Book · 2014

Competitive Archaeology in Jordan: Narrating Identity from the Ottomans to the Hashemites

Elena D. Corbett

Austin: University of Texas Press

A history of archaeology in Jordan and Palestine from the late Ottoman period, on how empires and Jordanian governments used antiquities and historical narratives to build political identities.

Corbett traces archaeology and antiquities in Jordan and Palestine from the late Ottoman period to the Hashemite kingdom, asking how archaeological knowledge, heritage projects and competing historical narratives relate to territory and political identity. She follows foreign and local engagement with antiquities, changing borders and the uses of archaeology in public representation. The sources are archaeological surveys and excavations, antiquities laws, museums and their displays, maps, stamps, currency, schoolbooks, tourism materials and public heritage projects.

How it is organised

Seven chapters run in chronological order: the politics of archaeological heritage; the Holy Land’s core and periphery; Ottoman-era antiquity and modernity; the British Mandate; antiquities in the Hashemite state; narratives in the expanded kingdom; and the return, after 1967, to the Hashemite core. A concluding chapter, notes, bibliography and index follow.

The argument

Corbett argues that archaeology is a political practice through which imperial and national powers claim antiquities, organise historical geography and assert identity. British representations made Palestine the Holy Land’s historical core and the land east of the River Jordan its periphery, a framework that shaped Mandate borders and later affected Jordan’s ability to narrate its territory through antiquity (pp. 23–49, 88–124).

She contrasts western claims over archaeological objects and narratives with Ottoman engagement through museums, antiquities legislation and popular Arabic-language writing. She presents archaeology as a field of competition among foreign powers, institutions and individuals, and describes late Ottoman Arab engagement with the past as drawing on local experiences and historical consciousness (pp. 49–87).

In the Hashemite period, Corbett describes the state presenting Petra and Jerash as national symbols and using antiquity in stamps, currency and public heritage projects (pp. 125–152). After the loss of the West Bank in 1967, state heritage narratives increasingly promoted tribal and bedouin identity, Muslim religious sites and tourism, and she describes the Historical Passageway as linking ancient periods to modern Hashemite rule in one continuous national account. She concludes that Jordan’s heritage has often been defined in relation to Israel’s, while Jordan’s territorial history and Hashemite claims to legitimacy shaped which antiquities entered national narratives. She adds that Jordanians’ personal connections to Jerusalem and Amman are varied and overlapping.

The evidence

The discovery and dispersal of the Mesha Stela serve as an early case study in local negotiation and European competition. Corbett also considers Nelson Glueck’s surveys of Transjordan and the presentation of Petra and Jerash through state imagery, including stamps and currency (pp. 31–37, 110–118, 134–145).

Later chapters examine textbook accounts of ancient peoples and national identity, religious tourism, shrines, museums, the Historical Passageway in King Hussein Gardens and competing claims over the Dead Sea Scrolls. Archival records for Mandate-era policy and post-1967 heritage initiatives are discussed, alongside interviews and conversations with Jordanian heritage professionals and others; the conclusion draws on reported conversations about attachments to Amman, Jerusalem and archaeological heritage (pp. 172–210).

Dating

The historical account begins in the second half of the nineteenth century, treats the Tanzimat of 1839–76 and Ottoman rule through the First World War, then follows the Mandates and the establishment of Transjordan in 1921. Later periods include Jordan’s 1950 expansion to the West Bank, its control of the West Bank from 1950 to 1967, and the post-1967 period. Heritage displays are dated by period, among them the Neolithic, Late Bronze Age and Iron Age.

What it records

  • The Bani Hamida showed the inscribed stone to Reverend Frederick Augustus Klein in summer 1868.p. 33
  • Royal Engineers under Claude R. Conder and Horatio H. Kitchener conducted the Survey of Western Palestine from 1871 to 1877.p. 37
  • Legislation of 1874, 1884 and 1906 governed Ottoman antiquities in Arab lands, in connection with museum development.p. 54
  • Transjordan’s Department of Antiquities was constituted in 1923, and its first antiquities law was passed in 1924.p. 108
  • Transjordan’s antiquities law defined an antiquity as a human-made structure or art object made before 1700.p. 109
  • Transjordan’s Department of Antiquities undertook its first excavations at Jerash in 1924.p. 138
  • Transjordan’s first stamp series, issued in 1933, featured Jerash’s Nymphaeum and Temple of Artemis.p. 139
  • Jordan printed nine stamps in 1952 to commemorate the 1950 unification of the East and West Banks.p. 160
  • The first issue of the Annual of the Department of Antiquities of Jordan appeared in 1951.p. 163
  • Gerald Lankester Harding oversaw the opening of the Jordan Archaeological Museum on the Amman Citadel in 1951 and moved the department’s offices there.p. 163
  • Petra was designated a UNESCO World Heritage site in 1985, and the Jerash Festival was established in 1981.p. 197
  • Mohammad Waheeb led the excavation, interpretation and renovation of al-Maghtas.p. 199
  • The Jordan Museum became independent of government in 2005 and is governed by its own board of trustees.p. 203
  • A Japanese loan through the Japanese International Cooperation Agency, part of the Tourism Sector Development Project, financed the Jordan Museum.p. 203
  • As of early 2014, only the Jordan Museum’s archaeological galleries were open.p. 205
  • In early 2010 the Jordanian government made diplomatic representations to Canada concerning the Dead Sea Scrolls at the Royal Ontario Museum.p. 206
  • The authenticity of the Lead Codices remained suspect and unresolved, Corbett states.p. 207
  • Western scholarship has largely defined Jordan’s archaeological heritage by its difference from Israel’s, Corbett argues.p. 208

Where to read

  • The Mesha Stela’s discovery, destruction and transfer to the Louvrepp. 31–37
  • Ottoman antiquities law and museum policypp. 53–58
  • Transjordan’s Department of Antiquities and early legislationpp. 107–110
  • Glueck’s surveys and ancient kingdoms of Transjordanpp. 110–118
  • Petra and Jerash as national symbols in stamps and currencypp. 134–145
  • Jordanian textbooks on ancient Palestine and Arab originspp. 172–182
  • Post-1967 heritage narratives, religious tourism and tribal identitypp. 196–200
  • Historical Passageway, Jordan Museum and claims concerning the Dead Sea Scrollspp. 200–207

Contents

  • Archaeology Is Politics: The Meaning of Archaeological Heritage in Jordan1
  • Holy Land Core and Periphery20
  • Antiquity and Modernity in Southeastern Bilad al-Sham49
  • British Mandate: Core, Periphery, and Ownership of Narrative88
  • Antiquities of a Hashemite State in Mandatory Space125
  • Antiquity, Pan-National, and Nation-State Narratives in the Expanded Hashemite Kingdom153
  • Return to the Core195
  • A More Complex Canvas than Meets the Eye207
  • Bibliography253
  • Index271

Objects published here

8
  • Mesha Stela, also called the Moabite Stone, Louvre, Dhiban (p. 31)
  • Mesha Stela fragments, Louvre, Dhiban (p. 34)
  • Jordan’s 1952 unity stamp, Fig. 6.1 (p. 160)
  • Jordan’s first series of postage stamps (p. 141)
  • Petra Treasury on Jordan currency, Petra (p. 139)
  • Jerash Oval Forum on the one-dinar bill, Jerash (p. 139)
  • Façade of Qasr al-Mshatta, Pergamon Museum, Berlin, Qasr al-Mshatta (p. 141)
  • Copper Scroll, Jordan Museum (p. 206)

People, places and institutions

People

  • King Abdullah Iemir and king of Transjordan
  • Nelson Gluecksurveyed and excavated Transjordan
  • Colonel Ronald Storrsmilitary governor of Jerusalem
  • King Husseinking of Jordan; heritage projects
  • King Abdullah IIking of Jordan from 1999
  • Sharif Husayn of Meccasharif and emir of Mecca
  • Gerald Lankester Hardingdirector of Transjordan’s Department of Antiquities
  • Tawfiq Canaanstudied Petra folklore
  • ‘Ararpoet and critic of Abdullah’s government
  • Abu DawudDhiban resident and excavator
  • Mohammad Waheebarchaeologist associated with al-Maghtas
  • Y'aqub Sukkardesigned Transjordan stamps and Jordan currency
  • Charles Clermont-GanneauFrench diplomat and archaeologist
  • Claude R. Conderled Palestine Exploration Fund surveys
  • Horatio H. Kitchenerled the Survey of Western Palestine
  • Osman HamdiOttoman museum director and law author
  • Abdülhamid IIOttoman sultan
  • Frederick Augustus Kleinmissionary who saw the Mesha Stela
  • Charles WilsonRoyal Engineers survey leader
  • Charles WarrenRoyal Engineers surveyor in Jerusalem
  • George Horsfieldchief inspector of antiquities in Transjordan
  • Rida Tawfiq Beyadministrative head of Transjordan antiquities
  • ‘Adnan Lutfi ‘Uthmanauthor of al-Watan al-Arabi
  • Jamal Jouckadesigned the Historical Passageway

Institutions

  • Department of Antiquitiesgovernment antiquities administration
  • al-MuqtatafArabic popular science journal
  • Palestine Exploration Fundsurvey and research society
  • American Palestine Exploration SocietyAmerican survey society
  • British School of Archaeology in Jerusalemarchaeological institution in Jerusalem
  • Annual of the Department of Antiquities of JordanJordanian archaeology annual
  • Jordan Archaeological Museummuseum on the Amman Citadel
  • Jordan Museummuseum project and heritage displays
  • Japanese International Cooperation Agency (JICA)financed museum projects
  • Royal Ontario Museumhosted a Dead Sea Scrolls exhibit

Places

  • Jordancountry and subject of the book
  • Palestinecontested space in national narratives
  • JerusalemHashemite focus and contested holy city
  • Petraarchaeological site and national symbol
  • Dhibanfindspot of the Mesha Stela
  • JerashRoman city and national symbol
  • Ammancapital and archaeological site
  • Dome of the Rockrestoration and Hashemite heritage symbol
  • al-Haram al-SharifJerusalem sanctuary complex
  • Qasr al-Mshattadesert castle and façade site
  • Qasr Kharanadesert castle depicted on stamps
  • AqabaJordan’s port and museum location
  • al-Maghtasbaptism site and tourism destination
  • King Hussein Gardenspark containing the Historical Passageway
  • Historical Passagewaypanels narrating Jordan’s history
  • Shrines and Tombs of the Prophets and Companionsrenovated religious heritage sites

Also named: ‘Adnan al-Bakhit, Wadi Rum, Azraq Oasis.

Extent 11 figures, 2 maps; bibliography, index

Defines Holy Land core and periphery, Bilad al-Sham, turath, watan, wataniyya, qawmiyya, Cisjordan, antiquity

ModernHistory of ArchaeologyMuseumsKingship and PoliticsIconographyForeign Contacts

Who did what

2 records

Posts and family 2

People it is cited for

1 person

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.