording and attribute analysis of the Marki Alonia potterypp. 62–65
- Colour comparisons at Marki Alonia, Alambra Mouttes and Kalavasos Villagepp. 65–66
- Pottery production, technology transfer and social interactionpp. 69–70
Contents
- Introduction59
- Society and Social Interactions59
- Models of Social Interaction60
- Types of Data60
- Summary61
- Types or Attributes61
- Types or Attributes?61
- Current Problems with Wares62
- A First Impression of Red Polished Ware from Marki Alonia62
- Pottery Recording62
- Site-specific: Compilation and Primary Analyses63
- Intersite Comparisons65
- Discussion67
- Methodology67
- Meaning in Data: Redefining the Questions69
- Acknowledgments70
- Notes70
- Bibliography71
People, places and institutions
People
- Frankelproposes local production and kin-based interaction
- Karageorghisadvocates an island division by pottery styles
- Åströmproposed eastern and western divisions
- Barlowproposes technological ware definitions
- Swinycited on material culture and pottery classification
- Knappcited on metal grave goods
- Webbdocumented the pottery and assisted excavations
- Merrilleescited on ware classification
Places
- Marki Aloniasettlement supplying the pottery sample
- Alambra Mouttessite in pottery and colour comparisons
- Kalavasos Villagecemetery assemblage in the colour comparison
- Troodosarea of copper sources and foothills
Also named: Dhenia Kafkallia, Alykos Valley.
Extent pp. 59–72, 4 figs; bibliography
Early Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeChalcolithicPotteryTradeCraft ProductionFood and FarmingChronology and Dating
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
2 pages · 1 object- What Pots Were ForArticle
- BowlsCompendium
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.