Edited volume · 2018
Communities in Transition: The Circum-Aegean Area during the 5th and 4th Millennia BC
Søren Dietz, Fanis Mavridis, Žarko Tankosić and Turan Takaoğlu (eds.)
Oxford and Philadelphia: Oxbow Books
A collection of conference papers on settlement, material culture, chronology and exchange in the lands around the Aegean, from the Balkans to Anatolia, at the Neolithic and Early Bronze Age transition.
Regional studies and site reports on the transition from the Neolithic to the Early Bronze Age in the lands around the Aegean, during the 5th and 4th millennia BC, make up this volume of conference papers, edited by Dietz, Mavridis, Tankosić and Takaoğlu. The conference met at the Acropolis Museum at Athens, with the Danish Institute at Athens and INSTAP as supporters. The preface explains the editors’ use of “Later Neolithic Stages” for the conference’s chronological focus, while regional archaeological nomenclature is kept in the individual papers. The papers address chronology, material culture, metallurgical practices, interaction and exchange, social organisation, settlement space and caves.
How it is organised
The editors arrange the papers geographically, moving from the Balkans through Greece and the Aegean islands to Crete, Cyprus and western Anatolia. Before the first part come the preface, acknowledgements and an introduction that also surveys the papers by theme. Part I, “Introductory and Synthetic Papers”, opens with Renfrew’s “Inventing the Final Neolithic” and continues with Kotsakis on the end of the Neolithic, a comparative paper by Parkinson, Ridge and Gyucha on village nucleation in South-Eastern Europe, Aslanis on the “missing” 4th millennium in Greece, Coleman and Facorellis on a “proto-Early Bronze Age”, and Mina on metallurgy and social complexity (pp. 1–74).
Part II, “The Balkans”, groups studies of Central Balkan settlement patterns, Bulgaria in the 4th millennium, population change in the Lower Danube and Thrace, and the sites of Kozareva Mogila, Varhari and Tell Yunatsite. Papers on chronology, pottery, lithic technology and the Kallamas settlement follow (pp. 75–194).
Part III, “Northern Greece and Thessaly”, takes in Dikili Tash, the transformation of space at Makriyalos and Thermi, Visviki Magoula, Theopetra Cave, the Middle Neolithic–Late Neolithic ceramic divide and bodies in the 5th millennium BC (pp. 195–246).
Part IV, “West and Southern Greece”, covers demographic change in Boeotia and Sarakenos Cave and Lion’s Cave, then caves, settlements and material culture at Oinoe IV, Kontra Gliate, Thorikos Mine 3, Kastria and Pangali, Drakaina Cave, Aigeira, Franchthi, Kalyvia and Alepotrypa (pp. 247–354).
Part V, “Aegean Islands, Crete and Cyprus”, runs from Ayios Ioannis on Thasos, Uğurlu on Gökçeada, Southern Euboea, island settlement and Strofilas to Kos, Crete, Phaistos and Gavdos, and ends with the two Cyprus papers, Peltenburg on the entry of Cyprus into the circum-Aegean world and Voskos on the “Cypriot paradox” (pp. 355–475).
Part VI, “West Anatolia”, presents Gülpınar, Yeşiltepe, Yeşilova Höyük, Ulucak, Liman Tepe, Çukuriçi Höyük, Çine-Tepecik, Tavabaşı and changing settlement patterns in Phrygia; the bibliography follows (pp. 477–633).
The papers
Peltenburg’s paper on Cyprus discusses the Chalcolithic settlement of Kissonerga-Mosphilia through Periods 4A–5, with Lemba Lakkous, Marki-Alonia and Kissonerga-Skalia also discussed. At Kissonerga the Period 4A Pithos House was burnt on purpose after surplus and personal-adornment crafts had built up in it. Peltenburg reports new dates that put Philia Red Polished pottery on Cyprus by about 2500 BC, and notes that roughouts and finished spurred annular pendants occur in Buildings 3 and 706 before that pottery appears in Building 86. Voskos takes up socio-economic change in Late Neolithic and Chalcolithic Cyprus under the heading of the “Cypriot paradox”.
Renfrew gives a date for the Final Neolithic in his proposed Aegean sequence and reads the Aegean “missing millennium” as the decline of tells and the rise of coastal proto-urban centres. Kotsakis ties the breakdown of traditional community structures to growing domestic independence. Coleman proposes dividing the earlier part of the Greek Chalcolithic/Final Neolithic period into a Chalcolithic phase and a Transitional phase, and Facorellis tabulates published radiocarbon ages from Greek sites. Mina argues for studying metallurgy as social practice instead of reading it as a direct measure of social complexity.
The evidence
In the Balkans, Kapuran and colleagues count Bubanj-Hum I settlements in Serbia, and Merkyte applies network analysis to trace-metal analyses from Bulgaria, which suggests a fragmented society. Georgieva, Popova and Danov read the burnt-level buildings and kilns of Kozareva Mogila as a pottery workshop that worked continuously for exchange. Varhari is presented as a production and trade centre in the Eastern Rhodope Mountains, with lithic finds in the tens of thousands, and Tell Yunatsite receives a plan of its latest Late Chalcolithic settlement and a classification of its cult tables into triangular, three-legged and rectangular, four-legged forms. Kufel and Pospieszny model published radiocarbon dates and find little support for one occupation hiatus across the whole South-East Balkans in the 4th millennium BC.
Dating also runs through the papers on Greece. Tsirtsoni and colleagues place the destruction of the sector 6 houses at Dikili Tash and the first Early Bronze Age layer in absolute terms. Perlès revisits the Middle–Late Neolithic and Late–Final Neolithic transitions at Franchthi through its ornaments, and Riebe traces changes in the long-distance exchange of obsidian at Alepotrypa through sourcing and p-XRF results. The cave papers give counts of finds: figurines from Lion’s Cave, projectile points from Drakaina Cave, animal bone from Pangali. Kyparissi-Apostolika asks whether Theopetra Cave served habitual or symbolic use, and Rambach describes the Early Helladic I graves at Kalyvia in Ancient Ellis.
On the islands, Papadopoulos and colleagues describe the economy of Ayios Ioannis on Thasos, whose assemblage includes spindle whorls and weights, and Televantou presents the Strofilas fortification, buildings and rock art on Andros. Further papers treat land management in Southern Euboea, the Cyclades, Kos, settlement patterns in Crete, the introduction of pressure blade technology into Crete, Phaistos and Gavdos.
In western Anatolia, Takaoğlu and Özdemir treat the Middle Chalcolithic of the Troad from Gülpınar, and Takaoğlu and Bamıyacı discuss two marble rhyta from Yeşiltepe with comparative evidence. At Liman Tepe, Tuncel and Şahoğlu take a probable copper object from a secure context as evidence for metallurgy in the 5th millennium BC. Horejs and Schwall frame the Late Chalcolithic–Early Bronze Age transition at Çukuriçi Höyük around interaction, and Korkut, Işin and Takaoğlu report radiocarbon dates and rock paintings from the cave deposits of Tavabaşı.
What it records
- At Kissonerga, the Period 4A Pithos House was deliberately burnt after accumulating economic surplus and personal-adornment craft activity.p. 457
- Peltenburg reports new dates indicating that Philia Red Polished pottery was present on Cyprus by about 2500 BC.p. 457
- At Kissonerga, roughouts and finished spurred annular pendants occur in Buildings 3 and 706 before Red Polished Philia pottery appears in Building 86.p. 459
- Renfrew dates the Final Neolithic in his proposed Aegean sequence to around 4100–3200 BC.p. 1
- Renfrew argues that the Aegean “missing millennium” reflects the decline of tell settlements and their replacement by coastal proto-urban centres.p. 10
- Kotsakis argues that growing domestic independence contributed to the breakdown of traditional community structures in the later 5th and 4th millennia BC.p. 15
- Coleman proposes distinguishing a Chalcolithic phase around 4500–4000 BC from a Transitional phase around 4000–3600 BC.p. 33
- Facorellis’s Table 5.1 summarises 256 published radiocarbon ages from 43 Greek archaeological sites.p. 45
- Mina argues that metallurgy should be studied as social practice and not treated as a direct measure of social complexity.p. 67
- Kapuran and colleagues identify more than 50 Bubanj-Hum I settlements in Serbia.p. 81
- Network analysis of more than 1,200 trace-metal analyses suggests a fragmented society in Copper Age Bulgaria, Merkyte reports.p. 91
- Eleven graves at the Kozareva Mogila necropolis, assigned to the Late Eneolithic and the transitional period to the Bronze Age, had been excavated by the time of writing.p. 107
- Georgieva, Popova and Danov interpret the burnt-level buildings and kilns at Kozareva Mogila as a permanently operating pottery workshop producing goods for exchange.p. 111
- The Varhari settlement yielded more than 60,000 lithic artefacts, with jasper and chalcedony predominating.p. 124
- Thirteen buildings were excavated in the latest Chalcolithic settlement at Tell Yunatsite.p. 138
- Kufel and Pospieszny collected 302 published radiocarbon dates to model their chronology.p. 149
- Kufel and Pospieszny conclude that the evidence gives little support to a synchronous occupation hiatus across the whole South-East Balkans in the 4th millennium BC.p. 153
- Tsirtsoni and colleagues date the destruction of the sector 6 houses at Dikili Tash to around 4300/4260 cal BC and the first Early Bronze Age layer to about 3300/3000 cal BC.p. 203
- Lion’s Cave yielded twelve figurines, ten from Trench A and two from other trenches.p. 275
- Oinoe IV covers approximately 315 square metres and has two low, narrow entrances.p. 284
- Excavations at Pangali recovered almost 1,400 animal-bone fragments.p. 298
- At least 213 projectile points were identified in the chipped-stone assemblage of Drakaina Cave.p. 308
- The Kalyvia rescue excavation discovered 24 Early Helladic I graves in 2004.p. 341
- Of 78 secure obsidian samples from Alepotrypa, 51 were assigned to Sta Nychia and 27 to Demenegaki.p. 353
- The textile assemblage of Ayios Ioannis includes 38 spindle whorls, one pierced spool and nine cylindrical weights.p. 361
- Building 3 at Uğurlu measured approximately 10 by 10 metres and had multiple rooms.p. 368
- The Strofilas fortification wall is approximately 100 metres long and is preserved to about two metres high.p. 389
- Excavations at Gülpınar exposed 1,200 square metres of prehistoric occupation, mainly Early Chalcolithic 2 and Middle Chalcolithic levels.p. 481
- The two Yeşiltepe marble rhyta are held by the Eskişehir Archaeology Museum, with inventory numbers A.30.87 and A31.87.p. 498
- Tuncel and Şahoğlu identify a probable copper object from secure context Loc. 959 at Liman Tepe as evidence for 5th-millennium BC metallurgy.p. 525
- The lower cave at Tavabaşı yielded two radiocarbon dates placing its Middle Chalcolithic occupation between about 4838 and 4459 cal BC.p. 549
- “Later Neolithic Stages” is the editors’ general term for the chronological focus of the conference.
Where to read
- Renfrew on the Final Neolithic and the “missing millennium”pp. 1–11
- Kotsakis on household autonomy, communal solidarity and hospitalitypp. 12–16
- Kozareva Mogila buildings, pottery workshop and kilnspp. 107–115
- Tell Yunatsite house plans and cult tablespp. 128–147
- Dikili Tash chronology and the Late Neolithic–Early Bronze Age transitionpp. 196–210
- Drakaina Cave projectile points, pigment, pottery and social changepp. 305–313
- Alepotrypa obsidian sourcing and p-XRF resultspp. 350–354
- Strofilas fortification, buildings and rock artpp. 389–396
- Kissonerga Pithos House, Philia pottery and annular pendantspp. 456–465
- Yeşiltepe marble rhyta and comparable vesselspp. 491–498
- Liman Tepe Chalcolithic stratigraphy, pottery, exchange and datespp. 513–529
- Tavabaşı cave deposits, radiocarbon dates and rock paintingspp. 548–555
Contents
- Inventing the Final NeolithicColin Renfrew1
- Transformation and changes at the end of the NeolithicKostas Kotsakis12
- Village nucleation and centralisation in the Later Neolithic of South-Eastern Europe: A long-term, comparative approachWilliam A. Parkinson, William P. Ridge, Attila Gyucha17
- Greece in the 5th and 4th millennia BC: Researching the “missing” 4th millenniumIoannis Aslanis27
- The shadowy “proto-Early Bronze Age” in the AegeanJohn E. Coleman, Yorgos Facorellis33
- Casting doubts on metallurgy and the transition to social complexity: The evidence from the AegeanMaria Mina67
- Settlement pattern changes during the Central Balkans Copper AgeAleksandar Kapuran, Aleksandar Bulatović, Dragan Milanović77
- Modelling the black box: Bulgaria in the 4th millennium BCInga Merkyte89
- Possible approaches to tracing the fate of the population of the Varna, Kodjadermen-Gumelnita-Karanovo VI and Krivodol-Sălucu culturesPetya Georgieva95
- Kozareva Mogila: A settlement and necropolis in the West Black Sea regionPetya Georgieva, Margarita Popova, Veselin Danov107
- The Chalcolithic settlement at Varhari: A production and trade centre in the Eastern Rhodope MountainsKamen Boyadzhiev, Yavor Boyadzhiev120
- The latest Late Chalcolithic settlement at Tell Yunatsite: Plan and architectural remainsVelichka Matsanova, Tatyana Mishina128
- Late Chalcolithic cult tables from Tell Yunatsite, BulgariaStoilka Terzijska-Ignatova140
- Rethinking the absolute chronology of the South-Eastern Balkans in the latter half of the 5th and in the 4th millennium BCMariusz Kufel, Łukasz Pospieszny148
- Graphite and carbon: Relative and absolute chronology between the Aegean and the Black Sea in the 5th millennium BCAgathe Reingruber155
- Lithic technology in the region between the Lower Danube and Marmara in the 6th and 5th millennia BCIvan Gatsov, Petranka Nedelcheva178
- Synchronisation of the Albanian and North Aegean Late Neolithic periods: New data from the lakeside dwelling of Kallamas (Albania)Cécile Oberweiler, Gilles Touchais, Petrika Lera185
- The chronological and social dimensions of the Late Neolithic I–II and the Late Neolithic–Early Bronze Age transitions in a long-lived settlement in Northern Greece (Dikili Tash, Kavala district)Zoï Tsirtsoni, Pascal Darcque, Haido Koukouli-Chryssanthaki, Dimitra Malamidou, René Treuil196
- Transformations of space in the Late Neolithic settlements of Northern Greece: Review of the evidence from Makriyalos and ThermiMaria Pappa211
- Visviki Magoula, Thessaly: Reconsidering cultural change from the Arapi to the Dimini phaseEva Alram-Stern217
- The role of the Theopetra Cave in Thessaly, Greece, at the end of the Neolithic: Habitual or symbolic use?Nina Kyparissi-Apostolika227
- Beyond transition: Tracing eventfulness behind the Middle Neolithic–Late Neolithic ceramic divideStella Katsarou234
- The beast with many heads: Assembling bodies and changing history in the 5th millennium BCStratos Nanoglou242
- Demographic transitions from the Earlier Neolithic stages until the first Early Bronze Age settlements in the plains and hill-country of Boeotia, GreeceJohn Bintliff, Kalliope Sarri248
- Late Neolithic traditions: Evidence from Sarakenos CaveAdamantios Sampson, Vagia Mastrogiannopoulou260
- Lion’s Cave, Hymettus Mountain, Attica: Figurines, structures and material culture associationsLilian Karali, Fanis Mavridis, Dimitris Lambropoulos269
- The Later Neolithic use of the cave Oinoe IV, at Marathon (Attica, Greece): Preliminary reportAlexandra Mari283
- The end of the Neolithic in East Attica: New data from Kontra Gliate (Kiapha Thiti) and Thorikos Mine 3Margarita Nazou289
- The Kastria/Pangali group and the beginning of the Chalcolithic in Southern GreeceSøren Dietz, Pernille Bangsgaard296
- Tracing social changes in the Late Neolithic/Final Neolithic transition at Drakaina Cave, Kephalonia, Western GreeceGeorgia Stratouli, Odysseas Metaxas305
- Caves and the landscape of Late Neolithic to Early Helladic I Greece: Comparing excavation and survey data from the PeloponneseDaniel J. Pullen314
- New evidence for the beginning of habitation at Aigeira, Achaia (Greece)Walter Gauss323
- Stones, pots ... and now ornaments: Revisiting the Middle–Late Neolithic and the Late–Final Neolithic transitions at FranchthiCatherine Perlès331
- The Early Helladic I cemetery at Kalyvia in Ancient EllisJörg Rambach341
- Long-distance exchange of obsidian: Diachronic changes at the cave site of Alepotrypa, GreeceDanielle J. Riebe350
- Ayios Ioannis, Thasos: The economy of a small coastal site dated to the second half of the 4th millennium BCStratis Papadopoulos, Ourania Palli, Sophia Vakirtzi, Eleni Psathi357
- The Neolithic to Chalcolithic transition on the island of Gökçada (Imbros)Burçin Erdoğu367
- Land management in the Final Neolithic/Early Bronze Age Aegean? Some tantalising indications from Southern EuboeaŽarko Tankosić373
- The Late Neolithic cultures of the Aegean archipelago with special reference to the Cyclades: Connecting strategies of space useFanis Mavridis381
- Strofilas, Andros: New perspectives on the Neolithic AegeanChristina A. Televantou389
- The Late Neolithic and Final Neolithic phases on Kos and the Alasarna settlement patternMercourios Georgiadis397
- Settlement patterns and social organisation in Crete during the Final Neolithic and the beginning of the Bronze Age (ca. 3700–3000 BC)Krzysztof Nowicki405
- The introduction of pressure blade technologies into Crete in the late 4th millennium BC: Where, how, and to what end?Tristan Carter415
- The earliest phase of the Final Neolithic at Phaistos in a wider Cretan context: New perspectivesSerena Di Tonto420
- The Final Neolithic–Early Minoan I transition in South-Central Crete: New data from PhaistosSimona Todaro426
- Gavdos, or living on the southernmost Aegean island in the Neolithic cultural horizonKaterina Kopaka, Efthimis Theou441
- The entry of Cyprus into the circum-Aegean world and the growth of regionalism on the islandEdgar Peltenburg†456
- Rethinking the “Cypriot paradox”: Socio-economic change in Late Neolithic and Chalcolithic CyprusIoannis Voskos466
- The Middle Chalcolithic period in the Troad: A new look from GülpinarTuran Takaoğlu, Abdulkadir Özdemir478
- On marble, conical rhyta: New evidence from Yeşiltepe in the West Anatolian hinterlandTuran Takaoğlu, Onur Bamıyacı491
- The Chalcolithic period at Yeşilova HöyükZafer Derin, Tayfun Caymaz499
- What follows the Late Neolithic occupation in Central-Western Anatolia? A view from UlucakÖzlem Çevik506
- The Chalcolithic of Coastal Western Anatolia: A view from Liman Tepe, İzmirRiza Tuncel, Vasif Şahoğlu513
- Interaction as a stimulus? Çukuriçi Höyük and the transition from the Late Chalcolithic to the Early Bronze Age in Western AnatoliaBarbara Horejs, Christoph Schwall530
- Prehistoric culture at Çine-Tepecik and its contribution to the archaeology of the regionSevinç Günel538
- Cave habitations in Chalcolithic Lycia: The case of Tavabaşı near TlosTaner Korkut, Gül Işin, Turan Takaoğlu548
- At the crossroads: Changing Chalcolithic settlement patterns in PhrygiaAli Umut Türkcan556
Objects published here
10- Copper knife or dagger with a leaf-shaped blade, Kozareva Mogila, north of the deeper-sunken building, Fig. 10.8 (p. 115)
- Large storage vessel from the burnt stratum, Kozareva Mogila settlement mound, Fig. 10.6 (p. 114)
- Copper shaft-hole axes of Pločnik type, Tell Yunatsite, next to the western wall of House 12, Fig. 12.6 (p. 133)
- Fragmented collared pot with black-on-red decoration, Dikili Tash, level X30-11, Inv. nr. DT206, DT206, Fig. 18.3 (p. 198)
- Gold ring idol, Theopetra Cave, Fig. 21.3b (p. 228)
- Clay figurine, trench A, layer 5, Lion’s Cave, trench A, layer 5, SP.8, A07, Table 26.4 (p. 275)
- White stone figurine, Lion’s Cave, trench A, layer 8, SP.10, B04, Figure 26.10 (p. 275)
- Two complete marble rhyta with elongated bodies and flat bases, Eskişehir Archaeology Museum, Yeşiltepe, cist graves, A.30.87; A31.87, Fig. 50.2 (p. 498)
- Pointed base fragment of a marble beaker, Liman Tepe, Loc. 935, LMT 28388/5, Fig. 53.11d (p. 523)
- Much-corroded probable copper object, Liman Tepe, Loc. 959, LMT 28453/2 (p. 525)
People, places and institutions
People
- N. Chernykhconducted trace-metal analyses
Institutions
- Danish Institute at Athenssupported the conference; institute of the series
- Eskişehir Archaeology Museumholds the Yeşiltepe marble rhyta
Places
- Kissonerga-MosphiliaChalcolithic settlement, Periods 4A–5
- Kozareva Mogilasettlement mound and necropolis
- VarhariChalcolithic production and trade centre
- Tell YunatsiteLate Chalcolithic settlement and cult tables
- Lion's CaveLate Neolithic cave with figurines
- Oinoe IVLate Neolithic cave at Marathon
- PangaliFinal Neolithic settlement and assemblage
- Drakaina CaveNeolithic cave and social gatherings
- AigeiraNeolithic and Chalcolithic finds
- KalyviaEarly Helladic I cemetery
- Alepotrypa CaveNeolithic cave; obsidian source study
- Ayios Ioannissmall coastal settlement on Thasos
- UğurluNeolithic and Chalcolithic settlement on Gökçeada
- StrofilasAndros settlement with fortification and ship carvings
- PhaistosFinal Neolithic and Early Minoan settlement
- Gavdosisland with Neolithic and Chalcolithic settlement
- Kavos TsargoulioMiddle Neolithic settlement on Gavdos
- GülpınarTroad settlement excavated in levels II and III
- Yeşiltepefindspot of marble rhyta from cist graves
- Liman Tepecoastal Chalcolithic settlement and exchange site
- Çine-TepecikChalcolithic settlement with marble finds
- UlucakLate Neolithic and Chalcolithic sequence
- TavabaşıMiddle Chalcolithic cave near Tlos
- Kissonerga-SkaliaPhilia material and settlement size
- LembaChalcolithic settlement compared with Kissonerga
- Marki-AloniaPhilia settlement with radiocarbon dates
- Dikili Tashlong-lived settlement used for chronology
- Kallamaslakeside Neolithic settlement in Albania
- MakriyalosLate Neolithic settlement, spatial organisation
- ThermiLate Neolithic settlement compared with Makriyalos
- Visviki MagoulaThessalian settlement and pottery
- Theopetra Cavecave assemblage and pottery traditions
- Sarakenos CaveLate Neolithic cave sequence
- Franchthi Caveexcavated cave; study of its ornaments
Also named: Ivan Ivanov, Oxbow Books, Acropolis Museum at Athens, INSTAP.
Extent Bibliography, pp. 574–633
Defines Later Neolithic Stages, Transitional, EB IA, cult tables, triangular (with three legs), rectangular (with four legs), Drakaina I, Drakaina II, FN I, FN II, pressure blade technology, Kavos ware
NeolithicChalcolithicEarly Bronze AgeChronology and DatingSettlementsPotteryCraft ProductionArchitecture
Chapters in our registers
1 in our registersCited on Ancient Cyprus
5 pagesMentioned in
7 mentionsTomb records · 2
- Kissonerga-Mosphilia, LAP Tomb 504
Discussion · 2018 · p. 458
- Kissonerga-Mosphilia, LAP Tomb 530
Discussion · 2018 · p. 458
- On Ancient Cyprus · 5listed under Cited on Ancient Cyprus
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.